Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2608.07047

Stationarity is not enough: tightness of the quantum mechanical bootstrap and the copositive cone

Daniel Keren

Published Aug 7, 2026• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The numerical bootstrap for quantum mechanics tests a candidate state's positivity only against sums of squares, whereas every physical state assigns nonnegative expectation to every pointwise nonnegative polynomial. In one dimension the two coincide; in two or more they do not. Whether this gap is realized depends sharply on which constraint set is imposed. For the stationary bootstrap, which imposes <[H,O]> = 0 and is the relaxation appropriate to thermal and mixed states, we exhibit a two-dimensional quartic double well and a moment vector that satisfies every level-three stationary constraint exactly, has a positive definite moment matrix, and yet assigns a negative expectation to a polynomial nonnegative on R^2; it is therefore the moment sequence of no state. All data are rational, and every step is verified in exact arithmetic. For the eigenstate bootstrap, which additionally imposes = E, the same search finds no violation in any of five settings spanning two, three and five degrees of freedom and truncation levels three and four, tested against complete families of separating polynomials. The single exception occurs at a truncation so low that only one eigenstate constraint survives, and the theory presented here accounts for it. We identify the mechanism: the eigenstate constraints bound the high momentum moments, otherwise unbounded on the feasible set, and it is those unbounded directions that reach the region between the two cones. Finally, under the reflection symmetries of a typical potential the relevant obstruction is copositivity rather than nonnegativity, which, for the quartic witnesses available at the lowest truncation, places the first possible failure at five degrees of freedom. We conjecture that the eigenstate constraints imply an Archimedean-type bound on the momentum moments, and formulate the corresponding tightness statement.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2608.07047

Related papers

Strict non-tightness of the level-3 quantum bootstrap for a natural three-dimensional Hamiltonian, at an excited level

Daniel Keren, Ye Zhou

For the coupled three-dimensional double well $H=\tfrac12|p|^2+2\sum_i(q_i^2-1)^2-\sum_{i<j}q_i^2q_j^2$ we exhibit, at the first excited energy level (and also at the ground state), a linear functional on polynomials of degree $\le 6$ that satisfies every constraint of the standard level-3 eigenstate bootstrap, has a \emph{strictly} positive definite moment matrix, and nevertheless assigns a negative value to a nonnegative polynomial. It is therefore an interior point of the level-3 relaxation that is realized by no quantum state. The construction reflects a fact that holds at every level: the eigenstate rows never reach the top-degree momentum moments. At level 3, where strictly feasible points exist, this means that the corresponding block of the moment matrix carries no information about which energies admit one. Every algebraic ingredient is an exact rational certificate, and the only numerical ingredients (spectral enclosures of an eigenfunction) are carried out in rigorous ball arithmetic.

quant-pharXiv:2610.03362•Oct 5, 2026•1 citation

Convergence Without Finite Exactness in the Eigenstate Quantum Bootstrap

Ye Zhou, Daniel Keren

The eigenstate quantum-mechanical bootstrap can converge to the physical moment set while remaining nonexact at every finite order. We prove this for a one-dimensional quasi-exactly solvable sextic oscillator at explicitly known eigenvalues, including excited levels. At every finite order, the lower and upper bounds on $u^2$ remain strictly below and above its physical value, even after adjoining arbitrary finite polynomial Gram tests and all eigenstate-annihilator relations visible in the retained moment space. Hence neither side of the centered observable admits a finite sum-of-squares certificate modulo the eigenstate annihilator. The gap persists under any finite set of additional localizing constraints whose weights are strictly positive on polynomial vectors. We then prove convergence for polynomial Schrödinger operators satisfying explicit sum-of-squares confinement and derivative bounds. The eigenstate relations give moment estimates uniform in the truncation order; these yield a regular Schrödinger representation supported on the prescribed eigenspace. Finally, a four-mode extension combines this fixed-observable obstruction with feasible position moments having no positive representing measure at every finite order. At level three, this construction yields nonphysical feasible points with strictly positive definite moment matrices.

math-phCross-listedarXiv:2610.07775•Oct 7, 2026•1 citation

Semidefinite programming algorithm for the quantum mechanical bootstrap

David E Berenstein, George Hulsey

We present a semidefinite programming algorithm to find eigenvalues of Schrödinger operators within the bootstrap approach to quantum mechanics. The bootstrap approach involves two ingredients: a nonlinear set of constraints on the variables (expectation values of operators in an energy eigenstate), plus positivity constraints (unitarity) that need to be satisfied. By fixing the energy we linearize all the constraints and show that the feasibility problem can be presented as an optimization problem for the variables that are not fixed by the constraints and one additional slack variable that measures the failure of positivity. To illustrate the method we are able to obtain high-precision, sharp bounds on eigenenergies for arbitrary confining polynomial potentials in one dimension.

arXiv:2209.14332•Physical review. E•May 23, 2023•33 citations

The Failure of Simultaneous Quantum Typicality

Benoit Collins

We establish exact thresholds for the failure of simultaneous quantum typicality: three parties for mixed states and four for pure states. For the four-qubit Higuchi--Sudbery state, every sequence satisfying the expected purity bounds on three overlapping marginals, with sufficiently small fixed positive entropy slack, is asymptotically perfectly distinguishable from the tensor powers of the input: its trace distance from them tends to the maximum value $2$. This maximal separation persists, with a common positive slack, throughout an open neighborhood in the full four-qubit state space. Tracing out one party yields a mixed tripartite example. The proof connects simultaneous quantum smoothing with polynomial concentration on $\CP^1$. Symmetry reduces the problem to a frame inequality on $\Sym^n(\mathbb C^2)$, where a linear entropy deficit competes with a quadratic cost of polynomial concentration. Bernstein--Markov estimates and a subharmonic barrier control this cost, yielding an exponential obstruction to simultaneous typicality. These results disprove Dutil's multiparty quantum typicality conjecture, formulated in 2011, and the one-shot simultaneous min-entropy-smoothing conjectures of Drescher--Fawzi and Colomer--Winter. Together with the positive results for smaller systems, they determine the smallest numbers of parties at which simultaneous typicality can fail.

quant-pharXiv:2609.25726•Sep 23, 2026•0 citations

Maximum Entropy with Quartic Moments in Continuous-Variable Quantum Systems: Existence, Nonexistence, and Dual Geometry

Mitsutoshi Yamada

We study the quantum exponential family of n bosonic modes generated by the phase-space polynomials of degree at most four, and the maximization of the von Neumann entropy under prescribed moments up to order four, the quantum analogue of a classical problem of Junk. We prove that the family is an analytic dually flat manifold with the Bogoliubov–Kubo–Mori metric and that strong duality holds for moment data in the interior of the realizable region. For such data, and under a density hypothesis also in the relative interior of faces, we characterize nonexistence completely: the maximizer fails to exist exactly when the data are the moments of a family member plus an excess fourth-order tensor supported on the null directions of its quartic part. For one mode, the kernel of a nonzero positive semidefinite polynomial operator of degree at most four has dimension at most two, so that maximizers also exist on the boundary. For two or more modes the admissible set is strictly larger than the classical one (companion paper); faces of infinite dimension occur, and nonexistence of Junk type appears inside faces. We compute the curvature of two-parameter photon-number families at their stratum b = 0, which equals −(1 + 3v₂)/2 for quadratic variance functions and −2 for thermal states. Near the Gaussian boundary the log-partition function stays bounded along regular approaches (in a one-dimensional classical model and for one mode) and diverges in the classical model when the squared cubic coefficient dominates the quartic one. Files: paper1_jmp.pdf (manuscript, 22 pages); verify_paper1.py (Python 3 script that reproduces the numerical values reported in the paper; requires numpy, scipy and sympy; about 20 seconds; comments are in Japanese). The following article has been submitted to the Journal of Mathematical Physics. After it is published, it will be found at https://pubs.aip.org/aip/jmp.

•Oct 4, 2026•0 citations

Bootstrapping Euclidean Two-point Correlators

Minjae Cho, Barak Gabai, Henry W. Lin +2 more

We develop a bootstrap approach to Euclidean two-point correlators, in the thermal or ground state of quantum mechanical systems. We formulate the problem of bounding the two-point correlator as a semidefinite programming problem, subject to the constraints of reflection positivity, the Heisenberg equations of motion, and the Kubo-Martin-Schwinger condition or ground-state positivity. In the dual formulation, the Heisenberg equations of motion become "inequalities of motion" on the Lagrange multipliers that enforce the constraints. This enables us to derive rigorous bounds on continuous-time two-point correlators using a finite-dimensional semidefinite or polynomial matrix program. We illustrate this method by bootstrapping the two-point correlators of the ungauged one-matrix quantum mechanics, from which we extract the spectrum and matrix elements of the low-lying adjoint states. Along the way, we provide a new derivation of the energy-entropy balance inequality and establish a connection between the high-temperature two-point correlator bootstrap and the matrix integral bootstrap.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2511.08560•Journal of High Energy Physics•Nov 12, 2025•11 citations
The numerical bootstrap for quantum mechanics tests a candidate state's positivity only against sums of squares, whereas every physical state assigns nonnegative expectation to every pointwise nonnegative polynomial. In one dimension the two coincide; in two or more they do not. Whether this gap is realized depends sharply on which constraint set is imposed. For the stationary bootstrap, which imposes <[H,O]> = 0 and is the relaxation appropriate to thermal and mixed states, we exhibit a two-dimensional quartic double well and a moment vector that satisfies every level-three stationary constraint exactly, has a positive definite moment matrix, and yet assigns a negative expectation to a polynomial nonnegative on R^2; it is therefore the moment sequence of no state. All data are rational, and every step is verified in exact arithmetic. For the eigenstate bootstrap, which additionally imposes = E, the same search finds no violation in any of five settings spanning two, three and five degrees of freedom and truncation levels three and four, tested against complete families of separating polynomials. The single exception occurs at a truncation so low that only one eigenstate constraint survives, and the theory presented here accounts for it. We identify the mechanism: the eigenstate constraints bound the high momentum moments, otherwise unbounded on the feasible set, and it is those unbounded directions that reach the region between the two cones. Finally, under the reflection symmetries of a typical potential the relevant obstruction is copositivity rather than nonnegativity, which, for the quartic witnesses available at the lowest truncation, places the first possible failure at five degrees of freedom. We conjecture that the eigenstate constraints imply an Archimedean-type bound on the momentum moments, and formulate the corresponding tightness statement.
For the coupled three-dimensional double well H=12∣p∣2+2∑i(qi2−1)2−∑i<jqi2qj2H=\tfrac12|p|^2+2\sum_i(q_i^2-1)^2-\sum_{i<j}q_i^2q_j^2H=21​∣p∣2+2∑i​(qi2​−1)2−∑i<j​qi2​qj2​ we exhibit, at the first excited energy level (and also at the ground state), a linear functional on polynomials of degree ≤6\le 6≤6 that satisfies every constraint of the standard level-3 eigenstate bootstrap, has a \emph{strictly} positive definite moment matrix, and nevertheless assigns a negative value to a nonnegative polynomial. It is therefore an interior point of the level-3 relaxation that is realized by no quantum state. The construction reflects a fact that holds at every level: the eigenstate rows never reach the top-degree momentum moments. At level 3, where strictly feasible points exist, this means that the corresponding block of the moment matrix carries no information about which energies admit one. Every algebraic ingredient is an exact rational certificate, and the only numerical ingredients (spectral enclosures of an eigenfunction) are carried out in rigorous ball arithmetic.
The eigenstate quantum-mechanical bootstrap can converge to the physical moment set while remaining nonexact at every finite order. We prove this for a one-dimensional quasi-exactly solvable sextic oscillator at explicitly known eigenvalues, including excited levels. At every finite order, the lower and upper bounds on u2u^2u2 remain strictly below and above its physical value, even after adjoining arbitrary finite polynomial Gram tests and all eigenstate-annihilator relations visible in the retained moment space. Hence neither side of the centered observable admits a finite sum-of-squares certificate modulo the eigenstate annihilator. The gap persists under any finite set of additional localizing constraints whose weights are strictly positive on polynomial vectors. We then prove convergence for polynomial Schrödinger operators satisfying explicit sum-of-squares confinement and derivative bounds. The eigenstate relations give moment estimates uniform in the truncation order; these yield a regular Schrödinger representation supported on the prescribed eigenspace. Finally, a four-mode extension combines this fixed-observable obstruction with feasible position moments having no positive representing measure at every finite order. At level three, this construction yields nonphysical feasible points with strictly positive definite moment matrices.
We present a semidefinite programming algorithm to find eigenvalues of Schrödinger operators within the bootstrap approach to quantum mechanics. The bootstrap approach involves two ingredients: a nonlinear set of constraints on the variables (expectation values of operators in an energy eigenstate), plus positivity constraints (unitarity) that need to be satisfied. By fixing the energy we linearize all the constraints and show that the feasibility problem can be presented as an optimization problem for the variables that are not fixed by the constraints and one additional slack variable that measures the failure of positivity. To illustrate the method we are able to obtain high-precision, sharp bounds on eigenenergies for arbitrary confining polynomial potentials in one dimension.
We establish exact thresholds for the failure of simultaneous quantum typicality: three parties for mixed states and four for pure states. For the four-qubit Higuchi--Sudbery state, every sequence satisfying the expected purity bounds on three overlapping marginals, with sufficiently small fixed positive entropy slack, is asymptotically perfectly distinguishable from the tensor powers of the input: its trace distance from them tends to the maximum value 222. This maximal separation persists, with a common positive slack, throughout an open neighborhood in the full four-qubit state space. Tracing out one party yields a mixed tripartite example. The proof connects simultaneous quantum smoothing with polynomial concentration on $\CP^1$. Symmetry reduces the problem to a frame inequality on $\Sym^n(\mathbb C^2)$, where a linear entropy deficit competes with a quadratic cost of polynomial concentration. Bernstein--Markov estimates and a subharmonic barrier control this cost, yielding an exponential obstruction to simultaneous typicality. These results disprove Dutil's multiparty quantum typicality conjecture, formulated in 2011, and the one-shot simultaneous min-entropy-smoothing conjectures of Drescher--Fawzi and Colomer--Winter. Together with the positive results for smaller systems, they determine the smallest numbers of parties at which simultaneous typicality can fail.
We study the quantum exponential family of n bosonic modes generated by the phase-space polynomials of degree at most four, and the maximization of the von Neumann entropy under prescribed moments up to order four, the quantum analogue of a classical problem of Junk. We prove that the family is an analytic dually flat manifold with the Bogoliubov–Kubo–Mori metric and that strong duality holds for moment data in the interior of the realizable region. For such data, and under a density hypothesis also in the relative interior of faces, we characterize nonexistence completely: the maximizer fails to exist exactly when the data are the moments of a family member plus an excess fourth-order tensor supported on the null directions of its quartic part. For one mode, the kernel of a nonzero positive semidefinite polynomial operator of degree at most four has dimension at most two, so that maximizers also exist on the boundary. For two or more modes the admissible set is strictly larger than the classical one (companion paper); faces of infinite dimension occur, and nonexistence of Junk type appears inside faces. We compute the curvature of two-parameter photon-number families at their stratum b = 0, which equals −(1 + 3v₂)/2 for quadratic variance functions and −2 for thermal states. Near the Gaussian boundary the log-partition function stays bounded along regular approaches (in a one-dimensional classical model and for one mode) and diverges in the classical model when the squared cubic coefficient dominates the quartic one. Files: paper1_jmp.pdf (manuscript, 22 pages); verify_paper1.py (Python 3 script that reproduces the numerical values reported in the paper; requires numpy, scipy and sympy; about 20 seconds; comments are in Japanese). The following article has been submitted to the Journal of Mathematical Physics. After it is published, it will be found at https://pubs.aip.org/aip/jmp.
We develop a bootstrap approach to Euclidean two-point correlators, in the thermal or ground state of quantum mechanical systems. We formulate the problem of bounding the two-point correlator as a semidefinite programming problem, subject to the constraints of reflection positivity, the Heisenberg equations of motion, and the Kubo-Martin-Schwinger condition or ground-state positivity. In the dual formulation, the Heisenberg equations of motion become "inequalities of motion" on the Lagrange multipliers that enforce the constraints. This enables us to derive rigorous bounds on continuous-time two-point correlators using a finite-dimensional semidefinite or polynomial matrix program. We illustrate this method by bootstrapping the two-point correlators of the ungauged one-matrix quantum mechanics, from which we extract the spectrum and matrix elements of the low-lying adjoint states. Along the way, we provide a new derivation of the energy-entropy balance inequality and establish a connection between the high-temperature two-point correlator bootstrap and the matrix integral bootstrap.