Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Theory of Quantum Uncertainties and Quantum Measurements

Harsh Anand

Published Oct 31, 2022• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

1) We shall discuss what modern interpretations say about the Heisenberg's uncertainties. These interpretations explain that a quantity begins to 'lose' meaning when a conjugate property begins to 'acquire' definite meaning. We know that a quantity losing meaning means that it has no fixed value and has an uncertainty . In this paper we look deeper into this interpretation and the outcome reveals more evidence of the quantity losing meaning. Newer insights appear. 2) We consider two extreme cases of hypothetical processes nature undergoes, without interference by a measurement: One, a system collapses to an energy eigenstate under the influence of a Hamiltonian instantaneously at a time $t$. This is thus what would happen if we would measure the system's energy. Next, when a particle becomes localised to a point at a time $t_0$ under the influence of a Hamiltonian. This is thus what would happen if we would measure the system's position. We shall prove that both these situations cannot arise under ordinary circumstances and thus measurement processes cannot be modelled by physical Hamiltonians.

DOI
10.20944/preprints202201.0297.v3

Related papers

Foundations of quantum physics III. Measurement

Arnold Neumaier

This paper presents the measurement problem from the point of view of the thermal interpretation of quantum physics introduced in Part II. The measurement of a Hermitian quantity $A$ is regarded as giving an uncertain value approximating the q-expectation $\langle A\rangle$ rather than (as tradition wanted to have it) as an exact revelation of an eigenvalue of $A$. Single observations of microscopic systems are (except under special circumstances) very uncertain measurements only. The thermal interpretation * treats detection events as a statistical measurement of particle beam intensity. * claims that the particle concept is only asymptotically valid, under conditions where particles are essentially free. * claims that the unmodeled environment influences the results enough to cause all randomness in quantum physics. * allows one to derive Born's rule for scattering and in the limit of ideal measurements; but in general, only part of Born's rule holds exactly: Whenever a quantity A with zero uncertainty is measured exactly, its value is an eigenvalue of A. * has no explicit collapse -- the latter emerges approximately in non-isolated subsystems. * gives a valid interpretation of systems modeled by a quantum-classical dynamics. * explains the peculiar features of the Copenhagen interpretation (lacking realism between measurements) and the minimal statistical interpretation (lacking realism for the single case) where these interpretations apply -- in the microscopic domain. The thermal interpretation is an interpretation of quantum physics that is in principle refutable by theoretical arguments leading to a negative answer to a number of open issues collected at the end of the paper, since there is plenty of experimental evidence for each of the points mentioned there.

arXiv:1902.10782•Feb 27, 2019•6 citations

Unprincipling Heisenberg’s uncertainties

Jean-Marc Lévy-Leblond

The first part of this paper is a critical essay on the conceptual meaning of the so-called « Uncertainty principle ». It will be stressed that there is no independent principle underlying the Heisenberg’s inequalities as they derive from the fundamental theoretical structure of quantum theory. More to the point, it will be emphasized that the term « uncertainty » is a misnomer, leading to subjective interpretations about the limits of our knowledge. Recognizing at face value the conceptual nature of quantum physical quantities, as endowed with a spectrum of numerical values, one should rather call « dispersions », « extensions » or « spectrum widths » the magnitudes entering Heisenberg’s type inequalities. A historical inquiry about the origins of the conventional terminology, from German to other languages, will reveal the roots and extent of the confusion. The second part of the paper will review and assess many of the various formal definitions leading to Heisenberg’s type inequalities, well beyond the pairs of physical quantities, such as the position and velocity of a particle and the customary use of quadratic dispersions. Some still open issues, such as the time-energy inequality or the angle-phase inequality will be briefly discussed. A sobering conclusion will assess the concrete uses of Heisenberg’s inequalities and stress that their genuine relevance and indisputable importance lie mainly at the heuristic and qualitative level, thus somewhat reducing the interest of the continuous discussions concerning their mathematical validity and philosophical interpretation.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jul 1, 2026•0 citations

Retrodiction beyond the Heisenberg uncertainty relation

Han Bao, Shenchao Jin, Junlei Duan +4 more

Abstract In quantum mechanics, the Heisenberg uncertainty relation presents an ultimate limit to the precision by which one can predict the outcome of position and momentum measurements on a particle. Heisenberg explicitly stated this relation for the prediction of “hypothetical future measurements”, and it does not describe the situation where knowledge is available about the system both earlier and later than the time of the measurement. Here, we study what happens under such circumstances with an atomic ensemble containing 1011 rubidium atoms, initiated nearly in the ground state in the presence of a magnetic field. The collective spin observables of the atoms are then well described by canonical position and momentum observables, $${\hat{x}}_{\text{A}}$$ x ̂ A and $${\hat{p}}_{\text{A}}$$ p ̂ A that satisfy $$[{\hat{x}}_{\text{A}},{\hat{p}}_{\text{A}}]=i\hslash$$ [ x ̂ A , p ̂ A ] = i ℏ . Quantum non-demolition measurements of $${\hat{p}}_{\text{A}}$$ p ̂ A before and of $${\hat{x}}_{\text{A}}$$ x ̂ A after time t allow precise estimates of both observables at time t. By means of the past quantum state formalism, we demonstrate that outcomes of measurements of both the $${\hat{x}}_{\text{A}}$$ x ̂ A and $${\hat{p}}_{A}$$ p ̂ A observables can be inferred with errors below the standard quantum limit. The capability of assigning precise values to multiple observables and to observe their variation during physical processes may have implications in quantum state estimation and sensing.

arXiv:2009.12642•Nature Communications•Nov 9, 2020•30 citations

Remarks on Uncertainty Principles

E. U. Condon

Since the publication of Heisenberg’s paper1 on the “anschaulichen Inhalt” of quantum mechanics, discussions of the fundamental limitations on the accuracy of physical measurements have been much in the foreground. According to Heisenberg, the quantum mechanics implies that it is impossible to measure simultaneous values of a coordinate and its conjugate momentum with unlimited precision. Instead, if Δp be the estimated error or uncertainty in a momentum and Δq that in the associated coordinate one must have the inequality, $$ \Delta p\Delta q>\frac{h}{{2\pi}} $$ (1) This inequality has come to be known quite generally as Heisenberg’s uncertainty relation.

Science•May 31, 1929•16 citations

The Formal Theory of Quantum Mechanics

In classical mechanics, the state of a physical object is determined by quantities such as mass, momentum, and angular momentum. According to Newton’s laws, for a given initial state, the evolution of the system is deterministic—that is, the state of the object (i.e., its parameters) can be precisely predicted at any future time. In quantum mechanics, however, based on the theory of matter waves, the state of a system is described by a probability wave function. Given an initial state, the time evolution of the system is governed by the Schrödinger equation, which determines the probability distribution of the particle’s position (or other observables) in space over time. The probabilistic nature of the quantum state implies that prior to measurement, the system may exist in a superposition of possible states, each associated with a certain probability amplitude. In physics, measurement refers to the experimental determination of mechanical quantities such as position, momentum, energy, and angular momentum. In classical mechanics, the act of measurement does not influence the physical state of the object; the system remains unaffected by the observation. In contrast, quantum measurement fundamentally alters the state: once a definite value of an observable is measured, the wave function collapses to the corresponding eigenstate. This signifies that the probabilistic description of the system with respect to that observable becomes a definite state—the system’s wave function is projected accordingly. Thus, the state of a quantum system is inherently measurement-dependent, and by measuring a mechanical quantity, one effectively determines the corresponding probability distribution, or wave function, associated with that observable. Therefore, the relationship between observables (mechanical quantities) and state wave functions, as well as the mathematical structure connecting them, constitutes one of the central concerns of quantum theory. As previously discussed, the Schrödinger equation involves expressions for energy and momentum that act on wave functions in the form of operators. Accordingly, we now proceed to explore the formalism of quantum mechanics based on the concept of operators.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Sep 16, 2026•0 citations

Which way are the photons pointing?

Alastair I. M. Rae

The previous chapter surveyed part of the rich variety of physical phenomena that can be understood using the ideas of quantum physics. Now that we are beginning the task of looking more deeply into the subject we shall find it useful to concentrate on examples that are comparatively simple to understand but which still illustrate the fundamental principles and highlight the basic conceptual problems. Some years ago most writers discussing such topics would probably have turned to the example of a ‘particle’ passing through a two-slit apparatus (as in Figure 1.2), whose wave properties are revealed in the interference pattern. Much of the discussion would have been in terms of wave–particle duality and the problems involved in position and momentum measurements, as in the discussion of the uncertainty principle in the last chapter. However, there are essentially an infinite number of places where the particle can be and an infinite number of possible values of its momentum, and this complicates the discussion considerably. We can illustrate all the points of principle we want to discuss by considering situations where a measurement has only a small number of possible outcomes. One such quantity relating to the physics of light beams and photons is known as polarisation. In the next section we discuss it in the context of the classical wave theory of light, and the rest of the chapter extends the concept to situations where the photon nature of light is important.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Mar 26, 2012•0 citations
  1. We shall discuss what modern interpretations say about the Heisenberg's uncertainties. These interpretations explain that a quantity begins to 'lose' meaning when a conjugate property begins to 'acquire' definite meaning. We know that a quantity losing meaning means that it has no fixed value and has an uncertainty . In this paper we look deeper into this interpretation and the outcome reveals more evidence of the quantity losing meaning. Newer insights appear. 2) We consider two extreme cases of hypothetical processes nature undergoes, without interference by a measurement: One, a system collapses to an energy eigenstate under the influence of a Hamiltonian instantaneously at a time ttt. This is thus what would happen if we would measure the system's energy. Next, when a particle becomes localised to a point at a time t0t_0t0​ under the influence of a Hamiltonian. This is thus what would happen if we would measure the system's position. We shall prove that both these situations cannot arise under ordinary circumstances and thus measurement processes cannot be modelled by physical Hamiltonians.
This paper presents the measurement problem from the point of view of the thermal interpretation of quantum physics introduced in Part II. The measurement of a Hermitian quantity AAA is regarded as giving an uncertain value approximating the q-expectation ⟨A⟩\langle A\rangle⟨A⟩ rather than (as tradition wanted to have it) as an exact revelation of an eigenvalue of AAA. Single observations of microscopic systems are (except under special circumstances) very uncertain measurements only. The thermal interpretation * treats detection events as a statistical measurement of particle beam intensity. * claims that the particle concept is only asymptotically valid, under conditions where particles are essentially free. * claims that the unmodeled environment influences the results enough to cause all randomness in quantum physics. * allows one to derive Born's rule for scattering and in the limit of ideal measurements; but in general, only part of Born's rule holds exactly: Whenever a quantity A with zero uncertainty is measured exactly, its value is an eigenvalue of A. * has no explicit collapse -- the latter emerges approximately in non-isolated subsystems. * gives a valid interpretation of systems modeled by a quantum-classical dynamics. * explains the peculiar features of the Copenhagen interpretation (lacking realism between measurements) and the minimal statistical interpretation (lacking realism for the single case) where these interpretations apply -- in the microscopic domain. The thermal interpretation is an interpretation of quantum physics that is in principle refutable by theoretical arguments leading to a negative answer to a number of open issues collected at the end of the paper, since there is plenty of experimental evidence for each of the points mentioned there.
The first part of this paper is a critical essay on the conceptual meaning of the so-called « Uncertainty principle ». It will be stressed that there is no independent principle underlying the Heisenberg’s inequalities as they derive from the fundamental theoretical structure of quantum theory. More to the point, it will be emphasized that the term « uncertainty » is a misnomer, leading to subjective interpretations about the limits of our knowledge. Recognizing at face value the conceptual nature of quantum physical quantities, as endowed with a spectrum of numerical values, one should rather call « dispersions », « extensions » or « spectrum widths » the magnitudes entering Heisenberg’s type inequalities. A historical inquiry about the origins of the conventional terminology, from German to other languages, will reveal the roots and extent of the confusion. The second part of the paper will review and assess many of the various formal definitions leading to Heisenberg’s type inequalities, well beyond the pairs of physical quantities, such as the position and velocity of a particle and the customary use of quadratic dispersions. Some still open issues, such as the time-energy inequality or the angle-phase inequality will be briefly discussed. A sobering conclusion will assess the concrete uses of Heisenberg’s inequalities and stress that their genuine relevance and indisputable importance lie mainly at the heuristic and qualitative level, thus somewhat reducing the interest of the continuous discussions concerning their mathematical validity and philosophical interpretation.
Abstract In quantum mechanics, the Heisenberg uncertainty relation presents an ultimate limit to the precision by which one can predict the outcome of position and momentum measurements on a particle. Heisenberg explicitly stated this relation for the prediction of “hypothetical future measurements”, and it does not describe the situation where knowledge is available about the system both earlier and later than the time of the measurement. Here, we study what happens under such circumstances with an atomic ensemble containing 1011 rubidium atoms, initiated nearly in the ground state in the presence of a magnetic field. The collective spin observables of the atoms are then well described by canonical position and momentum observables, x^A{\hat{x}}_{\text{A}}x^A​ x ̂ A and p^A{\hat{p}}_{\text{A}}p^​A​ p ̂ A that satisfy [x^A,p^A]=iℏ[{\hat{x}}_{\text{A}},{\hat{p}}_{\text{A}}]=i\hslash[x^A​,p^​A​]=iℏ [ x ̂ A , p ̂ A ] = i ℏ . Quantum non-demolition measurements of p^A{\hat{p}}_{\text{A}}p^​A​ p ̂ A before and of x^A{\hat{x}}_{\text{A}}x^A​ x ̂ A after time t allow precise estimates of both observables at time t. By means of the past quantum state formalism, we demonstrate that outcomes of measurements of both the x^A{\hat{x}}_{\text{A}}x^A​ x ̂ A and p^A{\hat{p}}_{A}p^​A​ p ̂ A observables can be inferred with errors below the standard quantum limit. The capability of assigning precise values to multiple observables and to observe their variation during physical processes may have implications in quantum state estimation and sensing.
Since the publication of Heisenberg’s paper1 on the “anschaulichen Inhalt” of quantum mechanics, discussions of the fundamental limitations on the accuracy of physical measurements have been much in the foreground. According to Heisenberg, the quantum mechanics implies that it is impossible to measure simultaneous values of a coordinate and its conjugate momentum with unlimited precision. Instead, if Δp be the estimated error or uncertainty in a momentum and Δq that in the associated coordinate one must have the inequality, ΔpΔq>h2π \Delta p\Delta q>\frac{h}{{2\pi}} ΔpΔq>2πh​ (1) This inequality has come to be known quite generally as Heisenberg’s uncertainty relation.
In classical mechanics, the state of a physical object is determined by quantities such as mass, momentum, and angular momentum. According to Newton’s laws, for a given initial state, the evolution of the system is deterministic—that is, the state of the object (i.e., its parameters) can be precisely predicted at any future time. In quantum mechanics, however, based on the theory of matter waves, the state of a system is described by a probability wave function. Given an initial state, the time evolution of the system is governed by the Schrödinger equation, which determines the probability distribution of the particle’s position (or other observables) in space over time. The probabilistic nature of the quantum state implies that prior to measurement, the system may exist in a superposition of possible states, each associated with a certain probability amplitude. In physics, measurement refers to the experimental determination of mechanical quantities such as position, momentum, energy, and angular momentum. In classical mechanics, the act of measurement does not influence the physical state of the object; the system remains unaffected by the observation. In contrast, quantum measurement fundamentally alters the state: once a definite value of an observable is measured, the wave function collapses to the corresponding eigenstate. This signifies that the probabilistic description of the system with respect to that observable becomes a definite state—the system’s wave function is projected accordingly. Thus, the state of a quantum system is inherently measurement-dependent, and by measuring a mechanical quantity, one effectively determines the corresponding probability distribution, or wave function, associated with that observable. Therefore, the relationship between observables (mechanical quantities) and state wave functions, as well as the mathematical structure connecting them, constitutes one of the central concerns of quantum theory. As previously discussed, the Schrödinger equation involves expressions for energy and momentum that act on wave functions in the form of operators. Accordingly, we now proceed to explore the formalism of quantum mechanics based on the concept of operators.
The previous chapter surveyed part of the rich variety of physical phenomena that can be understood using the ideas of quantum physics. Now that we are beginning the task of looking more deeply into the subject we shall find it useful to concentrate on examples that are comparatively simple to understand but which still illustrate the fundamental principles and highlight the basic conceptual problems. Some years ago most writers discussing such topics would probably have turned to the example of a ‘particle’ passing through a two-slit apparatus (as in Figure 1.2), whose wave properties are revealed in the interference pattern. Much of the discussion would have been in terms of wave–particle duality and the problems involved in position and momentum measurements, as in the discussion of the uncertainty principle in the last chapter. However, there are essentially an infinite number of places where the particle can be and an infinite number of possible values of its momentum, and this complicates the discussion considerably. We can illustrate all the points of principle we want to discuss by considering situations where a measurement has only a small number of possible outcomes. One such quantity relating to the physics of light beams and photons is known as polarisation. In the next section we discuss it in the context of the classical wave theory of light, and the rest of the chapter extends the concept to situations where the photon nature of light is important.