Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2602.05626 · Physical Review Letters

Direct comparison of multi-ion optical clocks based on 40 Ca + and 88 Sr +

Yosef Sokolik, Roee Ozeri, Nitzan Akerman

Published Nov 9, 2026• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We report the first direct frequency comparison between two multi-ion optical clocks based on the S$_{1/2}$ to D$_{5/2}$ transition in \Ca and \Sr ions. Using linear chains of up to nine \Ca ions and six \Sr ions, we demonstrate improved stability as a function of the number of ions that are contributing to the laser frequency stabilization servo. The measured joint fractional frequency stability of the two clocks reaches $1.37(12)\times 10^{-15}$ at one second, placing an upper bound on the same stability of one of the clocks at $9.6(8)\times 10^{-16}$ in one second. We measured the frequency ratio of the two clocks to be $R_{\text{Sr/Ca}}=1.082076536381896986(18)$, where the systematic uncertainty is primarily limited by the room temperature blackbody radiation. Our direct measurement represents an order of magnitude improvement compared to existing indirect frequency ratio measurements. Furthermore, by combining our results with recent absolute frequency measurements of the \Sr transition, referenced to a primary frequency standard, we refined the absolute frequency of the \Ca transition to $ν_{\text{Ca}^+}=411042129776400.21(4)$ Hz, reducing its uncertainty by a factor of three. This study presents the first direct comparison between two multi-ion optical clocks, highlighting their significant potential for future applications in fundamental physics tests, geodesy, and precision metrology.

DOI
10.1103/kny3-9tsz

Related papers

Evaluation of a Sr+88 Optical Clock with a Direct Measurement of the Blackbody Radiation Shift and Determination of the Clock Frequency

Martin Steinel, H. Shao, Melina Filzinger +7 more

We report on an evaluation of an optical clock that uses the ^{2}S_{1/2}→^{2}D_{5/2} transition of a single ^{88}Sr^{+} ion as the reference. In contrast to previous work, we estimate the effective temperature of the blackbody radiation that shifts the reference transition directly during operation from the corresponding frequency shift and the well-characterized sensitivity to thermal radiation. We measure the clock output frequency against an independent ^{171}Yb^{+} ion clock, based on the ^{2}S_{1/2}(F=0)→^{2}F_{7/2}(F=3) electric octupole (E3) transition, and determine the frequency ratio with a total fractional uncertainty of 2.3×10^{-17}. Relying on a previous measurement of the ^{171}Yb^{+} (E3) clock frequency, we find the absolute frequency of the ^{88}Sr^{+} clock transition to be 444 779 044 095 485.277(59) Hz. Our result reduces the uncertainty by a factor of 3 compared with the previously most accurate measurement and may help to resolve so far inconsistent determinations of this value. We also show that for three simultaneously interrogated ^{88}Sr^{+} ions, the increased number causes the expected improvement of the short-term frequency instability of the optical clock without degrading its systematic uncertainty.

arXiv:2212.08687•Physical Review Letters•Aug 23, 2023•31 citations

Progress towards a 40Ca+ optical clock with a fractional uncertainty at the 10−18 level

Yao Huang, Hua Guan, Kelin Gao

We recently reported a 5×10-17level frequency comparison of two40Ca+optical clocks, one of which has fractional frequency uncertainty of 3.4×10-17, limited by the BBR effect. Here we present progress towards a40Ca+optical clock with uncertainty at the 10-18level. The differential static scalar polarizability Δα0 of the40Ca+ion clock transition is obtained by precisely measuring the “magic” rf drive frequency. Δα0 is measured as -7.2653(44)x10-40J m2/V2, the blackbody radiation shift is then calculated to be 0.3790(2) Hz at 300 K. The contribution of the blackbody shift coefficient to the uncertainty of the optical clock at room temperature is reduced to 5.6×10-19, the excess micromotion induced clock uncertainty is also reduced to the 10-19level by choosing the appropriate trap drive frequency. With a suppression of the BBR field temperature uncertainty to the sub-Kelvin level and improved clock stability, a robust, relatively low-cost40Ca+ion clock with uncertainty at 10-18level can be made.

Joint Conference of the European Frequency and Time Forum and IEEE International Frequency Control Symposium (EFTF/IFCS)•Jul 1, 2017•0 citations

Progress on the 40Ca+ ion optical clock*

Baolin Zhang, Yao Huang, Huaqing Zhang +4 more

Progress of the 40Ca+ ion optical clock based on the 42S1/2 – 3d 2D5/2 electric quadrupole transition is reported. By setting the drive frequency to the “magic” frequency Ω 0, the frequency uncertainty caused by the scalar Stark shift and second-order Doppler shift induced by micromotion is reduced to the 10−19 level. By precisely measuring the differential static scalar polarizability Δα 0, the uncertainty due to the blackbody radiation (BBR) shift (coefficient) is reduced to the 10−19 level. With the help of a second-order integrating servo algorithm, the uncertainty due to the servo error is reduced to the 10−18 level. The total fractional uncertainty of the 40Ca+ ion optical clock is then improved to 2.2× 10−17, whereas this value is mainly restricted by the uncertainty of the BBR shift due to temperature fluctuations. The state preparation is introduced together with improvements in the pulse sequence, and furthermore, a better signal to noise ratio (SNR) and less dead time are achieved. The clock stability of a single clock is improved to 4.8 × 10 − 15 / τ ( in seconds ) .

Chinese Physics B•May 19, 2020•18 citations

AN OPTICAL CLOCK BASED ON A SINGLE TRAPPED 88 Sr + ION

Helen S. Margolis, G. P. Barwood, G. HUANG +6 more

The 5 s 2 S 1/2 -4 d 2 D 5/2 electric quadrupole transition in a single trapped and laser-cooled 88 Sr + ion provides the reference for a highly stable and accurate optical clock. This paper describes recent progress on the 88 Sr + optical clocks under development at NPL. An ultrastable laser at 674 nm is used to excite the clock transition and a fractional frequency resolution of 2 × 10 -14 has been achieved, corresponding to a linewidth of 9 Hz. A relative frequency instability of 2 × 10 -15 at 5000 s has been observed in the comparison between two similar systems and the fractional uncertainty in the absolute frequency of the clock transition is 3.8 × 10 -15 . Improvements to the experimental arrangement are in progress and are expected to lead to a 88 Sr + optical clock with stability and reproducibility exceeding that of the primary caesium standard.

Symposium on Frequency Standards and Metrology•May 1, 2009•0 citations

A multi-ion optical clock with $\mathbf{5 \times 10^{-19}}$ uncertainty

Melina Filzinger, Martin R. Steinel, Jian Jiang +4 more

Today's most accurate clocks are based on laser spectroscopy of electronic transitions in single trapped ions and feature fractional frequency uncertainties below $1\times10^{-18}$. Scaling these systems to multiple, simultaneously interrogated ions reduces measurement times, driving recent advances in multi-ion clocks. However, maintaining state-of-the-art systematic uncertainties while increasing the number of ions remains a central challenge. Here, we report on a multi-ion optical atomic clock with a fractional frequency uncertainty of $5.3\times10^{-19}$ and up to 10 \Sr ions. Ion-resolved state detection enables minimization of position-dependent shifts, with residual effects suppressed below the $10^{-20}$-level. Clock operation with eight to ten ions reduces the measurement time by a factor of 4.8 compared to single-ion operation. A comparison with an established \Yb single-ion clock yields an unperturbed frequency ratio of $0.6926711632159660405(20)$, with a statistical uncertainty of $0.9\times10^{-18}$ and a combined uncertainty of $2.9\times 10^{-18}$. These results demonstrate robust multi-ion clock operation with reduced averaging time and state-of-the-art accuracy.

physics.atom-phCross-listedarXiv:2603.23446•Mar 25, 2026•9 citations

Frequency ratio measurement of Al⁺ at the 10⁻¹⁸ level

Fabian Dawel

The invention of the atomic clock has enabled applications like the global navigation satellite system, are important for telecommunication and are used for the definition of the SI second. Nowadays, optical clocks allow for measurement of height differences on the centimeter scale and can be employed for tests of the standard model of particle physics. Among the various implementations of optical clocks, this thesis focuses on an Al⁺ clock. For this work an optical resonator is examined, which enables the simultaneous frequency stabilization of two laser on the same mirror pair through the use of a dual-wavelength coating. Various contributions on the frequency stability are characterized and correlations are investigated. This cavity enables high fidelities in coherent manipulation of trapped ions, as required to operate the Al⁺ clock. This thesis partly builds upon the findings presented in Ref. Kramer, 2023. The setup and the systematic shifts are revisited and a detailed evaluation of the shifts is conducted, resulting in a total fractional frequency uncertainty of 1.6×10⁻¹⁸. The biggest contribution is from an ac-Stark shift induced by cooling during the clock interrogation, resulting in a shift of −9.3(1.1) × 10⁻¹⁸. The cooling reduces the second order Doppler shift to −1.6(0.2)×10⁻¹⁸. Additionally, a position dependent micromotion of the ion was investigated, which contributes an uncertainty of 0.38 × 10⁻¹⁸. Moreover, the first-order Doppler shift, servo error, ac-Stark shift of the clock laser and the phase chirp are determined for the first time, showing uncertainties below 10⁻¹⁸. The first frequency comparison between the Al⁺ clock and the ¹¹⁵In⁺, ¹⁷¹Yb⁺ and ⁸⁷Sr clocks at PTB are demonstrated. Measurements against Sr reveal a stability of the Al+ clock of 5.9 × 10⁻¹⁶ at 1s , which is one of the best single ion clock stabilities to date. All measured frequency ratios fall within the 10⁻¹⁸ uncertainty regime. The ratio between Sr/Al⁺ exhibits a significant deviation of more than 8.6𝜎 from published measurement data, underscoring the importance of inter-institutional frequency ratio measurements to verify the uncertainty budgets and reproducibility of optical clocks.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations
We report the first direct frequency comparison between two multi-ion optical clocks based on the S1/2_{1/2}1/2​ to D5/2_{5/2}5/2​ transition in \Ca and \Sr ions. Using linear chains of up to nine \Ca ions and six \Sr ions, we demonstrate improved stability as a function of the number of ions that are contributing to the laser frequency stabilization servo. The measured joint fractional frequency stability of the two clocks reaches 1.37(12)×10−151.37(12)\times 10^{-15}1.37(12)×10−15 at one second, placing an upper bound on the same stability of one of the clocks at 9.6(8)×10−169.6(8)\times 10^{-16}9.6(8)×10−16 in one second. We measured the frequency ratio of the two clocks to be RSr/Ca=1.082076536381896986(18)R_{\text{Sr/Ca}}=1.082076536381896986(18)RSr/Ca​=1.082076536381896986(18), where the systematic uncertainty is primarily limited by the room temperature blackbody radiation. Our direct measurement represents an order of magnitude improvement compared to existing indirect frequency ratio measurements. Furthermore, by combining our results with recent absolute frequency measurements of the \Sr transition, referenced to a primary frequency standard, we refined the absolute frequency of the \Ca transition to νCa+=411042129776400.21(4)ν_{\text{Ca}^+}=411042129776400.21(4)νCa+​=411042129776400.21(4) Hz, reducing its uncertainty by a factor of three. This study presents the first direct comparison between two multi-ion optical clocks, highlighting their significant potential for future applications in fundamental physics tests, geodesy, and precision metrology.
We report on an evaluation of an optical clock that uses the ^{2}S_{1/2}→^{2}D_{5/2} transition of a single ^{88}Sr^{+} ion as the reference. In contrast to previous work, we estimate the effective temperature of the blackbody radiation that shifts the reference transition directly during operation from the corresponding frequency shift and the well-characterized sensitivity to thermal radiation. We measure the clock output frequency against an independent ^{171}Yb^{+} ion clock, based on the ^{2}S_{1/2}(F=0)→^{2}F_{7/2}(F=3) electric octupole (E3) transition, and determine the frequency ratio with a total fractional uncertainty of 2.3×10^{-17}. Relying on a previous measurement of the ^{171}Yb^{+} (E3) clock frequency, we find the absolute frequency of the ^{88}Sr^{+} clock transition to be 444 779 044 095 485.277(59) Hz. Our result reduces the uncertainty by a factor of 3 compared with the previously most accurate measurement and may help to resolve so far inconsistent determinations of this value. We also show that for three simultaneously interrogated ^{88}Sr^{+} ions, the increased number causes the expected improvement of the short-term frequency instability of the optical clock without degrading its systematic uncertainty.
We recently reported a 5×10-17level frequency comparison of two40Ca+optical clocks, one of which has fractional frequency uncertainty of 3.4×10-17, limited by the BBR effect. Here we present progress towards a40Ca+optical clock with uncertainty at the 10-18level. The differential static scalar polarizability Δα0 of the40Ca+ion clock transition is obtained by precisely measuring the “magic” rf drive frequency. Δα0 is measured as -7.2653(44)x10-40J m2/V2, the blackbody radiation shift is then calculated to be 0.3790(2) Hz at 300 K. The contribution of the blackbody shift coefficient to the uncertainty of the optical clock at room temperature is reduced to 5.6×10-19, the excess micromotion induced clock uncertainty is also reduced to the 10-19level by choosing the appropriate trap drive frequency. With a suppression of the BBR field temperature uncertainty to the sub-Kelvin level and improved clock stability, a robust, relatively low-cost40Ca+ion clock with uncertainty at 10-18level can be made.
Progress of the 40Ca+ ion optical clock based on the 42S1/2 – 3d 2D5/2 electric quadrupole transition is reported. By setting the drive frequency to the “magic” frequency Ω 0, the frequency uncertainty caused by the scalar Stark shift and second-order Doppler shift induced by micromotion is reduced to the 10−19 level. By precisely measuring the differential static scalar polarizability Δα 0, the uncertainty due to the blackbody radiation (BBR) shift (coefficient) is reduced to the 10−19 level. With the help of a second-order integrating servo algorithm, the uncertainty due to the servo error is reduced to the 10−18 level. The total fractional uncertainty of the 40Ca+ ion optical clock is then improved to 2.2× 10−17, whereas this value is mainly restricted by the uncertainty of the BBR shift due to temperature fluctuations. The state preparation is introduced together with improvements in the pulse sequence, and furthermore, a better signal to noise ratio (SNR) and less dead time are achieved. The clock stability of a single clock is improved to 4.8 × 10 − 15 / τ ( in seconds ) .
The 5 s 2 S 1/2 -4 d 2 D 5/2 electric quadrupole transition in a single trapped and laser-cooled 88 Sr + ion provides the reference for a highly stable and accurate optical clock. This paper describes recent progress on the 88 Sr + optical clocks under development at NPL. An ultrastable laser at 674 nm is used to excite the clock transition and a fractional frequency resolution of 2 × 10 -14 has been achieved, corresponding to a linewidth of 9 Hz. A relative frequency instability of 2 × 10 -15 at 5000 s has been observed in the comparison between two similar systems and the fractional uncertainty in the absolute frequency of the clock transition is 3.8 × 10 -15 . Improvements to the experimental arrangement are in progress and are expected to lead to a 88 Sr + optical clock with stability and reproducibility exceeding that of the primary caesium standard.
A multi-ion optical clock with 5×10−19\mathbf{5 \times 10^{-19}}5×10−19 uncertainty
Today's most accurate clocks are based on laser spectroscopy of electronic transitions in single trapped ions and feature fractional frequency uncertainties below 1×10−181\times10^{-18}1×10−18. Scaling these systems to multiple, simultaneously interrogated ions reduces measurement times, driving recent advances in multi-ion clocks. However, maintaining state-of-the-art systematic uncertainties while increasing the number of ions remains a central challenge. Here, we report on a multi-ion optical atomic clock with a fractional frequency uncertainty of 5.3×10−195.3\times10^{-19}5.3×10−19 and up to 10 \Sr ions. Ion-resolved state detection enables minimization of position-dependent shifts, with residual effects suppressed below the 10−2010^{-20}10−20-level. Clock operation with eight to ten ions reduces the measurement time by a factor of 4.8 compared to single-ion operation. A comparison with an established \Yb single-ion clock yields an unperturbed frequency ratio of 0.6926711632159660405(20)0.6926711632159660405(20)0.6926711632159660405(20), with a statistical uncertainty of 0.9×10−180.9\times10^{-18}0.9×10−18 and a combined uncertainty of 2.9×10−182.9\times 10^{-18}2.9×10−18. These results demonstrate robust multi-ion clock operation with reduced averaging time and state-of-the-art accuracy.
The invention of the atomic clock has enabled applications like the global navigation satellite system, are important for telecommunication and are used for the definition of the SI second. Nowadays, optical clocks allow for measurement of height differences on the centimeter scale and can be employed for tests of the standard model of particle physics. Among the various implementations of optical clocks, this thesis focuses on an Al⁺ clock. For this work an optical resonator is examined, which enables the simultaneous frequency stabilization of two laser on the same mirror pair through the use of a dual-wavelength coating. Various contributions on the frequency stability are characterized and correlations are investigated. This cavity enables high fidelities in coherent manipulation of trapped ions, as required to operate the Al⁺ clock. This thesis partly builds upon the findings presented in Ref. Kramer, 2023. The setup and the systematic shifts are revisited and a detailed evaluation of the shifts is conducted, resulting in a total fractional frequency uncertainty of 1.6×10⁻¹⁸. The biggest contribution is from an ac-Stark shift induced by cooling during the clock interrogation, resulting in a shift of −9.3(1.1) × 10⁻¹⁸. The cooling reduces the second order Doppler shift to −1.6(0.2)×10⁻¹⁸. Additionally, a position dependent micromotion of the ion was investigated, which contributes an uncertainty of 0.38 × 10⁻¹⁸. Moreover, the first-order Doppler shift, servo error, ac-Stark shift of the clock laser and the phase chirp are determined for the first time, showing uncertainties below 10⁻¹⁸. The first frequency comparison between the Al⁺ clock and the ¹¹⁵In⁺, ¹⁷¹Yb⁺ and ⁸⁷Sr clocks at PTB are demonstrated. Measurements against Sr reveal a stability of the Al+ clock of 5.9 × 10⁻¹⁶ at 1s , which is one of the best single ion clock stabilities to date. All measured frequency ratios fall within the 10⁻¹⁸ uncertainty regime. The ratio between Sr/Al⁺ exhibits a significant deviation of more than 8.6𝜎 from published measurement data, underscoring the importance of inter-institutional frequency ratio measurements to verify the uncertainty budgets and reproducibility of optical clocks.