European Journal of Physics
The quantum mechanical tipping pencil—a caution for physics teachers
Don Easton
Abstract
Since at least as long ago as 1960, quantum mechanics has been applied with varying degrees of rigour to the problem of a pencil balancing on its point. Although the analysis of the problem may have some merit in terms of solving for the evolution of and the final state of a similarly shaped (rod-like) but microscopic object, it is misleading when students are given the idea that quantum mechanics is useful in describing the behaviour of macroscopic objects.