Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

Nobody Understands Quantum Mechanics

Jeffrey Bub

Published Feb 11, 2016• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

In a quantum world, there are nonlocal correlations with no common cause, where a direct causal influence between the correlated events can be excluded. Moreover, these correlated events are separately intrinsically random. In the contemporary quantum information literature, correlations are studied abstractly in “Boxworld.” A “box” is an imaginary device, with input and output ports on each side, defined by a particular correlation between inputs and outputs, without any specification of an internal mechanism that could produce the correlation. Bananaworld is Boxworld, with bananas and peelings and tastes instead of boxes with inputs and outputs. The idea is to get at what is puzzling about quantum correlations by considering the extent to which Alice and Bob, limited to certain resources, could simulate various correlations in Bananaworld. This introductory chapter introduces these ideas, beginning with a brief exposition of the birth of quantum mechanics in Heisenberg’s 1925 breakthrough paper. The chapter concludes with a self-contained introduction to special relativity.

DOI
10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198718536.003.0001

Related papers

Introduction

Alyssa Ney

The aim of this volume is to develop and evaluate the suggestion that if one adopts the interpretation of quantum mechanics initially proposed by Hugh Everett, today frequently referred to as the “many-worlds interpretation,” then one can avoid the kind of nonlocality that is often thought to be a consequence of quantum entanglement according to other approaches, and thus permit the compatibility of these two pillars of modern physics: quantum mechanics and special relativity. Although this is an idea that seems to have been recognized by Everett and is sometimes touted as a reason to prefer his approach to interpreting quantum mechanics over others, the precise way in which Everett’s interpretation achieves this locality, indeed whether it even does achieve locality, has been debated, including among the interpretation’s proponents. The aim of this introductory chapter is to provide readers with a background of this debate concerning the locality of Everettian quantum mechanics. We begin with a brief historical introduction to Everett’s proposed interpretation of quantum mechanics and its later development into the many-worlds interpretation. The following section discusses how the by now well-established phenomenon of quantum entanglement seems to imply what Albert Einstein, in a 1947 letter to Max Born, called “spooky action at a distance,” and a tension with special relativity. We then discuss why one might think that the many-worlds interpretation allows one to avoid nonlocality in this sense. The next sections bring the reader up to date with how the locality of Everettian quantum mechanics has been debated both by critics and proponents of the interpretation. As we will see, the desire to understand Everettian quantum mechanics as an interpretation that avoids nonlocality has opened up some interesting debates concerning both what it means to say an interpretation of quantum mechanics is local and over the metaphysical and mathematical interpretation of Everettian quantum mechanics itself. This introductory chapter concludes with a summary of the contributions to the present volume in the context of this ongoing debate.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Aug 26, 2026•0 citations

The Quantum World and Its Description

Ana María Cetto, Luis de la Peña

Chapter 1 begins by introducing the quantum world as part of the physical world, not in opposition to or separate from the classical world. It then introduces the basic tools needed to work with quantum mechanics, and describes the scope and purpose of this textbook. It discusses how despite its successes, current quantum mechanics lacks adequate explanations for important observed atomic properties, suggesting an incompleteness of the theory. After a brief overview of its main interpretative issues , the chapter concludes with an introduction of the vacuum or zero-point field as the physical element that restores causality and serves to complete the quantum picture by providing a causal explanation of characteristic quantum phenomena.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 18, 2025•0 citations

Introduction: Nobody Understands Quantum Mechanics

W. M. Stuckey, Michael Silberstein, Timothy J. McDevitt

Abstract Chapter 1 points out that the mystery of entanglement has led Physics Nobel Laureates to claim “nobody understands quantum mechanics.” The Chapter goes on to introduce: the EPR and EPR–Bell paradoxes, various attempts to resolve them, our proposed resolution whereby the relativity principle (no preferred reference frame, NPRF) justifies the Planck postulate (NPRF + h) exactly like the relativity principle justifies the light postulate (NPRF + c), the Planck postulate as a result of Information Invariance & Continuity from quantum information theory, the importance of the relativity principle, subjective versus objective spacetime models of reality, spacelike and timelike relations in spacetime, and four experiments leading to our Poincaré symmetric ontology.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jul 26, 2024•0 citations

Introduction

Konstantin K Likharev

This introductory chapter briefly reviews the major experimental motivations for quantum mechanics, and then discusses its simplest formalism—the Schrödinger’s wave mechanics. Much of this material (perhaps besides the last section) may be found in undergraduate textbooks, so that the discussion is rather brief, and focused on the most important conceptual issues.

Institute of Physics eBooks•May 1, 2019•0 citations

Bananaworld

Jeffrey Bub

This chapter discusses a Bananaworld version of a correlation analyzed by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen in a 1935 argument for the incompleteness of quantum mechanics. This correlation can be simulated by Alice and Bob with a shared random local resource, which is equivalent to showing that the correlation has a common cause explanation. A superquantum correlation proposed by Popescu and Rohrlich can’t be perfectly simulated with local resources, but a quantum simulation with entangled quantum states can do better than the optimal simulation with local resources (up to a quantum limit called the “Tsirelson bound”). So there is no common cause explanation of the correlation of a pair of Popescu–Rohrlich bananas. Since the correlated events can be arbitrarily far apart, there is no direct causal explanation either, because information would have to be transmitted faster than light between the correlated events. This is a version of Bell’s theorem.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Feb 11, 2016•1 citation

Quantum Mechanics

Susan Loepp, William K. Wootters

The early twentieth century was a revolutionary time in the history of physics. People often think of Einstein's special theory of relativity of 1905, which changed our conceptions of time and space. But among physicists, quantum mechanics is usually regarded as an even more radical change in our thinking about the physical world. Quantum mechanics, which was developed between 1900 and 1926, began as a theory of atoms and light but has now become the framework in terms of which all basic physical theories are expected to be cast. We need quantum ideas not only to understand atoms, molecules, and elementary particles, but also to understand the electronic properties of solids and even certain astronomical phenomena such as the stability of white dwarf stars. The theory was radical in part because it introduced probabilistic behavior as a fundamental aspect of the world, but even more because it seems to allow mutually exclusive situations to exist simultaneously in a "quantum superposition." We will see later that the possibility of quantum superposition is largely responsible for a quantum computer's distinctive advantage over an ordinary computer. The present chapter is devoted to introducing the basic principles of quantum mechanics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jul 10, 2006•1 citation
In a quantum world, there are nonlocal correlations with no common cause, where a direct causal influence between the correlated events can be excluded. Moreover, these correlated events are separately intrinsically random. In the contemporary quantum information literature, correlations are studied abstractly in “Boxworld.” A “box” is an imaginary device, with input and output ports on each side, defined by a particular correlation between inputs and outputs, without any specification of an internal mechanism that could produce the correlation. Bananaworld is Boxworld, with bananas and peelings and tastes instead of boxes with inputs and outputs. The idea is to get at what is puzzling about quantum correlations by considering the extent to which Alice and Bob, limited to certain resources, could simulate various correlations in Bananaworld. This introductory chapter introduces these ideas, beginning with a brief exposition of the birth of quantum mechanics in Heisenberg’s 1925 breakthrough paper. The chapter concludes with a self-contained introduction to special relativity.
The aim of this volume is to develop and evaluate the suggestion that if one adopts the interpretation of quantum mechanics initially proposed by Hugh Everett, today frequently referred to as the “many-worlds interpretation,” then one can avoid the kind of nonlocality that is often thought to be a consequence of quantum entanglement according to other approaches, and thus permit the compatibility of these two pillars of modern physics: quantum mechanics and special relativity. Although this is an idea that seems to have been recognized by Everett and is sometimes touted as a reason to prefer his approach to interpreting quantum mechanics over others, the precise way in which Everett’s interpretation achieves this locality, indeed whether it even does achieve locality, has been debated, including among the interpretation’s proponents. The aim of this introductory chapter is to provide readers with a background of this debate concerning the locality of Everettian quantum mechanics. We begin with a brief historical introduction to Everett’s proposed interpretation of quantum mechanics and its later development into the many-worlds interpretation. The following section discusses how the by now well-established phenomenon of quantum entanglement seems to imply what Albert Einstein, in a 1947 letter to Max Born, called “spooky action at a distance,” and a tension with special relativity. We then discuss why one might think that the many-worlds interpretation allows one to avoid nonlocality in this sense. The next sections bring the reader up to date with how the locality of Everettian quantum mechanics has been debated both by critics and proponents of the interpretation. As we will see, the desire to understand Everettian quantum mechanics as an interpretation that avoids nonlocality has opened up some interesting debates concerning both what it means to say an interpretation of quantum mechanics is local and over the metaphysical and mathematical interpretation of Everettian quantum mechanics itself. This introductory chapter concludes with a summary of the contributions to the present volume in the context of this ongoing debate.
Chapter 1 begins by introducing the quantum world as part of the physical world, not in opposition to or separate from the classical world. It then introduces the basic tools needed to work with quantum mechanics, and describes the scope and purpose of this textbook. It discusses how despite its successes, current quantum mechanics lacks adequate explanations for important observed atomic properties, suggesting an incompleteness of the theory. After a brief overview of its main interpretative issues , the chapter concludes with an introduction of the vacuum or zero-point field as the physical element that restores causality and serves to complete the quantum picture by providing a causal explanation of characteristic quantum phenomena.
Abstract Chapter 1 points out that the mystery of entanglement has led Physics Nobel Laureates to claim “nobody understands quantum mechanics.” The Chapter goes on to introduce: the EPR and EPR–Bell paradoxes, various attempts to resolve them, our proposed resolution whereby the relativity principle (no preferred reference frame, NPRF) justifies the Planck postulate (NPRF + h) exactly like the relativity principle justifies the light postulate (NPRF + c), the Planck postulate as a result of Information Invariance & Continuity from quantum information theory, the importance of the relativity principle, subjective versus objective spacetime models of reality, spacelike and timelike relations in spacetime, and four experiments leading to our Poincaré symmetric ontology.
This chapter discusses a Bananaworld version of a correlation analyzed by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen in a 1935 argument for the incompleteness of quantum mechanics. This correlation can be simulated by Alice and Bob with a shared random local resource, which is equivalent to showing that the correlation has a common cause explanation. A superquantum correlation proposed by Popescu and Rohrlich can’t be perfectly simulated with local resources, but a quantum simulation with entangled quantum states can do better than the optimal simulation with local resources (up to a quantum limit called the “Tsirelson bound”). So there is no common cause explanation of the correlation of a pair of Popescu–Rohrlich bananas. Since the correlated events can be arbitrarily far apart, there is no direct causal explanation either, because information would have to be transmitted faster than light between the correlated events. This is a version of Bell’s theorem.
The early twentieth century was a revolutionary time in the history of physics. People often think of Einstein's special theory of relativity of 1905, which changed our conceptions of time and space. But among physicists, quantum mechanics is usually regarded as an even more radical change in our thinking about the physical world. Quantum mechanics, which was developed between 1900 and 1926, began as a theory of atoms and light but has now become the framework in terms of which all basic physical theories are expected to be cast. We need quantum ideas not only to understand atoms, molecules, and elementary particles, but also to understand the electronic properties of solids and even certain astronomical phenomena such as the stability of white dwarf stars. The theory was radical in part because it introduced probabilistic behavior as a fundamental aspect of the world, but even more because it seems to allow mutually exclusive situations to exist simultaneously in a "quantum superposition." We will see later that the possibility of quantum superposition is largely responsible for a quantum computer's distinctive advantage over an ordinary computer. The present chapter is devoted to introducing the basic principles of quantum mechanics.