Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks

The Hydrogen Atom: The Rutherford Model

Homer B. Tilton

Published Jun 1, 1996• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

Early this century Ernest Rutherford established the nuclear model of the hydrogen atom, presently taught as representing the best visual model after modification by Niels Bohr and Arnold Sommerfeld. It replaced the so-called “plum pudding” model of J. J. Thomson which held sway previously. While the Rutherford model represented a large step forward in our understanding of the hydrogen atom, questions remained, and still do.

DOI
10.1142/9789812830876_0003

Related papers

Thomson Atom

Henry Zatzkis

The historical development leading up to the Rutherford-Bohr model of the atom is briefly surveyed. The atomic model, suggested by J. J. Thomson before Rutherford's model, is investigated. The quantization shows that the bound states bear a marked resemblance to those of the hydrogen atom. However, the states are in general nondegenerate. Thus, the Thomson atom could not have survived the spectroscopic evidence even if no Rutherford scattering experiments had been performed.

American Journal of Physics•Dec 1, 1958•2 citations

Bohr Model of the Atom

R Manjunath

Through his experiments, the physicist Niels Bohr improved upon Rutherford's model of the atom and developed his model of the atomic structure in 1913 that succeeded in explaining the spectral features of the hydrogen atom. A simple means for extending the conventional non-relativistic Bohr model of the atom to include the wave nature of electrons is presented. As the derivation requires basic knowledge of classical and wave mechanics, it can be taught in standard courses in modern physics and introductory quantum mechanics.

•Mar 1, 2021•0 citations

Niels Bohr — Through Hydrogen Towards the Nature of Matter

Daniel Stewart Robertson

This essay on the work of Niels Bohr as “modeller of hydrogen” outlines the state of knowledge of the atom in the late 19th and early 20th centuries and details the particular background and discoveries which influenced Niels Bohr in developing his concept of the structure of the atom of hydrogen. It shows that although he was not the first to propose a structure of the atom, he was the first to successfully use the experimental and theoretical developments of the day to produce an atomic structure from which results could be obtained in agreement with experiment. Based on the original paper, the development of the structure of the hydrogen atom is discussed and the difficulties encountered detailed. The original paper by Bohr can be seen as one of the works at the beginning of the application of the quantum concept of Max Planck to natural phenomena other than the emission of light. The limitations of the Bohr model which resulted in its gradual replacement with other models of the atomic structure are discussed.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jun 1, 1996•2 citations

Constitution and model. The quantum theory of Bohr and imagining the atom

Giora Hon, Bernard R. Goldstein

The quantum theory of Bohr has roots in the theories of Rutherford and J. J. Thomson on the one hand, and that of Nicholson on the other. We note that Bohr neither presented the theories of Rutherford and Thomson faithfully, nor did he refer to the theory of Nicholson in its own terms. The contrasting attitudes towards these antecedent theories is telling and reveals the philosophical disposition of Bohr. We argue that Bohr intentionally avoided the concept of model as inappropriate for describing his proposed theory. Bohr had no problem in referring to the works of others as 'models', thus separating his theory from previous theories. He was interested in uncovering 'a little piece of reality'.

arXiv:1406.6993•Jun 26, 2014•0 citations

THE BOHR– SOMMERFELD MODEL FOR ENERGY OF ELECTRON IN HYDROGEN ATOM

Motiur Rahman Ansari

This paper discusses Bohr-Somerfield quantization theory and tries to explain how all earlier propositions about energy at atomic level failed to correspond to observed facts and further how this model solved the mathematical discrepancies leading to a near perfect model of energy exchange at the atomic level. The author has attempted here to show the historical connections, logical justifications as well as mathematical expressions for the energy of electron in hydrogen atom and prove how Bohr’s celebrated theory of atomic structure is an application of Planck’s theory of quanta to the Rutherford nuclear atom in an attempt, extraordinary fruitful, to define the nature of the orbits in which the electrons might revolve round the nucleus and to explain the origin of spectral lines of the elements. It further shows how Sommerfeld extended the model so as to include elliptical orbits. The introduction of the elliptic orbits has no new energy for the electron of the hydrogen atom. Bohr had also solved the dilemma arose due to the Rutherford’s atomic model and he admitting the failure of the classical theory, applied with remarkable success of the quantum theory to the Rutherford nuclear atom with revolving electron, which leads us to understand the significance of the Bohr’s atom model.  Keywords: Electromagnetic theory, Model, Electrical attraction, Energy, Atom.

Sustainable Humanosphere•May 19, 2020•1 citation

The Arrival of Bohr’s Atomic Theory

David K. Ferry

The aim of Niels Bohr’s “great” paper was to try to explain how Ernest Rutherford’s planetary model of the atom could exist. Bohr never used the words “quantum jump” in the paper, but it became very much in vogue shortly after this. Max Planck and even A. Einstein had not yet made the full evolution beyond classical physics, and the purely classical atomic views of Rutherford and H. Nagaoka did not provide the explanation of the absorption and emission spectra of hydrogen. In truth, Bohr’s “theory” consisted of a very few equations, with very great assumptions. As de Broglie’s work became known, he was hailed for his advances and he would join the list of Nobel Prizes for advances in quantum theory. Wolfgang Pauli did not particularly like the wave and particle approach that de Broglie introduced with his pilot waves in 1924, and would forcefully express these objections a few years later at the Solvay conference.

•Jan 2, 2019•0 citations
Early this century Ernest Rutherford established the nuclear model of the hydrogen atom, presently taught as representing the best visual model after modification by Niels Bohr and Arnold Sommerfeld. It replaced the so-called “plum pudding” model of J. J. Thomson which held sway previously. While the Rutherford model represented a large step forward in our understanding of the hydrogen atom, questions remained, and still do.
Through his experiments, the physicist Niels Bohr improved upon Rutherford's model of the atom and developed his model of the atomic structure in 1913 that succeeded in explaining the spectral features of the hydrogen atom. A simple means for extending the conventional non-relativistic Bohr model of the atom to include the wave nature of electrons is presented. As the derivation requires basic knowledge of classical and wave mechanics, it can be taught in standard courses in modern physics and introductory quantum mechanics.
This essay on the work of Niels Bohr as “modeller of hydrogen” outlines the state of knowledge of the atom in the late 19th and early 20th centuries and details the particular background and discoveries which influenced Niels Bohr in developing his concept of the structure of the atom of hydrogen. It shows that although he was not the first to propose a structure of the atom, he was the first to successfully use the experimental and theoretical developments of the day to produce an atomic structure from which results could be obtained in agreement with experiment. Based on the original paper, the development of the structure of the hydrogen atom is discussed and the difficulties encountered detailed. The original paper by Bohr can be seen as one of the works at the beginning of the application of the quantum concept of Max Planck to natural phenomena other than the emission of light. The limitations of the Bohr model which resulted in its gradual replacement with other models of the atomic structure are discussed.
The quantum theory of Bohr has roots in the theories of Rutherford and J. J. Thomson on the one hand, and that of Nicholson on the other. We note that Bohr neither presented the theories of Rutherford and Thomson faithfully, nor did he refer to the theory of Nicholson in its own terms. The contrasting attitudes towards these antecedent theories is telling and reveals the philosophical disposition of Bohr. We argue that Bohr intentionally avoided the concept of model as inappropriate for describing his proposed theory. Bohr had no problem in referring to the works of others as 'models', thus separating his theory from previous theories. He was interested in uncovering 'a little piece of reality'.
This paper discusses Bohr-Somerfield quantization theory and tries to explain how all earlier propositions about energy at atomic level failed to correspond to observed facts and further how this model solved the mathematical discrepancies leading to a near perfect model of energy exchange at the atomic level. The author has attempted here to show the historical connections, logical justifications as well as mathematical expressions for the energy of electron in hydrogen atom and prove how Bohr’s celebrated theory of atomic structure is an application of Planck’s theory of quanta to the Rutherford nuclear atom in an attempt, extraordinary fruitful, to define the nature of the orbits in which the electrons might revolve round the nucleus and to explain the origin of spectral lines of the elements. It further shows how Sommerfeld extended the model so as to include elliptical orbits. The introduction of the elliptic orbits has no new energy for the electron of the hydrogen atom. Bohr had also solved the dilemma arose due to the Rutherford’s atomic model and he admitting the failure of the classical theory, applied with remarkable success of the quantum theory to the Rutherford nuclear atom with revolving electron, which leads us to understand the significance of the Bohr’s atom model.  Keywords: Electromagnetic theory, Model, Electrical attraction, Energy, Atom.
The aim of Niels Bohr’s “great” paper was to try to explain how Ernest Rutherford’s planetary model of the atom could exist. Bohr never used the words “quantum jump” in the paper, but it became very much in vogue shortly after this. Max Planck and even A. Einstein had not yet made the full evolution beyond classical physics, and the purely classical atomic views of Rutherford and H. Nagaoka did not provide the explanation of the absorption and emission spectra of hydrogen. In truth, Bohr’s “theory” consisted of a very few equations, with very great assumptions. As de Broglie’s work became known, he was hailed for his advances and he would join the list of Nobel Prizes for advances in quantum theory. Wolfgang Pauli did not particularly like the wave and particle approach that de Broglie introduced with his pilot waves in 1924, and would forcefully express these objections a few years later at the Solvay conference.