The performance of quantum computing hardware is nearly always limited by coherent errors arising from miscalibration.New methods for calibration have the potential to completely eliminate these errors.With quantum devices growing ever larger and more difficult to calibrate, the community needs new testing protocols, new post-processing routines, new controller designs, and new software frameworks that together enable quantum devices to operate at their peak.In this white paper, we argue that a central design goal of future testbeds should be to enable creative research and development into novel hardware calibration routines.We suggest this can be accomplished by a deep commitment to low-level transparency, carefully designed control infrastructure, and flexible software frameworks.Quantum computers are large-scale, integrated systems with many free parameters, each of which must be carefully and continuously calibrated to ensure optimal and stable performance.Extracting the system information needed for calibration demands very careful experiment design, and acting on this information effectively requires rapid post-processing and low-latency feedback.Doing this optimally is hard.Many of the most common techniques for calibrating contemporary devices are inefficient in both experimental and postprocessing resources, and still lead to suboptimal performance.Transparency -When calibrating quantum hardware, transparency is essential.Users cannot correct parameters that they don't know about.When developing calibration protocols, users require direct, lowlevel access to as many controllable device parameters as possible -any parameter that an experimentalist regularly adjusts should be accessible programmatically.This degree of control is essential for efficient calibration, which must be automated and free from high-latency, manual adjustments.To support this automation, clear and complete documentation of a device at the lowest level must be available to the users.This includes details of exactly what each parameter controls, its allowed ranges, and -ideally -a model for how it impacts qubit operations.While not strictly necessary, these models can provide shortcuts for the calibration routines-it is much easier to correct over-rotation errors if the calibration routine knows which parameters impact rotation angles.Not all parameters are adjustable, and uncontrolled environmental degrees of freedom can have serious impacts on the performance of the device.Temperature measurements, microwave powers, and even laser phase stabilization servo values should be measured, recorded, and exposed to users.In our own work with trapped ion hardware [2] we have observed strong correlations between gate error rates and laboratory temperatures.In similar situations, continuous monitoring of the temperature can enable feed-forward compensation to correct these errors, reducing drift.In our experience, however, environmental data was recorded by offline monitoring tools and was available to us only after our experimental colleagues happened to mention its existence.By explicitly and programmatically exposing side-channel information, testbed designers will enable future drift-control protocols that exploit adaptive, feed-forward techniques to monitor and correct for unstable environments.This approach can dramatically reduce the resource overhead demanded by tomographic protocols that leverage comparatively expensive quantum measurements.Calibration impacts every possible testbed application, and recorded details of device calibration should be made available to all users for all experimental runs.The ability to audit calibration data is critical for identifying inefficiencies in calibration protocols, as well as providing possible explanation of an algorithm's unexpected performance.Testbeds should therefore err on the side of over-reporting calibration data, and testbed designers must adopt a deep commitment to device transparency to maximize its value to the scientific community. SAND2021-14320CThis paper describes objective technical results and analysis.Any subjective views or opinions that might be expressed in the paper do not necessarily represent the views of the U.
The performance of quantum computing hardware is nearly always limited by coherent errors arising from miscalibration.New methods for calibration have the potential to completely eliminate these errors.With quantum devices growing ever larger and more difficult to calibrate, the community needs new testing protocols, new post-processing routines, new controller designs, and new software frameworks that together enable quantum devices to operate at their peak.In this white paper, we argue that a central design goal of future testbeds should be to enable creative research and development into novel hardware calibration routines.We suggest this can be accomplished by a deep commitment to low-level transparency, carefully designed control infrastructure, and flexible software frameworks.Quantum computers are large-scale, integrated systems with many free parameters, each of which must be carefully and continuously calibrated to ensure optimal and stable performance.Extracting the system information needed for calibration demands very careful experiment design, and acting on this information effectively requires rapid post-processing and low-latency feedback.Doing this optimally is hard.Many of the most common techniques for calibrating contemporary devices are inefficient in both experimental and postprocessing resources, and still lead to suboptimal performance.Transparency -When calibrating quantum hardware, transparency is essential.Users cannot correct parameters that they don't know about.When developing calibration protocols, users require direct, lowlevel access to as many controllable device parameters as possible -any parameter that an experimentalist regularly adjusts should be accessible programmatically.This degree of control is essential for efficient calibration, which must be automated and free from high-latency, manual adjustments.To support this automation, clear and complete documentation of a device at the lowest level must be available to the users.This includes details of exactly what each parameter controls, its allowed ranges, and -ideally -a model for how it impacts qubit operations.While not strictly necessary, these models can provide shortcuts for the calibration routines-it is much easier to correct over-rotation errors if the calibration routine knows which parameters impact rotation angles.Not all parameters are adjustable, and uncontrolled environmental degrees of freedom can have serious impacts on the performance of the device.Temperature measurements, microwave powers, and even laser phase stabilization servo values should be measured, recorded, and exposed to users.In our own work with trapped ion hardware [2] we have observed strong correlations between gate error rates and laboratory temperatures.In similar situations, continuous monitoring of the temperature can enable feed-forward compensation to correct these errors, reducing drift.In our experience, however, environmental data was recorded by offline monitoring tools and was available to us only after our experimental colleagues happened to mention its existence.By explicitly and programmatically exposing side-channel information, testbed designers will enable future drift-control protocols that exploit adaptive, feed-forward techniques to monitor and correct for unstable environments.This approach can dramatically reduce the resource overhead demanded by tomographic protocols that leverage comparatively expensive quantum measurements.Calibration impacts every possible testbed application, and recorded details of device calibration should be made available to all users for all experimental runs.The ability to audit calibration data is critical for identifying inefficiencies in calibration protocols, as well as providing possible explanation of an algorithm's unexpected performance.Testbeds should therefore err on the side of over-reporting calibration data, and testbed designers must adopt a deep commitment to device transparency to maximize its value to the scientific community. SAND2021-14320CThis paper describes objective technical results and analysis.Any subjective views or opinions that might be expressed in the paper do not necessarily represent the views of the U.
We introduce two classes of lightweight, adaptive calibration protocols for quantum computers that leverage fast feedback. The first enables shot-by-shot updates to device parameters using measurement outcomes from simple, indefinite-outcome quantum circuits. This low-latency approach supports rapid tuning of one or more parameters in real time to mitigate drift. The second protocol updates parameters after collecting measurements from definite-outcome circuits (e.g.~syndrome extraction circuits for quantum error correction), balancing efficiency with classical control overheads. We use numerical simulations to demonstrate that both methods can calibrate 1- and 2-qubit gates rapidly and accurately even in the presence of decoherence, state preparation and measurement (SPAM) errors, and parameter drift. We propose and demonstrate effective adaptive strategies for tuning the hyperparameters of both protocols. Finally, we demonstrate the feasibility of real-time in-situ calibration of qubits performing quantum error correction, using only syndrome data, via numerical simulations of syndrome extraction in the [[5,1,3]] code.
Scalable coherent control hardware for quantum information platforms is rapidly growing in priority as their number of available qubits continues to increase. As these systems scale, more calibration steps are needed, leading to challenges with system instability as calibrated parameters drift. Moreover, the sheer amount of data required to run circuits with large depth tends to balloon, especially when implementing state-of-the-art dynamical-decoupling gates which require advanced modulation techniques. We present a control system that addresses these challenges for trapped-ion systems, through a combination of novel features that eliminate the need for manual bookkeeping, reduction in data transfer bandwidth requirements via gate compression schemes, and other automated error handling techniques. Moreover, we describe an embedded pulse compiler that applies staged optimization, including compressed intermediate representations of parsed output products, performs in-situ mutation of compressed gate data to support high-level algorithmic feedback to account for drift, and can be run entirely on chip.
The calibration of quantum measurements is limited by the ability to accurately prepare quantum states under unknown device errors. We develop an accurate calibration protocol for the measurement apparatus of a quantum computer that is `blind' to the state preparation. Blind calibration quantifies and corrects measurement errors from simple tomographic data on a noisy quantum state. Importantly, it calibrates multiple error mechanisms in a single experiment, eliminating the need for bespoke, separate calibration experiments. Using a trapped-ion quantum computer, we systematically demonstrate the accuracy of the method. We use blind calibration to estimate the native calibration parameters of the experimental system. The recovered calibrations are consistent with directly measured values and perform similarly in predicting the state properties.
Quantum computing is transitioning from laboratory research to industrial deployment, yet significant challenges persist: system scalability and performance, fabrication yields, and the advancement of algorithms and applications. We emphasize that in building quantum computers -- spanning quantum chips, system integration, instruction sets, algorithms, and middleware such as quantum error correction schemes -- design is everywhere. In this paper, we advocate for a holistic design perspective in quantum computing, a perspective we argue is pivotal to unlocking innovative co-design opportunities and addressing the aforementioned key challenges. To equip readers with sufficient background for exploring co-optimization opportunities, we detail how interconnected computational methods and tools collaborate to enable end-to-end quantum computer design. This coverage encompasses critical stages -- such as chip layout design automation, high-fidelity system-level simulation, Hamiltonian derivation for quantum system modeling, control pulse simulation, decoherence analysis, and physical verification and testing -- followed by quantum instruction set design. We then proceed to quantum system and software development, including quantum circuit synthesis, quantum error correction and fault tolerance, and logic verification and testing. Through these discussions, we illustrate with concrete examples -- including co-optimizing quantum instruction sets with algorithmic considerations, customizing error correction circuits to hardware-specific constraints, and streamlining quantum chip design through tailored code design, among others. We hope that the detailed end-to-end design workflow as well as these examples will foster dialogue between the hardware and software communities, ultimately facilitating the translation of meaningful research findings into future quantum hardware implementations.
Abstract Effectively manipulating quantum computing (QC) hardware in the presence of imperfect devices and control systems is a central challenge in realizing useful quantum computers. Susceptibility to noise critically limits the performance and capabilities of today’s so-called noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices, as well as any future QC technologies. Fortunately, quantum control enables efficient execution of quantum logic operations and quantum algorithms with built-in robustness to errors, and without the need for complex logical encoding. In this manuscript we introduce software tools for the application and integration of quantum control in QC research, serving the needs of hardware R&D teams, algorithm developers, and end users. We provide an overview of a set of Python-based classical software tools for creating and deploying optimized quantum control solutions at various layers of the QC software stack. We describe a software architecture leveraging both high-performance distributed cloud computation and local custom integration into hardware systems, and explain how key functionality is integrable with other software packages and quantum programming languages. Our presentation includes a detailed mathematical overview of key features including a flexible optimization toolkit, engineering-inspired filter functions for analyzing noise susceptibility in high-dimensional Hilbert spaces, and new approaches to noise and hardware characterization. Pseudocode is presented in order to elucidate common programming workflows for these tasks, and performance benchmarking is reported for numerically intensive tasks, highlighting the benefits of the selected cloud-compute architecture. Finally, we present a series of case studies demonstrating the application of quantum control solutions derived from these tools in real experimental settings using both trapped-ion and superconducting quantum computer hardware.
The recently emerged field of quantum technology is aiming to employ quantum coherence and entanglement for realization of next generation sensors, standards, imaging systems, secure communication and computers.Although applications of quantum technologies cover a broad spectrum and their development stage varies from early demonstrations to commercially available devices, many challenges have been identified.The first includes tailoring materials for quantum technologies, which is playing an essential role in technological applications of quantum science.Solid state systems allowing long coherence time are essential for quantum computation and quantum sensing.Ultrapure materials with tailored isotopic content are important for reaching long coherence time of spin qubits (Awschalom et al., 2013).The ability to place single dopants with high precision and form spin qubits at desired location is essential for both quantum computing and quantum sensing applications (McCallum et al., 2012;Smith et al., 2019).The performance of different types of qubits is usually benchmarked in terms of controllability and coherence time.Usually solid-state systems allow fast control, but exhibit fast decoherence owing to complex environment.It is therefore important to search for new types of qubits combining isolation from environment and access via fast coherent control and readout.Novel approaches combining different quantum systems into build hybrid quantum devices for optimal performance is a promising avenue.Examples of such hybrid approaches are spin systems coupled to superconducting qubits (Kubo et al., 2011) and hybrid nuclear-electronic qubits (Morley et al., 2013).Optimal protocols for quantum technologies requires extension of coherence time of qubits beyond the coherence time of the isolated quantum system.The efficient protection toolkit includes dynamical decoupling (Yang et al., 2011) and quantum error correction (Terhal, 2015) based techniques.Although general principles of qubits protection were developed and tested experimentally in different model environments, it is essential to adapt them to realistic environmental noise.In the field of quantum sensing, it is also essential to combine protections against noise with non-reduced sensing performance.Experimental imperfections can be addressed using optimal control tools (Glaser et al., 2015).The development of efficient quantum algorithms is another growing field belonging to quantum software area.On one hand, it is essential to find problems where a quantum computer can outperform classical computers.On the other hand, it is essential to develop an application scenario for a limited number of qubits (Montanaro, 2016).In addition, in order to develop new algorithms, future work must include discoveries of application scenarios of already known algorithms.Application of quantum Fourier transform for sensing is a promising example of such new applications (Vorobyov et al., 2021).Signal processing is another field of quantum software that is becoming essential in applications.Advanced signal analysis protocols, like quantum compressed sensing, can be employed to quantify entanglement in large quantum devices via efficient quantum tomography (Riofrío et al., 2017).