Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

University of Minnesota Press eBooks

On The Plurality Of Dynamics: Transition Probabilities And Modal Interpretations

Michael Dickson

Published Jan 25, 2010• 0 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.5749/9780816688739-010

Related papers

Unique transition probabilities in the modal interpretation

Pieter E. Vermaas

Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics•Jun 1, 1996•45 citations

A Note on Dynamics in the Modal Interpretation

Guido Bacciagaluppi

International Journal of Theoretical Physics•Jan 1, 1998•1 citation

Dynamics for Modal Interpretations

Guido Bacciagaluppi, Michael Dickson

Foundations of Physics•Aug 1, 1999•93 citations

Modal semantics, modal dynamics and the problem of state preparation

Laura Ruetsche

It has been suggested that the Modal Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics (QM) is "incomplete" if it lacks a dynamics for possessed values. I argue that this is only one of two possible attitudes one might adopt toward a Modal Interpretation without dynamics. According to the other attitude, such an interpretation is a complete interpretation of QM as standardly formulated, an interpretation whose innovation is to attempt to make sense of the quantum realm without the expedient of novel physics. Then I explain why this attitude, though available, is unattractive. Without dynamics, the Modal Interpretation vanquishes the measurement problem only, it seems, to succumb to the problem of state preparation. On this view, the Modal Interpretation needs dynamics not to be an interpretation at all, but to be an adequate one. I review reasons to suspect that the dynamics which would best suit the Modal Interpretation--a dynamics equivalent to a set of two time transition probabilities of the sort used to solve the preparation problem--is not a dynamics the interpretation can have. I close with a brief discussion of versions of the Modal Interpretation that may not succumb to the considerations presented here.

International Studies in the Philosophy of Science•Mar 1, 2003•42 citations

MNOGI SVJETOVI KVANTNE MEHANIKE I MODALNOG REALIZMA

Milena Radović

The purpose of this paper is to give an overview of modal realism and many worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics and compare the concepts of many worlds in those two theories. Main source for modal realism is David Lewis' book On the Plurality of Worlds (1986). For many worlds interpretation I rely on Bryce DeWitt and Lev Vaidman. First part of the paper concerns modal realism, second is about many worlds interpretation and third is the comparison of those two. Many worlds in modal realism and many worlds interpretation have the same phenomenology, but are different ontologically. The worlds of modal realism are causally and spatiotemporally separated and have always been, while the worlds of many worlds interpretation are part of a branching universe. That means they were the same world at some point in the past, even though they are equally separated, as the worlds of modal realism are, after the branching.

•Aug 26, 2018•0 citations

Dynamical Autonomy and Locality

Pieter E. Vermaas

In this chapter I prove that the transition probabilities, which describe the dynamics of the actually possessed properties of systems, violate the assumption of Dynamical Autonomy for composite systems. And, related to this violation, it is also proved that the dynamics of the actually possessed properties is non-local in a quite explicit way. Introduction When I introduced the assumptions of Instantaneous and Dynamical Autonomy in Section 3.3, I motivated them by making an appeal to locality. In the case of Instantaneous Autonomy, I argued that a state of a system α should codify all the information about the property ascription to that system. For if a state does not codify all the information, it may happen that a change in the state of some distant system σ (I used the example of a far-away asteroid) means that the properties of α change as well. And this would make modal property ascriptions undesirably non-local. In the case of Dynamical Autonomy one can give a similar motivation. The state of a system α, as it evolves during a time interval i , should codify all the information about the simultaneous and sequential correlations between the properties ascribed to α in that interval i . For if the evolving state does not do so, it may happen that a change in a distant system changes the correlations between the properties of α as well. Modal interpretations satisfy a number of the Autonomy assumptions. All modal interpretations satisfy Instantaneous Autonomy by construction. The transition probabilities derived in Section 8.2 prove that the bi and spectral modal interpretations satisfy Dynamical Autonomy for whole systems and that the atomic modal interpretation satisfies Dynamical Autonomy for atomic systems.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 5, 2010•0 citations
It has been suggested that the Modal Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics (QM) is "incomplete" if it lacks a dynamics for possessed values. I argue that this is only one of two possible attitudes one might adopt toward a Modal Interpretation without dynamics. According to the other attitude, such an interpretation is a complete interpretation of QM as standardly formulated, an interpretation whose innovation is to attempt to make sense of the quantum realm without the expedient of novel physics. Then I explain why this attitude, though available, is unattractive. Without dynamics, the Modal Interpretation vanquishes the measurement problem only, it seems, to succumb to the problem of state preparation. On this view, the Modal Interpretation needs dynamics not to be an interpretation at all, but to be an adequate one. I review reasons to suspect that the dynamics which would best suit the Modal Interpretation--a dynamics equivalent to a set of two time transition probabilities of the sort used to solve the preparation problem--is not a dynamics the interpretation can have. I close with a brief discussion of versions of the Modal Interpretation that may not succumb to the considerations presented here.
The purpose of this paper is to give an overview of modal realism and many worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics and compare the concepts of many worlds in those two theories. Main source for modal realism is David Lewis' book On the Plurality of Worlds (1986). For many worlds interpretation I rely on Bryce DeWitt and Lev Vaidman. First part of the paper concerns modal realism, second is about many worlds interpretation and third is the comparison of those two. Many worlds in modal realism and many worlds interpretation have the same phenomenology, but are different ontologically. The worlds of modal realism are causally and spatiotemporally separated and have always been, while the worlds of many worlds interpretation are part of a branching universe. That means they were the same world at some point in the past, even though they are equally separated, as the worlds of modal realism are, after the branching.
In this chapter I prove that the transition probabilities, which describe the dynamics of the actually possessed properties of systems, violate the assumption of Dynamical Autonomy for composite systems. And, related to this violation, it is also proved that the dynamics of the actually possessed properties is non-local in a quite explicit way. Introduction When I introduced the assumptions of Instantaneous and Dynamical Autonomy in Section 3.3, I motivated them by making an appeal to locality. In the case of Instantaneous Autonomy, I argued that a state of a system α should codify all the information about the property ascription to that system. For if a state does not codify all the information, it may happen that a change in the state of some distant system σ (I used the example of a far-away asteroid) means that the properties of α change as well. And this would make modal property ascriptions undesirably non-local. In the case of Dynamical Autonomy one can give a similar motivation. The state of a system α, as it evolves during a time interval i , should codify all the information about the simultaneous and sequential correlations between the properties ascribed to α in that interval i . For if the evolving state does not do so, it may happen that a change in a distant system changes the correlations between the properties of α as well. Modal interpretations satisfy a number of the Autonomy assumptions. All modal interpretations satisfy Instantaneous Autonomy by construction. The transition probabilities derived in Section 8.2 prove that the bi and spectral modal interpretations satisfy Dynamical Autonomy for whole systems and that the atomic modal interpretation satisfies Dynamical Autonomy for atomic systems.