Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

Thomson Atom

Henry Zatzkis

Published Dec 1, 1958• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The historical development leading up to the Rutherford-Bohr model of the atom is briefly surveyed. The atomic model, suggested by J. J. Thomson before Rutherford's model, is investigated. The quantization shows that the bound states bear a marked resemblance to those of the hydrogen atom. However, the states are in general nondegenerate. Thus, the Thomson atom could not have survived the spectroscopic evidence even if no Rutherford scattering experiments had been performed.

DOI
10.1119/1.1934721

Related papers

Constitution and model. The quantum theory of Bohr and imagining the atom

Giora Hon, Bernard R. Goldstein

The quantum theory of Bohr has roots in the theories of Rutherford and J. J. Thomson on the one hand, and that of Nicholson on the other. We note that Bohr neither presented the theories of Rutherford and Thomson faithfully, nor did he refer to the theory of Nicholson in its own terms. The contrasting attitudes towards these antecedent theories is telling and reveals the philosophical disposition of Bohr. We argue that Bohr intentionally avoided the concept of model as inappropriate for describing his proposed theory. Bohr had no problem in referring to the works of others as 'models', thus separating his theory from previous theories. He was interested in uncovering 'a little piece of reality'.

arXiv:1406.6993•Jun 26, 2014•0 citations

The Hydrogen Atom: The Rutherford Model

Homer B. Tilton

Early this century Ernest Rutherford established the nuclear model of the hydrogen atom, presently taught as representing the best visual model after modification by Niels Bohr and Arnold Sommerfeld. It replaced the so-called “plum pudding” model of J. J. Thomson which held sway previously. While the Rutherford model represented a large step forward in our understanding of the hydrogen atom, questions remained, and still do.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jun 1, 1996•1 citation

Bohr Model of the Atom

R Manjunath

Through his experiments, the physicist Niels Bohr improved upon Rutherford's model of the atom and developed his model of the atomic structure in 1913 that succeeded in explaining the spectral features of the hydrogen atom. A simple means for extending the conventional non-relativistic Bohr model of the atom to include the wave nature of electrons is presented. As the derivation requires basic knowledge of classical and wave mechanics, it can be taught in standard courses in modern physics and introductory quantum mechanics.

•Mar 1, 2021•0 citations

of Bits and Bonds: Hi-Tech Methods Predict the Newest Molecules: Part 2. Quantization

Anne‐Frances Miller

A quick tour through the development of Bohr’s model of the atom concludes with calculation of the allowable (quantized) energies of an electron orbiting in a Hydrogen atom. Electron states, and transitions between states are presented, as are their related spectra.

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Model of Hydrogen and Helium Atoms

HenryS. Souttar

A model which I wish to show you was constructed to illustrate the motion of the electrons around the nucleus of the Rutherford atom, and the changing dimensions and varying plane of their orbit. More violent disturbance produces a series of secondary waves in each orbit, which divide the orbit in the manner suggested by the wave and quantum theories. The model is a very simple one, and my only excuse for bringing it to your notice is the pleasure which it has given to myself, and the fact that it has enabled me to realise as I could not previously do, Rutherford's theory of atomic structure. Rutherford's atom, which at present holds the field, consists essentially of a nucleus around which rotate a number of electrons. This number is the atomic number of the atom, so that with hydrogen there is one circulating electron, with helium there are two, and the number of electrons steadily rises with the atomic number until we reach uranium, which has ninety-two circulating electrons. Each of these electrons rotates independently, and its orbit is subject to very great variation. Indeed the motion of the electron is so complex that it is exceedingly difficult to form any concrete idea of what a variable orbit really means, or what perturbations in the orbit signify. It is with the idea of assisting the imagination that I have constructed this model, consisting of two prisms so placed that a horizontal beam of light is reflected downwards by the first prism on to the second, by which it is again reflected horizontally.

British Journal of Radiology•Feb 1, 1932•0 citations

New Ways of Thinking

Brian L. Silver

Abstract The way that Bohr treated the hydrogen atom was a mixture of concepts taken from classical physics, mixed with Planck’s idea of quantization and Einstein’s concept of photons. The theory did not survive; a far more serious break with classical physics was soon to come.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Feb 26, 1998•0 citations
The historical development leading up to the Rutherford-Bohr model of the atom is briefly surveyed. The atomic model, suggested by J. J. Thomson before Rutherford's model, is investigated. The quantization shows that the bound states bear a marked resemblance to those of the hydrogen atom. However, the states are in general nondegenerate. Thus, the Thomson atom could not have survived the spectroscopic evidence even if no Rutherford scattering experiments had been performed.
The quantum theory of Bohr has roots in the theories of Rutherford and J. J. Thomson on the one hand, and that of Nicholson on the other. We note that Bohr neither presented the theories of Rutherford and Thomson faithfully, nor did he refer to the theory of Nicholson in its own terms. The contrasting attitudes towards these antecedent theories is telling and reveals the philosophical disposition of Bohr. We argue that Bohr intentionally avoided the concept of model as inappropriate for describing his proposed theory. Bohr had no problem in referring to the works of others as 'models', thus separating his theory from previous theories. He was interested in uncovering 'a little piece of reality'.
Through his experiments, the physicist Niels Bohr improved upon Rutherford's model of the atom and developed his model of the atomic structure in 1913 that succeeded in explaining the spectral features of the hydrogen atom. A simple means for extending the conventional non-relativistic Bohr model of the atom to include the wave nature of electrons is presented. As the derivation requires basic knowledge of classical and wave mechanics, it can be taught in standard courses in modern physics and introductory quantum mechanics.
A model which I wish to show you was constructed to illustrate the motion of the electrons around the nucleus of the Rutherford atom, and the changing dimensions and varying plane of their orbit. More violent disturbance produces a series of secondary waves in each orbit, which divide the orbit in the manner suggested by the wave and quantum theories. The model is a very simple one, and my only excuse for bringing it to your notice is the pleasure which it has given to myself, and the fact that it has enabled me to realise as I could not previously do, Rutherford's theory of atomic structure. Rutherford's atom, which at present holds the field, consists essentially of a nucleus around which rotate a number of electrons. This number is the atomic number of the atom, so that with hydrogen there is one circulating electron, with helium there are two, and the number of electrons steadily rises with the atomic number until we reach uranium, which has ninety-two circulating electrons. Each of these electrons rotates independently, and its orbit is subject to very great variation. Indeed the motion of the electron is so complex that it is exceedingly difficult to form any concrete idea of what a variable orbit really means, or what perturbations in the orbit signify. It is with the idea of assisting the imagination that I have constructed this model, consisting of two prisms so placed that a horizontal beam of light is reflected downwards by the first prism on to the second, by which it is again reflected horizontally.