Physical Review
The Principle of Identity and the Exclusion of Quantum States
Gilbert Newton Lewis
Abstract
In classical physics it was assumed that a system of two bodies, both having the same mechanical and electrical properties, would show the same behavior regardless of their complete identity. This assumption, that gave rise to the paradoxes of Gibbs and of Einstein which are here discussed, must be abandoned in atomic physics. We must distinguish sharply between identical particles and those that are only quasiidentical, in the sense that they are the same in mass, charge and the potential fields to which they give rise. All of the results which have hitherto been obtained in quantum mechanics are valid even if we assume that two particles such as two electrons or two helium nuclei are only quasi-identical. The postulate of complete identity is a new mathematical condition which, operating simultaneously with the wave equation and its boundary conditions, restricts the number of possible solutions of the equation and thus gives rise mathematically to a number of exclusion laws such as those which have been empirically obtained.The assumption of identity is equivalent to the mathematical assumption that the ordinary configuration space is degenerate, in the sense that one portion is a mere reflection of another. By this method it is shown that if the wave function is a scalar, the laws of exclusion are obtained without ambiguity. Thus a perfectly symmetrical diatomic gas in its simplest electronic state can have only even rotational levels. It is pointed out that the experimental results with ${\mathrm{O}}_{2}$(${\mathrm{O}}_{16}$${\mathrm{O}}_{16}$) and ${\mathrm{He}}_{2}$ show that these atoms exist in a single nuclear state. It is predicted that with heavier atoms both even and odd states will be found owing to the existence of isobars. The monatomic gas is then discussed and it is shown that, if the Schr\"odinger function is a scalar, only the Bose-Einstein statistics are possible.The phenomenon of spin introduces a vector character into the wave function. If we assume that the spin factor changes sign upon reflection when the number of units of spin is odd but not when the number of units of spin is even, we have all the cases of exclusion now known, including the case of the nitrogen molecule. As an example of the method, the problem of the helium atom is discussed.