Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

Formalism

Pieter E. Vermaas

Published Feb 5, 2010• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In Chapter 4 the different modal interpretations are introduced. Their property ascription to a system α is characterised by a core property ascription {〈Pj,CαJ〉}j.
DOI
10.1017/cbo9780511608230.005

Related papers

Expanding The Property Ascriptions In The Modal Interpretation Of Quantum Theory

Pieter E. Vermaas

University of Minnesota Press eBooks•Jan 25, 2010•3 citations

The different versions

Pieter E. Vermaas

In this chapter I introduce the different versions of the modal interpretation, including the three on which I focus in this book. The property ascription of these versions is characterised by the map W α ↦ {〈p j , C α j 〉} j which I call the core property ascription. In the next chapter I discuss how this core property ascription determines the full property ascription W α ↦ The best modal interpretation The best imaginable modal interpretation is, I guess, an interpretation which (A) ascribes at all times all the properties to a system which pertain to that system, and (B) ascribes these properties such that the classical logical relations between the negation, conjunction and disjunction of properties are satisfied. The content of the first requirement (A) is clear: assuming that every projection onto a subspace of a Hilbert space ℋ α represents one and only one property of α, it follows that all sets of definite-valued projections should contain all the projections in ℋ α and that all the maps {. j } j should be maps from all the projections in ℋ α to the values {0,1}. The content of requirement (B) is, however, less clear because there is consensus neither about how to define the negation, conjunction and disjunction of properties in quantum mechanics nor about how to impose the logical relations. In Section 5.1 I present my choice for the definitions of the negation, conjunction and disjunction.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 5, 2010•0 citations

Projection Operators, Properties, and Idempotent Variables in the Modal Interpretations

Nick Reeder

The Western Ontario series in philosophy of science•Jan 1, 1998•1 citation

The full property ascription

Pieter E. Vermaas

The different modal interpretations all advance a core property ascription {〈P j , C α j 〉} j . This chapter is about how this core property ascription fixes the full property ascription. I start with some logic and algebra. I then present two existing proposals for determining the full property ascriptions as well as four conditions one can impose on them. Lastly I give my own proposal and end by discussing how the full property ascription leads to a value assignment to magnitudes. Some logic and algebra To prepare the ground for discussing the full property ascription, I firstly define the logical connectives (negation, conjunction and disjunction) for properties. Then because, as discussed in Section 4.1, all the modal interpretations which I consider give up on the idea that thefull property ascription assigns definite values to all properties, I secondly define two types of subsets of properties: Boolean algebras and faux-Boolean algebras. I have already assumed that every property Q α pertaining to a system α is represented by one and only one projection Q α defined on the Hilbert space ℋα associated with α. Each projection Q α in its turn corresponds one-to-one to the subspace of ℋα, denoted by 2α, onto which it projects. One thus has a bijective mapping from a property Q α to a projection Q α to a subspace 2α. For the set of subspaces of a Hilbert space one can in a natural way define an orthocomplement, a meet and a join. I now choose 45 to define the logical connectives for properties pertaining to a system by means of this orthocomplement, meet and join for subspaces and the bijective mapping between properties and subspaces (by means of an isomorphism, more shortly).

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 5, 2010•0 citations

A Note on Dynamics in the Modal Interpretation

Guido Bacciagaluppi

International Journal of Theoretical Physics•Jan 1, 1998•1 citation

Philosophy

Pieter E. Vermaas

In this final part I analyse the modal interpretations from a more philosophical point of view. In Chapter 12 I start by arguing that modal interpretations describe noumenal states of affairs and that therefore metaphysically tenable interpretations need only to meet the criteria of Consistency and Internal Completeness. Then I analyse the relations between properties, states and outcomes of measurements in the modal description of reality. I end by discussing how modal interpretations, when restricted to the description of measurement outcomes, recover the standard formulation of quantum mechanics. Chapter 13 concerns the relations between the properties ascribed to composite systems and subsystems. I show that the property ascriptions of the bi and spectral modal interpretations can be characterised as holistic and non-reductionistic, whereas the property ascription of the atomic modal interpretation is non-holistic and to a large extent reductionistic. I argue that notwithstanding the lack of reductionism, the bi and spectral modal interpretations are empirically adequate and metaphysically tenable. I also discuss the possibility of saving the metaphysical tenability of the atomic modal interpretation by taking holistic properties as dispositional properties. In Chapter 14 I give a survey of the possibilities and impossibilities of modal interpretations and in Chapter 15 I end with general conclusions.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 5, 2010•0 citations
In this chapter I introduce the different versions of the modal interpretation, including the three on which I focus in this book. The property ascription of these versions is characterised by the map W α ↦ {〈p j , C α j 〉} j which I call the core property ascription. In the next chapter I discuss how this core property ascription determines the full property ascription W α ↦ The best modal interpretation The best imaginable modal interpretation is, I guess, an interpretation which (A) ascribes at all times all the properties to a system which pertain to that system, and (B) ascribes these properties such that the classical logical relations between the negation, conjunction and disjunction of properties are satisfied. The content of the first requirement (A) is clear: assuming that every projection onto a subspace of a Hilbert space ℋ α represents one and only one property of α, it follows that all sets of definite-valued projections should contain all the projections in ℋ α and that all the maps {. j } j should be maps from all the projections in ℋ α to the values {0,1}. The content of requirement (B) is, however, less clear because there is consensus neither about how to define the negation, conjunction and disjunction of properties in quantum mechanics nor about how to impose the logical relations. In Section 5.1 I present my choice for the definitions of the negation, conjunction and disjunction.
The different modal interpretations all advance a core property ascription {〈P j , C α j 〉} j . This chapter is about how this core property ascription fixes the full property ascription. I start with some logic and algebra. I then present two existing proposals for determining the full property ascriptions as well as four conditions one can impose on them. Lastly I give my own proposal and end by discussing how the full property ascription leads to a value assignment to magnitudes. Some logic and algebra To prepare the ground for discussing the full property ascription, I firstly define the logical connectives (negation, conjunction and disjunction) for properties. Then because, as discussed in Section 4.1, all the modal interpretations which I consider give up on the idea that thefull property ascription assigns definite values to all properties, I secondly define two types of subsets of properties: Boolean algebras and faux-Boolean algebras. I have already assumed that every property Q α pertaining to a system α is represented by one and only one projection Q α defined on the Hilbert space ℋα associated with α. Each projection Q α in its turn corresponds one-to-one to the subspace of ℋα, denoted by 2α, onto which it projects. One thus has a bijective mapping from a property Q α to a projection Q α to a subspace 2α. For the set of subspaces of a Hilbert space one can in a natural way define an orthocomplement, a meet and a join. I now choose 45 to define the logical connectives for properties pertaining to a system by means of this orthocomplement, meet and join for subspaces and the bijective mapping between properties and subspaces (by means of an isomorphism, more shortly).
In this final part I analyse the modal interpretations from a more philosophical point of view. In Chapter 12 I start by arguing that modal interpretations describe noumenal states of affairs and that therefore metaphysically tenable interpretations need only to meet the criteria of Consistency and Internal Completeness. Then I analyse the relations between properties, states and outcomes of measurements in the modal description of reality. I end by discussing how modal interpretations, when restricted to the description of measurement outcomes, recover the standard formulation of quantum mechanics. Chapter 13 concerns the relations between the properties ascribed to composite systems and subsystems. I show that the property ascriptions of the bi and spectral modal interpretations can be characterised as holistic and non-reductionistic, whereas the property ascription of the atomic modal interpretation is non-holistic and to a large extent reductionistic. I argue that notwithstanding the lack of reductionism, the bi and spectral modal interpretations are empirically adequate and metaphysically tenable. I also discuss the possibility of saving the metaphysical tenability of the atomic modal interpretation by taking holistic properties as dispositional properties. In Chapter 14 I give a survey of the possibilities and impossibilities of modal interpretations and in Chapter 15 I end with general conclusions.