Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

Bananaworld

Jeffrey Bub

Published Feb 11, 2016• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

This chapter discusses a Bananaworld version of a correlation analyzed by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen in a 1935 argument for the incompleteness of quantum mechanics. This correlation can be simulated by Alice and Bob with a shared random local resource, which is equivalent to showing that the correlation has a common cause explanation. A superquantum correlation proposed by Popescu and Rohrlich can’t be perfectly simulated with local resources, but a quantum simulation with entangled quantum states can do better than the optimal simulation with local resources (up to a quantum limit called the “Tsirelson bound”). So there is no common cause explanation of the correlation of a pair of Popescu–Rohrlich bananas. Since the correlated events can be arbitrarily far apart, there is no direct causal explanation either, because information would have to be transmitted faster than light between the correlated events. This is a version of Bell’s theorem.

DOI
10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198718536.003.0003

Related papers

Nobody Understands Quantum Mechanics

Jeffrey Bub

In a quantum world, there are nonlocal correlations with no common cause, where a direct causal influence between the correlated events can be excluded. Moreover, these correlated events are separately intrinsically random. In the contemporary quantum information literature, correlations are studied abstractly in “Boxworld.” A “box” is an imaginary device, with input and output ports on each side, defined by a particular correlation between inputs and outputs, without any specification of an internal mechanism that could produce the correlation. Bananaworld is Boxworld, with bananas and peelings and tastes instead of boxes with inputs and outputs. The idea is to get at what is puzzling about quantum correlations by considering the extent to which Alice and Bob, limited to certain resources, could simulate various correlations in Bananaworld. This introductory chapter introduces these ideas, beginning with a brief exposition of the birth of quantum mechanics in Heisenberg’s 1925 breakthrough paper. The chapter concludes with a self-contained introduction to special relativity.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Feb 11, 2016•1 citation

Why the Quantum?

Jeffrey Bub

What principle excludes superquantum correlations that don’t violate the nosignaling principle? In an argument using PR boxes in a 2009 Nature paper, Pawlowski and colleagues show that the Tsirelson bound – the limit achievable in a simulation of a Popescu–Rohrlich correlation with quantum resources – follows from an information-theoretic principle they call “information causality.” For three qubits, it is now known that there are superquantum correlations that cannot be excluded by a bipartite principle like information causality, so this principle does not completely characterize quantum correlations. An intriguing principle, developed by Cabello as the “exclusivity principle” or “Specker’s principle” (from Ernst Specker’s story about a seer from Nineva), and separately by Fritz and colleagues as the principle of “local orthogonality,” yields the Tsirelson bound, and also rules out correlations beyond the quantum limit for the Klyachko correlation and other cases where contextuality or nonlocality is relevant.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Feb 11, 2016•0 citations

Bananaworld: Quantum Mechanics for Primates

Jeffrey Bub

This is intended to be a serious paper, in spite of the title. The idea is that quantum mechanics is about probabilistic correlations, i.e., about the structure of information, since a theory of information is essentially a theory of probabilistic correlations. To make this clear, it suffices to consider measurements of two binary-valued observables, x with outcomes a = 0 or 1, performed by Alice in a region A, and y with outcomes b = 0 or 1 performed by Bob in a separated region B --or, to emphasize the banality of the phenomena, two ways of peeling a banana, resulting in one of two tastes. The imagined bananas of Bananaworld are non-standard, with operational or phenomenal probabilistic correlations for peelings and tastes that lie outside the polytope of local correlations. The 'no go' theorems tell us that we can't shoe-horn these correlations into a classical correlation polytope, which has the structure of a simplex, by supposing that something has been left out of the story, without giving up fundamental principles that define what we mean by a physical system. The nonclassical features of quantum mechanics, including the irreducible information loss on measurement, are shown to be generic features of correlations that lie outside the local correlation polytope. As far as the conceptual problems are concerned, we might as well talk about bananas.

arXiv:1211.3062•Nov 13, 2012•25 citations

Quantum Secrets

Jeffrey Bub

Classical physics cannot guarantee the security of a procedure for distributing a cryptographic key between two parties. In a quantum world, any attempt by Eve to eavesdrop on communications between Alice and Bob can be revealed. The chapter shows how Alice and Bob can share secrets with unconditional security in Bananaworld by exploiting the “monogamous” correlations of Popescu–Rohrlich bananas, and discusses a protocol by Ekert that exploits the monogamy of entanglement in our quantum world to allow Alice and Bob to share a secret key. Finally, the chapter shows how this can be extended to a device-independent scenario, where Alice and Bob can share a secret key even if they suspect that the devices they use to prepare and measure entangled quantum states are insecure and might have been supplied by an adversary.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Feb 11, 2016•0 citations

Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen Paradox in Quantum Diagrams

S. V. Gantsevich

Quantum diagrams are the best language for Quantum Mechanics since they show not only a final result but also the physical process which leads to the result. The quantum correlation at a distance better known as the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox may be easily understood being depicted in the time-ordered quantum diagrams. In the diagrams one can clearly see what the so-called entangled quantum states really are and how they contribute to the violation of Bell inequality. The wave function phase relations that are the actual physical "common cause in the past" for the observed correlation become also visual and evident. Thus the diagram analysis shows that the phenomenon of distant quantum correlation has simple causal and local explanation and there is no need to invent various extravagant constructions contradicting the established physical principles as well as usual common sense considerations.

arXiv:1701.00448•Dec 19, 2016•0 citations

A Reasonable Thing That Just Might Work

Daniel Rohrlich

In 1964, John Bell proved that quantum mechanics is “unreasonable” (to use Einstein's term): there are nonlocal bipartite quantum correlations. But they are not the most nonlocal bipartite correlations consistent with relativistic causality (“no superluminal signalling”); maximally nonlocal “superquantum” (or “PR-box”) correlations are also consistent with relativistic causality. I show that – unlike quantum correlations – these correlations do not have a classical limit consistent with relativistic causality. The generalization of this result to all stronger-than-quantum nonlocal correlations is a derivation of Tsirelson's bound – a theorem of quantum mechanics – from the three axioms of relativistic causality, nonlocality, and the existence of a classical limit. But is it reasonable to derive (a part of) quantum mechanics from the unreasonable axiom of nonlocality?! I consider replacing the nonlocality axiom with an equivalent axiom that even Bell and Einstein might have considered reasonable: an axiom of local retrocausality. In 1964, John Bell [1] proved that quantum mechanics is “unreasonable,” as defined by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen [2] in 1935: “No reasonable definition of reality could be expected to permit this.” “This” (i.e., violation of “Einstein separability,” to use a technical term, or “spooky action at a distance,” as Einstein put it) turns out to be endemic to quantum mechanics. For example, pairs of photons measured at spacelike separations may yield nonlocal quantum correlations, i.e., correlations that cannot be traced to any data or “programs” the photons carry with them. As Bell [3] put it 20 years later, “For me, it is so reasonable to assume that the photons in those experiments carry with them programs, which have been correlated in advance, telling them how to behave. This is so rational that I think that when Einstein saw that, and the others refused to see it, he was the rational man. The other people, although history has justified them, were burying their heads in the sand. I feel that Einstein's intellectual superiority over Bohr, in this instance, was enormous; a vast gulf between the man who saw clearly what was needed, and the obscurantist. So for me, it is a pity that Einstein's idea doesn't work. The reasonable thing just doesn't work.”

arXiv:1507.01588•Cambridge University Press eBooks•Aug 31, 2016•2 citations
This chapter discusses a Bananaworld version of a correlation analyzed by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen in a 1935 argument for the incompleteness of quantum mechanics. This correlation can be simulated by Alice and Bob with a shared random local resource, which is equivalent to showing that the correlation has a common cause explanation. A superquantum correlation proposed by Popescu and Rohrlich can’t be perfectly simulated with local resources, but a quantum simulation with entangled quantum states can do better than the optimal simulation with local resources (up to a quantum limit called the “Tsirelson bound”). So there is no common cause explanation of the correlation of a pair of Popescu–Rohrlich bananas. Since the correlated events can be arbitrarily far apart, there is no direct causal explanation either, because information would have to be transmitted faster than light between the correlated events. This is a version of Bell’s theorem.
In a quantum world, there are nonlocal correlations with no common cause, where a direct causal influence between the correlated events can be excluded. Moreover, these correlated events are separately intrinsically random. In the contemporary quantum information literature, correlations are studied abstractly in “Boxworld.” A “box” is an imaginary device, with input and output ports on each side, defined by a particular correlation between inputs and outputs, without any specification of an internal mechanism that could produce the correlation. Bananaworld is Boxworld, with bananas and peelings and tastes instead of boxes with inputs and outputs. The idea is to get at what is puzzling about quantum correlations by considering the extent to which Alice and Bob, limited to certain resources, could simulate various correlations in Bananaworld. This introductory chapter introduces these ideas, beginning with a brief exposition of the birth of quantum mechanics in Heisenberg’s 1925 breakthrough paper. The chapter concludes with a self-contained introduction to special relativity.
What principle excludes superquantum correlations that don’t violate the nosignaling principle? In an argument using PR boxes in a 2009 Nature paper, Pawlowski and colleagues show that the Tsirelson bound – the limit achievable in a simulation of a Popescu–Rohrlich correlation with quantum resources – follows from an information-theoretic principle they call “information causality.” For three qubits, it is now known that there are superquantum correlations that cannot be excluded by a bipartite principle like information causality, so this principle does not completely characterize quantum correlations. An intriguing principle, developed by Cabello as the “exclusivity principle” or “Specker’s principle” (from Ernst Specker’s story about a seer from Nineva), and separately by Fritz and colleagues as the principle of “local orthogonality,” yields the Tsirelson bound, and also rules out correlations beyond the quantum limit for the Klyachko correlation and other cases where contextuality or nonlocality is relevant.
This is intended to be a serious paper, in spite of the title. The idea is that quantum mechanics is about probabilistic correlations, i.e., about the structure of information, since a theory of information is essentially a theory of probabilistic correlations. To make this clear, it suffices to consider measurements of two binary-valued observables, x with outcomes a = 0 or 1, performed by Alice in a region A, and y with outcomes b = 0 or 1 performed by Bob in a separated region B --or, to emphasize the banality of the phenomena, two ways of peeling a banana, resulting in one of two tastes. The imagined bananas of Bananaworld are non-standard, with operational or phenomenal probabilistic correlations for peelings and tastes that lie outside the polytope of local correlations. The 'no go' theorems tell us that we can't shoe-horn these correlations into a classical correlation polytope, which has the structure of a simplex, by supposing that something has been left out of the story, without giving up fundamental principles that define what we mean by a physical system. The nonclassical features of quantum mechanics, including the irreducible information loss on measurement, are shown to be generic features of correlations that lie outside the local correlation polytope. As far as the conceptual problems are concerned, we might as well talk about bananas.
Classical physics cannot guarantee the security of a procedure for distributing a cryptographic key between two parties. In a quantum world, any attempt by Eve to eavesdrop on communications between Alice and Bob can be revealed. The chapter shows how Alice and Bob can share secrets with unconditional security in Bananaworld by exploiting the “monogamous” correlations of Popescu–Rohrlich bananas, and discusses a protocol by Ekert that exploits the monogamy of entanglement in our quantum world to allow Alice and Bob to share a secret key. Finally, the chapter shows how this can be extended to a device-independent scenario, where Alice and Bob can share a secret key even if they suspect that the devices they use to prepare and measure entangled quantum states are insecure and might have been supplied by an adversary.
Quantum diagrams are the best language for Quantum Mechanics since they show not only a final result but also the physical process which leads to the result. The quantum correlation at a distance better known as the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox may be easily understood being depicted in the time-ordered quantum diagrams. In the diagrams one can clearly see what the so-called entangled quantum states really are and how they contribute to the violation of Bell inequality. The wave function phase relations that are the actual physical "common cause in the past" for the observed correlation become also visual and evident. Thus the diagram analysis shows that the phenomenon of distant quantum correlation has simple causal and local explanation and there is no need to invent various extravagant constructions contradicting the established physical principles as well as usual common sense considerations.
In 1964, John Bell proved that quantum mechanics is “unreasonable” (to use Einstein's term): there are nonlocal bipartite quantum correlations. But they are not the most nonlocal bipartite correlations consistent with relativistic causality (“no superluminal signalling”); maximally nonlocal “superquantum” (or “PR-box”) correlations are also consistent with relativistic causality. I show that – unlike quantum correlations – these correlations do not have a classical limit consistent with relativistic causality. The generalization of this result to all stronger-than-quantum nonlocal correlations is a derivation of Tsirelson's bound – a theorem of quantum mechanics – from the three axioms of relativistic causality, nonlocality, and the existence of a classical limit. But is it reasonable to derive (a part of) quantum mechanics from the unreasonable axiom of nonlocality?! I consider replacing the nonlocality axiom with an equivalent axiom that even Bell and Einstein might have considered reasonable: an axiom of local retrocausality. In 1964, John Bell [1] proved that quantum mechanics is “unreasonable,” as defined by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen [2] in 1935: “No reasonable definition of reality could be expected to permit this.” “This” (i.e., violation of “Einstein separability,” to use a technical term, or “spooky action at a distance,” as Einstein put it) turns out to be endemic to quantum mechanics. For example, pairs of photons measured at spacelike separations may yield nonlocal quantum correlations, i.e., correlations that cannot be traced to any data or “programs” the photons carry with them. As Bell [3] put it 20 years later, “For me, it is so reasonable to assume that the photons in those experiments carry with them programs, which have been correlated in advance, telling them how to behave. This is so rational that I think that when Einstein saw that, and the others refused to see it, he was the rational man. The other people, although history has justified them, were burying their heads in the sand. I feel that Einstein's intellectual superiority over Bohr, in this instance, was enormous; a vast gulf between the man who saw clearly what was needed, and the obscurantist. So for me, it is a pity that Einstein's idea doesn't work. The reasonable thing just doesn't work.”