Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Arbitrarily complete Bell-state measurement using only linear optical elements

Warren P. Grice

Published Oct 19, 2011• 243 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A complete Bell-state measurement is not possible using only linear-optic elements, and most schemes achieve a success rate of no more than 50%, distinguishing, for example, two of the four Bell states but returning degenerate results for the other two. It is shown here that the introduction of a pair of ancillary entangled photons improves the success rate to 75%. More generally, the addition of ${2}^{N}\ensuremath{-}2$ ancillary photons yields a linear-optic Bell-state measurement with a success rate of $1\ensuremath{-}1/{2}^{N}$.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.84.042331

Related papers

Improved Linear Optic Bell-State Measurement Using Ancillary Photons

Warren P. Grice

It is not possible to construct a linear optic device that unambiguously discriminates all four Bell states. However, the Bell-state measurement efficiency can be made arbitrarily close to unity by introducing additional entangled photons.

Frontiers in Optics•Jan 1, 2009•0 citations

Linear optics and the problem of Bell-like state discrimination

Jatin Ghai, Sibasish Ghosh

A linear optics-based scheme to implement various quantum information processing tasks is of paramount importance due to its ease of implementation and low noise. Many information-theoretic tasks depend on the successful discrimination of Bell states. A no-go theorem states that it is not possible to perfectly discriminate among the four Bell states when the measurement apparatus is restricted to linear optical elements. The success probability is only $50\%$. Using extra resources such as hyperentanglement, ancillary entanglement, and even a minimum amount of non-linearity, complete Bell-state discrimination can be achieved. The success probability for Bell-like state discrimination is only $25\%$. Bell-like states are non-maximally entangled two-qubit states that resemble Bell states in structure but have unequal Schmidt coefficients. We find that this can be boosted to $50\%$ using hyperentanglement, where extra ancillary degrees of freedom (DOF) of photons, such as polarization, momentum, or OAM, are also entangled along with the system DOF. This contrasts with Bell-state discrimination, where $100\%$ can be achieved. Furthermore, we find that using correlations in the photons' arrival times, all four Bell states can be distinguished with $100\%$ success probability, while for Bell-like state discrimination, it increases only to $37.5\%$ from $25\%$. We observe a similar contrast when using ancillary entangled photons. While the success probability for discriminating all four Bell states increases as $1-\frac{1}{2^N}$, where $N$ is the number of ancillary photon pairs, for Bell-like states, it depends on the state parameters and can be less than $25\%$ in some cases. Also, adding further ancillary photons decreases the success probability. We then show that using non-linear gadgets, namely SFG, $100\%$ success probability can be achieved even for Bell-like state discrimination.

quant-pharXiv:2402.00832•Feb 2, 2024•0 citations

Bell-state measurement exceeding 50% success probability with linear optics

Matthias J. Bayerbach, Simone Evaldo D’Aurelio, Peter van Loock +1 more

Bell-state projections serve as a fundamental basis for most quantum communication and computing protocols today. However, with current Bell-state measurement schemes based on linear optics, only two of four Bell states can be identified, which means that the maximum success probability of this vital step cannot exceed 50%. Here, we experimentally demonstrate a scheme that amends the original measurement with additional modes in the form of ancillary photons, which leads to a more complex measurement pattern, and ultimately a higher success probability of 62.5%. Experimentally, we achieve a success probability of (57.9 ± 1.4)%, a substantial improvement over the conventional scheme. With the possibility of extending the protocol to a larger number of ancillary photons, our work paves the way toward more efficient realizations of quantum technologies based on Bell-state measurements.

arXiv:2208.02271•Science Advances•Aug 9, 2023•88 citations

Near-complete polarization Bell-state analysis based on symmetry-broken scheme with linear optics

Ling‐Jun Kong, Yongnan Li, Yu Si +3 more

Bell-state analysis is a considerable challenge and an essential requirement for reliable implementation of quantum communication proposals. An open question is the one for the maximal fraction of successful Bell measurements. It has been pointed out that no scheme using only linear elements can implement a Bell state analyzer. Some effort has paid attention to the complete polarization-entangled Bell-state analysis using linear optics, with the aid of auxiliary means. Here we present a symmetry-broken scheme with linear optics only, without any aid of other auxiliary means, for discriminating polarization-entangled Bell states. Although our scheme is unable of realizing complete Bell-state measurement for less photon-pairs situation, it can deterministically identify four Bell states with success probabilities beyond 99.2% provided that photon-pairs are not less than 8. Our scheme as a significant breakthrough is simpler and feasible with respect to the current technology for the near-complete Bell-state analysis. Symmetry breaking is indispensable in our scheme as in other physical systems.

arXiv:1512.01131•Dec 2, 2015•1 citation

Boosted Bell-state measurements for photonic quantum computation

Nico Hauser, Matthias J. Bayerbach, Simone Evaldo D’Aurelio +5 more

We demonstrate a boosted linear-optical Bell-state measurement with up to 75% success probability using entangled ancillary photons. We show that this boosted Bell-state measurement significantly increases the feasibility of fusion-based quantum computation schemes.

Quantum 2.0 Conference and Exhibition•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Boosted Linear-Optical Bell-State Measurements and their Applications

Matthias J. Bayerbach, Simone Evaldo D’Aurelio, Peter van Loock +1 more

We present the realization of a linear optical Bell-state measurement scheme, surpassing the 50 % bound success by utilising ancillary states in a linear-optical circuit and discuss possible applications.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics•Jan 1, 2024•0 citations
A complete Bell-state measurement is not possible using only linear-optic elements, and most schemes achieve a success rate of no more than 50%, distinguishing, for example, two of the four Bell states but returning degenerate results for the other two. It is shown here that the introduction of a pair of ancillary entangled photons improves the success rate to 75%. More generally, the addition of 2N\ensuremath−2{2}^{N}\ensuremath{-}22N\ensuremath−2 ancillary photons yields a linear-optic Bell-state measurement with a success rate of 1\ensuremath−1/2N1\ensuremath{-}1/{2}^{N}1\ensuremath−1/2N.
A linear optics-based scheme to implement various quantum information processing tasks is of paramount importance due to its ease of implementation and low noise. Many information-theoretic tasks depend on the successful discrimination of Bell states. A no-go theorem states that it is not possible to perfectly discriminate among the four Bell states when the measurement apparatus is restricted to linear optical elements. The success probability is only 50%50\%50%. Using extra resources such as hyperentanglement, ancillary entanglement, and even a minimum amount of non-linearity, complete Bell-state discrimination can be achieved. The success probability for Bell-like state discrimination is only 25%25\%25%. Bell-like states are non-maximally entangled two-qubit states that resemble Bell states in structure but have unequal Schmidt coefficients. We find that this can be boosted to 50%50\%50% using hyperentanglement, where extra ancillary degrees of freedom (DOF) of photons, such as polarization, momentum, or OAM, are also entangled along with the system DOF. This contrasts with Bell-state discrimination, where 100%100\%100% can be achieved. Furthermore, we find that using correlations in the photons' arrival times, all four Bell states can be distinguished with 100%100\%100% success probability, while for Bell-like state discrimination, it increases only to 37.5%37.5\%37.5% from 25%25\%25%. We observe a similar contrast when using ancillary entangled photons. While the success probability for discriminating all four Bell states increases as 1−12N1-\frac{1}{2^N}1−2N1​, where NNN is the number of ancillary photon pairs, for Bell-like states, it depends on the state parameters and can be less than 25%25\%25% in some cases. Also, adding further ancillary photons decreases the success probability. We then show that using non-linear gadgets, namely SFG, 100%100\%100% success probability can be achieved even for Bell-like state discrimination.
Bell-state projections serve as a fundamental basis for most quantum communication and computing protocols today. However, with current Bell-state measurement schemes based on linear optics, only two of four Bell states can be identified, which means that the maximum success probability of this vital step cannot exceed 50%. Here, we experimentally demonstrate a scheme that amends the original measurement with additional modes in the form of ancillary photons, which leads to a more complex measurement pattern, and ultimately a higher success probability of 62.5%. Experimentally, we achieve a success probability of (57.9 ± 1.4)%, a substantial improvement over the conventional scheme. With the possibility of extending the protocol to a larger number of ancillary photons, our work paves the way toward more efficient realizations of quantum technologies based on Bell-state measurements.
Bell-state analysis is a considerable challenge and an essential requirement for reliable implementation of quantum communication proposals. An open question is the one for the maximal fraction of successful Bell measurements. It has been pointed out that no scheme using only linear elements can implement a Bell state analyzer. Some effort has paid attention to the complete polarization-entangled Bell-state analysis using linear optics, with the aid of auxiliary means. Here we present a symmetry-broken scheme with linear optics only, without any aid of other auxiliary means, for discriminating polarization-entangled Bell states. Although our scheme is unable of realizing complete Bell-state measurement for less photon-pairs situation, it can deterministically identify four Bell states with success probabilities beyond 99.2% provided that photon-pairs are not less than 8. Our scheme as a significant breakthrough is simpler and feasible with respect to the current technology for the near-complete Bell-state analysis. Symmetry breaking is indispensable in our scheme as in other physical systems.