Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

Systems of identical particles

Donald D. Fitts

Published Aug 26, 1999• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The postulates 1 to 6 of quantum mechanics as stated in Sections 3.7 and 7.2 apply to multi-particle systems provided that each of the particles is distinguishable from the others. For example, the nucleus and the electron in a hydrogen-like atom are readily distinguishable by their differing masses and charges. When a system contains two or more identical particles, however, postulates 1 to 6 are not sufficient to predict the properties of the system. These postulates must be augmented by an additional postulate. This chapter introduces this new postulate and discusses its consequences. Permutations of identical particles Particles are identical if they cannot be distinguished one from another by any intrinsic property, such as mass, charge, or spin. There does not exist, in fact and in principle, any experimental procedure which can identify any one of the particles. In classical mechanics, even though all particles in the system may have the same intrinsic properties, each may be identified, at least in principle, by its precise trajectory as governed by Newton's laws of motion. This identification is not possible in quantum theory because each particle does not possess a trajectory; instead, the wave function gives the probability density for finding the particle at each point in space. When a particle is found to be in some small region, there is no way of determining either theoretically or experimentally which particle it is.

DOI
10.1017/cbo9780511813542.009

Related papers

Identical Particles in Quantum Mechanics Revisited

Robert C. Hilborn, Candice L. Yuca

The treatment of identical particles in quantum mechanics rests on two (related) principles: the spin‐statistics connection and the Symmetrization Postulate. In light of recent theories (such as q‐deformed commutators) that allow for ‘small’ violations of the spin‐statistics connection and the Symmetrization Postulate, we revisit the issue of how quantum mechanics deals with identical particles and how it supports or fails to support various philosophical stances concerning individuality. As a consequence of the expanded possibilities for quantum statistics, we argue that permutation symmetry is best formulated as a formal property of the state function describing the system of particles rather than as a property of the individual particles.1 Introduction2 Philosophical background2.1 Important terminology2.1.1 Identity2.1.2 Indistinguishability2.1.3 Indiscernibility2.2 When are particles indistinguishable?2.3 The Principle of the Identity of Indiscernibles and quantum mechanics2.4 The Principle of the Identity of Indiscernibles and logic2.5 Particle history2.6 Transcendental individuality3 Some quantum formalism3.1 The Principle of Permutation Invariance and the Symmetrization Postulate3.2 The configuration‐space approach3.3 Commutators and anticommutators, and identical particle statistics3.4 Q‐mutators4 Identical particle statistics: a holistic point of view5 Conclusions

The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science•Sep 1, 2002•20 citations

The Principle of Identity and the Exclusion of Quantum States

Gilbert Newton Lewis

In classical physics it was assumed that a system of two bodies, both having the same mechanical and electrical properties, would show the same behavior regardless of their complete identity. This assumption, that gave rise to the paradoxes of Gibbs and of Einstein which are here discussed, must be abandoned in atomic physics. We must distinguish sharply between identical particles and those that are only quasiidentical, in the sense that they are the same in mass, charge and the potential fields to which they give rise. All of the results which have hitherto been obtained in quantum mechanics are valid even if we assume that two particles such as two electrons or two helium nuclei are only quasi-identical. The postulate of complete identity is a new mathematical condition which, operating simultaneously with the wave equation and its boundary conditions, restricts the number of possible solutions of the equation and thus gives rise mathematically to a number of exclusion laws such as those which have been empirically obtained.The assumption of identity is equivalent to the mathematical assumption that the ordinary configuration space is degenerate, in the sense that one portion is a mere reflection of another. By this method it is shown that if the wave function is a scalar, the laws of exclusion are obtained without ambiguity. Thus a perfectly symmetrical diatomic gas in its simplest electronic state can have only even rotational levels. It is pointed out that the experimental results with ${\mathrm{O}}_{2}$(${\mathrm{O}}_{16}$${\mathrm{O}}_{16}$) and ${\mathrm{He}}_{2}$ show that these atoms exist in a single nuclear state. It is predicted that with heavier atoms both even and odd states will be found owing to the existence of isobars. The monatomic gas is then discussed and it is shown that, if the Schr\"odinger function is a scalar, only the Bose-Einstein statistics are possible.The phenomenon of spin introduces a vector character into the wave function. If we assume that the spin factor changes sign upon reflection when the number of units of spin is odd but not when the number of units of spin is even, we have all the cases of exclusion now known, including the case of the nitrogen molecule. As an example of the method, the problem of the helium atom is discussed.

Physical Review•Oct 1, 1930•6 citations

Postulates of Quantum Mechanics

Ram Yatan Prasad Pranita

A postulate is an idea that is suggested as, or assumed to be, the basis for a theory, argument or calculation. In quantum mechanics, the postulates concern the atomic and molecular properties, which are quite far removed from everyday experience. Consequently, in this regard, these may be difficult to understand. The important point is that the postulates are justified by their ability to predict. They should also have the ability to correlate experimental facts by their general applicability. Before discussing the postulates of quantum mechanics, it will be useful to understand the meaning of two important terms: (a) dynamical variable and (b) observable. First of all, we should know about the dynamical variable. Any property of a system of interest is known as the dynamical variable. Examples are the position r, the energy E , the x -component of linear momentum px , and so on. Generally, any quantity of interest in classical mechanics is a dynamical variable. A very useful dynamical variable, which will be used later, comprise three components of the momentum vectors, which a particle in a system has when it remains at a fixed point. Now, we shall know about observable. An observable is defined as any dynamical variable that can be measured. It should be kept in mind that in classical mechanics, all dynamical variables are observables, but it is not so in quantum mechanics. In quantum mechanics, certain fundamental restrictions are imposed on simultaneously measurable variable quantities. To measure the component of the momentum vector, it is essential to make a simultaneous measurement of the position and momentum of the particle. We are aware of the fact that there exists an uncertainty relation for such kind of simultaneous measurement on microscopic particle, and the dynamical variable ‘the momentum at a point’ is not an observable. With this background in mind, we are going to introduce the basic postulates of quantum mechanics. Postulate 1 The state of the quantum mechanical objects is described by a wave function. or A quantum mechanical system of n particles is described as fully as possible by a function, ψ ( x, y, z, t ) called the wave function, which determines all the measurable quantities of the system, where x, y, z, t are spatial co-ordinates.

Foundation Books•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

Permutation Symmetry of Many-Particle Wave Functions

Marvin D. Girardeau

The symmetrization postulate (SP) states that wave functions are either completely symmetric or completely antisymmetric under permutations of identical particles. It is shown by one-dimensional counter-examples that SP is not demanded by the usual physical interpretation of the mathematical formalism of wave mechanics unless one makes use of further physical properties of real systems; the error in a standard proof of SP which ignores these properties is pointed out. It is then proved that SP is true for those systems of spinless particles which have the following properties: (a) probability densities are permutation-invariant, (b) allowable wave functions are continuous with continuous gradient, (c) the $3n$-dimensional configuration space is connected, (d) the Hamiltonian is symmetric, and (e) the nodes of allowed wave functions have certain properties. The counterexamples show that SP is not a necessary property of those systems which do not have property (c). The proof is extended to particles with internal degrees of freedom (including spin) by noting that any observable commutes with every permutation and making use of a particular observable acting only on internal variables. Extraneous mathematical assumptions, such as that of the existence of a "complete" set of commuting observables, criticized by Messiah and Greenberg, are not employed. Some comments are made on the conventional nature of the concept of identity for similar particles; the equivalence between the usual formulation in which different species of similar particles are treated as distinct, and that in which they are regarded as identical particles in different internal states, is emphasized.

Physical Review•Jul 26, 1965•206 citations

Identical particles

Roger M. Bowley, Mariana Sánchez

This chapter introduces the partition function that involves a sum over independent quantum states of the N-particle system. It outlines the problem of distinguishability, that is, how to distinguish one electron from another when they are replicas of each other and are all the same. It also emphasizes that electrons have no feature or label based on which they can be told apart, and they repeat the same attributes endlessly. The chapter explains that identical particles lead to complications in the quantum mechanical description of the microscopic state of the system as there are no observable changes in the system when any two particles are exchanged. It analyses the uncertainty principle, wherein the position of a particle cannot be accurately specified at each stage, nor can the precise trajectory of a particle be followed.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Oct 21, 1999•0 citations

Are all particles identical?

Sheldon Goldstein, James Taylor, Roderich Tumulka +1 more

We consider the possibility that all particles in the world are fundamentally identical, i.e., belong to the same species. Different masses, charges, spins, flavours or colours then merely correspond to different quantum states of the same particle, just as spin-up and spin-down do. The implications of this viewpoint can be best appreciated within Bohmian mechanics, a precise formulation of quantum mechanics with particle trajectories. The implementation of this viewpoint in such a theory leads to trajectories different from those of the usual formulation, and thus to a version of Bohmian mechanics that is inequivalent to, though arguably empirically indistinguishable from, the usual one. The mathematical core of this viewpoint is however rather independent of the detailed dynamical scheme Bohmian mechanics provides, and it amounts to the assertion that the configuration space for N particles, even N 'distinguishable particles', is the set of all N -point subsets of physical 3-space.

arXiv:quant-ph/0405039•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Feb 3, 2005•36 citations
The postulates 1 to 6 of quantum mechanics as stated in Sections 3.7 and 7.2 apply to multi-particle systems provided that each of the particles is distinguishable from the others. For example, the nucleus and the electron in a hydrogen-like atom are readily distinguishable by their differing masses and charges. When a system contains two or more identical particles, however, postulates 1 to 6 are not sufficient to predict the properties of the system. These postulates must be augmented by an additional postulate. This chapter introduces this new postulate and discusses its consequences. Permutations of identical particles Particles are identical if they cannot be distinguished one from another by any intrinsic property, such as mass, charge, or spin. There does not exist, in fact and in principle, any experimental procedure which can identify any one of the particles. In classical mechanics, even though all particles in the system may have the same intrinsic properties, each may be identified, at least in principle, by its precise trajectory as governed by Newton's laws of motion. This identification is not possible in quantum theory because each particle does not possess a trajectory; instead, the wave function gives the probability density for finding the particle at each point in space. When a particle is found to be in some small region, there is no way of determining either theoretically or experimentally which particle it is.
The treatment of identical particles in quantum mechanics rests on two (related) principles: the spin‐statistics connection and the Symmetrization Postulate. In light of recent theories (such as q‐deformed commutators) that allow for ‘small’ violations of the spin‐statistics connection and the Symmetrization Postulate, we revisit the issue of how quantum mechanics deals with identical particles and how it supports or fails to support various philosophical stances concerning individuality. As a consequence of the expanded possibilities for quantum statistics, we argue that permutation symmetry is best formulated as a formal property of the state function describing the system of particles rather than as a property of the individual particles.1 Introduction2 Philosophical background2.1 Important terminology2.1.1 Identity2.1.2 Indistinguishability2.1.3 Indiscernibility2.2 When are particles indistinguishable?2.3 The Principle of the Identity of Indiscernibles and quantum mechanics2.4 The Principle of the Identity of Indiscernibles and logic2.5 Particle history2.6 Transcendental individuality3 Some quantum formalism3.1 The Principle of Permutation Invariance and the Symmetrization Postulate3.2 The configuration‐space approach3.3 Commutators and anticommutators, and identical particle statistics3.4 Q‐mutators4 Identical particle statistics: a holistic point of view5 Conclusions
In classical physics it was assumed that a system of two bodies, both having the same mechanical and electrical properties, would show the same behavior regardless of their complete identity. This assumption, that gave rise to the paradoxes of Gibbs and of Einstein which are here discussed, must be abandoned in atomic physics. We must distinguish sharply between identical particles and those that are only quasiidentical, in the sense that they are the same in mass, charge and the potential fields to which they give rise. All of the results which have hitherto been obtained in quantum mechanics are valid even if we assume that two particles such as two electrons or two helium nuclei are only quasi-identical. The postulate of complete identity is a new mathematical condition which, operating simultaneously with the wave equation and its boundary conditions, restricts the number of possible solutions of the equation and thus gives rise mathematically to a number of exclusion laws such as those which have been empirically obtained.The assumption of identity is equivalent to the mathematical assumption that the ordinary configuration space is degenerate, in the sense that one portion is a mere reflection of another. By this method it is shown that if the wave function is a scalar, the laws of exclusion are obtained without ambiguity. Thus a perfectly symmetrical diatomic gas in its simplest electronic state can have only even rotational levels. It is pointed out that the experimental results with O2{\mathrm{O}}_{2}O2​(O16{\mathrm{O}}_{16}O16​O16{\mathrm{O}}_{16}O16​) and He2{\mathrm{He}}_{2}He2​ show that these atoms exist in a single nuclear state. It is predicted that with heavier atoms both even and odd states will be found owing to the existence of isobars. The monatomic gas is then discussed and it is shown that, if the Schr\"odinger function is a scalar, only the Bose-Einstein statistics are possible.The phenomenon of spin introduces a vector character into the wave function. If we assume that the spin factor changes sign upon reflection when the number of units of spin is odd but not when the number of units of spin is even, we have all the cases of exclusion now known, including the case of the nitrogen molecule. As an example of the method, the problem of the helium atom is discussed.
A postulate is an idea that is suggested as, or assumed to be, the basis for a theory, argument or calculation. In quantum mechanics, the postulates concern the atomic and molecular properties, which are quite far removed from everyday experience. Consequently, in this regard, these may be difficult to understand. The important point is that the postulates are justified by their ability to predict. They should also have the ability to correlate experimental facts by their general applicability. Before discussing the postulates of quantum mechanics, it will be useful to understand the meaning of two important terms: (a) dynamical variable and (b) observable. First of all, we should know about the dynamical variable. Any property of a system of interest is known as the dynamical variable. Examples are the position r, the energy E , the x -component of linear momentum px , and so on. Generally, any quantity of interest in classical mechanics is a dynamical variable. A very useful dynamical variable, which will be used later, comprise three components of the momentum vectors, which a particle in a system has when it remains at a fixed point. Now, we shall know about observable. An observable is defined as any dynamical variable that can be measured. It should be kept in mind that in classical mechanics, all dynamical variables are observables, but it is not so in quantum mechanics. In quantum mechanics, certain fundamental restrictions are imposed on simultaneously measurable variable quantities. To measure the component of the momentum vector, it is essential to make a simultaneous measurement of the position and momentum of the particle. We are aware of the fact that there exists an uncertainty relation for such kind of simultaneous measurement on microscopic particle, and the dynamical variable ‘the momentum at a point’ is not an observable. With this background in mind, we are going to introduce the basic postulates of quantum mechanics. Postulate 1 The state of the quantum mechanical objects is described by a wave function. or A quantum mechanical system of n particles is described as fully as possible by a function, ψ ( x, y, z, t ) called the wave function, which determines all the measurable quantities of the system, where x, y, z, t are spatial co-ordinates.
The symmetrization postulate (SP) states that wave functions are either completely symmetric or completely antisymmetric under permutations of identical particles. It is shown by one-dimensional counter-examples that SP is not demanded by the usual physical interpretation of the mathematical formalism of wave mechanics unless one makes use of further physical properties of real systems; the error in a standard proof of SP which ignores these properties is pointed out. It is then proved that SP is true for those systems of spinless particles which have the following properties: (a) probability densities are permutation-invariant, (b) allowable wave functions are continuous with continuous gradient, (c) the 3n3n3n-dimensional configuration space is connected, (d) the Hamiltonian is symmetric, and (e) the nodes of allowed wave functions have certain properties. The counterexamples show that SP is not a necessary property of those systems which do not have property (c). The proof is extended to particles with internal degrees of freedom (including spin) by noting that any observable commutes with every permutation and making use of a particular observable acting only on internal variables. Extraneous mathematical assumptions, such as that of the existence of a "complete" set of commuting observables, criticized by Messiah and Greenberg, are not employed. Some comments are made on the conventional nature of the concept of identity for similar particles; the equivalence between the usual formulation in which different species of similar particles are treated as distinct, and that in which they are regarded as identical particles in different internal states, is emphasized.
This chapter introduces the partition function that involves a sum over independent quantum states of the N-particle system. It outlines the problem of distinguishability, that is, how to distinguish one electron from another when they are replicas of each other and are all the same. It also emphasizes that electrons have no feature or label based on which they can be told apart, and they repeat the same attributes endlessly. The chapter explains that identical particles lead to complications in the quantum mechanical description of the microscopic state of the system as there are no observable changes in the system when any two particles are exchanged. It analyses the uncertainty principle, wherein the position of a particle cannot be accurately specified at each stage, nor can the precise trajectory of a particle be followed.
We consider the possibility that all particles in the world are fundamentally identical, i.e., belong to the same species. Different masses, charges, spins, flavours or colours then merely correspond to different quantum states of the same particle, just as spin-up and spin-down do. The implications of this viewpoint can be best appreciated within Bohmian mechanics, a precise formulation of quantum mechanics with particle trajectories. The implementation of this viewpoint in such a theory leads to trajectories different from those of the usual formulation, and thus to a version of Bohmian mechanics that is inequivalent to, though arguably empirically indistinguishable from, the usual one. The mathematical core of this viewpoint is however rather independent of the detailed dynamical scheme Bohmian mechanics provides, and it amounts to the assertion that the configuration space for N particles, even N 'distinguishable particles', is the set of all N -point subsets of physical 3-space.