Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Synthese Library/Synthese library

Not Individuals, Nor Even Objects: On the Ontological Nature of Quantum Systems

Olímpia Lombardi

Published Jan 1, 2023• 7 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1007/978-3-031-31840-5_4

Related papers

Quantum Theory and the Ontological Status of Non-individuals

Matteo Morganti

Synthese Library/Synthese library•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

METAPHYSICAL UNDERDETERMINATION AND LOGICAL DETERMINATION: THE CASE OF QUANTUM MECHANICS

Jonas R. Becker Arenhart

The ‘underdetermination of metaphysics by the physics’ is the thesis that our best scientific theories do not uniquely determine their ontologies. Non-relativistic quantum mechanics is famously thought to exemplify this kind of underdetermination: it may be seen as compatible with both an ontology of individual objects and with an ontology of non-individual objects. A possible way out of the dilema thus created consists in adopting some version of Ontic Structural Realism (OSR), a view according to which the metaphysically relevant aspect of the theory is its structure, not the nature of the objects dealt with. According to OSR, particular objects may be dispensed with (eliminated or re-conceptualized) in favor of the structure of the theory. In this paper we shall argue that the underdetermination of metaphysics by the physics is a consequence of a too strict naturalism in ontology. As a result, when a mitigated ontological naturalism is taken into account, underdetermination does not appear to have such dark consequences for object-oriented ontologies in quantum mechanics.

•Mar 5, 2014•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics: Ontology Without Individuals

Newton C. A. da Costa, Olímpia Lombardi

Foundations of Physics•Mar 21, 2014•56 citations

Metaphysical preliminaries

Olímpia Lombardi

Abstract The issue about the nature of quantum systems usually hinges on the category of individual: the question is whether this category can be applied to understand the peculiarities of quantum behavior. However, some metaphysical subtleties are commonly overlooked in this discussion. What is the difference between the notions of object and of individual? What metaphysical principles are quantum systems supposed to fulfill? What ontological kinds of properties are involved in the quantum domain? These questions should be taken into account when the issue at stake is the ontological nature of quantum systems and, more generally, the structure of the quantum realm. In order to address these and other metaphysical questions, different ontological distinctions that are scarcely taken into account in the debate are brought to the fore in this chapter. In light of these distinctions, the ontological challenges that quantum mechanics poses to the ontological picture presupposed by traditional metaphysics will be discussed in the following chapter.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Feb 19, 2026•0 citations

Quantum worlds : perspectives on the ontology of quantum mechanics

Federico Holik

•Jan 1, 2019•21 citations

<Articles>Modeling a Procedure for Providing the Ontology of Quantum Objects: Focussing on the Identity and Individuality of Single Particles in Individual Quantum Systems

IMAI, Keigo

Since the 2000s, studies on the ontology of quantum objects have developed relatively actively. However, few studies have thoroughly addressed not only theoretical and metaphysical perspectives but also experimental viewpoints within specific cases. This paper aims to clarify the ontology of quantum objects, focusing on the issues of identity and individuality. Specifically, it constructs a new model that represents a procedure for providing the ontology of quantum objects, with particular attention to single-particle experiments in individual quantum systems. The proposed model is developed by complementarily organizing, abstracting, and integrating the discussions of Bueno (2018), Imai (2024), and Chen (2016, 2018, 2023), which examine the ontology of microscopic objects from theoretical and/or experimental perspectives. Although this model cannot independently resolve the issues of identity and individuality for quantum objects in specific cases, it is a valuable tool for exploring the ontology of quantum objects from a broader framework.

•May 1, 2025•0 citations
The ‘underdetermination of metaphysics by the physics’ is the thesis that our best scientific theories do not uniquely determine their ontologies. Non-relativistic quantum mechanics is famously thought to exemplify this kind of underdetermination: it may be seen as compatible with both an ontology of individual objects and with an ontology of non-individual objects. A possible way out of the dilema thus created consists in adopting some version of Ontic Structural Realism (OSR), a view according to which the metaphysically relevant aspect of the theory is its structure, not the nature of the objects dealt with. According to OSR, particular objects may be dispensed with (eliminated or re-conceptualized) in favor of the structure of the theory. In this paper we shall argue that the underdetermination of metaphysics by the physics is a consequence of a too strict naturalism in ontology. As a result, when a mitigated ontological naturalism is taken into account, underdetermination does not appear to have such dark consequences for object-oriented ontologies in quantum mechanics.
Abstract The issue about the nature of quantum systems usually hinges on the category of individual: the question is whether this category can be applied to understand the peculiarities of quantum behavior. However, some metaphysical subtleties are commonly overlooked in this discussion. What is the difference between the notions of object and of individual? What metaphysical principles are quantum systems supposed to fulfill? What ontological kinds of properties are involved in the quantum domain? These questions should be taken into account when the issue at stake is the ontological nature of quantum systems and, more generally, the structure of the quantum realm. In order to address these and other metaphysical questions, different ontological distinctions that are scarcely taken into account in the debate are brought to the fore in this chapter. In light of these distinctions, the ontological challenges that quantum mechanics poses to the ontological picture presupposed by traditional metaphysics will be discussed in the following chapter.
Since the 2000s, studies on the ontology of quantum objects have developed relatively actively. However, few studies have thoroughly addressed not only theoretical and metaphysical perspectives but also experimental viewpoints within specific cases. This paper aims to clarify the ontology of quantum objects, focusing on the issues of identity and individuality. Specifically, it constructs a new model that represents a procedure for providing the ontology of quantum objects, with particular attention to single-particle experiments in individual quantum systems. The proposed model is developed by complementarily organizing, abstracting, and integrating the discussions of Bueno (2018), Imai (2024), and Chen (2016, 2018, 2023), which examine the ontology of microscopic objects from theoretical and/or experimental perspectives. Although this model cannot independently resolve the issues of identity and individuality for quantum objects in specific cases, it is a valuable tool for exploring the ontology of quantum objects from a broader framework.