Phase‐Dependent Oxygen Defect Energetics in Epitaxial NbN/AlN/NbN Films
Prachi Garg, Kedarsh Kaushik, Danqing Wang, Naomi A. Pieczulewski, Anand Ithepalli, John Wright, Debdeep Jena, David Anthony Muller, Hong X. Tang, Cyrus E. Dreyer, Baishakhi Mazumder
ABSTRACT Epitaxial all‐nitride Josephson junctions are promising components for high coherence superconducting qubits, yet nanoscale defects often limit their performance. The key to mitigating these defects lies in understanding the atomic‐scale relationship between polymorph selection, defect chemistry, and device performance. Here, we investigate structural and chemical defects in epitaxially grown 𝛿‐NbN/AlN/𝛿‐NbN, 𝛾‐Nb 4 N 3 /AlN/𝛾‐Nb 4 N 3 , β‐Nb 2 N/AlN/β‐Nb 2 N heterostructures on c‐plane sapphire using molecular beam epitaxy. Advanced microscopy integrated with density functional theory shows varying impurity distribution across different polymorphs. The chemical distribution reveals that δ‐NbN electrodes contain significant oxygen, whereas in β‐Nb 2 N/AlN/β‐Nb 2 N heterostructures oxygen preferentially segregates to the AlN barrier. DFT calculations indicate that these differences arise from phase‐dependent oxygen energetics and diffusion kinetics, with oxygen remaining kinetically trapped in δ‐NbN while exhibiting greater mobility in β‐Nb 2 N. These structural and chemical differences are consistent with the distinct transport behavior observed in the two junction architectures and provide mechanistic insight into the role of defect chemistry in epitaxial nitride Josephson junctions. The observed impurity distribution may influence superconducting properties and contribute to the formation of two‐level systems, a major source of loss and decoherence in superconducting quantum circuits.
ABSTRACT Epitaxial all‐nitride Josephson junctions are promising components for high coherence superconducting qubits, yet nanoscale defects often limit their performance. The key to mitigating these defects lies in understanding the atomic‐scale relationship between polymorph selection, defect chemistry, and device performance. Here, we investigate structural and chemical defects in epitaxially grown 𝛿‐NbN/AlN/𝛿‐NbN, 𝛾‐Nb 4 N 3 /AlN/𝛾‐Nb 4 N 3 , β‐Nb 2 N/AlN/β‐Nb 2 N heterostructures on c‐plane sapphire using molecular beam epitaxy. Advanced microscopy integrated with density functional theory shows varying impurity distribution across different polymorphs. The chemical distribution reveals that δ‐NbN electrodes contain significant oxygen, whereas in β‐Nb 2 N/AlN/β‐Nb 2 N heterostructures oxygen preferentially segregates to the AlN barrier. DFT calculations indicate that these differences arise from phase‐dependent oxygen energetics and diffusion kinetics, with oxygen remaining kinetically trapped in δ‐NbN while exhibiting greater mobility in β‐Nb 2 N. These structural and chemical differences are consistent with the distinct transport behavior observed in the two junction architectures and provide mechanistic insight into the role of defect chemistry in epitaxial nitride Josephson junctions. The observed impurity distribution may influence superconducting properties and contribute to the formation of two‐level systems, a major source of loss and decoherence in superconducting quantum circuits.
Microscopic inhomogeneity within superconducting films is a critical bottleneck hindering the performance and scalability of quantum circuits. All-nitride Josephson Junctions (JJs) have attracted substantial attention for their potential to provide enhanced coherence times and enable higher temperature operation. However, their performance is often limited by local variations caused by polymorphism, impurities, and interface quality. This work diagnoses atomic-scale limitations preventing superconducting NbN/AlN/NbN JJs from reaching their full potential. Electrical measurements reveal suppressed critical current density and soft onset of quasiparticle current. However, inverse proportionality between resistance and junction area confirms homogenous barrier thickness. This isolates structural and chemical variations in electrodes and barrier as the source of performance limitation. The observed characteristics are attributed to complex materials problems: NbN polymorphism, phase coexistence, and oxygen impurities. Using advanced microscopy and machine learning integrated approach, nanoscale inclusions of epsilon-Nb2N2 are found to coexist within dominant delta-NbN electrodes. DC performance of JJs may be affected by these defects, leading to unresolved supercurrent and soft transition to normal state. By identifying specific atomic scale defects, tracing its origin to initial film nucleation, and linking to its detrimental electrical signature, this work establishes a material-to-device correlation and provides targeted strategy for phase engineering towards reproducible, high coherence and scalable quantum devices.
Abstract Improving the coherence of superconducting qubits is a fundamental step towards the realization of fault-tolerant quantum computation. However, coherence times of quantum circuits made from conventional aluminum-based Josephson junctions are limited by the presence of microscopic two-level systems in the amorphous aluminum oxide tunnel barriers. Here, we have developed superconducting qubits based on NbN/AlN/NbN epitaxial Josephson junctions on silicon substrates which promise to overcome the drawbacks of qubits based on Al/AlOx/Al junctions. The all-nitride qubits have great advantages such as chemical stability against oxidation, resulting in fewer two-level fluctuators, feasibility for epitaxial tunnel barriers that reduce energy relaxation and dephasing, and a larger superconducting gap of ~5.2 meV for NbN, compared to ~0.3 meV for aluminum, which suppresses the excitation of quasiparticles. By replacing conventional MgO by a silicon substrate with a TiN buffer layer for epitaxial growth of nitride junctions, we demonstrate a qubit energy relaxation time $${T}_{1}=16.3\;{{\upmu }}{{{{{\rm{s}}}}}}$$ T 1 = 16.3 μ s and a spin-echo dephasing time $${T}_{2}=21.5\;{{\upmu }}{{{{{\rm{s}}}}}}$$ T 2 = 21.5 μ s . These significant improvements in quantum coherence are explained by the reduced dielectric loss compared to the previously reported $${T}_{1}\approx {T}_{2}\approx 0.5\;{{\upmu }}{{{{{\rm{s}}}}}}$$ T 1 ≈ T 2 ≈ 0.5 μ s of NbN-based qubits on MgO substrates. These results are an important step towards constructing a new platform for superconducting quantum hardware.
Superconductor-insulator-superconductor Josephson junctions with crystalline tunnel barriers have remained elusive by epitaxial techniques such as MOCVD or MBE that produce the junction materials and devices powering today's electronic and photonic systems like transistors and lasers. Here, we overcome the key materials hurdle to realize the first functional nitride crystalline barrier Josephson junctions by MBE. Despite an AlN barrier thickness of approximately 4.5 nm, the NbN/AlN/NbN trilayers exhibit coherent Josephson tunneling with critical current densities of approximately 17 A/cm2, an IcRn product of approximately 2.5 mV, and a superconducting gap voltage of approximately 3.7 mV with a BCS-like gap evolution with temperature. Hysteretic current-voltage characteristics and Fraunhofer current modulation with magnetic field establish underdamped SIS Josephson behavior. The realization of crystalline barrier Josephson junctions by MBE opens the doors to a richer materials palette with alloys and superlattice electrodes and tunnel barriers, as well as potential monolithic integration of superconducting quantum circuits with active electronic and photonic devices such as HEMTs and lasers.
Epitaxial NbN/AlN/NbN Josephson junctions are promising alternatives to conventional Al/AlOx/Al junctions for superconducting qubits due to their crystalline tunnel barriers and the high transition temperature of NbN. However, their integration into quantum circuits typically requires complex fabrication processes involving amorphous interlayer dielectrics, which can degrade qubit coherence times. To address these issues, we developed sidewall spacer passivated epitaxial NbN/AlN/NbN junctions using a fabrication process that reduces both the volume of amorphous dielectric material and fabrication complexity. The fabricated junctions exhibited a large gap voltage of approximately 5.6 mV and low subgap leakage currents. By varying the thickness of the AlN tunnel barrier, high-quality junctions were fabricated over a wide range of critical current densities Jc, from 0.3 to 104 A/cm2. In addition, the comparison of the current-voltage characteristics before and after buffered hydrofluoric acid treatment indicated that the wet etching process did not degrade the electrical characteristics of the junctions. These results establish a scalable fabrication process for epitaxial Josephson junctions and provide a promising platform for high-coherence nitride-based superconducting qubits.
The Josephson junction is a crucial element in superconducting devices, and niobium is a promising candidate for the superconducting material due to its large energy gap relative to aluminum. AlOx has long been regarded as the highest quality oxide tunnel barrier and is often used in niobium-based junctions. Here, we propose ZrOx as an alternative tunnel barrier material for Nb electrodes. We theoretically estimate that zirconium oxide has excellent oxygen retention properties and experimentally verify that there is no significant oxygen diffusion leading to NbOx formation in the adjacent Nb electrode. We develop a top–down, subtractive fabrication process for Nb/Zr–ZrOx/Nb Josephson junctions, which enables scalability and large-scale production of superconducting electronics. Using cross-sectional scanning transmission electron microscopy, we experimentally find that depending on the Zr thickness, ZrOx tunnel barriers can be fully crystalline with chemically abrupt interfaces with niobium. Further analysis using electron energy loss spectroscopy reveals that ZrOx corresponds to tetragonal ZrO2. Room temperature characterization of fabricated junctions using Simmons’ model shows that ZrO2 exhibits a low tunnel barrier height, which is promising in merged-element transmon applications. Low temperature transport measurements reveal sub-gap structure, while the low-voltage sub-gap resistance remains in the megaohm range.
Superconducting quantum circuits are promising platforms for scalable quantum computing, where qubit coherence is critically determined by microscopic defects in the oxide tunneling barrier of Josephson junctions. Amorphous Al2O3 is widely used as a barrier material, but under irradiation, oxygen vacancy (VO) defects are readily generated, introducing noise sources that accelerate qubit decoherence. We systematically investigate the structural characteristics and electronic impact of VO defects in amorphous Al2O3 using first-principles calculations and \textit{ab initio} molecular dynamics. Our results show that both the coordination environment and concentration of VOs strongly influence electrical conductivity. In particular, two- and three-coordinated VOs, unique to the amorphous structure, enhance conductivity more than conventional four-coordinated vacancies. Increasing VO concentration amplifies conductivity fluctuations, which we link to critical current noise in Josephson junctions. Using a noise model, we estimate that higher VO densities lead to shorter qubit coherence times. These findings provide insights for radiation-hard design of superconducting quantum devices.