Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Synthese Library/Synthese library

Quantum Theory and the Ontological Status of Non-individuals

Matteo Morganti

Published Jan 1, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1007/978-3-032-01408-5_8

Related papers

The Ontological Status Of Quantum Information

Robert R.A. Arnăutu

•Jan 1, 2010•0 citations

Não-individualidade em mecânica quântica

Valéria Gradinar

The non-relativistic quantum mechanics offers us conditions to consider at least two possible metaphysical packages, but incompatible between themselves: metaphysics of individuals, and metaphysics of non-individuals. In addition, the standard formalism is compatible with both the ontologies, without the theory being decided for either of them. From this particular kind of situation, the thesis of the underdetermination of metaphysics by physics can be established. Actually, it can be found, among scientists and philosophers, defenders of one, or another ontology, as well as those who do not address the issue, given that theory on its own does not decide. This means that if we make a choice for one of these packages, it will be happing in a metaphysical field, increasing a lot the philosophical discussions about individuality of quantic objects in quantum physics. From a naturalized methodological view, we present the issues from those defend the individuality of quantic objects, and from those, include us, defend non-individuality, focusing two approaches: (i) the ontological one, in which the fail of IIP as individuation principle is discussed; and, (ii) the logical one, in which non-reflexive logics, as well as a quasi-set theory became more suitable for representing the non-individuals. In this paper we stand for the choice of non-individuals ontology becomes more plausible, and should be taken in account seriously, opening up possibilities for ontological pluralism.

Principia an international journal of epistemology•May 1, 2014•0 citations

Ontology and the foundations of quantum theory

Gregg S. Jaeger

The European Physical Journal Special Topics•Sep 1, 2023•1 citation

Not Individuals, Nor Even Objects: On the Ontological Nature of Quantum Systems

Olímpia Lombardi

Synthese Library/Synthese library•Jan 1, 2023•7 citations

Ontology of quantum correlation: hidden parameter for a pair or an ensemble?

Andrey A. Gribkov

The article is dedicated to the analysis of the ontological status of the hidden parameter λ in the context of Bell's theorem and quantum correlations. In the standard formulation of Bell's inequalities, the hidden parameter is attributed to an individual pair of entangled particles: it is assumed that λ determines the measurement outcomes for each specific pair and, therefore, serves as the carrier of correlation at the level of a single event. This interpretation gives rise to a well-known dilemma: the violation of Bell's inequalities in an experiment is interpreted as evidence of the impossibility of any local realistic theory, leading to conclusions about the non-locality of nature or a rejection of realism. The subject of this study is the very legitimacy of attributing the hidden parameter to an individual pair of particles. The question is posed: is λ a property of a single pair or a characteristic of a statistical ensemble? The problem is considered in the context of the classical philosophical opposition between the singular and the general, as well as the mereological relationship between parts and the whole in relation to the quantum-mechanical description of reality. A conceptual analysis of the mathematical structure of Bell's theorem is employed, along with a comparison of the ontological assumptions of the standard and ensemble interpretations, as well as a philosophical analysis of the levels of realization of correlation. The scientific novelty of the work lies in the explicit formulation of the question regarding the level of ontological belonging of the hidden parameter—a question that is typically not addressed in standard discussions around Bell's theorem. It is shown that attributing λ to an individual pair of particles represents not an experimentally justified fact, but an ontological assumption embedded in the formalism at the stage of its construction. This assumption predetermines the interpretation of the results: the violation of Bell's inequalities is perceived as a collapse of local realism only under the condition that correlation must be realized at the level of a single pair. If the correlation is realized at the level of the ensemble—through the structure of the distribution ρ(λ)—then the violation of Bell's inequalities indicates not non-locality, but the inadequacy of an individual ontology of the hidden parameter. The conclusion is that the standard interpretation of Bell's theorem conflates two ontological levels of description, and a correct delineation of these levels removes the necessity of choosing between non-locality and a rejection of realism.

Философская мысль•Jul 22, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics: Ontology Without Individuals

Newton C. A. da Costa, Olímpia Lombardi

Foundations of Physics•Mar 21, 2014•56 citations
The non-relativistic quantum mechanics offers us conditions to consider at least two possible metaphysical packages, but incompatible between themselves: metaphysics of individuals, and metaphysics of non-individuals. In addition, the standard formalism is compatible with both the ontologies, without the theory being decided for either of them. From this particular kind of situation, the thesis of the underdetermination of metaphysics by physics can be established. Actually, it can be found, among scientists and philosophers, defenders of one, or another ontology, as well as those who do not address the issue, given that theory on its own does not decide. This means that if we make a choice for one of these packages, it will be happing in a metaphysical field, increasing a lot the philosophical discussions about individuality of quantic objects in quantum physics. From a naturalized methodological view, we present the issues from those defend the individuality of quantic objects, and from those, include us, defend non-individuality, focusing two approaches: (i) the ontological one, in which the fail of IIP as individuation principle is discussed; and, (ii) the logical one, in which non-reflexive logics, as well as a quasi-set theory became more suitable for representing the non-individuals. In this paper we stand for the choice of non-individuals ontology becomes more plausible, and should be taken in account seriously, opening up possibilities for ontological pluralism.
The article is dedicated to the analysis of the ontological status of the hidden parameter λ in the context of Bell's theorem and quantum correlations. In the standard formulation of Bell's inequalities, the hidden parameter is attributed to an individual pair of entangled particles: it is assumed that λ determines the measurement outcomes for each specific pair and, therefore, serves as the carrier of correlation at the level of a single event. This interpretation gives rise to a well-known dilemma: the violation of Bell's inequalities in an experiment is interpreted as evidence of the impossibility of any local realistic theory, leading to conclusions about the non-locality of nature or a rejection of realism. The subject of this study is the very legitimacy of attributing the hidden parameter to an individual pair of particles. The question is posed: is λ a property of a single pair or a characteristic of a statistical ensemble? The problem is considered in the context of the classical philosophical opposition between the singular and the general, as well as the mereological relationship between parts and the whole in relation to the quantum-mechanical description of reality. A conceptual analysis of the mathematical structure of Bell's theorem is employed, along with a comparison of the ontological assumptions of the standard and ensemble interpretations, as well as a philosophical analysis of the levels of realization of correlation. The scientific novelty of the work lies in the explicit formulation of the question regarding the level of ontological belonging of the hidden parameter—a question that is typically not addressed in standard discussions around Bell's theorem. It is shown that attributing λ to an individual pair of particles represents not an experimentally justified fact, but an ontological assumption embedded in the formalism at the stage of its construction. This assumption predetermines the interpretation of the results: the violation of Bell's inequalities is perceived as a collapse of local realism only under the condition that correlation must be realized at the level of a single pair. If the correlation is realized at the level of the ensemble—through the structure of the distribution ρ(λ)—then the violation of Bell's inequalities indicates not non-locality, but the inadequacy of an individual ontology of the hidden parameter. The conclusion is that the standard interpretation of Bell's theorem conflates two ontological levels of description, and a correct delineation of these levels removes the necessity of choosing between non-locality and a rejection of realism.