Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

Discontinuities, instabilities and other bad behaviour

Pieter E. Vermaas

Published Feb 5, 2010• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In this chapter I begin the discussion of the question of how the core properties of systems evolve in time. This question breaks up in two separate subquestions. Firstly, there is the question of how the set of all possible core properties of a system evolves. Secondly, one has the question of how, given this dynamics of the set of possible core properties, the actually possessed core property of that system evolves. Here, I consider only the first question of the dynamics of the whole set of core properties. In the next chapter I focus on the evolution of the actually possessed core property. The modal interpretations that I consider ascribe core properties to systems by means of the spectral resolutions of states. The dynamics of the set of core properties is thus determined by the dynamical behaviour of these spectral resolutions. Study of the dynamics of the spectral resolutions now reveals a number of problematic features of the modal property ascription. Firstly, the set of the eigenprojections of a state W α( t ) can evolve discontinuously. Secondly, this set can evolve highly unstably. Finally, the eigenprojections of a state can evolve rather deviantly when compared with the evolution of the state itself. As a result of all this, the evolution of the set of core properties of a system can be discontinuous, unstable and deviant as well. Discontinuities Up to now I have only considered the property ascription to systems at single instants. It is now time to set things in motion.

DOI
10.1017/cbo9780511608230.009

Related papers

Formalism

Pieter E. Vermaas

In Chapter 4 the different modal interpretations are introduced. Their property ascription to a system α is characterised by a core property ascription {〈Pj,CαJ〉}j.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 5, 2010•0 citations

Dynamical Evolution

Enrico G. Beltrametti, Gianni Cassinelli, Peter Carruthers

The Unitary Dynamical Group in Schrödinger's Picture Up to now we have been concerned with the description of a physical system at a fixed instant of time. The time evolution of quantum systems constitutes a many-faced, wide issue which, however, is somewhat tangential to the main aim of this volume. We shall touch upon it only briefly, restricting ourselves to the more familiar aspects of the problem. We assume, to begin with, that the physical system has no superselection rules, so that states and physical quantities correspond one-to-one to density operators and self-adjoint operators, respectively, on the Hilbert space. To describe the dynamical evolution of the system one has to specify the way the representatives of states and physical quantities evolve in, which is fixed in time, since the physical system is supposed to preserve its identity. There is an old tenet according to which there are two kinds of time evolution: the discontinuous, nondeterministic evolution undergone by the quantum system when a measurement is made on it, and the continuous, deterministic evolution caused by the interaction with external forces or with other quantum systems. The first kind of evolution will be dealt with in Chapter 8, where we shall find it less alarming than is often claimed.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 28, 1984•0 citations

The Essentials of Quantum Mechanics

Radhika Vathsan

How do we describe the state of a quantum mechanical physical system in a mathematically precise way? How do we ascribe physical properties to this system? How does the system evolve in time? How do its properties change when it interacts with another system or a force? How do we measure and determine its properties? These are the questions whose answers are encoded in the laws of quantum mechanics to be set down in this chapter. They have been inscribed in this form after nearly half a century of experimental observations, theoretical modeling, and intellectual gymnastics to tie up the two in a satisfactory and robust structure.

CRC Press eBooks•Jul 21, 2015•0 citations

Extension of the Dynamics of Unstable Systems

Ioannis E. Antoniou, Z. Suchanecki

The work of the Brussels–Austin groups over the last six years has demonstrated that for unstable systems, classical or quantum, there exist spectral decompositions of the evolution In terms of resonances and resonance states which appear as eigenvalues and eigenprojections of the evolution operator. These new spectral decompositions are non-trivial only for unstable systems and define an extension of the evolution to suitable dual pairs. Duality here is the states/observables duality and the spectral decompositions extend the algebraic approach to dynamical systems to an intrinsically probabilistic and irreversible formulation. The extended formulation allows for probabilistic prediction and control beyond the traditional local techniques.

Infinite Dimensional Analysis Quantum Probability and Related Topics•Jan 1, 1998•2 citations

Time evolution

Kenichi Konishi, Giampiero Paffuti

Abstract There is a vast class of interesting physical problems, however, which involve time-dependent Hamiltonians and which are not accessible to perturbative treatment. In this chapter, we discuss some of these systems.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Mar 5, 2009•0 citations

Dynamical Autonomy and Locality

Pieter E. Vermaas

In this chapter I prove that the transition probabilities, which describe the dynamics of the actually possessed properties of systems, violate the assumption of Dynamical Autonomy for composite systems. And, related to this violation, it is also proved that the dynamics of the actually possessed properties is non-local in a quite explicit way. Introduction When I introduced the assumptions of Instantaneous and Dynamical Autonomy in Section 3.3, I motivated them by making an appeal to locality. In the case of Instantaneous Autonomy, I argued that a state of a system α should codify all the information about the property ascription to that system. For if a state does not codify all the information, it may happen that a change in the state of some distant system σ (I used the example of a far-away asteroid) means that the properties of α change as well. And this would make modal property ascriptions undesirably non-local. In the case of Dynamical Autonomy one can give a similar motivation. The state of a system α, as it evolves during a time interval i , should codify all the information about the simultaneous and sequential correlations between the properties ascribed to α in that interval i . For if the evolving state does not do so, it may happen that a change in a distant system changes the correlations between the properties of α as well. Modal interpretations satisfy a number of the Autonomy assumptions. All modal interpretations satisfy Instantaneous Autonomy by construction. The transition probabilities derived in Section 8.2 prove that the bi and spectral modal interpretations satisfy Dynamical Autonomy for whole systems and that the atomic modal interpretation satisfies Dynamical Autonomy for atomic systems.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 5, 2010•0 citations
In this chapter I begin the discussion of the question of how the core properties of systems evolve in time. This question breaks up in two separate subquestions. Firstly, there is the question of how the set of all possible core properties of a system evolves. Secondly, one has the question of how, given this dynamics of the set of possible core properties, the actually possessed core property of that system evolves. Here, I consider only the first question of the dynamics of the whole set of core properties. In the next chapter I focus on the evolution of the actually possessed core property. The modal interpretations that I consider ascribe core properties to systems by means of the spectral resolutions of states. The dynamics of the set of core properties is thus determined by the dynamical behaviour of these spectral resolutions. Study of the dynamics of the spectral resolutions now reveals a number of problematic features of the modal property ascription. Firstly, the set of the eigenprojections of a state W α( t ) can evolve discontinuously. Secondly, this set can evolve highly unstably. Finally, the eigenprojections of a state can evolve rather deviantly when compared with the evolution of the state itself. As a result of all this, the evolution of the set of core properties of a system can be discontinuous, unstable and deviant as well. Discontinuities Up to now I have only considered the property ascription to systems at single instants. It is now time to set things in motion.
The Unitary Dynamical Group in Schrödinger's Picture Up to now we have been concerned with the description of a physical system at a fixed instant of time. The time evolution of quantum systems constitutes a many-faced, wide issue which, however, is somewhat tangential to the main aim of this volume. We shall touch upon it only briefly, restricting ourselves to the more familiar aspects of the problem. We assume, to begin with, that the physical system has no superselection rules, so that states and physical quantities correspond one-to-one to density operators and self-adjoint operators, respectively, on the Hilbert space. To describe the dynamical evolution of the system one has to specify the way the representatives of states and physical quantities evolve in, which is fixed in time, since the physical system is supposed to preserve its identity. There is an old tenet according to which there are two kinds of time evolution: the discontinuous, nondeterministic evolution undergone by the quantum system when a measurement is made on it, and the continuous, deterministic evolution caused by the interaction with external forces or with other quantum systems. The first kind of evolution will be dealt with in Chapter 8, where we shall find it less alarming than is often claimed.
How do we describe the state of a quantum mechanical physical system in a mathematically precise way? How do we ascribe physical properties to this system? How does the system evolve in time? How do its properties change when it interacts with another system or a force? How do we measure and determine its properties? These are the questions whose answers are encoded in the laws of quantum mechanics to be set down in this chapter. They have been inscribed in this form after nearly half a century of experimental observations, theoretical modeling, and intellectual gymnastics to tie up the two in a satisfactory and robust structure.
The work of the Brussels–Austin groups over the last six years has demonstrated that for unstable systems, classical or quantum, there exist spectral decompositions of the evolution In terms of resonances and resonance states which appear as eigenvalues and eigenprojections of the evolution operator. These new spectral decompositions are non-trivial only for unstable systems and define an extension of the evolution to suitable dual pairs. Duality here is the states/observables duality and the spectral decompositions extend the algebraic approach to dynamical systems to an intrinsically probabilistic and irreversible formulation. The extended formulation allows for probabilistic prediction and control beyond the traditional local techniques.
In this chapter I prove that the transition probabilities, which describe the dynamics of the actually possessed properties of systems, violate the assumption of Dynamical Autonomy for composite systems. And, related to this violation, it is also proved that the dynamics of the actually possessed properties is non-local in a quite explicit way. Introduction When I introduced the assumptions of Instantaneous and Dynamical Autonomy in Section 3.3, I motivated them by making an appeal to locality. In the case of Instantaneous Autonomy, I argued that a state of a system α should codify all the information about the property ascription to that system. For if a state does not codify all the information, it may happen that a change in the state of some distant system σ (I used the example of a far-away asteroid) means that the properties of α change as well. And this would make modal property ascriptions undesirably non-local. In the case of Dynamical Autonomy one can give a similar motivation. The state of a system α, as it evolves during a time interval i , should codify all the information about the simultaneous and sequential correlations between the properties ascribed to α in that interval i . For if the evolving state does not do so, it may happen that a change in a distant system changes the correlations between the properties of α as well. Modal interpretations satisfy a number of the Autonomy assumptions. All modal interpretations satisfy Instantaneous Autonomy by construction. The transition probabilities derived in Section 8.2 prove that the bi and spectral modal interpretations satisfy Dynamical Autonomy for whole systems and that the atomic modal interpretation satisfies Dynamical Autonomy for atomic systems.