Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2402.00832

Linear optics and the problem of Bell-like state discrimination

Jatin Ghai, Sibasish Ghosh

quant-phSubmitted Feb 1, 2024• Announced Feb 2, 2024• 0 citations• Revised Nov 3, 2026 (v2)
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A linear optics-based scheme to implement various quantum information processing tasks is of paramount importance due to its ease of implementation and low noise. Many information-theoretic tasks depend on the successful discrimination of Bell states. A no-go theorem states that it is not possible to perfectly discriminate among the four Bell states when the measurement apparatus is restricted to linear optical elements. The success probability is only $50\%$. Using extra resources such as hyperentanglement, ancillary entanglement, and even a minimum amount of non-linearity, complete Bell-state discrimination can be achieved. The success probability for Bell-like state discrimination is only $25\%$. Bell-like states are non-maximally entangled two-qubit states that resemble Bell states in structure but have unequal Schmidt coefficients. We find that this can be boosted to $50\%$ using hyperentanglement, where extra ancillary degrees of freedom (DOF) of photons, such as polarization, momentum, or OAM, are also entangled along with the system DOF. This contrasts with Bell-state discrimination, where $100\%$ can be achieved. Furthermore, we find that using correlations in the photons' arrival times, all four Bell states can be distinguished with $100\%$ success probability, while for Bell-like state discrimination, it increases only to $37.5\%$ from $25\%$. We observe a similar contrast when using ancillary entangled photons. While the success probability for discriminating all four Bell states increases as $1-\frac{1}{2^N}$, where $N$ is the number of ancillary photon pairs, for Bell-like states, it depends on the state parameters and can be less than $25\%$ in some cases. Also, adding further ancillary photons decreases the success probability. We then show that using non-linear gadgets, namely SFG, $100\%$ success probability can be achieved even for Bell-like state discrimination.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2402.00832
Comments
16 pages, 8 figures, 1 table, typos fixed

Related papers

Optimal unambiguous discrimination of Bell-like states with linear optics

Dov Fields, János A. Bergou, Mark S. Hillery +2 more

Quantum information processing using linear optics is challenging due to the limited set of deterministic operations achievable without using complicated resource-intensive methods. While techniques such as the use of ancillary photons can enhance the information processing capabilities of linear optical systems, they are technologically demanding. Therefore, determining the constraints posed by linear optics and optimizing linear optical operations for specific tasks under those constraints, without the use of ancillae, can facilitate their potential implementation. Here, we consider the task of unambiguously discriminating between Bell-like states using linear optics and without the use of ancillary photons. This is a basic problem relevant in diverse settings, for example, in the measurement of the output of an entangling quantum circuit or for entanglement swapping at a quantum repeater station. While it is known that exact Bell states of two qubits can be discriminated with an optimal success probability of 50%, we find, surprisingly, that for Bell-like states the optimal probability can be only 25%. We analyze a set of Bell-like states in terms of their distinguishability, entanglement as measured by concurrence, and parameters of the beam-splitter network used for unambiguous discrimination. Further, we provide the linear optical configuration comprising single-photon detectors and beam splitters with input-state-dependent parameters that achieves optimal discrimination in the Bell-like case.

arXiv:2112.01605•Physical Review A•Aug 8, 2022•4 citations

Stabilizer formalism in linear optics and application to Bell-state discrimination

Yamazaki, Tomohiro, Rikizo Ikuta, Takashi Yamamoto

We propose a framework to analyze linear optical circuits based on an analogy with stabilizer formalism in quantum circuits, which provides efficiently computable formulas related to state discriminations. Hence, we analyze a Bell-state discrimination scheme with linear optics and ancillary single photons. With an increasing number of ancilla photons, the success probability of Bell-state discrimination has a maximum of $\frac{403}{512} \simeq 0.787$ at $28$ ancilla photons. By contrast, the corresponding two-qubit measurement asymptotically approaches a maximally entangling measurement.

arXiv:2301.06551•Jan 16, 2023•4 citations

Hyperentangled Bell-state analysis

Tzu-Chieh Wei, Julio T. Barreiro, Paul G. Kwiat

It is known that it is impossible to unambiguously distinguish the four Bell states encoded in pairs of photon polarizations using only linear optics. However, hyperentanglement, the simultaneous entanglement in more than one degree of freedom, has been shown to assist the complete Bell analysis of the four Bell states (given a fixed state of the other degrees of freedom). Yet introducing other degrees of freedom also enlarges the total number of Bell-like states. We investigate the limits for unambiguously distinguishing these Bell-like states. In particular, when the additional degree of freedom is qubitlike, we find that the optimal one-shot discrimination schemes are to group the 16 states into seven distinguishable classes, and that an unambiguous discrimination is possible with two identical copies.

arXiv:quant-ph/0703117•Physical Review A•Jun 27, 2007•151 citations

Optimal Linear Optical Discrimination of Bell-Like states

Dov Fields, Vladimir S. Malinovsky, János A. Bergou +1 more

One major challenge in utilizing linear optical setups for quantum computing, is that only a limited set of operations can be preformed. Achieving universal quantum computing using only linear optical components comes at the cost of either requiring an untenable number of ancillary photons or the acceptance of some probability of failure. Understanding the constraints and optimizing general linear optical operations under these constraints is both an important and challenging task. Here we consider the problem of perfectly discriminating between Bell-like states without the use of ancillary photons. For the discrimination between Bell states, the optimal success probability cannot exceed 50%. Here we derive the optimal approach for Bell-like states and show that the success probability without ancillary photons can only reach 25%.

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Oct 1, 2021•0 citations

Complete and deterministic discrimination of polarization Bell states assisted by momentum entanglement

Marco Barbieri, Giuseppe Vallone, Paolo Mataloni +1 more

A complete and deterministic Bell state measurement was realized by a simple linear optics experimental scheme which adopts two-photon polarization-momentum hyperentanglement. The scheme, which is based on the discrimination among the single photon Bell states of the hyperentangled state, requires the adoption of standard single photon detectors. The four polarization Bell states have been measured with average fidelity $F=0.889\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.010$ by using the linear momentum degree of freedom as the ancilla. The feasibility of the scheme has been characterized as a function of the purity of momentum entanglement.

arXiv:quant-ph/0609080•Physical Review A•Apr 17, 2007•192 citations

Arbitrarily complete Bell-state measurement using only linear optical elements

Warren P. Grice

A complete Bell-state measurement is not possible using only linear-optic elements, and most schemes achieve a success rate of no more than 50%, distinguishing, for example, two of the four Bell states but returning degenerate results for the other two. It is shown here that the introduction of a pair of ancillary entangled photons improves the success rate to 75%. More generally, the addition of ${2}^{N}\ensuremath{-}2$ ancillary photons yields a linear-optic Bell-state measurement with a success rate of $1\ensuremath{-}1/{2}^{N}$.

Physical Review A•Oct 19, 2011•243 citations
A linear optics-based scheme to implement various quantum information processing tasks is of paramount importance due to its ease of implementation and low noise. Many information-theoretic tasks depend on the successful discrimination of Bell states. A no-go theorem states that it is not possible to perfectly discriminate among the four Bell states when the measurement apparatus is restricted to linear optical elements. The success probability is only 50%50\%50%. Using extra resources such as hyperentanglement, ancillary entanglement, and even a minimum amount of non-linearity, complete Bell-state discrimination can be achieved. The success probability for Bell-like state discrimination is only 25%25\%25%. Bell-like states are non-maximally entangled two-qubit states that resemble Bell states in structure but have unequal Schmidt coefficients. We find that this can be boosted to 50%50\%50% using hyperentanglement, where extra ancillary degrees of freedom (DOF) of photons, such as polarization, momentum, or OAM, are also entangled along with the system DOF. This contrasts with Bell-state discrimination, where 100%100\%100% can be achieved. Furthermore, we find that using correlations in the photons' arrival times, all four Bell states can be distinguished with 100%100\%100% success probability, while for Bell-like state discrimination, it increases only to 37.5%37.5\%37.5% from 25%25\%25%. We observe a similar contrast when using ancillary entangled photons. While the success probability for discriminating all four Bell states increases as 1−12N1-\frac{1}{2^N}1−2N1​, where NNN is the number of ancillary photon pairs, for Bell-like states, it depends on the state parameters and can be less than 25%25\%25% in some cases. Also, adding further ancillary photons decreases the success probability. We then show that using non-linear gadgets, namely SFG, 100%100\%100% success probability can be achieved even for Bell-like state discrimination.
Quantum information processing using linear optics is challenging due to the limited set of deterministic operations achievable without using complicated resource-intensive methods. While techniques such as the use of ancillary photons can enhance the information processing capabilities of linear optical systems, they are technologically demanding. Therefore, determining the constraints posed by linear optics and optimizing linear optical operations for specific tasks under those constraints, without the use of ancillae, can facilitate their potential implementation. Here, we consider the task of unambiguously discriminating between Bell-like states using linear optics and without the use of ancillary photons. This is a basic problem relevant in diverse settings, for example, in the measurement of the output of an entangling quantum circuit or for entanglement swapping at a quantum repeater station. While it is known that exact Bell states of two qubits can be discriminated with an optimal success probability of 50%, we find, surprisingly, that for Bell-like states the optimal probability can be only 25%. We analyze a set of Bell-like states in terms of their distinguishability, entanglement as measured by concurrence, and parameters of the beam-splitter network used for unambiguous discrimination. Further, we provide the linear optical configuration comprising single-photon detectors and beam splitters with input-state-dependent parameters that achieves optimal discrimination in the Bell-like case.
We propose a framework to analyze linear optical circuits based on an analogy with stabilizer formalism in quantum circuits, which provides efficiently computable formulas related to state discriminations. Hence, we analyze a Bell-state discrimination scheme with linear optics and ancillary single photons. With an increasing number of ancilla photons, the success probability of Bell-state discrimination has a maximum of 403512≃0.787\frac{403}{512} \simeq 0.787512403​≃0.787 at 282828 ancilla photons. By contrast, the corresponding two-qubit measurement asymptotically approaches a maximally entangling measurement.
It is known that it is impossible to unambiguously distinguish the four Bell states encoded in pairs of photon polarizations using only linear optics. However, hyperentanglement, the simultaneous entanglement in more than one degree of freedom, has been shown to assist the complete Bell analysis of the four Bell states (given a fixed state of the other degrees of freedom). Yet introducing other degrees of freedom also enlarges the total number of Bell-like states. We investigate the limits for unambiguously distinguishing these Bell-like states. In particular, when the additional degree of freedom is qubitlike, we find that the optimal one-shot discrimination schemes are to group the 16 states into seven distinguishable classes, and that an unambiguous discrimination is possible with two identical copies.
One major challenge in utilizing linear optical setups for quantum computing, is that only a limited set of operations can be preformed. Achieving universal quantum computing using only linear optical components comes at the cost of either requiring an untenable number of ancillary photons or the acceptance of some probability of failure. Understanding the constraints and optimizing general linear optical operations under these constraints is both an important and challenging task. Here we consider the problem of perfectly discriminating between Bell-like states without the use of ancillary photons. For the discrimination between Bell states, the optimal success probability cannot exceed 50%. Here we derive the optimal approach for Bell-like states and show that the success probability without ancillary photons can only reach 25%.
A complete and deterministic Bell state measurement was realized by a simple linear optics experimental scheme which adopts two-photon polarization-momentum hyperentanglement. The scheme, which is based on the discrimination among the single photon Bell states of the hyperentangled state, requires the adoption of standard single photon detectors. The four polarization Bell states have been measured with average fidelity $F=0.889\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.010$ by using the linear momentum degree of freedom as the ancilla. The feasibility of the scheme has been characterized as a function of the purity of momentum entanglement.
A complete Bell-state measurement is not possible using only linear-optic elements, and most schemes achieve a success rate of no more than 50%, distinguishing, for example, two of the four Bell states but returning degenerate results for the other two. It is shown here that the introduction of a pair of ancillary entangled photons improves the success rate to 75%. More generally, the addition of ${2}^{N}\ensuremath{-}2$ ancillary photons yields a linear-optic Bell-state measurement with a success rate of $1\ensuremath{-}1/{2}^{N}$.