arXiv:2610.03362
Strict non-tightness of the level-3 quantum bootstrap for a natural three-dimensional Hamiltonian, at an excited level
Daniel Keren, Ye Zhou
Abstract
For the coupled three-dimensional double well $H=\tfrac12|p|^2+2\sum_i(q_i^2-1)^2-\sum_{i<j}q_i^2q_j^2$ we exhibit, at the first excited energy level (and also at the ground state), a linear functional on polynomials of degree $\le 6$ that satisfies every constraint of the standard level-3 eigenstate bootstrap, has a \emph{strictly} positive definite moment matrix, and nevertheless assigns a negative value to a nonnegative polynomial. It is therefore an interior point of the level-3 relaxation that is realized by no quantum state. The construction reflects a fact that holds at every level: the eigenstate rows never reach the top-degree momentum moments. At level 3, where strictly feasible points exist, this means that the corresponding block of the moment matrix carries no information about which energies admit one. Every algebraic ingredient is an exact rational certificate, and the only numerical ingredients (spectral enclosures of an eigenfunction) are carried out in rigorous ball arithmetic.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether a finite-level eigenstate quantum bootstrap can admit moment data that satisfy all retained constraints yet correspond to no quantum state—even when the moment matrix is strictly positive definite. It studies the coupled three-dimensional double well $H=\tfrac12|p|^2+2\sum_i(q_i^2-1)^2-\sum_{i<j}q_i^2q_j^2$ at level $K=3$, retaining moments through degree six. At the first excited energy, $E_1=1.61488137077986920\pm2\times10^{-17}$, it constructs feasible functionals $L_\tau=B+\tau\Delta$ with $\lambda_{\min}(M_3(L_\tau))\ge1.45\times10^{-5}$ that assign a negative value to a nonnegative momentum polynomial whenever $\tau>10683.13$. Here $B$ contains genuine eigenstate moments. An analogous ground-state construction is also established. The mechanism combines the gap between nonnegative ternary sextics and sums of squares with a structural observation: the specified bootstrap rows never constrain the highest-degree pure-momentum moments. At levels up to three, deleting the corresponding matrix block leaves unchanged which energies admit strictly feasible points. The algebraic ingredients have exact rational certificates. Rigorous ball-arithmetic spectral calculations, Temple bounds, and an explicit sum-of-squares graph-norm estimate certify the eigenstate moments and strict positivity. The result concerns fixed-level moment representability, not failure of asymptotic convergence or exclusion of incorrect energies. Non-tightness is also certified at level four, but strict positive definiteness is impossible from that level onward because $H-E$ forces a kernel. The construction survives certain additional relations through generator degree eight; unrestricted higher-degree cancellations are not covered.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 14 pages. Code and certificates included as ancillary files. Updated reference to companion paper arXiv:2610.07775; results unchanged