Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

European Journal of Physics

The quantum mechanical tipping pencil—a caution for physics teachers

Don Easton

Published Sep 12, 2007• 4 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Since at least as long ago as 1960, quantum mechanics has been applied with varying degrees of rigour to the problem of a pencil balancing on its point. Although the analysis of the problem may have some merit in terms of solving for the evolution of and the final state of a similarly shaped (rod-like) but microscopic object, it is misleading when students are given the idea that quantum mechanics is useful in describing the behaviour of macroscopic objects.

DOI
10.1088/0143-0807/28/6/007

Related papers

The Not-so-simple Pendulum: Balancing a Pencil on its Point

Peter Lynch

Does quantum mechanics matter at everyday scales? We generally assume that its consequences are confined to microscopic scales. It would be very surprising if quantum effects were to be manifest in a macroscopic system. This has been claimed for the problem of balancing a pencil on its tip. The claim has also been disputed. We argue that the behaviour of a tipping pencil can be explained by the asymptotic properties of the complete elliptic function, and can be understood in purely classical terms.

arXiv:1406.1125•Jun 4, 2014•3 citations

The Quantum world

Christian Ngô, J. B. Natowitz

The motion of macroscopic objects such as soccer balls, vehicles and planets can be well described using classical mechanics. However, classical mechanics is inadequate to describe the movements or the structure of microscopic objects such as atoms, molecules or nuclei. To properly describe the properties of microscopic objects, the theory of quantum mechanics was developed. While quantum mechanics can be applied to macroscopic objects, it turns out that for objects of large dimensions the quantum mechanical laws evolve naturally into classical mechanics. In general, solving a problem in quantum mechanics is far more difficult than solving it in classical mechanics. Therefore, the laws of classical mechanics are employed when they can be applied safely.

Routledge eBooks•Oct 1, 2025•0 citations

Exploring Quantum Mechanics: A Collection of 700+ Solved Problems for Students, Lecturers, and Researchers

Victor M. Galitski, Boris Mikhailovich Karnakov, Vladimir I Kogan

Abstract A series of seminal technological revolutions has led to a new generation of electronic devices miniaturized to such tiny scales that the strange laws of quantum physics come into play. There is no doubt that, unlike scientists and engineers of the past, technology leaders of the future will have to rely on quantum mechanics in their everyday work. This makes teaching and learning the subject of paramount importance for further progress. Mastering quantum physics is a very non-trivial task and its deep understanding can only be achieved through working out real-life problems and examples. It is notoriously difficult to come up with new quantum-mechanical problems that would be solvable with a pencil and paper, and within a finite amount of time. This book presents some 700+ original problems in quantum mechanics together with detailed solutions, covering nearly 1,000 pages on all aspects of quantum science.

•Feb 28, 2013•61 citations

Thinking in quantum terms

Leonard I. Schiff

It is now generally accepted that quantum mechanics occupies a central place in microscopic physical theory. The importance of this discipline shows up in the research journals, and also in the graduate physics curriculum. Not only is quantum mechanics a required subject, both for experimental and theoretical students; it appears as well to be influencing the way in which classical physics is taught. Presentations of classical mechanics that slight the traditional problems of planetary motion, unsymmetrical tops and dissipative systems in favor of collision theory and Poisson brackets are becoming more and more prevalent. With the much younger subject of classical electrodynamics, the analogous tendency is less marked, although here again emphasis is being placed on those examples that bring the student closest to the formalism of quantum electrodynamics. Such trends are of course proper and reasonable, especially so long as no important classical ideas are omitted from consideration. Indeed, the study of acoustics, hydrodynamics, and elasticity probably benefits from an early introduction of field concepts.

Physics Today•Jun 1, 1951•0 citations

The quantum pencil revisited

Kevin E. Riley, M. E. Riley

Abstract A quantum description is used to find the time limit for balancing an idealized pencil-like object on end. In agreement with some prior studies, analysis for this system shows that quantum effects are not observable in any foreseeable circumstances, either by casual experimentation or by extensive laboratory preparation. A direct solution of Schrodinger’s equation avoids an a priori use of the Heisenberg uncertainty relation in the classical equations of motion, which, although very much a proper usage, may lead to misunderstanding of the results. The classical equations of motion are adequate for the pencil in all circumstances.

European Journal of Physics•Sep 7, 2021•2 citations

What Quantum Mechanics Doesn't Show

Justin P. McBrayer, Dugald Owen

Students often invoke quantum mechanics in class or papers to make philosophical points.This tendency has been encouraged by pop culture influences like the film What the Bleep do We Know?There is little merit to most of these putative implications.However, it is difficult for philosophy teachers unfamiliar with quantum mechanics to handle these supposed implications in a clear and careful way.This paper is a philosophy of science version of MythBusters.We offer a brief primer on the nature of quantum mechanics, enumerate nine of the most common implications associated with quantum mechanics, and finally clarify each implication with the facts.Our goal is to explain what quantum mechanics doesn't show.

Teaching Philosophy•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations
Since at least as long ago as 1960, quantum mechanics has been applied with varying degrees of rigour to the problem of a pencil balancing on its point. Although the analysis of the problem may have some merit in terms of solving for the evolution of and the final state of a similarly shaped (rod-like) but microscopic object, it is misleading when students are given the idea that quantum mechanics is useful in describing the behaviour of macroscopic objects.
Does quantum mechanics matter at everyday scales? We generally assume that its consequences are confined to microscopic scales. It would be very surprising if quantum effects were to be manifest in a macroscopic system. This has been claimed for the problem of balancing a pencil on its tip. The claim has also been disputed. We argue that the behaviour of a tipping pencil can be explained by the asymptotic properties of the complete elliptic function, and can be understood in purely classical terms.
The motion of macroscopic objects such as soccer balls, vehicles and planets can be well described using classical mechanics. However, classical mechanics is inadequate to describe the movements or the structure of microscopic objects such as atoms, molecules or nuclei. To properly describe the properties of microscopic objects, the theory of quantum mechanics was developed. While quantum mechanics can be applied to macroscopic objects, it turns out that for objects of large dimensions the quantum mechanical laws evolve naturally into classical mechanics. In general, solving a problem in quantum mechanics is far more difficult than solving it in classical mechanics. Therefore, the laws of classical mechanics are employed when they can be applied safely.
Abstract A series of seminal technological revolutions has led to a new generation of electronic devices miniaturized to such tiny scales that the strange laws of quantum physics come into play. There is no doubt that, unlike scientists and engineers of the past, technology leaders of the future will have to rely on quantum mechanics in their everyday work. This makes teaching and learning the subject of paramount importance for further progress. Mastering quantum physics is a very non-trivial task and its deep understanding can only be achieved through working out real-life problems and examples. It is notoriously difficult to come up with new quantum-mechanical problems that would be solvable with a pencil and paper, and within a finite amount of time. This book presents some 700+ original problems in quantum mechanics together with detailed solutions, covering nearly 1,000 pages on all aspects of quantum science.
It is now generally accepted that quantum mechanics occupies a central place in microscopic physical theory. The importance of this discipline shows up in the research journals, and also in the graduate physics curriculum. Not only is quantum mechanics a required subject, both for experimental and theoretical students; it appears as well to be influencing the way in which classical physics is taught. Presentations of classical mechanics that slight the traditional problems of planetary motion, unsymmetrical tops and dissipative systems in favor of collision theory and Poisson brackets are becoming more and more prevalent. With the much younger subject of classical electrodynamics, the analogous tendency is less marked, although here again emphasis is being placed on those examples that bring the student closest to the formalism of quantum electrodynamics. Such trends are of course proper and reasonable, especially so long as no important classical ideas are omitted from consideration. Indeed, the study of acoustics, hydrodynamics, and elasticity probably benefits from an early introduction of field concepts.
Abstract A quantum description is used to find the time limit for balancing an idealized pencil-like object on end. In agreement with some prior studies, analysis for this system shows that quantum effects are not observable in any foreseeable circumstances, either by casual experimentation or by extensive laboratory preparation. A direct solution of Schrodinger’s equation avoids an a priori use of the Heisenberg uncertainty relation in the classical equations of motion, which, although very much a proper usage, may lead to misunderstanding of the results. The classical equations of motion are adequate for the pencil in all circumstances.
Students often invoke quantum mechanics in class or papers to make philosophical points.This tendency has been encouraged by pop culture influences like the film What the Bleep do We Know?There is little merit to most of these putative implications.However, it is difficult for philosophy teachers unfamiliar with quantum mechanics to handle these supposed implications in a clear and careful way.This paper is a philosophy of science version of MythBusters.We offer a brief primer on the nature of quantum mechanics, enumerate nine of the most common implications associated with quantum mechanics, and finally clarify each implication with the facts.Our goal is to explain what quantum mechanics doesn't show.