Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

An LLM as a controllable, fully-inspectable model of measurement: which features of quantum measurement are generic to bounded inference, and which are not

Tomas Pødenphant Lund

Published Jun 16, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

An autoregressive language model, read at the token-commit step, is a near-fully-inspectable classical bounded-inference substrate: the competing-route distribution over candidate tokens — the live propensity before it resolves into one committed answer — is read directly from the output logits. Used as a measurement model, it lets each structural signature of quantum measurement be tested one by one, and the genuinely-quantum residue isolated by its absence. The substrate reproduces the phenomenology of quantum measurement from classical self-conditioning — back-action, non-commutativity (order effects), entropy-collapse on commitment, a substantial Busemeyer–Wang QQ-structure (order-effect difference q not distinguishable from the parameter-free quantum value 0; pooled across eight de-saturated base models over five vendors and four architectures, N=96, q=-0.003, 95% CI [-0.025, +0.019]), interference, einselection, an Aharonov-style weak-versus-strong asymmetry, and measurement-mode dependence — but not the quantum core: genuine contextuality is robustly absent (an analog Contextuality-by-Default cyclic-4 analysis gives CNT < 0 in every model and scenario), and no phase/coherence is demonstrated. A controllable analog Bell-loophole testbed makes each premise's price visible within one substrate (S_analog ~ 2.00 with all loopholes closed; ~ 2.8 on opening locality or measurement-independence), and a within-substrate timeline reads the propensity resolving across network depth, including a maximally-contested case whose outcome is never created. The order-effect incompatibility is shown to be a measured, correctly-signed classical-complementarity dial that falls as the readout partition refines. Positioning. The contribution is the demarcation itself, with statistics, made possible by an inspectability no veiled (physical or psychological) substrate allows. It instantiates beim Graben & Atmanspacher's classical complementarity and the Busemeyer–Wang / Pothos quantum-cognition program empirically; it makes no claim about physical reality. Companion papers (Friction Theory series): Paper 1 — Friction as the cost of probabilistic computation (10.5281/zenodo.20012654); Paper 10 — Race all the way down/up (10.5281/zenodo.20014567); Paper 21 — LLMs as a measurement model for bounded-decision cognition (10.5281/zenodo.20562416); Paper 28 — Dread without a dreader (10.5281/zenodo.20690747).Paper 18 in the Friction Theory paper-series. Submitted as a careful, honestly-scoped empirical demarcation (target venue: Entropy, Quantum Information / quantum-cognition & foundations-of-measurement). v2 (August 2026) — prior-art revision. The paper describes competition resolving to a commitment and cited none of the tradition that formalised it. Luce (1959) for the choice axiom the softmax implements, Ratcliff (1978) for evidence accumulated to a bound, and Usher and McClelland (2001) for the leaky competing accumulator are now credited at the point where the reading is made, with the limit stated: the estimators here are computed on a language model's output distribution, and the parallel is why the measurement was worth making rather than evidence of a shared mechanism. Editorial pass. Earlier versions remain in the version history.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.20586317

Related papers

Substrate-Flexible Informational Quantum Mechanics: QBism, RQM, and the Question of Non-Human Epistemic Systems

Ian Staley

The QBist and Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM) informational readings of quantum theory have been developed across two decades without a clear position on what kind of physical system qualifies as an "agent" or "observer" for the formalism. Fuchs, Mermin, and Schack write as if the agent is a human physicist or a generic Bayesian; Rovelli writes as if any physical system can play the relational-observer role; Healey deflates the agent into an abstract Bayesian without specifying its substrate; the recent Khrennikov-Schack-Zwirn intersubjectivity exchange sharpens the question without resolving it. This paper argues that the QBism/RQM informational reading is substrate-flexible: any physical system whose input-output statistics admit characterization through quantum-probability structure with non-trivial Contextuality-by-Default (CbD) signatures resistant to simplex-embeddable ontological models is a candidate epistemic agent for the formalism. Substrate flexibility is the most coherent reading of the shared formal commitments of QBism and RQM once the agent role is separated from historically human-centered examples; the non-triviality requirement is necessary but not sufficient for agency, which additionally requires an input-output architecture capable of state-sensitive updating across measurement contexts. The thesis preserves the QBist objection to view-from-nowhere framings while removing the requirement that agents be human or conscious; it disciplines Rovelli's "any physical system" claim by indexing it to the non-triviality requirement; and it specifies what would count as evidence for or against. Engineered cortical wetware preparations (Cortical Labs CL1, DishBrain) provide a non-human, non-conscious-in-any-unambiguous-sense, controllable testbed on which the question can be empirically pursued; nothing in the argument requires attributing phenomenal consciousness or quantum-coherent biological dynamics to such systems. The paper distinguishes substrate flexibility from Pienaar's prior extension of the QBist agent (which extends the agent's senses, not its substrate), engages the neo-Everettian opposition (Wallace 2012, 2023) directly, and rejects the recent attempts (Edwards 2024, 2025) to fold classical large language models into a QBism-grounded formalism. Classical AI architectures admit simplex-embeddable models for their token-generation processes and therefore fail the non-triviality requirement; substrate flexibility is narrower, not wider, than such proposals.

•May 8, 2026•0 citations

Auditing Question-Order Effects in Large Language Models with the QQ Equality: Mechanism Characterization and a Saturation Caveat

Pilsung Kang

Question-order effects in human survey data have been reported to approximately satisfy the QQ (quantum question) equality, a parameter-free prediction of the standard projective quantum question-order model. We develop this equality into an audit framework for sequential binary judgments of autoregressive large language models (LLMs). Theoretically, we characterize mechanism families that satisfy QQ robustly, show that classical repetition can reproduce the equality exactly, and combine QQ with the rank-2 Contextuality-by-Default criterion through $|q_{QQ}| \le \mathrm{OSS}$. This separates order sensitivity, QQ imbalance, and residual contextuality rather than treating them as interchangeable signatures. Methodologically, we introduce a committed multi-turn forced-branch protocol that reconstructs order-conditioned joint distributions from next-token log-probabilities under counterbalanced label mappings and pre-specified health gates. A first-signal pilot on an open-weight instruction-tuned model reveals the central measurement problem. Although all pre-specified health gates passed, the binary-conditioned distributions were near-deterministic for 17 of 18 item pairs under the direct-evaluation framing and 7 of 8 under the persona framing. Label assignment materially changed several mapping-specific QQ verdicts, and no item was certified as residually contextual. Thus, under the tested conditions, the observed QQ outcomes did not uniquely identify a response mechanism in the presence of a saturated and label-sensitive measurement interface. The main implication is methodological: next-token probabilities should not be interpreted as survey-response distributions without first establishing adequate dispersion. We therefore argue that saturation screening and label counterbalancing should precede structural interpretation in distribution-level audits of LLM judgments.

cs.CLCross-listedarXiv:2607.17219•Jul 21, 2026•0 citations

Quantum phenomenology from a classical integer automaton: an emergent Schrödinger sector, a measurable collapse law, exact exchange statistics, CHSH violation without randomness, and a surviving isotropy no-go

Daniel Marko

A single bit-exactly reversible, integer-valued lattice automaton in which a broad range of quantum phenomenology arises as measurable, checksum-reproducible behaviour of one classical substrate. A second-order Frenkel–Kontorova / sine-Gordon integer automaton supports localized particles with additive mass towers (1 : 2 : 3 and 1 : 4 : 9), emergent Lorentz contraction (fitted c to 0.3 %), and a token-accounted local-time sector with a general-relativity-like time well (ω ∝ n to 0.06 %). Within it, a first-order Visscher–Feistel integer Schrödinger sector is realized in pure integer arithmetic with exact bit-reversibility. The integer/floor-reversible lifting of the Visscher scheme was already noted by Fredkin (1999) and Martin-Delgado (2004); the contribution here is its first computationally tested and validated realization — against exact dispersion, group velocity and envelope reduction — embedded in an interacting substrate. Main results: Emergence bridge. The narrow-band envelope of the classical automaton obeys the Schrödinger equation with an effective mass fixed by the curvature of the exact discrete dispersion (group velocity to ≤0.2 %, curvature to ≤2 %). The dimensionless spreading of two microscopically different substrates collapses onto the single universal law √(1+τ²). Deterministic quantum statistics. Bohmian tracers reproduce double-slit single-object interference (p < 10⁻⁴), with trajectories matching the weak-measurement reconstruction of Kocsis et al. (2011). Bell / CHSH. A value of S = 2.79 from position-valued outcomes with a no-signalling control (0.3 %), via explicitly nonlocal guidance in configuration space. Measurement. A measurable Gaussian collapse law (R² = 0.997); a quantum eraser with literal bit-reversible un-measurement of the entire measurement chain; Pauli exclusion as a bit-conserved invariant; and relaxation to the Born rule with a reversible arrow of time. Surviving the isotropy no-go, and a falsifiable prediction (new in v2). On the live integer engine, velocity anisotropy vanishes as k² in the infrared with first-principles coefficients in both 2D and 3D (agreement ≈ 1 %) — rotational isotropy emerges as an infrared fixed point, meeting the sharpest no-go every lattice candidate faces. From the same structure follows a concrete, quadratically Planck-suppressed dispersion prediction (δγ,2 ≈ 2×10−40 GeV−2, subluminal), lying only ~50× below the tightest ultra-high-energy cosmic-ray bound — the programme's first falsifiable departure from standard QM/GR. Individual phenomena have known precedents — double-slit Bohmian trajectories (Philippidis, Dewdney & Hiley 1979), Born-rule relaxation (Valentini & Westman 2005), the Schrödinger update scheme (Visscher 1991; integer lifting Fredkin 1999, Martin-Delgado 2004) — and are framed accordingly. The contribution is their tested, validated realization on one exactly reproducible integer substrate, several genuinely new exact constructions (tested integer bit-reversible Schrödinger sector; literal bit-exact un-measurement; exchange statistics as a bit-conserved invariant; two-substrate universal collapse; measured lattice isotropy with a Planck-scale dispersion prediction), and a pre-registered, falsification-first methodology (criteria committed to version control before each run; fourteen self-retractions on record). This is an existence result, strengthened by a survived no-go and a falsifiable prediction — not a claim that our universe is this automaton (that step requires a prediction to pass experiment): a fully classical, deterministic, reversible integer computation can carry quantum phenomenology, quantitatively and reproducibly, and this substrate meets a no-go every discrete candidate must survive. Preprint v2 (self-contained; bibliographic audit completed against arXiv/DOI sources). Code, pre-registered gates, per-run reports and figures are included in this archive. Produced in an AI-assisted workflow (Anthropic Claude) under the author's direction; all pre-registration and interpretation is on record in the version history.

•Jul 21, 2026•0 citations

Substrate-Flexible Informational Quantum Mechanics: QBism, RQM, and the Question of Non-Human Epistemic Systems

Ian Staley

The QBist and Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM) informational readings of quantum theory have long lacked a clear account of what kind of physical system qualifies as an “agent” or “observer.” Fuchs, Mermin, and Schack often treat the agent as a human physicist or Bayesian decision-maker; Rovelli suggests that any physical system may serve as a relational observer; Healey abstracts the agent into a Bayesian role without specifying its substrate; and the Khrennikov-Schack-Zwirn exchange sharpens, but does not resolve, the intersubjectivity problem. This paper argues that the QBism/RQM informational reading is best understood as substrate-flexible: any physical system whose input-output statistics exhibit quantum-probability structure, including non-trivial Contextuality-by-Default (CbD) signatures resistant to simplex-embeddable ontological models, is a candidate epistemic agent. This condition is necessary but not sufficient: agency also requires state-sensitive updating across measurement contexts. The argument preserves QBism’s rejection of view-from-nowhere objectivity while removing the assumption that agents must be human or conscious, and disciplines Rovelli’s “any physical system” claim by tying observerhood to measurable non-triviality. Engineered cortical wetware systems such as CL1 and DishBrain offer controllable, non-human, and not clearly conscious testbeds for evaluating this claim, without requiring phenomenal consciousness or quantum-coherent biological dynamics. The paper distinguishes substrate flexibility from Pienaar’s extension of the QBist agent, which expands the agent’s senses rather than its substrate; engages neo-Everettian objections; and rejects Edwards’s attempts to fold classical large language models into QBist formalism. Classical AI token-generation systems remain simplex-embeddable and therefore fail the non-triviality requirement. Substrate flexibility is thus narrower than proposals that include current AI systems.

•Aug 11, 2026•0 citations

A Classical Candidate-Geometry Baseline Audit Framework for Quantum-like Contextuality in AI

John Jude Hathway

This preprint defines the classical candidate-geometry baselines that should be compared before any claim of non-classicality in the quantum-like contextual non-additivity, order effects, and Bell-type indicators reported for large language models (LLMs) and masked language models (MLMs), and quantifies their explanatory power and limits. It does not claim physical quantum coherence in AI, nor a full explanation of AI quantum-like behavior. The revised edition adds four components. (i) Detection-power certification: the detector's condition is ICC < S_odd - 2, and Tsirelson-level injection tests certify that genuine contextuality of that magnitude would be detectable at the empirical signaling levels; the 312 Experiment-4 tables all satisfy S_odd < 2 with zero corrected excess, so the negative result is not attributable to ICC-induced blindness. (ii) A product-distribution theorem establishing that the zero excess of independent scoring is a mathematical necessity, not an empirical finding. (iii) A structural reproduction of the Lo et al. construction with a no-model null: uniformly random marginals without any language model already reach a CbD-contextual rate of 0.667 (vs. 0.711 reported), and the real BERT/RoBERTa rates are largely indistinguishable from a marginal-matched sign-randomized null at substantive effect sizes. (iv) A multi-model audit across six models from four families: raw S_odd > 2 appears (max 2.773) but is entirely explained by direct influence, with zero corrected excess across all 144 tables and on the powered subset. The package includes the manuscript (LaTeX source and PDF), figures, reproduction code, and data (including the raw joint probabilities from which the per-table metrics are regenerated and cross-checked). Central thesis: reading AI quantum-like behavior as non-classicality requires exceeding not the raw score but the combination of classical candidate-geometry baselines, direct-influence correction, detector-power certification, and a no-model null. This work is neither a full reproduction nor a refutation of Lo et al.; it audits the interpretation of raw contextual-instance counts. Manuscript language: English. Code is released under the MIT License; text and figures under CC BY 4.0. Note: Parts of the manuscript were linguistically and structurally refined with the assistance of AI-based tools.All scientific content, analysis, and conclusions are the author's own.

•Jun 13, 2026•0 citations

Measurement as Record-Registration: A Locked-Null Protocol for Testing Record-Level Structure in Quantum Computing Readout

William T Partin

This manuscript presents a methods-forward, operational protocol for evaluating whether any structured dependence remains in quantum-computing measurement records after explicit modeling of standard quantum and device-level mechanisms. Classical definiteness is defined at the record layer, and pre-record states are treated as predictive descriptions rather than as classical outcome facts. Within this operational stance, the protocol converts questions about outcome status and record formation into a falsifiable test program grounded in preregistered analysis rules and standard measurement telemetry. A locked null-model family is specified in advance, incorporating standard quantum dynamics together with documented device-level mechanisms including drift, correlated and non-Markovian noise, crosstalk proxies, and leakage indicators. The framework provides operational definitions, a conservative postulate set, preregistered endpoints, residual-adjudication criteria, negative controls, a fixed windowing discipline, and a bound-first reporting standard designed to yield informative constraints under null results. Any candidate contribution beyond the declared null family must appear as structured, reproducible residual dependence that survives the locked null family and the full residual-filter sequence. Version 4.4 refines the protocol specification, clarifies evidentiary boundaries, and strengthens the integration of the synthetic demonstration. The manuscript includes a fully specified classical simulation that executes the decision pipeline under controlled conditions. The synthetic study illustrates how the protocol classifies a bounded-null case, a measured-artifact case, a partial-artifact/unresolved-covariate case, an injected structured-residual case, and a failed-topology case. This demonstration establishes computational executability of the protocol and clarifies the behavior of the decision tree, but it does not constitute empirical evidence for any physical mechanism. Because the protocol relies only on standard measurement telemetry and preregistered analysis rules, it is directly implementable across contemporary quantum-computing platforms and does not depend on any single dataset, backend, or hardware realization. The manuscript is a specification paper: it defines a reproducible evidentiary framework for record-level claims, while large-scale empirical implementation, hardware benchmarking, and cross-platform replication remain subsequent studies.

•Mar 17, 2026•0 citations
An autoregressive language model, read at the token-commit step, is a near-fully-inspectable classical bounded-inference substrate: the competing-route distribution over candidate tokens — the live propensity before it resolves into one committed answer — is read directly from the output logits. Used as a measurement model, it lets each structural signature of quantum measurement be tested one by one, and the genuinely-quantum residue isolated by its absence. The substrate reproduces the phenomenology of quantum measurement from classical self-conditioning — back-action, non-commutativity (order effects), entropy-collapse on commitment, a substantial Busemeyer–Wang QQ-structure (order-effect difference q not distinguishable from the parameter-free quantum value 0; pooled across eight de-saturated base models over five vendors and four architectures, N=96, q=-0.003, 95% CI [-0.025, +0.019]), interference, einselection, an Aharonov-style weak-versus-strong asymmetry, and measurement-mode dependence — but not the quantum core: genuine contextuality is robustly absent (an analog Contextuality-by-Default cyclic-4 analysis gives CNT < 0 in every model and scenario), and no phase/coherence is demonstrated. A controllable analog Bell-loophole testbed makes each premise's price visible within one substrate (S_analog ~ 2.00 with all loopholes closed; ~ 2.8 on opening locality or measurement-independence), and a within-substrate timeline reads the propensity resolving across network depth, including a maximally-contested case whose outcome is never created. The order-effect incompatibility is shown to be a measured, correctly-signed classical-complementarity dial that falls as the readout partition refines. Positioning. The contribution is the demarcation itself, with statistics, made possible by an inspectability no veiled (physical or psychological) substrate allows. It instantiates beim Graben & Atmanspacher's classical complementarity and the Busemeyer–Wang / Pothos quantum-cognition program empirically; it makes no claim about physical reality. Companion papers (Friction Theory series): Paper 1 — Friction as the cost of probabilistic computation (10.5281/zenodo.20012654); Paper 10 — Race all the way down/up (10.5281/zenodo.20014567); Paper 21 — LLMs as a measurement model for bounded-decision cognition (10.5281/zenodo.20562416); Paper 28 — Dread without a dreader (10.5281/zenodo.20690747).Paper 18 in the Friction Theory paper-series. Submitted as a careful, honestly-scoped empirical demarcation (target venue: Entropy, Quantum Information / quantum-cognition & foundations-of-measurement). v2 (August 2026) — prior-art revision. The paper describes competition resolving to a commitment and cited none of the tradition that formalised it. Luce (1959) for the choice axiom the softmax implements, Ratcliff (1978) for evidence accumulated to a bound, and Usher and McClelland (2001) for the leaky competing accumulator are now credited at the point where the reading is made, with the limit stated: the estimators here are computed on a language model's output distribution, and the parallel is why the measurement was worth making rather than evidence of a shared mechanism. Editorial pass. Earlier versions remain in the version history.
The QBist and Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM) informational readings of quantum theory have been developed across two decades without a clear position on what kind of physical system qualifies as an "agent" or "observer" for the formalism. Fuchs, Mermin, and Schack write as if the agent is a human physicist or a generic Bayesian; Rovelli writes as if any physical system can play the relational-observer role; Healey deflates the agent into an abstract Bayesian without specifying its substrate; the recent Khrennikov-Schack-Zwirn intersubjectivity exchange sharpens the question without resolving it. This paper argues that the QBism/RQM informational reading is substrate-flexible: any physical system whose input-output statistics admit characterization through quantum-probability structure with non-trivial Contextuality-by-Default (CbD) signatures resistant to simplex-embeddable ontological models is a candidate epistemic agent for the formalism. Substrate flexibility is the most coherent reading of the shared formal commitments of QBism and RQM once the agent role is separated from historically human-centered examples; the non-triviality requirement is necessary but not sufficient for agency, which additionally requires an input-output architecture capable of state-sensitive updating across measurement contexts. The thesis preserves the QBist objection to view-from-nowhere framings while removing the requirement that agents be human or conscious; it disciplines Rovelli's "any physical system" claim by indexing it to the non-triviality requirement; and it specifies what would count as evidence for or against. Engineered cortical wetware preparations (Cortical Labs CL1, DishBrain) provide a non-human, non-conscious-in-any-unambiguous-sense, controllable testbed on which the question can be empirically pursued; nothing in the argument requires attributing phenomenal consciousness or quantum-coherent biological dynamics to such systems. The paper distinguishes substrate flexibility from Pienaar's prior extension of the QBist agent (which extends the agent's senses, not its substrate), engages the neo-Everettian opposition (Wallace 2012, 2023) directly, and rejects the recent attempts (Edwards 2024, 2025) to fold classical large language models into a QBism-grounded formalism. Classical AI architectures admit simplex-embeddable models for their token-generation processes and therefore fail the non-triviality requirement; substrate flexibility is narrower, not wider, than such proposals.
Question-order effects in human survey data have been reported to approximately satisfy the QQ (quantum question) equality, a parameter-free prediction of the standard projective quantum question-order model. We develop this equality into an audit framework for sequential binary judgments of autoregressive large language models (LLMs). Theoretically, we characterize mechanism families that satisfy QQ robustly, show that classical repetition can reproduce the equality exactly, and combine QQ with the rank-2 Contextuality-by-Default criterion through ∣qQQ∣≤OSS|q_{QQ}| \le \mathrm{OSS}∣qQQ​∣≤OSS. This separates order sensitivity, QQ imbalance, and residual contextuality rather than treating them as interchangeable signatures. Methodologically, we introduce a committed multi-turn forced-branch protocol that reconstructs order-conditioned joint distributions from next-token log-probabilities under counterbalanced label mappings and pre-specified health gates. A first-signal pilot on an open-weight instruction-tuned model reveals the central measurement problem. Although all pre-specified health gates passed, the binary-conditioned distributions were near-deterministic for 17 of 18 item pairs under the direct-evaluation framing and 7 of 8 under the persona framing. Label assignment materially changed several mapping-specific QQ verdicts, and no item was certified as residually contextual. Thus, under the tested conditions, the observed QQ outcomes did not uniquely identify a response mechanism in the presence of a saturated and label-sensitive measurement interface. The main implication is methodological: next-token probabilities should not be interpreted as survey-response distributions without first establishing adequate dispersion. We therefore argue that saturation screening and label counterbalancing should precede structural interpretation in distribution-level audits of LLM judgments.
A single bit-exactly reversible, integer-valued lattice automaton in which a broad range of quantum phenomenology arises as measurable, checksum-reproducible behaviour of one classical substrate. A second-order Frenkel–Kontorova / sine-Gordon integer automaton supports localized particles with additive mass towers (1 : 2 : 3 and 1 : 4 : 9), emergent Lorentz contraction (fitted c to 0.3 %), and a token-accounted local-time sector with a general-relativity-like time well (ω ∝ n to 0.06 %). Within it, a first-order Visscher–Feistel integer Schrödinger sector is realized in pure integer arithmetic with exact bit-reversibility. The integer/floor-reversible lifting of the Visscher scheme was already noted by Fredkin (1999) and Martin-Delgado (2004); the contribution here is its first computationally tested and validated realization — against exact dispersion, group velocity and envelope reduction — embedded in an interacting substrate. Main results: Emergence bridge. The narrow-band envelope of the classical automaton obeys the Schrödinger equation with an effective mass fixed by the curvature of the exact discrete dispersion (group velocity to ≤0.2 %, curvature to ≤2 %). The dimensionless spreading of two microscopically different substrates collapses onto the single universal law √(1+τ²). Deterministic quantum statistics. Bohmian tracers reproduce double-slit single-object interference (p < 10⁻⁴), with trajectories matching the weak-measurement reconstruction of Kocsis et al. (2011). Bell / CHSH. A value of S = 2.79 from position-valued outcomes with a no-signalling control (0.3 %), via explicitly nonlocal guidance in configuration space. Measurement. A measurable Gaussian collapse law (R² = 0.997); a quantum eraser with literal bit-reversible un-measurement of the entire measurement chain; Pauli exclusion as a bit-conserved invariant; and relaxation to the Born rule with a reversible arrow of time. Surviving the isotropy no-go, and a falsifiable prediction (new in v2). On the live integer engine, velocity anisotropy vanishes as k² in the infrared with first-principles coefficients in both 2D and 3D (agreement ≈ 1 %) — rotational isotropy emerges as an infrared fixed point, meeting the sharpest no-go every lattice candidate faces. From the same structure follows a concrete, quadratically Planck-suppressed dispersion prediction (δγ,2 ≈ 2×10−40 GeV−2, subluminal), lying only ~50× below the tightest ultra-high-energy cosmic-ray bound — the programme's first falsifiable departure from standard QM/GR. Individual phenomena have known precedents — double-slit Bohmian trajectories (Philippidis, Dewdney & Hiley 1979), Born-rule relaxation (Valentini & Westman 2005), the Schrödinger update scheme (Visscher 1991; integer lifting Fredkin 1999, Martin-Delgado 2004) — and are framed accordingly. The contribution is their tested, validated realization on one exactly reproducible integer substrate, several genuinely new exact constructions (tested integer bit-reversible Schrödinger sector; literal bit-exact un-measurement; exchange statistics as a bit-conserved invariant; two-substrate universal collapse; measured lattice isotropy with a Planck-scale dispersion prediction), and a pre-registered, falsification-first methodology (criteria committed to version control before each run; fourteen self-retractions on record). This is an existence result, strengthened by a survived no-go and a falsifiable prediction — not a claim that our universe is this automaton (that step requires a prediction to pass experiment): a fully classical, deterministic, reversible integer computation can carry quantum phenomenology, quantitatively and reproducibly, and this substrate meets a no-go every discrete candidate must survive. Preprint v2 (self-contained; bibliographic audit completed against arXiv/DOI sources). Code, pre-registered gates, per-run reports and figures are included in this archive. Produced in an AI-assisted workflow (Anthropic Claude) under the author's direction; all pre-registration and interpretation is on record in the version history.
The QBist and Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM) informational readings of quantum theory have long lacked a clear account of what kind of physical system qualifies as an “agent” or “observer.” Fuchs, Mermin, and Schack often treat the agent as a human physicist or Bayesian decision-maker; Rovelli suggests that any physical system may serve as a relational observer; Healey abstracts the agent into a Bayesian role without specifying its substrate; and the Khrennikov-Schack-Zwirn exchange sharpens, but does not resolve, the intersubjectivity problem. This paper argues that the QBism/RQM informational reading is best understood as substrate-flexible: any physical system whose input-output statistics exhibit quantum-probability structure, including non-trivial Contextuality-by-Default (CbD) signatures resistant to simplex-embeddable ontological models, is a candidate epistemic agent. This condition is necessary but not sufficient: agency also requires state-sensitive updating across measurement contexts. The argument preserves QBism’s rejection of view-from-nowhere objectivity while removing the assumption that agents must be human or conscious, and disciplines Rovelli’s “any physical system” claim by tying observerhood to measurable non-triviality. Engineered cortical wetware systems such as CL1 and DishBrain offer controllable, non-human, and not clearly conscious testbeds for evaluating this claim, without requiring phenomenal consciousness or quantum-coherent biological dynamics. The paper distinguishes substrate flexibility from Pienaar’s extension of the QBist agent, which expands the agent’s senses rather than its substrate; engages neo-Everettian objections; and rejects Edwards’s attempts to fold classical large language models into QBist formalism. Classical AI token-generation systems remain simplex-embeddable and therefore fail the non-triviality requirement. Substrate flexibility is thus narrower than proposals that include current AI systems.
This preprint defines the classical candidate-geometry baselines that should be compared before any claim of non-classicality in the quantum-like contextual non-additivity, order effects, and Bell-type indicators reported for large language models (LLMs) and masked language models (MLMs), and quantifies their explanatory power and limits. It does not claim physical quantum coherence in AI, nor a full explanation of AI quantum-like behavior. The revised edition adds four components. (i) Detection-power certification: the detector's condition is ICC < S_odd - 2, and Tsirelson-level injection tests certify that genuine contextuality of that magnitude would be detectable at the empirical signaling levels; the 312 Experiment-4 tables all satisfy S_odd < 2 with zero corrected excess, so the negative result is not attributable to ICC-induced blindness. (ii) A product-distribution theorem establishing that the zero excess of independent scoring is a mathematical necessity, not an empirical finding. (iii) A structural reproduction of the Lo et al. construction with a no-model null: uniformly random marginals without any language model already reach a CbD-contextual rate of 0.667 (vs. 0.711 reported), and the real BERT/RoBERTa rates are largely indistinguishable from a marginal-matched sign-randomized null at substantive effect sizes. (iv) A multi-model audit across six models from four families: raw S_odd > 2 appears (max 2.773) but is entirely explained by direct influence, with zero corrected excess across all 144 tables and on the powered subset. The package includes the manuscript (LaTeX source and PDF), figures, reproduction code, and data (including the raw joint probabilities from which the per-table metrics are regenerated and cross-checked). Central thesis: reading AI quantum-like behavior as non-classicality requires exceeding not the raw score but the combination of classical candidate-geometry baselines, direct-influence correction, detector-power certification, and a no-model null. This work is neither a full reproduction nor a refutation of Lo et al.; it audits the interpretation of raw contextual-instance counts. Manuscript language: English. Code is released under the MIT License; text and figures under CC BY 4.0. Note: Parts of the manuscript were linguistically and structurally refined with the assistance of AI-based tools.All scientific content, analysis, and conclusions are the author's own.
This manuscript presents a methods-forward, operational protocol for evaluating whether any structured dependence remains in quantum-computing measurement records after explicit modeling of standard quantum and device-level mechanisms. Classical definiteness is defined at the record layer, and pre-record states are treated as predictive descriptions rather than as classical outcome facts. Within this operational stance, the protocol converts questions about outcome status and record formation into a falsifiable test program grounded in preregistered analysis rules and standard measurement telemetry. A locked null-model family is specified in advance, incorporating standard quantum dynamics together with documented device-level mechanisms including drift, correlated and non-Markovian noise, crosstalk proxies, and leakage indicators. The framework provides operational definitions, a conservative postulate set, preregistered endpoints, residual-adjudication criteria, negative controls, a fixed windowing discipline, and a bound-first reporting standard designed to yield informative constraints under null results. Any candidate contribution beyond the declared null family must appear as structured, reproducible residual dependence that survives the locked null family and the full residual-filter sequence. Version 4.4 refines the protocol specification, clarifies evidentiary boundaries, and strengthens the integration of the synthetic demonstration. The manuscript includes a fully specified classical simulation that executes the decision pipeline under controlled conditions. The synthetic study illustrates how the protocol classifies a bounded-null case, a measured-artifact case, a partial-artifact/unresolved-covariate case, an injected structured-residual case, and a failed-topology case. This demonstration establishes computational executability of the protocol and clarifies the behavior of the decision tree, but it does not constitute empirical evidence for any physical mechanism. Because the protocol relies only on standard measurement telemetry and preregistered analysis rules, it is directly implementable across contemporary quantum-computing platforms and does not depend on any single dataset, backend, or hardware realization. The manuscript is a specification paper: it defines a reproducible evidentiary framework for record-level claims, while large-scale empirical implementation, hardware benchmarking, and cross-platform replication remain subsequent studies.