Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The European Physical Journal Plus

Do quantum fluctuations really tip the pencil? A classical trigger mechanism

J. Ricardo de Sousa

Published Jun 28, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract We revisit the classic “tipping pencil” instability, a rigid rod balanced upright on its tip and allowed to rotate in a vertical plane, long used as an introductory illustration of the quantum–classical boundary. In the standard semiclassical argument, the upright configuration is destabilized by minimal uncertainties in the initial angle and angular momentum, $$ \delta \theta $$ δ θ and $$\delta L$$ δ L , constrained by $$\delta \theta \,\delta L\gtrsim \hbar /2$$ δ θ δ L ≳ ħ / 2 , with $$\delta L\simeq I\delta \omega $$ δ L ≃ I δ ω . For a homogeneous cylinder of length $$a=10\,\textrm{cm}$$ a = 10 cm and mass $$m=100\,\textrm{g}$$ m = 100 g , the resulting uncertainty-based initial scales are extremely small and lead to tipping times of order a few seconds. We show, however, that quantum fluctuations are not required as the dominant physical seed for a finite tipping time. A purely classical microscopic perturbation, such as the angular-momentum transfer from a single elastic collision with a residual $$ O_{2}$$ O 2 molecule under ultrahigh-vacuum conditions, already provides a conservative seed for the exponential instability. Using conservation of angular momentum, we estimate an imparted angular velocity $$ \omega _{0,O_{2}}\simeq 1.5\times 10^{-20}\,\textrm{s}^{-1}$$ ω 0 , O 2 ≃ 1.5 × 10 - 20 s - 1 , about five orders of magnitude smaller than the uncertainty-based angular-velocity scale, yet still sufficient to produce a macroscopic fall because the dependence on the seed is only logarithmic. We also include the more natural classical estimate due to thermal angular fluctuations. At room temperature, equipartition gives $$\theta _{\textrm{th}}\sim 3\times 10^{-10}\,\textrm{rad}$$ θ th ∼ 3 × 10 - 10 rad and $$\omega _{\textrm{th}}\sim 3.5\times 10^{-9}\,\textrm{s}^{-1}$$ ω th ∼ 3.5 × 10 -

DOI
10.1140/epjp/s13360-026-07964-3

Related papers

Tipping time of a quantum rod

Mark R. A. Shegelski, Mark B. Lundeberg, Glen L. Goodvin

We study the tipping time of a quantum mechanical rod that is constrained to move in a plane in a gravitational potential. The initial state of the center of mass of the rod is localized within the base of support of the rod. The tipping time is found to increase exponentially with the height H of the rod as C1t0 exp[C2(H/H0)9], where C1 and C2 are dimensionless constants of order one, t0 is the time scale of the motion, and H0 is the length scale of the rod. We show that the tipping time cannot be obtained using the uncertainty principle alone, and compare our result to that obtained using the Wentzel–Kramers–Brillouin approximation.

American Journal of Physics•Jul 21, 2005•6 citations

Tipping time of a quantum rod

Onkar Parrikar

The behaviour of a quantum rod, pivoted at its lower end on an impenetrable floor and restricted to moving in the vertical plane under the gravitational potential, is studied analytically under the approximation that the rod is initially localized to a 'small-enough' neighbourhood around the point of classical unstable equilibrium. It is shown that the rod evolves out of this neighbourhood. The time required for this to happen, i.e. the tipping time, is calculated using the semi-classical path integral. It is shown that equilibrium is recovered in the classical limit, and that our calculations are consistent with the uncertainty principle.

arXiv:0910.0551•European Journal of Physics•Jan 8, 2010•4 citations

The Not-so-simple Pendulum: Balancing a Pencil on its Point

Peter Lynch

Does quantum mechanics matter at everyday scales? We generally assume that its consequences are confined to microscopic scales. It would be very surprising if quantum effects were to be manifest in a macroscopic system. This has been claimed for the problem of balancing a pencil on its tip. The claim has also been disputed. We argue that the behaviour of a tipping pencil can be explained by the asymptotic properties of the complete elliptic function, and can be understood in purely classical terms.

arXiv:1406.1125•Jun 4, 2014•3 citations

The quantum mechanical tipping pencil—a caution for physics teachers

Don Easton

Since at least as long ago as 1960, quantum mechanics has been applied with varying degrees of rigour to the problem of a pencil balancing on its point. Although the analysis of the problem may have some merit in terms of solving for the evolution of and the final state of a similarly shaped (rod-like) but microscopic object, it is misleading when students are given the idea that quantum mechanics is useful in describing the behaviour of macroscopic objects.

European Journal of Physics•Sep 12, 2007•4 citations

Long tipping times of a quantum rod

Mark B. Lundeberg, Mark R. A. Shegelski

We calculate the tipping time of a quantum rod that has a height several times that of the edge length of its square base. We use an expression for the tipping time that has heuristic value, and gives the average time at which, upon measurement, the initially balanced rod is found to tip. We use two methods to calculate the tipping time. One method is to examine the "late time" behaviour of the quantum state of the center of mass of the rod by using an equation that has the form of the time-independent Schrödinger equation except that it involves a "complex energy." The other method uses energy resonances in the eigenstates of the Hamiltonian to determine the tipping time. We use the well-known Wentzel–Kramers–Brillouin approximation to calculate the energy eigenstates. With these methods, we obtain expressions for the tipping time that are valid for very long tipping times. PACS Nos.: 03.65.–w, 03.65.Xp

Canadian Journal of Physics•Jan 1, 2006•9 citations

Quantum-mechanical histories and the uncertainty principle. II. Fluctuations about classical predictability

J. J. Halliwell

This paper is concerned with two questions in the decoherent histories approach to quantum mechanics: the emergence of approximate classical predictability, and the fluctuations about it necessitated by the uncertainty principle. It is in part a continuation of an earlier paper on the uncertainty principle for quantum-mechanical histories. We consider histories characterized by position samplings at n moments of time. This includes the case of position sampling continuous in time in the limit n\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}. We use this to construct a probability distribution on the value of (discrete approximations to) the field equations, F=mx\ifmmode\ddot\else\textasciidieresis\fi{}+V'(x), at n-2 times. We find that it is peaked around F=0; thus classical correlations are exhibited. We show that the width of the peak \ensuremath{\Delta}F is largely independent of the initial state. We show that the uncertainty principle takes the form 2${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}^{2}$(\ensuremath{\Delta}F${)}^{2}$\ensuremath{\ge}${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Elzxh}}}^{2}$/${\mathit{t}}^{2}$, where \ensuremath{\sigma} is the width of the position samplings, and t is the time scale between projections. We determine the modifications to this result when the system is coupled to a thermal environment, thus obtaining a measure of the comparative sizes of quantum and thermal fluctuations. We show that the thermal fluctuations become comparable to the quantum fluctuations under the same conditions that decoherence effects come into play, in agreement with earlier work. We also study an alternative measure of classical correlations, namely, the conditional probability of finding a sequence of position samplings, given that particular initial phase space data have occurred.We use these results to address the issue of the formal interpretation of the probabilities for sequences of position samplings in the decoherent histories approach to quantum mechanics. Under appropriate conditions, which we describe, they admit an interpretation as a statistical ensemble of classical solutions, with the probability of each individual classical solution given by a smeared Wigner function of its initial data. We study the decoherence properties of histories characterized by the value of the field equations, F, at a sequence of times. We argue that they will be decoherent if their initial data are decoherent.

arXiv:gr-qc/9307013•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Nov 15, 1993•48 citations
Abstract We revisit the classic “tipping pencil” instability, a rigid rod balanced upright on its tip and allowed to rotate in a vertical plane, long used as an introductory illustration of the quantum–classical boundary. In the standard semiclassical argument, the upright configuration is destabilized by minimal uncertainties in the initial angle and angular momentum, δθ\delta \thetaδθ δ θ and δL\delta LδL δ L , constrained by δθ δL≳ℏ/2\delta \theta \,\delta L\gtrsim \hbar /2δθδL≳ℏ/2 δ θ δ L ≳ ħ / 2 , with δL≃Iδω\delta L\simeq I\delta \omega δL≃Iδω δ L ≃ I δ ω . For a homogeneous cylinder of length a=10 cma=10\,\textrm{cm}a=10cm a = 10 cm and mass m=100 gm=100\,\textrm{g}m=100g m = 100 g , the resulting uncertainty-based initial scales are extremely small and lead to tipping times of order a few seconds. We show, however, that quantum fluctuations are not required as the dominant physical seed for a finite tipping time. A purely classical microscopic perturbation, such as the angular-momentum transfer from a single elastic collision with a residual O2 O_{2}O2​ O 2 molecule under ultrahigh-vacuum conditions, already provides a conservative seed for the exponential instability. Using conservation of angular momentum, we estimate an imparted angular velocity ω0,O2≃1.5×10−20 s−1 \omega _{0,O_{2}}\simeq 1.5\times 10^{-20}\,\textrm{s}^{-1}ω0,O2​​≃1.5×10−20s−1 ω 0 , O 2 ≃ 1.5 × 10 - 20 s - 1 , about five orders of magnitude smaller than the uncertainty-based angular-velocity scale, yet still sufficient to produce a macroscopic fall because the dependence on the seed is only logarithmic. We also include the more natural classical estimate due to thermal angular fluctuations. At room temperature, equipartition gives θth∼3×10−10 rad\theta _{\textrm{th}}\sim 3\times 10^{-10}\,\textrm{rad}θth​∼3×10−10rad θ th ∼ 3 × 10 - 10 rad and ωth∼3.5×10−9 s−1\omega _{\textrm{th}}\sim 3.5\times 10^{-9}\,\textrm{s}^{-1}ωth​∼3.5×10−9s−1 ω th ∼ 3.5 × 10 -
We study the tipping time of a quantum mechanical rod that is constrained to move in a plane in a gravitational potential. The initial state of the center of mass of the rod is localized within the base of support of the rod. The tipping time is found to increase exponentially with the height H of the rod as C1t0 exp[C2(H/H0)9], where C1 and C2 are dimensionless constants of order one, t0 is the time scale of the motion, and H0 is the length scale of the rod. We show that the tipping time cannot be obtained using the uncertainty principle alone, and compare our result to that obtained using the Wentzel–Kramers–Brillouin approximation.
The behaviour of a quantum rod, pivoted at its lower end on an impenetrable floor and restricted to moving in the vertical plane under the gravitational potential, is studied analytically under the approximation that the rod is initially localized to a 'small-enough' neighbourhood around the point of classical unstable equilibrium. It is shown that the rod evolves out of this neighbourhood. The time required for this to happen, i.e. the tipping time, is calculated using the semi-classical path integral. It is shown that equilibrium is recovered in the classical limit, and that our calculations are consistent with the uncertainty principle.
Does quantum mechanics matter at everyday scales? We generally assume that its consequences are confined to microscopic scales. It would be very surprising if quantum effects were to be manifest in a macroscopic system. This has been claimed for the problem of balancing a pencil on its tip. The claim has also been disputed. We argue that the behaviour of a tipping pencil can be explained by the asymptotic properties of the complete elliptic function, and can be understood in purely classical terms.
We calculate the tipping time of a quantum rod that has a height several times that of the edge length of its square base. We use an expression for the tipping time that has heuristic value, and gives the average time at which, upon measurement, the initially balanced rod is found to tip. We use two methods to calculate the tipping time. One method is to examine the "late time" behaviour of the quantum state of the center of mass of the rod by using an equation that has the form of the time-independent Schrödinger equation except that it involves a "complex energy." The other method uses energy resonances in the eigenstates of the Hamiltonian to determine the tipping time. We use the well-known Wentzel–Kramers–Brillouin approximation to calculate the energy eigenstates. With these methods, we obtain expressions for the tipping time that are valid for very long tipping times. PACS Nos.: 03.65.–w, 03.65.Xp
This paper is concerned with two questions in the decoherent histories approach to quantum mechanics: the emergence of approximate classical predictability, and the fluctuations about it necessitated by the uncertainty principle. It is in part a continuation of an earlier paper on the uncertainty principle for quantum-mechanical histories. We consider histories characterized by position samplings at n moments of time. This includes the case of position sampling continuous in time in the limit n\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}. We use this to construct a probability distribution on the value of (discrete approximations to) the field equations, F=mx\ifmmode\ddot\else\textasciidieresis\fi{}+V'(x), at n-2 times. We find that it is peaked around F=0; thus classical correlations are exhibited. We show that the width of the peak \ensuremath{\Delta}F is largely independent of the initial state. We show that the uncertainty principle takes the form 2${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}^{2}$(\ensuremath{\Delta}F)2{)}^{2})2\ensuremath{\ge}${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Elzxh}}}^{2}$/t2{\mathit{t}}^{2}t2, where \ensuremath{\sigma} is the width of the position samplings, and t is the time scale between projections. We determine the modifications to this result when the system is coupled to a thermal environment, thus obtaining a measure of the comparative sizes of quantum and thermal fluctuations. We show that the thermal fluctuations become comparable to the quantum fluctuations under the same conditions that decoherence effects come into play, in agreement with earlier work. We also study an alternative measure of classical correlations, namely, the conditional probability of finding a sequence of position samplings, given that particular initial phase space data have occurred.We use these results to address the issue of the formal interpretation of the probabilities for sequences of position samplings in the decoherent histories approach to quantum mechanics. Under appropriate conditions, which we describe, they admit an interpretation as a statistical ensemble of classical solutions, with the probability of each individual classical solution given by a smeared Wigner function of its initial data. We study the decoherence properties of histories characterized by the value of the field equations, F, at a sequence of times. We argue that they will be decoherent if their initial data are decoherent.