Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.07775

Convergence Without Finite Exactness in the Eigenstate Quantum Bootstrap

Ye Zhou, Daniel Keren

math-phquant-phSubmitted Oct 6, 2026• Announced Oct 7, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The eigenstate quantum-mechanical bootstrap can converge to the physical moment set while remaining nonexact at every finite order. We prove this for a one-dimensional quasi-exactly solvable sextic oscillator at explicitly known eigenvalues, including excited levels. At every finite order, the lower and upper bounds on $u^2$ remain strictly below and above its physical value, even after adjoining arbitrary finite polynomial Gram tests and all eigenstate-annihilator relations visible in the retained moment space. Hence neither side of the centered observable admits a finite sum-of-squares certificate modulo the eigenstate annihilator. The gap persists under any finite set of additional localizing constraints whose weights are strictly positive on polynomial vectors. We then prove convergence for polynomial Schrödinger operators satisfying explicit sum-of-squares confinement and derivative bounds. The eigenstate relations give moment estimates uniform in the truncation order; these yield a regular Schrödinger representation supported on the prescribed eigenspace. Finally, a four-mode extension combines this fixed-observable obstruction with feasible position moments having no positive representing measure at every finite order. At level three, this construction yields nonphysical feasible points with strictly positive definite moment matrices.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether the eigenstate quantum bootstrap can converge to physical moments without becoming exact at any finite truncation. It separates finite-order feasibility, exact bounds on a fixed observable, and asymptotic reconstruction for polynomial Schrödinger Hamiltonians. For the sextic oscillator $h=\tfrac12(p^2+u^6-11u^2)$, it proves that at the explicitly known energies $e=-4,0,4$—the ground, second-excited and fourth-excited levels—the bootstrap bounds on $\langle u^2\rangle$ strictly bracket the physical value at every order $K\ge3$. This remains true after arbitrary finite polynomial Gram tests, all retained eigenstate-annihilator relations, and finitely many localizing tests with weights strictly positive on polynomial vectors. Consequently, neither sign of the centered observable has a finite polynomial-square certificate modulo the annihilator. The construction deforms a quartic-weight moment recurrence while preserving eigenstate identities; finite-degree positivity survives near the physical parameter. A separate convergence theorem assumes explicit SOS confinement and derivative-domination identities. Uniform moment bounds yield compactness and analytic vectors in the limiting GNS representation; integration of the canonical relations reconstructs a Schrödinger density operator supported on the prescribed eigenspace. Fixed-degree moment projections converge to the physical set, and nonspectral energies eventually become infeasible. A four-mode extension supplies feasible position moments without a positive representing measure at every finite order, including strictly positive definite moment matrices at level three, using a Robinson-sextic witness. This particular construction is removable by a localizing inequality. The convergence assumptions may be restrictive; no quantitative convergence rates or effective energy-exclusion levels are obtained.

No sign of AI-generated textStrong assumptions

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
36 pages. Numerical scripts and solver inputs and outputs included as ancillary files. Companion paper: arXiv:2610.03362

Related papers

Strict non-tightness of the level-3 quantum bootstrap for a natural three-dimensional Hamiltonian, at an excited level

Daniel Keren, Ye Zhou

For the coupled three-dimensional double well $H=\tfrac12|p|^2+2\sum_i(q_i^2-1)^2-\sum_{i<j}q_i^2q_j^2$ we exhibit, at the first excited energy level (and also at the ground state), a linear functional on polynomials of degree $\le 6$ that satisfies every constraint of the standard level-3 eigenstate bootstrap, has a \emph{strictly} positive definite moment matrix, and nevertheless assigns a negative value to a nonnegative polynomial. It is therefore an interior point of the level-3 relaxation that is realized by no quantum state. The construction reflects a fact that holds at every level: the eigenstate rows never reach the top-degree momentum moments. At level 3, where strictly feasible points exist, this means that the corresponding block of the moment matrix carries no information about which energies admit one. Every algebraic ingredient is an exact rational certificate, and the only numerical ingredients (spectral enclosures of an eigenfunction) are carried out in rigorous ball arithmetic.

quant-pharXiv:2610.03362•Oct 5, 2026•1 citation

Semidefinite programming algorithm for the quantum mechanical bootstrap

David E Berenstein, George Hulsey

We present a semidefinite programming algorithm to find eigenvalues of Schrödinger operators within the bootstrap approach to quantum mechanics. The bootstrap approach involves two ingredients: a nonlinear set of constraints on the variables (expectation values of operators in an energy eigenstate), plus positivity constraints (unitarity) that need to be satisfied. By fixing the energy we linearize all the constraints and show that the feasibility problem can be presented as an optimization problem for the variables that are not fixed by the constraints and one additional slack variable that measures the failure of positivity. To illustrate the method we are able to obtain high-precision, sharp bounds on eigenenergies for arbitrary confining polynomial potentials in one dimension.

arXiv:2209.14332•Physical review. E•May 23, 2023•33 citations

The Completeness of Eigenstates in Quantum Mechanics

Guoping Zhang

We delineate the scope of research on the completeness of eigenstates in quantum mechanics. Based on the limit of the potential function at infinity, the proof of completeness is divided into eight cases, and theoretical proofs or numerical simulations are provided for each case. We present the definition of orthonormalization for general free states and the solution to the normalization coefficients, as well as a general set of initial states, which simplifies and concretizes the proof of completeness. Additionally, we define the spectral function for continuous energy eigenvalues. By taking the spectral function as the original integral variable of the expansion function, the relationship between the measured probability amplitude and the expansion function is endowed with the physical meaning of coordinate-momentum transformation.

quant-pharXiv:2601.01136•Jan 6, 2026•0 citations

Stationarity is not enough: tightness of the quantum mechanical bootstrap and the copositive cone

Daniel Keren

The numerical bootstrap for quantum mechanics tests a candidate state's positivity only against sums of squares, whereas every physical state assigns nonnegative expectation to every pointwise nonnegative polynomial. In one dimension the two coincide; in two or more they do not. Whether this gap is realized depends sharply on which constraint set is imposed. For the stationary bootstrap, which imposes <[H,O]> = 0 and is the relaxation appropriate to thermal and mixed states, we exhibit a two-dimensional quartic double well and a moment vector that satisfies every level-three stationary constraint exactly, has a positive definite moment matrix, and yet assigns a negative expectation to a polynomial nonnegative on R^2; it is therefore the moment sequence of no state. All data are rational, and every step is verified in exact arithmetic. For the eigenstate bootstrap, which additionally imposes = E, the same search finds no violation in any of five settings spanning two, three and five degrees of freedom and truncation levels three and four, tested against complete families of separating polynomials. The single exception occurs at a truncation so low that only one eigenstate constraint survives, and the theory presented here accounts for it. We identify the mechanism: the eigenstate constraints bound the high momentum moments, otherwise unbounded on the feasible set, and it is those unbounded directions that reach the region between the two cones. Finally, under the reflection symmetries of a typical potential the relevant obstruction is copositivity rather than nonnegativity, which, for the quartic witnesses available at the lowest truncation, places the first possible failure at five degrees of freedom. We conjecture that the eigenstate constraints imply an Archimedean-type bound on the momentum moments, and formulate the corresponding tightness statement.

arXiv:2608.07047•Aug 7, 2026•3 citations

Quantum mechanical bootstrap without inequalities: SYK bilinear spectrum

Kok Hong Thong, David Vegh

We study a quantum mechanical system whose spectrum coincides with that of bilinear operators of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model. The standard positivity-based quantum mechanical bootstrap is degenerate with respect to the boundary data: it does not distinguish the boundary conditions that select the SYK spectrum, and hence is insufficient to determine the eigenvalues. Instead, by considering fractional powers of operators, we obtain constraint equations that determine the spectrum without imposing positivity. The resulting roots converge to exact eigenvalues as the truncation order increases. We call this the direct bootstrap.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2604.26007•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Apr 30, 2026•1 citation

Complete Gauss Cutoffs and Certified Spectral Gaps for Finite SU(3) Lattice Gauge Hamiltonians

Ken Umeno

We construct complete Gauss cutoffs and certify spectral gaps for finite SU(3) lattice gauge Hamiltonians with positive electric coefficients and Wilson potentials. Each cutoff retains all allowed edge representations and invariant tensors. A separate finite extension retains every one-step Wilson output and determines the exact boundary Gram matrix. Decomposing these outputs by excess-edge sets gives local overlap and electric-energy- relative bounds. Under explicit uniform local hypotheses, they imply a volume-independent O(N−2) norm-resolvent error for the Hamiltonian before vacuum subtraction. A quadratic- form Schur argument combines the finite data with an analytic bound on the entire omitted space to certify the original untruncated operator. For two adjacent plaquettes, the complete cutoff has dimension nine and its full-output extension has dimension thirty-five. Exact rational arithmetic gives eigenvalue intervals, a gap lower bound 154/39 at coupling 1/2, and the bound 3/5 throughout [1/2, 5/6]. We also give an exact weighted-cycle formula for the electric gap and an explicit positive interacting gap on each fixed graph. As a representation result, a common Cauchy-relative Perron–Frobenius embedding transports the heat semigroup, Gauss constraints, and ordered observables. Its integer parameter K does not determine a physical gap law in log K. Conditional limit statements identify the additional vacuum, reconstruction, and uniform infrared estimates required for a four-dimensional Yang–Mills theory.

•Oct 12, 2026•0 citations
The eigenstate quantum-mechanical bootstrap can converge to the physical moment set while remaining nonexact at every finite order. We prove this for a one-dimensional quasi-exactly solvable sextic oscillator at explicitly known eigenvalues, including excited levels. At every finite order, the lower and upper bounds on u2u^2u2 remain strictly below and above its physical value, even after adjoining arbitrary finite polynomial Gram tests and all eigenstate-annihilator relations visible in the retained moment space. Hence neither side of the centered observable admits a finite sum-of-squares certificate modulo the eigenstate annihilator. The gap persists under any finite set of additional localizing constraints whose weights are strictly positive on polynomial vectors. We then prove convergence for polynomial Schrödinger operators satisfying explicit sum-of-squares confinement and derivative bounds. The eigenstate relations give moment estimates uniform in the truncation order; these yield a regular Schrödinger representation supported on the prescribed eigenspace. Finally, a four-mode extension combines this fixed-observable obstruction with feasible position moments having no positive representing measure at every finite order. At level three, this construction yields nonphysical feasible points with strictly positive definite moment matrices.
The paper asks whether the eigenstate quantum bootstrap can converge to physical moments without becoming exact at any finite truncation. It separates finite-order feasibility, exact bounds on a fixed observable, and asymptotic reconstruction for polynomial Schrödinger Hamiltonians.
For the sextic oscillator h=12(p2+u6−11u2)h=\tfrac12(p^2+u^6-11u^2)h=21​(p2+u6−11u2), it proves that at the explicitly known energies e=−4,0,4e=-4,0,4e=−4,0,4—the ground, second-excited and fourth-excited levels—the bootstrap bounds on ⟨u2⟩\langle u^2\rangle⟨u2⟩ strictly bracket the physical value at every order K≥3K\ge3K≥3. This remains true after arbitrary finite polynomial Gram tests, all retained eigenstate-annihilator relations, and finitely many localizing tests with weights strictly positive on polynomial vectors. Consequently, neither sign of the centered observable has a finite polynomial-square certificate modulo the annihilator. The construction deforms a quartic-weight moment recurrence while preserving eigenstate identities; finite-degree positivity survives near the physical parameter.
A separate convergence theorem assumes explicit SOS confinement and derivative-domination identities. Uniform moment bounds yield compactness and analytic vectors in the limiting GNS representation; integration of the canonical relations reconstructs a Schrödinger density operator supported on the prescribed eigenspace. Fixed-degree moment projections converge to the physical set, and nonspectral energies eventually become infeasible.
A four-mode extension supplies feasible position moments without a positive representing measure at every finite order, including strictly positive definite moment matrices at level three, using a Robinson-sextic witness. This particular construction is removable by a localizing inequality. The convergence assumptions may be restrictive; no quantitative convergence rates or effective energy-exclusion levels are obtained.
For the coupled three-dimensional double well H=12∣p∣2+2∑i(qi2−1)2−∑i<jqi2qj2H=\tfrac12|p|^2+2\sum_i(q_i^2-1)^2-\sum_{i<j}q_i^2q_j^2H=21​∣p∣2+2∑i​(qi2​−1)2−∑i<j​qi2​qj2​ we exhibit, at the first excited energy level (and also at the ground state), a linear functional on polynomials of degree ≤6\le 6≤6 that satisfies every constraint of the standard level-3 eigenstate bootstrap, has a \emph{strictly} positive definite moment matrix, and nevertheless assigns a negative value to a nonnegative polynomial. It is therefore an interior point of the level-3 relaxation that is realized by no quantum state. The construction reflects a fact that holds at every level: the eigenstate rows never reach the top-degree momentum moments. At level 3, where strictly feasible points exist, this means that the corresponding block of the moment matrix carries no information about which energies admit one. Every algebraic ingredient is an exact rational certificate, and the only numerical ingredients (spectral enclosures of an eigenfunction) are carried out in rigorous ball arithmetic.
We present a semidefinite programming algorithm to find eigenvalues of Schrödinger operators within the bootstrap approach to quantum mechanics. The bootstrap approach involves two ingredients: a nonlinear set of constraints on the variables (expectation values of operators in an energy eigenstate), plus positivity constraints (unitarity) that need to be satisfied. By fixing the energy we linearize all the constraints and show that the feasibility problem can be presented as an optimization problem for the variables that are not fixed by the constraints and one additional slack variable that measures the failure of positivity. To illustrate the method we are able to obtain high-precision, sharp bounds on eigenenergies for arbitrary confining polynomial potentials in one dimension.
We delineate the scope of research on the completeness of eigenstates in quantum mechanics. Based on the limit of the potential function at infinity, the proof of completeness is divided into eight cases, and theoretical proofs or numerical simulations are provided for each case. We present the definition of orthonormalization for general free states and the solution to the normalization coefficients, as well as a general set of initial states, which simplifies and concretizes the proof of completeness. Additionally, we define the spectral function for continuous energy eigenvalues. By taking the spectral function as the original integral variable of the expansion function, the relationship between the measured probability amplitude and the expansion function is endowed with the physical meaning of coordinate-momentum transformation.
The numerical bootstrap for quantum mechanics tests a candidate state's positivity only against sums of squares, whereas every physical state assigns nonnegative expectation to every pointwise nonnegative polynomial. In one dimension the two coincide; in two or more they do not. Whether this gap is realized depends sharply on which constraint set is imposed. For the stationary bootstrap, which imposes <[H,O]> = 0 and is the relaxation appropriate to thermal and mixed states, we exhibit a two-dimensional quartic double well and a moment vector that satisfies every level-three stationary constraint exactly, has a positive definite moment matrix, and yet assigns a negative expectation to a polynomial nonnegative on R^2; it is therefore the moment sequence of no state. All data are rational, and every step is verified in exact arithmetic. For the eigenstate bootstrap, which additionally imposes = E, the same search finds no violation in any of five settings spanning two, three and five degrees of freedom and truncation levels three and four, tested against complete families of separating polynomials. The single exception occurs at a truncation so low that only one eigenstate constraint survives, and the theory presented here accounts for it. We identify the mechanism: the eigenstate constraints bound the high momentum moments, otherwise unbounded on the feasible set, and it is those unbounded directions that reach the region between the two cones. Finally, under the reflection symmetries of a typical potential the relevant obstruction is copositivity rather than nonnegativity, which, for the quartic witnesses available at the lowest truncation, places the first possible failure at five degrees of freedom. We conjecture that the eigenstate constraints imply an Archimedean-type bound on the momentum moments, and formulate the corresponding tightness statement.
We study a quantum mechanical system whose spectrum coincides with that of bilinear operators of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model. The standard positivity-based quantum mechanical bootstrap is degenerate with respect to the boundary data: it does not distinguish the boundary conditions that select the SYK spectrum, and hence is insufficient to determine the eigenvalues. Instead, by considering fractional powers of operators, we obtain constraint equations that determine the spectrum without imposing positivity. The resulting roots converge to exact eigenvalues as the truncation order increases. We call this the direct bootstrap.
We construct complete Gauss cutoffs and certify spectral gaps for finite SU(3) lattice gauge Hamiltonians with positive electric coefficients and Wilson potentials. Each cutoff retains all allowed edge representations and invariant tensors. A separate finite extension retains every one-step Wilson output and determines the exact boundary Gram matrix. Decomposing these outputs by excess-edge sets gives local overlap and electric-energy- relative bounds. Under explicit uniform local hypotheses, they imply a volume-independent O(N−2) norm-resolvent error for the Hamiltonian before vacuum subtraction. A quadratic- form Schur argument combines the finite data with an analytic bound on the entire omitted space to certify the original untruncated operator. For two adjacent plaquettes, the complete cutoff has dimension nine and its full-output extension has dimension thirty-five. Exact rational arithmetic gives eigenvalue intervals, a gap lower bound 154/39 at coupling 1/2, and the bound 3/5 throughout [1/2, 5/6]. We also give an exact weighted-cycle formula for the electric gap and an explicit positive interacting gap on each fixed graph. As a representation result, a common Cauchy-relative Perron–Frobenius embedding transports the heat semigroup, Gauss constraints, and ordered observables. Its integer parameter K does not determine a physical gap law in log K. Conditional limit statements identify the additional vacuum, reconstruction, and uniform infrared estimates required for a four-dimensional Yang–Mills theory.