Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2512.07815 · Physical Review Applied

Fast-feedback protocols for calibration and drift control in quantum computers

Alicia B. Magann, Nathan E. Miller, Robin Blume-Kohout, Peter Maunz, Kevin C. Young

quant-phSubmitted Dec 8, 2025• Announced Dec 9, 2025• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We introduce two classes of lightweight, adaptive calibration protocols for quantum computers that leverage fast feedback. The first enables shot-by-shot updates to device parameters using measurement outcomes from simple, indefinite-outcome quantum circuits. This low-latency approach supports rapid tuning of one or more parameters in real time to mitigate drift. The second protocol updates parameters after collecting measurements from definite-outcome circuits (e.g.~syndrome extraction circuits for quantum error correction), balancing efficiency with classical control overheads. We use numerical simulations to demonstrate that both methods can calibrate 1- and 2-qubit gates rapidly and accurately even in the presence of decoherence, state preparation and measurement (SPAM) errors, and parameter drift. We propose and demonstrate effective adaptive strategies for tuning the hyperparameters of both protocols. Finally, we demonstrate the feasibility of real-time in-situ calibration of qubits performing quantum error correction, using only syndrome data, via numerical simulations of syndrome extraction in the [[5,1,3]] code.

Related papers

Low-Latency Digital Feedback for Stochastic Quantum Calibration Using Cryogenic CMOS

Nathan Eli Miller, Laith A. Shamieh, Saibal Mukhopadhyay

In order to develop quantum computing systems towards practically useful applications, their physical quantum bits (qubits) must be able to operate with minimal error. Recent work has demonstrated stochastic gate calibration protocols for quantum systems which are meant to track drifting control parameters and tune gate operations to high fidelity. These protocols critically rely on low-latency feedback between the quantum system and its classical control hardware, which is impossible without on-board classical compute from FPGAs or ASICs. In this work, we analyze the performance of a single-shot stochastic calibration protocol for indefinite outcome quantum circuits under various latency conditions based on timing considerations from experimental quantum systems. We also demonstrate the benefits that can be achieved with ASIC implementation of the protocol by synthesizing the classical control logic in a 28 nm CMOS design node, with simulations extended to 14 nm FinFET and at both room and cryogenic temperatures. We show that these classes of quantum calibration protocols can be easily implemented within contemporary control system architectures for low-latency performance without significant power or resource utilization, allowing for the rapid tuning and drift control of any gate-model quantum system towards fault-tolerant computation.

Design, Automation, and Test in Europe•Mar 31, 2025•1 citation

Testbeds should enable development of new calibration routines.

Kevin C Young

The performance of quantum computing hardware is nearly always limited by coherent errors arising from miscalibration.New methods for calibration have the potential to completely eliminate these errors.With quantum devices growing ever larger and more difficult to calibrate, the community needs new testing protocols, new post-processing routines, new controller designs, and new software frameworks that together enable quantum devices to operate at their peak.In this white paper, we argue that a central design goal of future testbeds should be to enable creative research and development into novel hardware calibration routines.We suggest this can be accomplished by a deep commitment to low-level transparency, carefully designed control infrastructure, and flexible software frameworks.Quantum computers are large-scale, integrated systems with many free parameters, each of which must be carefully and continuously calibrated to ensure optimal and stable performance.Extracting the system information needed for calibration demands very careful experiment design, and acting on this information effectively requires rapid post-processing and low-latency feedback.Doing this optimally is hard.Many of the most common techniques for calibrating contemporary devices are inefficient in both experimental and postprocessing resources, and still lead to suboptimal performance.Transparency -When calibrating quantum hardware, transparency is essential.Users cannot correct parameters that they don't know about.When developing calibration protocols, users require direct, lowlevel access to as many controllable device parameters as possible -any parameter that an experimentalist regularly adjusts should be accessible programmatically.This degree of control is essential for efficient calibration, which must be automated and free from high-latency, manual adjustments.To support this automation, clear and complete documentation of a device at the lowest level must be available to the users.This includes details of exactly what each parameter controls, its allowed ranges, and -ideally -a model for how it impacts qubit operations.While not strictly necessary, these models can provide shortcuts for the calibration routines-it is much easier to correct over-rotation errors if the calibration routine knows which parameters impact rotation angles.Not all parameters are adjustable, and uncontrolled environmental degrees of freedom can have serious impacts on the performance of the device.Temperature measurements, microwave powers, and even laser phase stabilization servo values should be measured, recorded, and exposed to users.In our own work with trapped ion hardware [2] we have observed strong correlations between gate error rates and laboratory temperatures.In similar situations, continuous monitoring of the temperature can enable feed-forward compensation to correct these errors, reducing drift.In our experience, however, environmental data was recorded by offline monitoring tools and was available to us only after our experimental colleagues happened to mention its existence.By explicitly and programmatically exposing side-channel information, testbed designers will enable future drift-control protocols that exploit adaptive, feed-forward techniques to monitor and correct for unstable environments.This approach can dramatically reduce the resource overhead demanded by tomographic protocols that leverage comparatively expensive quantum measurements.Calibration impacts every possible testbed application, and recorded details of device calibration should be made available to all users for all experimental runs.The ability to audit calibration data is critical for identifying inefficiencies in calibration protocols, as well as providing possible explanation of an algorithm's unexpected performance.Testbeds should therefore err on the side of over-reporting calibration data, and testbed designers must adopt a deep commitment to device transparency to maximize its value to the scientific community. SAND2021-14320CThis paper describes objective technical results and analysis.Any subjective views or opinions that might be expressed in the paper do not necessarily represent the views of the U.

•Nov 28, 2022•0 citations

Enhancement of Machine Learning for Adaptive Quantum Computing Control: The Optimization Performance and Prevention of Real Time Error

V. Saravanan, Ganesan M, R. Balasubramaniyan +3 more

Adaptive quantum computing control is important for the stability and efficiency of quantum systems, especially in the presence of dynamic environmental noise and hardware fluctuations. We present a unified strategy for machine learning (ML) techniques to improve adaptive quantum control in two main directions: optimization speed and out-of-sample error. Here, we propose a hybrid learning method combining reinforcement learning (RL), deep neural networks (DNNs), and quantum-inspired models to actively and adaptively update quantum gate parameters and error mitigation strategies on the fly. Embedding of quantum noise models directly into the learning allows the system to predict and correct for decoherence, gate errors and measurement inaccuracy before they affect computational fidelity. Using extensive simulations as well as experimental validation on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) processors, our improved ML model achieves a substantially higher fidelity and robustness compared to standard model-free and static control approaches. We introduce a novel feedback-loop mechanism based on online learning algorithms enabling the system to adjust for changing noise profiles and hardware drift without retraining. The optimization part uses metaheuristic methods to quickly converge to control parameters that perform well, and the error prevention mechanism features anomaly detection and prediction correction layers to minimize the effects of cumulative decoherence. The results demonstrate that our adaptive control framework can be used to not only speed up the convergence in training quantum algorithms, but also sustain the performance of gates against error at a variety of error rates with the reduction of the real-time impact of the error up to 35 %. This work highlights the promise of machine learningaugmented quantum control for improving reliability and scalability in quantum computing and serves as a stepping stone for future incorporation with fault-tolerant designs.

International Conference on Electronics and Computing, Communication Networking Automation Technologies (ICEC2NT)•Sep 3, 2025•3 citations

Real-time calibration with spectator qubits

Swarnadeep Majumder, Leonardo Andreta de Castro, Kenneth R. Brown

Abstract Accurate control of quantum systems requires a precise measurement of the parameters that govern the dynamics, including control fields and interactions with the environment. Parameters will drift in time and experiments interleave protocols that perform parameter estimation, with protocols that measure the dynamics of interest. Here we specialize to a system made of qubits where the dynamics correspond to a quantum computation. We propose setting aside some qubits, which we call spectator qubits, to be measured periodically during the computation, to act as probes of the changing experimental and environmental parameters. By using control strategies that minimize the sensitivity of the qubits involved in the computation, we can acquire sufficient information from the spectator qubits to update our estimates of the parameters and improve our control. As a result, we can increase the length of experiments where the dynamics of the data qubits are highly reliable. In particular, we simulate how spectator qubits can keep the error level of operations on data qubits below a 10 −4 threshold in two scenarios involving coherent errors: a classical magnetic field gradient dynamically decoupled with sequences of two or four π -pulses, and laser beam instability detected via crosstalk with neighboring atoms in an ion trap.

arXiv:1907.03864•npj Quantum Information•Feb 7, 2020•53 citations

Feedback stabilization of multi-qubit Hamiltonian parameters enabled by single-shot measurement-based sequential Monte Carlo

Hyeongyu Jang, Jaemin Park, Younguk Song +6 more

Fast measurement, signal processing, and accurate estimation of Hamiltonian parameters are essential for feedback control in quantum-classical interface circuitry. However, existing frequentist and Bayesian inference methods typically require a large number of measurements to achieve the accuracy needed to mitigate qubit decoherence. Consequently, feedback control of semiconductor qubits has largely been limited to single-qubit frequency stabilization, whereas two-qubit parameter stabilization remains experimentally unexplored. Here, we demonstrate a real-time feedback framework based on sequential Monte Carlo estimation using one bit of data from a single-shot measurement. Using a four-qubit semiconductor quantum dot device, we rapidly estimate individual qubit frequencies, yielding an approximately twofold increase in coherence time compared with a conventional Bayesian strategy. Moreover, sequential two-qubit parameter estimation using two bits of data enables stabilization of qubit-qubit coupling, allowing both quasi-static frequency drift and exchange-interaction noise to be estimated and suppressed. By shortening the time required for precise parameter estimation, these results demonstrate the importance of the synergistic development of classical and quantum electronics for building robust and scalable quantum technologies in fluctuating environments.

quant-pharXiv:2607.26480•Jul 30, 2026•0 citations

Fast quantum calibration using Bayesian optimization with state parameter estimator for non-Markovian environment

Anonymous, Shahid Qamar, Xiao Xiao +5 more

As quantum systems expand in size and complexity, manual qubit characterization and gate optimization will be a non-scalable and time-consuming venture. Physical qubits have to be carefully calibrated because quantum processors are very sensitive to the external environment, with control hardware parameters slowly drifting during operation, affecting gate fidelity. Currently, existing calibration techniques require complex and lengthy measurements to independently control the different parameters of each gate and are unscalable to large quantum systems. Therefore, fully automated protocols with the desired functionalities are required to speed up the calibration process. This paper aims to propose single-qubit calibration of superconducting qubits under continuous weak measurements from a real physical experimental settings point of view. We propose a real-time optimal estimator of qubit states, which utilizes weak measurements and Bayesian optimization to find the optimal control pulses for gate design. Our numerical results demonstrate a significant reduction in the calibration process, obtaining a high gate fidelity. Using the proposed estimator we estimated the qubit state with and without measurement noise and the estimation error between the qubit state and the estimator state is less than 0.02. With this setup, we drive an approximated pi pulse with final fidelity of 0.9928. This shows that our proposed strategy is robust against the presence of measurement and environmental noise and can also be applicable for the calibration of many other quantum computation technologies.

arXiv:2205.12929•Physical Review A•Jul 14, 2026•5 citations
We introduce two classes of lightweight, adaptive calibration protocols for quantum computers that leverage fast feedback. The first enables shot-by-shot updates to device parameters using measurement outcomes from simple, indefinite-outcome quantum circuits. This low-latency approach supports rapid tuning of one or more parameters in real time to mitigate drift. The second protocol updates parameters after collecting measurements from definite-outcome circuits (e.g.~syndrome extraction circuits for quantum error correction), balancing efficiency with classical control overheads. We use numerical simulations to demonstrate that both methods can calibrate 1- and 2-qubit gates rapidly and accurately even in the presence of decoherence, state preparation and measurement (SPAM) errors, and parameter drift. We propose and demonstrate effective adaptive strategies for tuning the hyperparameters of both protocols. Finally, we demonstrate the feasibility of real-time in-situ calibration of qubits performing quantum error correction, using only syndrome data, via numerical simulations of syndrome extraction in the [[5,1,3]] code.
In order to develop quantum computing systems towards practically useful applications, their physical quantum bits (qubits) must be able to operate with minimal error. Recent work has demonstrated stochastic gate calibration protocols for quantum systems which are meant to track drifting control parameters and tune gate operations to high fidelity. These protocols critically rely on low-latency feedback between the quantum system and its classical control hardware, which is impossible without on-board classical compute from FPGAs or ASICs. In this work, we analyze the performance of a single-shot stochastic calibration protocol for indefinite outcome quantum circuits under various latency conditions based on timing considerations from experimental quantum systems. We also demonstrate the benefits that can be achieved with ASIC implementation of the protocol by synthesizing the classical control logic in a 28 nm CMOS design node, with simulations extended to 14 nm FinFET and at both room and cryogenic temperatures. We show that these classes of quantum calibration protocols can be easily implemented within contemporary control system architectures for low-latency performance without significant power or resource utilization, allowing for the rapid tuning and drift control of any gate-model quantum system towards fault-tolerant computation.
The performance of quantum computing hardware is nearly always limited by coherent errors arising from miscalibration.New methods for calibration have the potential to completely eliminate these errors.With quantum devices growing ever larger and more difficult to calibrate, the community needs new testing protocols, new post-processing routines, new controller designs, and new software frameworks that together enable quantum devices to operate at their peak.In this white paper, we argue that a central design goal of future testbeds should be to enable creative research and development into novel hardware calibration routines.We suggest this can be accomplished by a deep commitment to low-level transparency, carefully designed control infrastructure, and flexible software frameworks.Quantum computers are large-scale, integrated systems with many free parameters, each of which must be carefully and continuously calibrated to ensure optimal and stable performance.Extracting the system information needed for calibration demands very careful experiment design, and acting on this information effectively requires rapid post-processing and low-latency feedback.Doing this optimally is hard.Many of the most common techniques for calibrating contemporary devices are inefficient in both experimental and postprocessing resources, and still lead to suboptimal performance.Transparency -When calibrating quantum hardware, transparency is essential.Users cannot correct parameters that they don't know about.When developing calibration protocols, users require direct, lowlevel access to as many controllable device parameters as possible -any parameter that an experimentalist regularly adjusts should be accessible programmatically.This degree of control is essential for efficient calibration, which must be automated and free from high-latency, manual adjustments.To support this automation, clear and complete documentation of a device at the lowest level must be available to the users.This includes details of exactly what each parameter controls, its allowed ranges, and -ideally -a model for how it impacts qubit operations.While not strictly necessary, these models can provide shortcuts for the calibration routines-it is much easier to correct over-rotation errors if the calibration routine knows which parameters impact rotation angles.Not all parameters are adjustable, and uncontrolled environmental degrees of freedom can have serious impacts on the performance of the device.Temperature measurements, microwave powers, and even laser phase stabilization servo values should be measured, recorded, and exposed to users.In our own work with trapped ion hardware [2] we have observed strong correlations between gate error rates and laboratory temperatures.In similar situations, continuous monitoring of the temperature can enable feed-forward compensation to correct these errors, reducing drift.In our experience, however, environmental data was recorded by offline monitoring tools and was available to us only after our experimental colleagues happened to mention its existence.By explicitly and programmatically exposing side-channel information, testbed designers will enable future drift-control protocols that exploit adaptive, feed-forward techniques to monitor and correct for unstable environments.This approach can dramatically reduce the resource overhead demanded by tomographic protocols that leverage comparatively expensive quantum measurements.Calibration impacts every possible testbed application, and recorded details of device calibration should be made available to all users for all experimental runs.The ability to audit calibration data is critical for identifying inefficiencies in calibration protocols, as well as providing possible explanation of an algorithm's unexpected performance.Testbeds should therefore err on the side of over-reporting calibration data, and testbed designers must adopt a deep commitment to device transparency to maximize its value to the scientific community. SAND2021-14320CThis paper describes objective technical results and analysis.Any subjective views or opinions that might be expressed in the paper do not necessarily represent the views of the U.
Adaptive quantum computing control is important for the stability and efficiency of quantum systems, especially in the presence of dynamic environmental noise and hardware fluctuations. We present a unified strategy for machine learning (ML) techniques to improve adaptive quantum control in two main directions: optimization speed and out-of-sample error. Here, we propose a hybrid learning method combining reinforcement learning (RL), deep neural networks (DNNs), and quantum-inspired models to actively and adaptively update quantum gate parameters and error mitigation strategies on the fly. Embedding of quantum noise models directly into the learning allows the system to predict and correct for decoherence, gate errors and measurement inaccuracy before they affect computational fidelity. Using extensive simulations as well as experimental validation on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) processors, our improved ML model achieves a substantially higher fidelity and robustness compared to standard model-free and static control approaches. We introduce a novel feedback-loop mechanism based on online learning algorithms enabling the system to adjust for changing noise profiles and hardware drift without retraining. The optimization part uses metaheuristic methods to quickly converge to control parameters that perform well, and the error prevention mechanism features anomaly detection and prediction correction layers to minimize the effects of cumulative decoherence. The results demonstrate that our adaptive control framework can be used to not only speed up the convergence in training quantum algorithms, but also sustain the performance of gates against error at a variety of error rates with the reduction of the real-time impact of the error up to 35 %. This work highlights the promise of machine learningaugmented quantum control for improving reliability and scalability in quantum computing and serves as a stepping stone for future incorporation with fault-tolerant designs.
Abstract Accurate control of quantum systems requires a precise measurement of the parameters that govern the dynamics, including control fields and interactions with the environment. Parameters will drift in time and experiments interleave protocols that perform parameter estimation, with protocols that measure the dynamics of interest. Here we specialize to a system made of qubits where the dynamics correspond to a quantum computation. We propose setting aside some qubits, which we call spectator qubits, to be measured periodically during the computation, to act as probes of the changing experimental and environmental parameters. By using control strategies that minimize the sensitivity of the qubits involved in the computation, we can acquire sufficient information from the spectator qubits to update our estimates of the parameters and improve our control. As a result, we can increase the length of experiments where the dynamics of the data qubits are highly reliable. In particular, we simulate how spectator qubits can keep the error level of operations on data qubits below a 10 −4 threshold in two scenarios involving coherent errors: a classical magnetic field gradient dynamically decoupled with sequences of two or four π -pulses, and laser beam instability detected via crosstalk with neighboring atoms in an ion trap.
Fast measurement, signal processing, and accurate estimation of Hamiltonian parameters are essential for feedback control in quantum-classical interface circuitry. However, existing frequentist and Bayesian inference methods typically require a large number of measurements to achieve the accuracy needed to mitigate qubit decoherence. Consequently, feedback control of semiconductor qubits has largely been limited to single-qubit frequency stabilization, whereas two-qubit parameter stabilization remains experimentally unexplored. Here, we demonstrate a real-time feedback framework based on sequential Monte Carlo estimation using one bit of data from a single-shot measurement. Using a four-qubit semiconductor quantum dot device, we rapidly estimate individual qubit frequencies, yielding an approximately twofold increase in coherence time compared with a conventional Bayesian strategy. Moreover, sequential two-qubit parameter estimation using two bits of data enables stabilization of qubit-qubit coupling, allowing both quasi-static frequency drift and exchange-interaction noise to be estimated and suppressed. By shortening the time required for precise parameter estimation, these results demonstrate the importance of the synergistic development of classical and quantum electronics for building robust and scalable quantum technologies in fluctuating environments.
As quantum systems expand in size and complexity, manual qubit characterization and gate optimization will be a non-scalable and time-consuming venture. Physical qubits have to be carefully calibrated because quantum processors are very sensitive to the external environment, with control hardware parameters slowly drifting during operation, affecting gate fidelity. Currently, existing calibration techniques require complex and lengthy measurements to independently control the different parameters of each gate and are unscalable to large quantum systems. Therefore, fully automated protocols with the desired functionalities are required to speed up the calibration process. This paper aims to propose single-qubit calibration of superconducting qubits under continuous weak measurements from a real physical experimental settings point of view. We propose a real-time optimal estimator of qubit states, which utilizes weak measurements and Bayesian optimization to find the optimal control pulses for gate design. Our numerical results demonstrate a significant reduction in the calibration process, obtaining a high gate fidelity. Using the proposed estimator we estimated the qubit state with and without measurement noise and the estimation error between the qubit state and the estimator state is less than 0.02. With this setup, we drive an approximated pi pulse with final fidelity of 0.9928. This shows that our proposed strategy is robust against the presence of measurement and environmental noise and can also be applicable for the calibration of many other quantum computation technologies.