Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

First Measurements of Spectral Hole Line Shifts at Dilution Temperatures for Laser Stabilization

M. T. Hartman, Xiuji Lin, Benjamin Pointard, Rodolphe Le Targat, Bess Fang, Yann Le Coq, Philippe Goldner, Signe Louise Seidelin

Published May 15, 2023• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Here we report on the status of the Spectral-Hole Burning (SHB) laser-stabilization experiment at LNE-SYRTE, focusing on our first measurements of thermally induced frequency shifts of spectral holes at dilution temperatures (T0 < 1 K). The effect, which is predicated to scale as T 4 , produces shifts of order 1-10 Hz over its ≈ 517 THz center at these temperatures. To meet this challenge, we introduced a novel temperaturemodulation based approach to spectral-hole line shift measurements, allowing integration time of the small signals. We find a preliminary value for the line-shift constant of Eu 3+ :Y2SiO5, α = 107 Hz K-4 , a first at dilution temperatures.

Related papers

Thermal-noise limits to the frequency stability of burned spectral holes

M. T. Hartman, N. Wagner, S. Kroker +2 more

Techniques in frequency stabilization of lasers to fixed-spacer optical cavities have advanced to the point where the ultimate frequency stabilities are limited by thermal noise for standard cavity configurations at room temperature. In early experiments, laser stabilization via spectral-hole burning (SHB) has been shown to be a promising alternative. In this Letter, we explore the thermal-noise limits to frequency stability in spectral holes and compile known material parameters for a typical system used in SHB experiments (Eu3+ doped Y2SiO5) to make numerical estimates for the fundamental thermal-noise induced frequency instability in spectral holes for the liquid-helium temperature and dilution temperature cases. These efforts can guide the design of future SHB experiments and clarify which important material parameters remain to be measured.

arXiv:2412.08665•Applied Physics Letters•Jul 14, 2025•5 citations

Detection Techniques and Fundamental Limits in Frequency Stabilization via Spectral Hole Burning

Michael Hartman, Xiuji Lin, Benjamin Pointard +5 more

This poster presents the status of the development of an ultra-frequency stable laser via a spectroscopic technique known as Spectral Hole Burning (SHB). In short, we can use a pump laser to imprint, or ’burn’, transmissive spectral lines, or ’spectral holes’, in the otherwise inhomogeneously broadened absorptive spectral sites of a Eu3+ doped Y2SiO5 crystal. We can then lock a probe laser to these narrow spectral features achieving our frequency stabilized laser. Of great concern is the frequency stability of the spectral holes, such as their sensitivity to temperature changes which we characterize here. Additionally, a challenge this experiment faces is the restriction of probe laser power to avoid damaging the spectral features. This sets a relatively high level of shot noise, limiting the detection sensitivity. Here we present our solution to overcome this difficulty by using a multi-spectral- hole probing scheme to average the probing signals of several burned spectral holes.

•Nov 8, 2023•0 citations

Shifts of optical frequency references based on spectral-hole burning in Eu3+:Y2SiO5

Michael J. Thorpe, David R. Leibrandt, Till Rosenband

Several properties of Eu 3+ :Y 2 SiO 5 spectral holes are measured, to assess the suitability of broad-band hole-patterns for use as laser-frequency references. We measure frequency shifts due to magnetic fields, side-features of neighboring spectral holes and changing optical probe power. A precise calibration of a temperature insensitive point is also performed, where the temperature-induced frequency shift is canceled to first order by the pressure-induced shift from the crystal's helium-gas environment.

arXiv:1210.4458•New Journal of Physics•Mar 6, 2013•40 citations

Sub-Kelvin Spectral Hole Burning in Eu:YSO for Laser Frequency Stabilisation

A Robbes, Y Yuan, Philippe Goldner +4 more

As basic building blocks for quantum devices, ultra-stable lasers have a profound impact on various fields. Longer laser coherence times enhance the performance of quantum sensors, computers, communications, and optical clocks. Although optical lattice clocks have accomplished significant high-precision measurements, they often fall short of their quantum projection noise limits due to dead times during atom preparation: the instability in the laser frequency introduces stochastic fluctuations during the interrogation of atomic transitions (Dick effect). High-resolution optical clock comparisons are crucial for evaluating their accuracy and could lead to a redefinition of the SI second based on optical transitions [1].However, the most common technique for achieving ultra-stable lasers, the Pound-Drever-Hall method with Fabry-Perot cavities, faces thermal noise limitations of the cavities. To overcome these constraints, alternative methods such as Spectral Hole Burning (SHB) in rare-earth-doped crystals (REICs) have been explored. Indeed, REICs experience inhomogeneous broadening due to local lattice distortions caused by the size difference between dopant and host ions. An SHB protocol, which creates narrow spectral features through selective depletion of specific dopant ion populations using narrow-linewidth lasers, allows to overcome the inhomogeneous broadening and fully exploit the coherence of rare-earth ions. At cryogenic temperatures, Eu:YSO crystal exhibit persistent Spectral Holes a few kHz narrow and with a lifetime up to 10 h, at 4 K [2], making it a high-precision frequency reference, ideal for intermediate-timescale sensing.We report recent experimental progress on SHB in Eu:YSO crystals at specific sub-K dilution temperature setpoints that cancel the thermal sensitivity of the hole frequency [3]. The latest recorded performances on our experiment reach a fractional frequency stability of 4.10-16 at 1 s [4], which is close to the perfomance of our reference cavity at LTE. Therefore, a second SHB setup is needed for our future stability comparisons. On one front, we rationalize our SHB protocol and investigate new optimal burning parameters as well as test various doping concentrations to achieve the narrowest possible spectral holes on both setups. On another, we continue to further improving the laser frequency lock onto spectral holes, by cancelling as many systematic noise sources as possible. We provide the performances of our Michelson interferometer to reject frequency noise induced on light propagation to the crystal and by the cryostat acoustic vibrations. In addition, we explore a group delay measurement technique via phase modulation to enhance the precision on the pointing of the center of spectral holes. This should help removing slow frequency drifts due to asymmetric burning of the hole while it is probed by the laser.

•Sep 16, 2025•0 citations

Laser stabilization at 1536 nm using regenerative spectral hole burning

Peter B. Sellin, Nick Strickland, Thomas Böttger +2 more

Laser frequency stabilization giving a 500-Hz Allan deviation for a 2-ms integration time with drift reduced to 7 kHz/min over several minutes was achieved at 1536 nm in the optical communication band. A continuously regenerated spectral hole in the inhomogeneously broadened ${}^{4}{I}_{15/2}{(1)}^{4}{I}_{13/2}(1)$ optical absorption of an ${\mathrm{Er}}^{3+}:{\mathrm{Y}}_{2}{\mathrm{SiO}}_{5}$ crystal was used as the short-term frequency reference, while a variation on the locking technique allowed simultaneous use of the inhomogeneously broadened absorption line as a long-term reference. The reported frequency stability was achieved without vibration isolation. Spectral hole burning frequency stabilization provides ideal laser sources for high-resolution spectroscopy, real-time optical signal processing, and a range of applications requiring ultra-narrow-band light sources or coherent detection; the time scale for stability and the compatibility with spectral hole burning devices make this technique complementary to other frequency references for laser stabilization.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Mar 30, 2001•54 citations

LASER FREQUENCY STABILIZATION TO SPECTRAL HOLE BURNING FREQUENCY REFERENCES IN ERBIUM-DOPED CRYSTALS: MATERIAL AND DEVICE OPTIMIZATION

Thomas Böttger

Narrow spectral holes in the absorption lines of Er doped crystals have been explored as references for frequency stabilizing external cavity diode lasers at the important 1.5 μm optical communication wavelength. Allan deviations of the beat signal between two independent stabilized lasers as low as 200 Hz over 10 ms integration time have been achieved using regenerative spectral holes in Er:Y2SiO5 and Er:KTP, while drift was reduced to ~ 7 kHz/min by incorporating the inhomogeneous absorption line as a fixed reference. During active stabilization, the transient spectral hole was continuously regenerated as hole burning balanced relaxation. In contrast, persistent spectral holes in Er:D:CaF2, with lifetimes of several weeks, provided programmable and transportable secondary frequency references that maintained sub-kilohertz stability over several seconds and enabled 6 kHz stability over 3 1.6 10 s × . The error signal was derived from the spectral hole transmission using frequency modulation spectroscopy. A servo amplifier applied fast frequency corrections to the injection current of the laser diode and slower adjustments to the piezo-driven feedback prism plate. These stabilized lasers provide ideal sources for spectral hole burning applications based on optical coherent transients, where laser stability is required over the storage time of the material. Since the lifetime of the frequency reference is exactly the material storage time, this requirement is automatically met by using our technique. This was demonstrated in Er:Y2SiO5 and successfully transferred to high-bandwidth signal processing applications. The material Er:Y2SiO5 was optimized for these applications. The I15/2 and I13/2 crystal field levels were site-selectively determined by absorption and fluorescence spectroscopy. The excited state lifetime was measured to be 11.4 ms for site 1 and 9.2 ms for site 2. Zeeman experiments and two-pulse photon echo spectroscopy as a function of magnetic field orientation were used to determine the anisotropic electronic g-values for both Er sites and established a preferred magnetic field orientation for minimizing homogeneous line broadening by spectral diffusion. The spectral diffusion was characterized by stimulated photon echo spectroscopy and successfully described with established theories. In a 0.02 atomic percent Er:Y2SiO5 crystal at B = 0.8 T and T = 1.6 K, line broadening became significant after 10 μs, increasing the homogeneous linewidth from 7.5 kHz to 75 kHz after 120 μs. Spectral diffusion, primarily caused by direct phonon driven Er spin-flips in the ground state, can be controlled to negligible levels with proper magnetic field strength and orientation, temperature, and erbium concentration. In optimizing Er:Y2SiO5, the narrowest optical resonance in any solid-state material of 73 Hz was measured.

•Jan 1, 2002•16 citations
Here we report on the status of the Spectral-Hole Burning (SHB) laser-stabilization experiment at LNE-SYRTE, focusing on our first measurements of thermally induced frequency shifts of spectral holes at dilution temperatures (T0 < 1 K). The effect, which is predicated to scale as T 4 , produces shifts of order 1-10 Hz over its ≈ 517 THz center at these temperatures. To meet this challenge, we introduced a novel temperaturemodulation based approach to spectral-hole line shift measurements, allowing integration time of the small signals. We find a preliminary value for the line-shift constant of Eu 3+ :Y2SiO5, α = 107 Hz K-4 , a first at dilution temperatures.
Techniques in frequency stabilization of lasers to fixed-spacer optical cavities have advanced to the point where the ultimate frequency stabilities are limited by thermal noise for standard cavity configurations at room temperature. In early experiments, laser stabilization via spectral-hole burning (SHB) has been shown to be a promising alternative. In this Letter, we explore the thermal-noise limits to frequency stability in spectral holes and compile known material parameters for a typical system used in SHB experiments (Eu3+ doped Y2SiO5) to make numerical estimates for the fundamental thermal-noise induced frequency instability in spectral holes for the liquid-helium temperature and dilution temperature cases. These efforts can guide the design of future SHB experiments and clarify which important material parameters remain to be measured.
This poster presents the status of the development of an ultra-frequency stable laser via a spectroscopic technique known as Spectral Hole Burning (SHB). In short, we can use a pump laser to imprint, or ’burn’, transmissive spectral lines, or ’spectral holes’, in the otherwise inhomogeneously broadened absorptive spectral sites of a Eu3+ doped Y2SiO5 crystal. We can then lock a probe laser to these narrow spectral features achieving our frequency stabilized laser. Of great concern is the frequency stability of the spectral holes, such as their sensitivity to temperature changes which we characterize here. Additionally, a challenge this experiment faces is the restriction of probe laser power to avoid damaging the spectral features. This sets a relatively high level of shot noise, limiting the detection sensitivity. Here we present our solution to overcome this difficulty by using a multi-spectral- hole probing scheme to average the probing signals of several burned spectral holes.
Several properties of Eu 3+ :Y 2 SiO 5 spectral holes are measured, to assess the suitability of broad-band hole-patterns for use as laser-frequency references. We measure frequency shifts due to magnetic fields, side-features of neighboring spectral holes and changing optical probe power. A precise calibration of a temperature insensitive point is also performed, where the temperature-induced frequency shift is canceled to first order by the pressure-induced shift from the crystal's helium-gas environment.
As basic building blocks for quantum devices, ultra-stable lasers have a profound impact on various fields. Longer laser coherence times enhance the performance of quantum sensors, computers, communications, and optical clocks. Although optical lattice clocks have accomplished significant high-precision measurements, they often fall short of their quantum projection noise limits due to dead times during atom preparation: the instability in the laser frequency introduces stochastic fluctuations during the interrogation of atomic transitions (Dick effect). High-resolution optical clock comparisons are crucial for evaluating their accuracy and could lead to a redefinition of the SI second based on optical transitions [1].However, the most common technique for achieving ultra-stable lasers, the Pound-Drever-Hall method with Fabry-Perot cavities, faces thermal noise limitations of the cavities. To overcome these constraints, alternative methods such as Spectral Hole Burning (SHB) in rare-earth-doped crystals (REICs) have been explored. Indeed, REICs experience inhomogeneous broadening due to local lattice distortions caused by the size difference between dopant and host ions. An SHB protocol, which creates narrow spectral features through selective depletion of specific dopant ion populations using narrow-linewidth lasers, allows to overcome the inhomogeneous broadening and fully exploit the coherence of rare-earth ions. At cryogenic temperatures, Eu:YSO crystal exhibit persistent Spectral Holes a few kHz narrow and with a lifetime up to 10 h, at 4 K [2], making it a high-precision frequency reference, ideal for intermediate-timescale sensing.We report recent experimental progress on SHB in Eu:YSO crystals at specific sub-K dilution temperature setpoints that cancel the thermal sensitivity of the hole frequency [3]. The latest recorded performances on our experiment reach a fractional frequency stability of 4.10-16 at 1 s [4], which is close to the perfomance of our reference cavity at LTE. Therefore, a second SHB setup is needed for our future stability comparisons. On one front, we rationalize our SHB protocol and investigate new optimal burning parameters as well as test various doping concentrations to achieve the narrowest possible spectral holes on both setups. On another, we continue to further improving the laser frequency lock onto spectral holes, by cancelling as many systematic noise sources as possible. We provide the performances of our Michelson interferometer to reject frequency noise induced on light propagation to the crystal and by the cryostat acoustic vibrations. In addition, we explore a group delay measurement technique via phase modulation to enhance the precision on the pointing of the center of spectral holes. This should help removing slow frequency drifts due to asymmetric burning of the hole while it is probed by the laser.
Laser frequency stabilization giving a 500-Hz Allan deviation for a 2-ms integration time with drift reduced to 7 kHz/min over several minutes was achieved at 1536 nm in the optical communication band. A continuously regenerated spectral hole in the inhomogeneously broadened 4I15/2(1)4I13/2(1){}^{4}{I}_{15/2}{(1)}^{4}{I}_{13/2}(1)4I15/2​(1)4I13/2​(1) optical absorption of an Er3+:Y2SiO5{\mathrm{Er}}^{3+}:{\mathrm{Y}}_{2}{\mathrm{SiO}}_{5}Er3+:Y2​SiO5​ crystal was used as the short-term frequency reference, while a variation on the locking technique allowed simultaneous use of the inhomogeneously broadened absorption line as a long-term reference. The reported frequency stability was achieved without vibration isolation. Spectral hole burning frequency stabilization provides ideal laser sources for high-resolution spectroscopy, real-time optical signal processing, and a range of applications requiring ultra-narrow-band light sources or coherent detection; the time scale for stability and the compatibility with spectral hole burning devices make this technique complementary to other frequency references for laser stabilization.
Narrow spectral holes in the absorption lines of Er doped crystals have been explored as references for frequency stabilizing external cavity diode lasers at the important 1.5 μm optical communication wavelength. Allan deviations of the beat signal between two independent stabilized lasers as low as 200 Hz over 10 ms integration time have been achieved using regenerative spectral holes in Er:Y2SiO5 and Er:KTP, while drift was reduced to ~ 7 kHz/min by incorporating the inhomogeneous absorption line as a fixed reference. During active stabilization, the transient spectral hole was continuously regenerated as hole burning balanced relaxation. In contrast, persistent spectral holes in Er:D:CaF2, with lifetimes of several weeks, provided programmable and transportable secondary frequency references that maintained sub-kilohertz stability over several seconds and enabled 6 kHz stability over 3 1.6 10 s × . The error signal was derived from the spectral hole transmission using frequency modulation spectroscopy. A servo amplifier applied fast frequency corrections to the injection current of the laser diode and slower adjustments to the piezo-driven feedback prism plate. These stabilized lasers provide ideal sources for spectral hole burning applications based on optical coherent transients, where laser stability is required over the storage time of the material. Since the lifetime of the frequency reference is exactly the material storage time, this requirement is automatically met by using our technique. This was demonstrated in Er:Y2SiO5 and successfully transferred to high-bandwidth signal processing applications. The material Er:Y2SiO5 was optimized for these applications. The I15/2 and I13/2 crystal field levels were site-selectively determined by absorption and fluorescence spectroscopy. The excited state lifetime was measured to be 11.4 ms for site 1 and 9.2 ms for site 2. Zeeman experiments and two-pulse photon echo spectroscopy as a function of magnetic field orientation were used to determine the anisotropic electronic g-values for both Er sites and established a preferred magnetic field orientation for minimizing homogeneous line broadening by spectral diffusion. The spectral diffusion was characterized by stimulated photon echo spectroscopy and successfully described with established theories. In a 0.02 atomic percent Er:Y2SiO5 crystal at B = 0.8 T and T = 1.6 K, line broadening became significant after 10 μs, increasing the homogeneous linewidth from 7.5 kHz to 75 kHz after 120 μs. Spectral diffusion, primarily caused by direct phonon driven Er spin-flips in the ground state, can be controlled to negligible levels with proper magnetic field strength and orientation, temperature, and erbium concentration. In optimizing Er:Y2SiO5, the narrowest optical resonance in any solid-state material of 73 Hz was measured.