Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.03362

Strict non-tightness of the level-3 quantum bootstrap for a natural three-dimensional Hamiltonian, at an excited level

Daniel Keren, Ye Zhou

quant-phmath-phSubmitted Oct 2, 2026• Announced Oct 5, 2026• 1 citation• Revised Oct 7, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Oct 2, 2026v2 · Oct 7, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

For the coupled three-dimensional double well $H=\tfrac12|p|^2+2\sum_i(q_i^2-1)^2-\sum_{i<j}q_i^2q_j^2$ we exhibit, at the first excited energy level (and also at the ground state), a linear functional on polynomials of degree $\le 6$ that satisfies every constraint of the standard level-3 eigenstate bootstrap, has a \emph{strictly} positive definite moment matrix, and nevertheless assigns a negative value to a nonnegative polynomial. It is therefore an interior point of the level-3 relaxation that is realized by no quantum state. The construction reflects a fact that holds at every level: the eigenstate rows never reach the top-degree momentum moments. At level 3, where strictly feasible points exist, this means that the corresponding block of the moment matrix carries no information about which energies admit one. Every algebraic ingredient is an exact rational certificate, and the only numerical ingredients (spectral enclosures of an eigenfunction) are carried out in rigorous ball arithmetic.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether a finite-level eigenstate quantum bootstrap can admit moment data that satisfy all retained constraints yet correspond to no quantum state—even when the moment matrix is strictly positive definite. It studies the coupled three-dimensional double well $H=\tfrac12|p|^2+2\sum_i(q_i^2-1)^2-\sum_{i<j}q_i^2q_j^2$ at level $K=3$, retaining moments through degree six. At the first excited energy, $E_1=1.61488137077986920\pm2\times10^{-17}$, it constructs feasible functionals $L_\tau=B+\tau\Delta$ with $\lambda_{\min}(M_3(L_\tau))\ge1.45\times10^{-5}$ that assign a negative value to a nonnegative momentum polynomial whenever $\tau>10683.13$. Here $B$ contains genuine eigenstate moments. An analogous ground-state construction is also established. The mechanism combines the gap between nonnegative ternary sextics and sums of squares with a structural observation: the specified bootstrap rows never constrain the highest-degree pure-momentum moments. At levels up to three, deleting the corresponding matrix block leaves unchanged which energies admit strictly feasible points. The algebraic ingredients have exact rational certificates. Rigorous ball-arithmetic spectral calculations, Temple bounds, and an explicit sum-of-squares graph-norm estimate certify the eigenstate moments and strict positivity. The result concerns fixed-level moment representability, not failure of asymptotic convergence or exclusion of incorrect energies. Non-tightness is also certified at level four, but strict positive definiteness is impossible from that level onward because $H-E$ forces a kernel. The construction survives certain additional relations through generator degree eight; unrestricted higher-degree cancellations are not covered.

No sign of AI-generated textIncremental

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
14 pages. Code and certificates included as ancillary files. Updated reference to companion paper arXiv:2610.07775; results unchanged

Related papers

Quantum Many-body Bootstrap

Xizhi Han

A numerical bootstrap method is proposed to provide rigorous and nontrivial bounds in general quantum many-body systems with locality. In particular, lower bounds on ground state energies of local lattice systems are obtained by imposing positivity constraints on certain operator expectation values. Complemented with variational upper bounds, ground state observables are constrained to be within a narrow range. The method is demonstrated with the Hubbard model in one and two dimensions, and bounds on ground state double occupancy and magnetization are discussed.

arXiv:2006.06002•Jun 10, 2020•40 citations

Convergence Without Finite Exactness in the Eigenstate Quantum Bootstrap

Ye Zhou, Daniel Keren

The eigenstate quantum-mechanical bootstrap can converge to the physical moment set while remaining nonexact at every finite order. We prove this for a one-dimensional quasi-exactly solvable sextic oscillator at explicitly known eigenvalues, including excited levels. At every finite order, the lower and upper bounds on $u^2$ remain strictly below and above its physical value, even after adjoining arbitrary finite polynomial Gram tests and all eigenstate-annihilator relations visible in the retained moment space. Hence neither side of the centered observable admits a finite sum-of-squares certificate modulo the eigenstate annihilator. The gap persists under any finite set of additional localizing constraints whose weights are strictly positive on polynomial vectors. We then prove convergence for polynomial Schrödinger operators satisfying explicit sum-of-squares confinement and derivative bounds. The eigenstate relations give moment estimates uniform in the truncation order; these yield a regular Schrödinger representation supported on the prescribed eigenspace. Finally, a four-mode extension combines this fixed-observable obstruction with feasible position moments having no positive representing measure at every finite order. At level three, this construction yields nonphysical feasible points with strictly positive definite moment matrices.

math-phCross-listedarXiv:2610.07775•Oct 7, 2026•1 citation

Stationarity is not enough: tightness of the quantum mechanical bootstrap and the copositive cone

Daniel Keren

The numerical bootstrap for quantum mechanics tests a candidate state's positivity only against sums of squares, whereas every physical state assigns nonnegative expectation to every pointwise nonnegative polynomial. In one dimension the two coincide; in two or more they do not. Whether this gap is realized depends sharply on which constraint set is imposed. For the stationary bootstrap, which imposes <[H,O]> = 0 and is the relaxation appropriate to thermal and mixed states, we exhibit a two-dimensional quartic double well and a moment vector that satisfies every level-three stationary constraint exactly, has a positive definite moment matrix, and yet assigns a negative expectation to a polynomial nonnegative on R^2; it is therefore the moment sequence of no state. All data are rational, and every step is verified in exact arithmetic. For the eigenstate bootstrap, which additionally imposes = E, the same search finds no violation in any of five settings spanning two, three and five degrees of freedom and truncation levels three and four, tested against complete families of separating polynomials. The single exception occurs at a truncation so low that only one eigenstate constraint survives, and the theory presented here accounts for it. We identify the mechanism: the eigenstate constraints bound the high momentum moments, otherwise unbounded on the feasible set, and it is those unbounded directions that reach the region between the two cones. Finally, under the reflection symmetries of a typical potential the relevant obstruction is copositivity rather than nonnegativity, which, for the quartic witnesses available at the lowest truncation, places the first possible failure at five degrees of freedom. We conjecture that the eigenstate constraints imply an Archimedean-type bound on the momentum moments, and formulate the corresponding tightness statement.

arXiv:2608.07047•Aug 7, 2026•3 citations

Understanding quantum phenomena without solving the Schrödinger equation: the case of the finite square well

Victor Bârsan

An approximate formula for the energy levels of the bound states of a particle in a finite square well are obtained, without using the Schrodinger equation. The physics and mathematics involved in this approach are accessible to a gifted high school student.

European Journal of Physics•Aug 28, 2015•4 citations

ARCHANGEL: Joint Matrix Realization, Exact Directional Compatibility Obstructions, and Sharp Holonomy Bounds

Maciej Nowicki, Eve Artificilal Hyperintelligence

ARCHANGEL develops a constructive mathematical framework for the common realization of positive matrix moments, compatibility testing across directional data, and rigorous certification of operator-valued responses. Its principal contributions connect matrix inequalities, constrained realization theory, spectral geometry, semidefinite certification, and finite-dimensional quantum tomography. The central result is a necessary-and-sufficient common-realization criterion within a specified finite positive Gaussian model class. Under explicit kernel and positive-curvature assumptions, the construction determines whether complete joint moment data admit one realization satisfying a prescribed spectral cutoff constraint. It provides an explicit extremizer attaining the resolvent lower bound Lₐ = Q(Q + aR)⁺Q simultaneously for every positive parameter a. The auxiliary dimension is minimal and equals rank(Q); in the three-direction, ten-dimensional formulation, at most 30 auxiliary modes are required. A particularly distinctive result is an exact rational counterexample to the inference from separate directional feasibility to joint realizability. Every real direction individually passes its optimized feasibility test, yet no single common realization satisfies all directional constraints together. The obstruction survives every compatible complex completion of the unmeasured imaginary entries. This establishes a precise limitation of reconstructing a shared system from separately successful directional tests. Additional results include: Sharp directional coverage bounds. A general coverage parameter quantifies how much finite directional testing can underestimate the largest response. The optimal missed-peak factor is 4/3 for planar trigonal sampling and 3/2 even when every direction in all three coordinate planes is tested. Sharp reconstruction stability. Three planar trigonal measurements reconstruct the complete quadratic directional operator, with an optimal 5/3 amplification factor for uniformly bounded measurement errors. Ten-dimensional holonomy certification. Two Weyl transformations detect every nonscalar component of a Hermitian response operator. A sharp Hilbert–Schmidt robustness inequality has the golden ratio as its optimal constant. Exact continuum positivity certification. A planar operator-valued trigonometric inequality is reduced to a finite semidefinite feasibility problem using matrix Fejér–Riesz factorization. For the ten-dimensional code, the degree-one certificate uses a 20 × 20 block matrix. Explicit tomography and combined bounds. A construction using 100 preparations reconstructs any ten-dimensional Hermitian response. Combining spatial reconstruction with holonomy contrasts gives a sharp joint certification inequality. The mathematical value lies in distinguishing independently compatible observations from data that admit one shared realization, constructing extremal realizations with minimal auxiliary dimension, and replacing incomplete sampling arguments with quantitative or exact certificates. These questions are relevant to matrix moment problems, inverse spectral modelling, constrained system identification, and quantum response certification. The release includes a 95-page compendium, complete proofs, five preserved research studies, correction and theorem indexes, reproducible Python code, three synthetic figures, and 32 passing computational verification groups. Exact arguments establish the continuum statements; numerical calculations provide supplementary consistency checks. Status and scope: The stated finite-matrix problems are resolved under their explicit assumptions. The work is an AI-assisted theory and methods contribution using established tools, including Schur complements, Weyl operator methods, and matrix polynomial factorization. External peer review and a comprehensive literature-priority assessment remain outstanding. No experimental validation is claimed.

•Sep 29, 2026•0 citations

A simpler graphical solution and an approximate formula for energy eigenvalues in finite square quantum wells

F. M. S. Lima

The computation of allowed energy levels for a particle bounded to a finite square well potential is ubiquitous in modern physics and introductory quantum mechanics textbooks. For stationary bound states, the matching conditions for the wave functions lead to a pair of transcendental equations whose roots correspond to the energy eigenvalues. However, the graphical solutions available do not make clear the dependence of the energies on the well potential parameters. In this note, I present a simpler graphical solution involving only one dimensionless parameter that determines a straight-line crossing identical sinusoidal curves. I then reduce this solution to a single cosine curve, and from a three-point interpolation, I derive an approximate formula for all energy levels valid for any square quantum well and that demands only a pocket calculator.

American Journal of Physics•Oct 21, 2020•13 citations
For the coupled three-dimensional double well H=12∣p∣2+2∑i(qi2−1)2−∑i<jqi2qj2H=\tfrac12|p|^2+2\sum_i(q_i^2-1)^2-\sum_{i<j}q_i^2q_j^2H=21​∣p∣2+2∑i​(qi2​−1)2−∑i<j​qi2​qj2​ we exhibit, at the first excited energy level (and also at the ground state), a linear functional on polynomials of degree ≤6\le 6≤6 that satisfies every constraint of the standard level-3 eigenstate bootstrap, has a \emph{strictly} positive definite moment matrix, and nevertheless assigns a negative value to a nonnegative polynomial. It is therefore an interior point of the level-3 relaxation that is realized by no quantum state. The construction reflects a fact that holds at every level: the eigenstate rows never reach the top-degree momentum moments. At level 3, where strictly feasible points exist, this means that the corresponding block of the moment matrix carries no information about which energies admit one. Every algebraic ingredient is an exact rational certificate, and the only numerical ingredients (spectral enclosures of an eigenfunction) are carried out in rigorous ball arithmetic.
The paper asks whether a finite-level eigenstate quantum bootstrap can admit moment data that satisfy all retained constraints yet correspond to no quantum state—even when the moment matrix is strictly positive definite. It studies the coupled three-dimensional double well H=12∣p∣2+2∑i(qi2−1)2−∑i<jqi2qj2H=\tfrac12|p|^2+2\sum_i(q_i^2-1)^2-\sum_{i<j}q_i^2q_j^2H=21​∣p∣2+2∑i​(qi2​−1)2−∑i<j​qi2​qj2​ at level K=3K=3K=3, retaining moments through degree six.
At the first excited energy, E1=1.61488137077986920±2×10−17E_1=1.61488137077986920\pm2\times10^{-17}E1​=1.61488137077986920±2×10−17, it constructs feasible functionals Lτ=B+τΔL_\tau=B+\tau\DeltaLτ​=B+τΔ with λmin⁡(M3(Lτ))≥1.45×10−5\lambda_{\min}(M_3(L_\tau))\ge1.45\times10^{-5}λmin​(M3​(Lτ​))≥1.45×10−5 that assign a negative value to a nonnegative momentum polynomial whenever τ>10683.13\tau>10683.13τ>10683.13. Here BBB contains genuine eigenstate moments. An analogous ground-state construction is also established. The mechanism combines the gap between nonnegative ternary sextics and sums of squares with a structural observation: the specified bootstrap rows never constrain the highest-degree pure-momentum moments. At levels up to three, deleting the corresponding matrix block leaves unchanged which energies admit strictly feasible points.
The algebraic ingredients have exact rational certificates. Rigorous ball-arithmetic spectral calculations, Temple bounds, and an explicit sum-of-squares graph-norm estimate certify the eigenstate moments and strict positivity.
The result concerns fixed-level moment representability, not failure of asymptotic convergence or exclusion of incorrect energies. Non-tightness is also certified at level four, but strict positive definiteness is impossible from that level onward because H−EH-EH−E forces a kernel. The construction survives certain additional relations through generator degree eight; unrestricted higher-degree cancellations are not covered.
A numerical bootstrap method is proposed to provide rigorous and nontrivial bounds in general quantum many-body systems with locality. In particular, lower bounds on ground state energies of local lattice systems are obtained by imposing positivity constraints on certain operator expectation values. Complemented with variational upper bounds, ground state observables are constrained to be within a narrow range. The method is demonstrated with the Hubbard model in one and two dimensions, and bounds on ground state double occupancy and magnetization are discussed.
The eigenstate quantum-mechanical bootstrap can converge to the physical moment set while remaining nonexact at every finite order. We prove this for a one-dimensional quasi-exactly solvable sextic oscillator at explicitly known eigenvalues, including excited levels. At every finite order, the lower and upper bounds on u2u^2u2 remain strictly below and above its physical value, even after adjoining arbitrary finite polynomial Gram tests and all eigenstate-annihilator relations visible in the retained moment space. Hence neither side of the centered observable admits a finite sum-of-squares certificate modulo the eigenstate annihilator. The gap persists under any finite set of additional localizing constraints whose weights are strictly positive on polynomial vectors. We then prove convergence for polynomial Schrödinger operators satisfying explicit sum-of-squares confinement and derivative bounds. The eigenstate relations give moment estimates uniform in the truncation order; these yield a regular Schrödinger representation supported on the prescribed eigenspace. Finally, a four-mode extension combines this fixed-observable obstruction with feasible position moments having no positive representing measure at every finite order. At level three, this construction yields nonphysical feasible points with strictly positive definite moment matrices.
The numerical bootstrap for quantum mechanics tests a candidate state's positivity only against sums of squares, whereas every physical state assigns nonnegative expectation to every pointwise nonnegative polynomial. In one dimension the two coincide; in two or more they do not. Whether this gap is realized depends sharply on which constraint set is imposed. For the stationary bootstrap, which imposes <[H,O]> = 0 and is the relaxation appropriate to thermal and mixed states, we exhibit a two-dimensional quartic double well and a moment vector that satisfies every level-three stationary constraint exactly, has a positive definite moment matrix, and yet assigns a negative expectation to a polynomial nonnegative on R^2; it is therefore the moment sequence of no state. All data are rational, and every step is verified in exact arithmetic. For the eigenstate bootstrap, which additionally imposes = E, the same search finds no violation in any of five settings spanning two, three and five degrees of freedom and truncation levels three and four, tested against complete families of separating polynomials. The single exception occurs at a truncation so low that only one eigenstate constraint survives, and the theory presented here accounts for it. We identify the mechanism: the eigenstate constraints bound the high momentum moments, otherwise unbounded on the feasible set, and it is those unbounded directions that reach the region between the two cones. Finally, under the reflection symmetries of a typical potential the relevant obstruction is copositivity rather than nonnegativity, which, for the quartic witnesses available at the lowest truncation, places the first possible failure at five degrees of freedom. We conjecture that the eigenstate constraints imply an Archimedean-type bound on the momentum moments, and formulate the corresponding tightness statement.
ARCHANGEL develops a constructive mathematical framework for the common realization of positive matrix moments, compatibility testing across directional data, and rigorous certification of operator-valued responses. Its principal contributions connect matrix inequalities, constrained realization theory, spectral geometry, semidefinite certification, and finite-dimensional quantum tomography. The central result is a necessary-and-sufficient common-realization criterion within a specified finite positive Gaussian model class. Under explicit kernel and positive-curvature assumptions, the construction determines whether complete joint moment data admit one realization satisfying a prescribed spectral cutoff constraint. It provides an explicit extremizer attaining the resolvent lower bound Lₐ = Q(Q + aR)⁺Q simultaneously for every positive parameter a. The auxiliary dimension is minimal and equals rank(Q); in the three-direction, ten-dimensional formulation, at most 30 auxiliary modes are required. A particularly distinctive result is an exact rational counterexample to the inference from separate directional feasibility to joint realizability. Every real direction individually passes its optimized feasibility test, yet no single common realization satisfies all directional constraints together. The obstruction survives every compatible complex completion of the unmeasured imaginary entries. This establishes a precise limitation of reconstructing a shared system from separately successful directional tests. Additional results include: Sharp directional coverage bounds. A general coverage parameter quantifies how much finite directional testing can underestimate the largest response. The optimal missed-peak factor is 4/3 for planar trigonal sampling and 3/2 even when every direction in all three coordinate planes is tested. Sharp reconstruction stability. Three planar trigonal measurements reconstruct the complete quadratic directional operator, with an optimal 5/3 amplification factor for uniformly bounded measurement errors. Ten-dimensional holonomy certification. Two Weyl transformations detect every nonscalar component of a Hermitian response operator. A sharp Hilbert–Schmidt robustness inequality has the golden ratio as its optimal constant. Exact continuum positivity certification. A planar operator-valued trigonometric inequality is reduced to a finite semidefinite feasibility problem using matrix Fejér–Riesz factorization. For the ten-dimensional code, the degree-one certificate uses a 20 × 20 block matrix. Explicit tomography and combined bounds. A construction using 100 preparations reconstructs any ten-dimensional Hermitian response. Combining spatial reconstruction with holonomy contrasts gives a sharp joint certification inequality. The mathematical value lies in distinguishing independently compatible observations from data that admit one shared realization, constructing extremal realizations with minimal auxiliary dimension, and replacing incomplete sampling arguments with quantitative or exact certificates. These questions are relevant to matrix moment problems, inverse spectral modelling, constrained system identification, and quantum response certification. The release includes a 95-page compendium, complete proofs, five preserved research studies, correction and theorem indexes, reproducible Python code, three synthetic figures, and 32 passing computational verification groups. Exact arguments establish the continuum statements; numerical calculations provide supplementary consistency checks. Status and scope: The stated finite-matrix problems are resolved under their explicit assumptions. The work is an AI-assisted theory and methods contribution using established tools, including Schur complements, Weyl operator methods, and matrix polynomial factorization. External peer review and a comprehensive literature-priority assessment remain outstanding. No experimental validation is claimed.
The computation of allowed energy levels for a particle bounded to a finite square well potential is ubiquitous in modern physics and introductory quantum mechanics textbooks. For stationary bound states, the matching conditions for the wave functions lead to a pair of transcendental equations whose roots correspond to the energy eigenvalues. However, the graphical solutions available do not make clear the dependence of the energies on the well potential parameters. In this note, I present a simpler graphical solution involving only one dimensionless parameter that determines a straight-line crossing identical sinusoidal curves. I then reduce this solution to a single cosine curve, and from a three-point interpolation, I derive an approximate formula for all energy levels valid for any square quantum well and that demands only a pocket calculator.