Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1406.6993

Constitution and model. The quantum theory of Bohr and imagining the atom

Giora Hon, Bernard R. Goldstein

Published Jun 26, 2014• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The quantum theory of Bohr has roots in the theories of Rutherford and J. J. Thomson on the one hand, and that of Nicholson on the other. We note that Bohr neither presented the theories of Rutherford and Thomson faithfully, nor did he refer to the theory of Nicholson in its own terms. The contrasting attitudes towards these antecedent theories is telling and reveals the philosophical disposition of Bohr. We argue that Bohr intentionally avoided the concept of model as inappropriate for describing his proposed theory. Bohr had no problem in referring to the works of others as 'models', thus separating his theory from previous theories. He was interested in uncovering 'a little piece of reality'.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1406.6993

Related papers

Thomson Atom

Henry Zatzkis

The historical development leading up to the Rutherford-Bohr model of the atom is briefly surveyed. The atomic model, suggested by J. J. Thomson before Rutherford's model, is investigated. The quantization shows that the bound states bear a marked resemblance to those of the hydrogen atom. However, the states are in general nondegenerate. Thus, the Thomson atom could not have survived the spectroscopic evidence even if no Rutherford scattering experiments had been performed.

American Journal of Physics•Dec 1, 1958•2 citations

Niels Bohr and the dawn of quantum theory

P. Weinberger

Bohr’s atomic model, one of the very few pieces of physics known to the general public, turned a hundred in 2013: a very good reason to revisit Bohr’s original publications in the Philosophical Magazine, in which he introduced this model. It is indeed rewarding to (re-)discover what ideas and concepts stood behind it, to see not only ‘orbits’, but also ‘rings’ and ‘flat ellipses’ as electron trajectories at work, and, in particular, to admire Bohr’s strong belief in the importance of Planck’s law.

The Philosophical Magazine A Journal of Theoretical Experimental and Applied Physics•Aug 28, 2014•18 citations

The Quantum of Action and Atomic Models

Mituo Taketani, Masayuki Nagasaki

Einstein consider that in a new electromagnetic theory that would settle the problem of the self-energy of electron, the Planck constant h would be given in terms of the elementary electric charge and light velocity. In contrast to this, Haas supposed that h could be deduced from the atomic radius assumed in the Thomson model of the atom and the charge and mass of electron. In connection with this, it should be greatly appreciated concerning in the history of the formation of quantum mechanics that Sommerfeld gave the view that the existence of the molecule is the function and result of the existence of h. It should never be forgotten also that, different from Ritz who tried to explain the combination rule of spectral lines with special mathematical models, Nicholson followed Sommerfeld's view to discuss the spectra of coronae of the sun on the basis of an atomic model of the Nagaoka type with several electrons, in which no assumption is made of the atomic radius, and came to point out the existence of the quantum nature of angular momentum due to h, together with an estimation of the atomic radius. Bohr, who determined the number of electrons in the hydrogen atom from his analysis of the energy loss of α-rays through hydrogen gas, and thus understood that the problem of the stability of atoms could not be solved with the classical mechanics, presented the Bohr model of the atom, in which the existence of atomic discrete energy levels results from the quantum nature of angular momentum, and the combination rule of spectral lines is grasped with the frequency relation.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Nov 1, 2001•0 citations

The Hydrogen Atom: The Rutherford Model

Homer B. Tilton

Early this century Ernest Rutherford established the nuclear model of the hydrogen atom, presently taught as representing the best visual model after modification by Niels Bohr and Arnold Sommerfeld. It replaced the so-called “plum pudding” model of J. J. Thomson which held sway previously. While the Rutherford model represented a large step forward in our understanding of the hydrogen atom, questions remained, and still do.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jun 1, 1996•1 citation

Bohr's philosophy of physics

Dugald R. Murdoch

Now that Bohr's philosophy of quantum physics has been surveyed in detail, it is time to provide a general description of his philosophy that illuminates the details. The question which I wish to address, then is: what is the general philosophy, or philosophical point of view, that underlies Bohr's philosophy of physics? Can his philosophy be neatly categorised in terms of any well known philosophical position? Apropos his philosophy of physics in particular, the question of primary interest is: to what extent, if any, is Bohr's philosophy of physics realist? No simple answer to this question can be given: indeed, certain realist and non-realist components are subtly interwoven in his philosophy, and to unravel them we shall need a fairly refined conception of what constitutes a realist interpretation of physics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 5, 1987•19 citations

A bolt from the blue

Jim Baggott

Abstract The confrontation between Einstein and Bohr over the interpretation of quantum theory has been painted in the past as a direct conflict between realism and positivism. However, more recent attempts to uncover the philosophical positions of both Einstein and Bohr have revealed that these were not so black and white. Einstein’s realism was conditioned by the strong empiricist influence in his own early experiences as a theorist and the growing wariness that led him eventually to reject Machian positivism. His was a realism born of a sense of necessity: a belief that a realist stance is the only one that leads to productive theorizing about the physical world. Bohr’s philosophy went through some quite marked changes, principally in response to Einstein’s challenges. The father of modem atomic theory could hardly subscribe to an uncompromising positivist position that rejected the reality of atoms. But the reality of the inner workings of those atoms was, Bohr contended, beyond the reach of a knowledge founded on complementary classical concepts of waves and particles. As Einstein’s challenges became deeper and more subtle, so Bohr’s position shifted to that of a distinctive anti-realism. Add to this a rhetoric in Bohr’s speeches and published writings that insisted on the logical inevitability of the Copenhagen interpretation, that insisted on its status as the only feasible interpretation, and that countenanced no other alternative, and you have dogma in the making. Heisenberg called it ‘Kopen hagener Geist der Quantentheorie’, the Copenhagen spirit of quantum theory which, he declared in 1930, ‘has directed the entire development of modem atomic physics’. Einstein frequently referred to the Copenhagen doctrine as ‘Talmudic’.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Nov 6, 2003•0 citations
The quantum theory of Bohr has roots in the theories of Rutherford and J. J. Thomson on the one hand, and that of Nicholson on the other. We note that Bohr neither presented the theories of Rutherford and Thomson faithfully, nor did he refer to the theory of Nicholson in its own terms. The contrasting attitudes towards these antecedent theories is telling and reveals the philosophical disposition of Bohr. We argue that Bohr intentionally avoided the concept of model as inappropriate for describing his proposed theory. Bohr had no problem in referring to the works of others as 'models', thus separating his theory from previous theories. He was interested in uncovering 'a little piece of reality'.
Bohr’s atomic model, one of the very few pieces of physics known to the general public, turned a hundred in 2013: a very good reason to revisit Bohr’s original publications in the Philosophical Magazine, in which he introduced this model. It is indeed rewarding to (re-)discover what ideas and concepts stood behind it, to see not only ‘orbits’, but also ‘rings’ and ‘flat ellipses’ as electron trajectories at work, and, in particular, to admire Bohr’s strong belief in the importance of Planck’s law.
Einstein consider that in a new electromagnetic theory that would settle the problem of the self-energy of electron, the Planck constant h would be given in terms of the elementary electric charge and light velocity. In contrast to this, Haas supposed that h could be deduced from the atomic radius assumed in the Thomson model of the atom and the charge and mass of electron. In connection with this, it should be greatly appreciated concerning in the history of the formation of quantum mechanics that Sommerfeld gave the view that the existence of the molecule is the function and result of the existence of h. It should never be forgotten also that, different from Ritz who tried to explain the combination rule of spectral lines with special mathematical models, Nicholson followed Sommerfeld's view to discuss the spectra of coronae of the sun on the basis of an atomic model of the Nagaoka type with several electrons, in which no assumption is made of the atomic radius, and came to point out the existence of the quantum nature of angular momentum due to h, together with an estimation of the atomic radius. Bohr, who determined the number of electrons in the hydrogen atom from his analysis of the energy loss of α-rays through hydrogen gas, and thus understood that the problem of the stability of atoms could not be solved with the classical mechanics, presented the Bohr model of the atom, in which the existence of atomic discrete energy levels results from the quantum nature of angular momentum, and the combination rule of spectral lines is grasped with the frequency relation.
Now that Bohr's philosophy of quantum physics has been surveyed in detail, it is time to provide a general description of his philosophy that illuminates the details. The question which I wish to address, then is: what is the general philosophy, or philosophical point of view, that underlies Bohr's philosophy of physics? Can his philosophy be neatly categorised in terms of any well known philosophical position? Apropos his philosophy of physics in particular, the question of primary interest is: to what extent, if any, is Bohr's philosophy of physics realist? No simple answer to this question can be given: indeed, certain realist and non-realist components are subtly interwoven in his philosophy, and to unravel them we shall need a fairly refined conception of what constitutes a realist interpretation of physics.
Abstract The confrontation between Einstein and Bohr over the interpretation of quantum theory has been painted in the past as a direct conflict between realism and positivism. However, more recent attempts to uncover the philosophical positions of both Einstein and Bohr have revealed that these were not so black and white. Einstein’s realism was conditioned by the strong empiricist influence in his own early experiences as a theorist and the growing wariness that led him eventually to reject Machian positivism. His was a realism born of a sense of necessity: a belief that a realist stance is the only one that leads to productive theorizing about the physical world. Bohr’s philosophy went through some quite marked changes, principally in response to Einstein’s challenges. The father of modem atomic theory could hardly subscribe to an uncompromising positivist position that rejected the reality of atoms. But the reality of the inner workings of those atoms was, Bohr contended, beyond the reach of a knowledge founded on complementary classical concepts of waves and particles. As Einstein’s challenges became deeper and more subtle, so Bohr’s position shifted to that of a distinctive anti-realism. Add to this a rhetoric in Bohr’s speeches and published writings that insisted on the logical inevitability of the Copenhagen interpretation, that insisted on its status as the only feasible interpretation, and that countenanced no other alternative, and you have dogma in the making. Heisenberg called it ‘Kopen hagener Geist der Quantentheorie’, the Copenhagen spirit of quantum theory which, he declared in 1930, ‘has directed the entire development of modem atomic physics’. Einstein frequently referred to the Copenhagen doctrine as ‘Talmudic’.