Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1406.1125

The Not-so-simple Pendulum: Balancing a Pencil on its Point

Peter Lynch

Published Jun 4, 2014• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Does quantum mechanics matter at everyday scales? We generally assume that its consequences are confined to microscopic scales. It would be very surprising if quantum effects were to be manifest in a macroscopic system. This has been claimed for the problem of balancing a pencil on its tip. The claim has also been disputed. We argue that the behaviour of a tipping pencil can be explained by the asymptotic properties of the complete elliptic function, and can be understood in purely classical terms.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1406.1125

Related papers

The quantum mechanical tipping pencil—a caution for physics teachers

Don Easton

Since at least as long ago as 1960, quantum mechanics has been applied with varying degrees of rigour to the problem of a pencil balancing on its point. Although the analysis of the problem may have some merit in terms of solving for the evolution of and the final state of a similarly shaped (rod-like) but microscopic object, it is misleading when students are given the idea that quantum mechanics is useful in describing the behaviour of macroscopic objects.

European Journal of Physics•Sep 12, 2007•4 citations

The Emergence of Classical Dynamics in a Quantum World

Tanmoy Bhattacharya A, Salman Habib, Kurt A. Jacobs

Ever since the advent of quantum mechanics, it has been clear that the atoms composing matter do not obey Newton's laws. Instead, their behavior is described by the Schroedinger equation. Surprisingly though, until recently, no clear explanation was given for why everyday objects, which are merely collections of atoms, are observed to obey Newton's laws. It would seem that, if quantum mechanics explains all the properties of atoms accurately, they, too, should obey quantum mechanics. This reasoning led some scientists to believe in a distinct macroscopic, or ``big and complicated,'' world in which quantum mechanics fails and classical mechanics takes over, although there has never been experimental evidence for such a failure. Even those who insisted that Newtonian mechanics would somehow emerge from the underlying quantum mechanics as the system became increasingly macroscopic were hindered by the lack of adequate experimental and theoretical tools. In the last decade, however, this quantum-to-classical transition has become accessible to experimental study and quantitative description, and the resulting insights are the subject of this article.

arXiv:quant-ph/0407096•Jul 14, 2004•12 citations

On the Classical Limit of Quantum Mechanics

M. Baldo

One of the main unsolved question in Quantum Mechanics (QM) is its compatibility with classical mechanics. The laws of QM, which describe the microscopic world, must merge into the classical ones for large enough physical systems, but it is still unknown at which point, if any, the transition occurs and if the transition is smooth or sudden as the size increases. Furthermore, a strict extension of QM to the macroscopic world leads to well known 'paradoxes', which is not straightforward to solve. This question is tightly connected with the measurement problem, since any measurement apparatus must give a response which can be described at classical level. Many experiments have been performed to answer to this question. They mainly try to find to which extent the number of particles can be increased in order to observe clear evidence of violation of standard QM. In this paper we argue that the macroscopicity parameter is not the number of particles but the number of independent degrees of freedom, as proposed in a recent model for the completion of QM. This introduces a sort of change of paradigm. To support this claim a representative set of well known experiments are analyzed from this point of view. This brings to a new interpretation of the experiments. A general scheme for the quantum-classical transition is discussed in some details.

arXiv:2607.09735•Jul 2, 2026•1 citation

The quantum pendulum: Small and large

Gregory L. Baker, James A. Blackburn, H. Smith

The quantum pendulum finds application in surprising contexts. We use commercially available software to numerically solve the Schrödinger equation for a microscopic pendulum subject to molecular (electromagnetic) restoring forces, and a macroscopic pendulum subject to a gravitational restoring force. The dynamics of the microscopic quantum pendulum are closely related to molecular motions known as hindered rotations. We use standard probabilistic methods to predict whether this motion is weakly or strongly hindered at ambient temperature and test the prediction against experimental data for C2H6 and K2PtCl6. For the macroscopic gravitational pendulum, we examine the uncertainty in position and find, not surprisingly, that it is too small to measure physically, but is nevertheless relatively large compared to present-day limits in computation. The latter juxtaposition of computational precision with quantum uncertainty has consequences for the study of chaotic dynamics.

American Journal of Physics•May 1, 2002•33 citations

Nanomechanical Quantum Limits

M. P. Blencowe

Quantum effects usually manifest themselves only in the microscopic world of atoms, whereas macroscopic objects of the everyday world follow the classical laws of Newtonian mechanics. But can large objects also behave quantum mechanically? In his Perspective, Blencowe discusses work reported in the same issue by LaHaye et al. on attempts to observe the phenomenon of Heisenberg9s uncertainty principle in a relatively large vibrating beam. Although still small by everyday standards, the microfabricated beam consists of about 10atoms. The measurements indicate that the apparatus is within striking distance of direct observation of quantum fluctuations.

Science•Apr 1, 2004•32 citations

The quantum pencil revisited

Kevin E. Riley, M. E. Riley

Abstract A quantum description is used to find the time limit for balancing an idealized pencil-like object on end. In agreement with some prior studies, analysis for this system shows that quantum effects are not observable in any foreseeable circumstances, either by casual experimentation or by extensive laboratory preparation. A direct solution of Schrodinger’s equation avoids an a priori use of the Heisenberg uncertainty relation in the classical equations of motion, which, although very much a proper usage, may lead to misunderstanding of the results. The classical equations of motion are adequate for the pencil in all circumstances.

European Journal of Physics•Sep 7, 2021•2 citations
Does quantum mechanics matter at everyday scales? We generally assume that its consequences are confined to microscopic scales. It would be very surprising if quantum effects were to be manifest in a macroscopic system. This has been claimed for the problem of balancing a pencil on its tip. The claim has also been disputed. We argue that the behaviour of a tipping pencil can be explained by the asymptotic properties of the complete elliptic function, and can be understood in purely classical terms.
Ever since the advent of quantum mechanics, it has been clear that the atoms composing matter do not obey Newton's laws. Instead, their behavior is described by the Schroedinger equation. Surprisingly though, until recently, no clear explanation was given for why everyday objects, which are merely collections of atoms, are observed to obey Newton's laws. It would seem that, if quantum mechanics explains all the properties of atoms accurately, they, too, should obey quantum mechanics. This reasoning led some scientists to believe in a distinct macroscopic, or ``big and complicated,'' world in which quantum mechanics fails and classical mechanics takes over, although there has never been experimental evidence for such a failure. Even those who insisted that Newtonian mechanics would somehow emerge from the underlying quantum mechanics as the system became increasingly macroscopic were hindered by the lack of adequate experimental and theoretical tools. In the last decade, however, this quantum-to-classical transition has become accessible to experimental study and quantitative description, and the resulting insights are the subject of this article.
One of the main unsolved question in Quantum Mechanics (QM) is its compatibility with classical mechanics. The laws of QM, which describe the microscopic world, must merge into the classical ones for large enough physical systems, but it is still unknown at which point, if any, the transition occurs and if the transition is smooth or sudden as the size increases. Furthermore, a strict extension of QM to the macroscopic world leads to well known 'paradoxes', which is not straightforward to solve. This question is tightly connected with the measurement problem, since any measurement apparatus must give a response which can be described at classical level. Many experiments have been performed to answer to this question. They mainly try to find to which extent the number of particles can be increased in order to observe clear evidence of violation of standard QM. In this paper we argue that the macroscopicity parameter is not the number of particles but the number of independent degrees of freedom, as proposed in a recent model for the completion of QM. This introduces a sort of change of paradigm. To support this claim a representative set of well known experiments are analyzed from this point of view. This brings to a new interpretation of the experiments. A general scheme for the quantum-classical transition is discussed in some details.
The quantum pendulum finds application in surprising contexts. We use commercially available software to numerically solve the Schrödinger equation for a microscopic pendulum subject to molecular (electromagnetic) restoring forces, and a macroscopic pendulum subject to a gravitational restoring force. The dynamics of the microscopic quantum pendulum are closely related to molecular motions known as hindered rotations. We use standard probabilistic methods to predict whether this motion is weakly or strongly hindered at ambient temperature and test the prediction against experimental data for C2H6 and K2PtCl6. For the macroscopic gravitational pendulum, we examine the uncertainty in position and find, not surprisingly, that it is too small to measure physically, but is nevertheless relatively large compared to present-day limits in computation. The latter juxtaposition of computational precision with quantum uncertainty has consequences for the study of chaotic dynamics.
Quantum effects usually manifest themselves only in the microscopic world of atoms, whereas macroscopic objects of the everyday world follow the classical laws of Newtonian mechanics. But can large objects also behave quantum mechanically? In his Perspective, Blencowe discusses work reported in the same issue by LaHaye et al. on attempts to observe the phenomenon of Heisenberg9s uncertainty principle in a relatively large vibrating beam. Although still small by everyday standards, the microfabricated beam consists of about 10atoms. The measurements indicate that the apparatus is within striking distance of direct observation of quantum fluctuations.
Abstract A quantum description is used to find the time limit for balancing an idealized pencil-like object on end. In agreement with some prior studies, analysis for this system shows that quantum effects are not observable in any foreseeable circumstances, either by casual experimentation or by extensive laboratory preparation. A direct solution of Schrodinger’s equation avoids an a priori use of the Heisenberg uncertainty relation in the classical equations of motion, which, although very much a proper usage, may lead to misunderstanding of the results. The classical equations of motion are adequate for the pencil in all circumstances.