Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Routledge eBooks

Quantum Theory

Michael L. G. Redhead

Published Sep 30, 2020• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

The history of the quantum theory has received rather uneven treatment from professional historians of science. There has been a great deal of emphasis on the early period from 1900 to 1926, during which time the classic formulations of the so-called old and new quantum theories were laid down. But there have been many important subsequent improvements in the underlying theory, its applications and interpretation. The present article attempts a more balanced perspective on the whole theory from the initial inception to its ongoing development. The subject is necessarily a technical and mathematical one, and no account, worthy of any pretensions to accuracy, can avoid reference to some technical matters. An attempt has been made to keep these to a minimum, but it is not entirely possible to eliminate them. This probably helps to explain why the more recent history has largely been dealt with by practising physicists, rather than by historians.

DOI
10.4324/9781003070818-35

Related papers

Quantum Physics: Illusion or Reality?

Alastair I. M. Rae

Quantum physics is believed to be the fundamental theory underlying our understanding of the physical universe. However, it is based on concepts and principles that have always been difficult to understand and controversial in their interpretation. This book aims to explain these issues using a minimum of technical language and mathematics. After a brief introduction to the ideas of quantum physics, the problems of interpretation are identified and explained. The rest of the book surveys, describes and criticises a range of suggestions that have been made with the aim of resolving these problems; these include the traditional, or 'Copenhagen' interpretation, the possible role of the conscious mind in measurement and the postulate of parallel universes. This new edition has been revised throughout to take into account developments in this field over the past fifteen years, including the idea of 'consistent histories' to which a completely new chapter is devoted.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Mar 26, 2012•3 citations

Quantum Physics: Illusion or Reality?

Alastair I. M. Rae

Quantum physics is believed to be the fundamental theory underlying our understanding of the physical universe. However, it is based on concepts and principles that have always been difficult to understand and controversial in their interpretation. This book aims to explain these issues using a minimum of technical language and mathematics. After a brief introduction to the ideas of quantum physics, the problems of interpretation are identified and explained. The rest of the book surveys, describes and criticises a range of suggestions that have been made with the aim of resolving these problems; these include the traditional, or 'Copenhagen' interpretation, the possible role of the conscious mind in measurement, and the postulate of parallel universes. This new edition has been revised throughout to take into account developments in this field over the past fifteen years, including the idea of 'consistent histories' to which a completely new chapter is devoted.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Oct 7, 2004•18 citations

Genealogy

Jonathan Allday

Quantum theory was not the work of one person. During a period from ca. 1900 to 1927, a collection of highly talented minds worked toward a communal understanding of the new theory and experimental results. ere were many wrong turns and not everyone who made decisive contributions fully agreed with the end result. Figure 14.1 attempts to summarize the chain of in uences in terms of ideas leading to the end products, at least as far as 1927 is concerned. Not everyone is represented here (Wolfgang Pauli, made several important contributions). I have focussed on people whose ideas will be helpful to us in understanding the nature of quantum theory. Inevitably, not everyone will agree with my choice. Figure 14.1 is only an outline at best, and the number of arrows connecting a person to the rest of the group is not an entirely fair representation of how in uential they were, as it takes no account of the importance of the ideas involved. However, as we work our way through this outline history, you might nd it useful to refer back to the gure from time to time to check your bearings.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 3, 2009•0 citations

〈Articles〉The History of Quantum Theory -from the Bohr's Hydrogen Model to the Old Quantum Theory

Akira Morikawa

[概要]本論では,ボーアの水素原子モデルがどのようにして前期量子論へと結実していったのかを見る。ボーアの理論は,ゾンマーフェルトによる量子条件のさらなる一般化とアインシュタインによる遷移確率の理論の定式化を促した。さらにまた,これらの一般化がボーアの対応原理の定式化を準備することとなる。しかしながら,かかる理論の進展にもかかわらず,量子の過程において何が生じているのかは依然として謎なのであった。本論は,この知識の欠如がやがて哲学的問いを誘発することについても若干の考察を施すものである。 [Abstract] We will see the theoretical development of Bohr’s new theory about the hydrogen atom in this paper. This theory shows a new perspective on the so-called old quantum theory. His theory was a trigger for the Sommerfeld theory and the Einstein theory of transition probability. Additionally, we will see how the Bohr’s correspondence principle was formulated. These theoretical developments will help to create a quantum theory in near future. However, in spite of these developments related to the theory, nobody knows about the real quantum process. This lack of knowledge leads us to the philosophical questions about quantum. This paper implies these points in order to prompt some discussion regarding our future research, plan into the history of quantum theory.

•Jul 31, 2017•0 citations

The Tiger and the Shark: Empirical Roots of Wave-Particle Dualism

Bruce R. Wheaton, Thomas Kühn

The early twentieth century brought about the rejection by physicists of the doctrine of determinism - the belief that complete knowledge of the initial conditions of an interaction in nature allows precise and unambiguous prediction of the outcome. This book traces the origins of a central problem leading to this change in viewpoint and paradoxes raised by attempts to formulate a consistent theory of the nature of light. It outlines the different approaches adopted by members of different national cultures to the apparent inconsistencies, explains why Einstein's early (1905) attempt at a resolution was not taken seriously for fifteen years, and describes the mixture of ideas that created a route to a new, antideterministic formulation of the laws of nature. Dr Wheaton describes the experimental work on the new forms of radiation found at the turn of the century and shows how the interpretation of energy transfer from X-rays to matter gradually transformed a classical wave explanation of light to one based on particle like quanta of energy, and further, he explains how influential scientists came reluctantly to accept a wavelike interpretation of matter as well. This new and distinctively different account of one of the major theoretical shifts in modern physical thought will be of fundamental interest to physical scientists and philosophers, as well as to historians of science.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 30, 1983•83 citations

Conclusions

Jonathan Allday

Now that we have reached the end of our brief tour through the early history of quantum theory, we need to stop and consider some important themes. From a historical point of view, a distinction can be drawn between ‘old quantum theory’ and the full quantum theory that we now use. Old quantum theory was in essence a patchwork cobbled together from classical physics with a few quantum ideas thrown in. e works of Planck, Einstein, Bohr, and Sommerfeld can be classed as old quantum theory. is is not meant to undermine the tremendous achievements that old quantum theory represents, but simply to underline its standing as a stage on the way to a fully formed quantum theory, which slowly emerged from the works of Heisenberg, Schrödinger, Born, and Dirac.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 3, 2009•0 citations
The history of the quantum theory has received rather uneven treatment from professional historians of science. There has been a great deal of emphasis on the early period from 1900 to 1926, during which time the classic formulations of the so-called old and new quantum theories were laid down. But there have been many important subsequent improvements in the underlying theory, its applications and interpretation. The present article attempts a more balanced perspective on the whole theory from the initial inception to its ongoing development. The subject is necessarily a technical and mathematical one, and no account, worthy of any pretensions to accuracy, can avoid reference to some technical matters. An attempt has been made to keep these to a minimum, but it is not entirely possible to eliminate them. This probably helps to explain why the more recent history has largely been dealt with by practising physicists, rather than by historians.
Quantum physics is believed to be the fundamental theory underlying our understanding of the physical universe. However, it is based on concepts and principles that have always been difficult to understand and controversial in their interpretation. This book aims to explain these issues using a minimum of technical language and mathematics. After a brief introduction to the ideas of quantum physics, the problems of interpretation are identified and explained. The rest of the book surveys, describes and criticises a range of suggestions that have been made with the aim of resolving these problems; these include the traditional, or 'Copenhagen' interpretation, the possible role of the conscious mind in measurement and the postulate of parallel universes. This new edition has been revised throughout to take into account developments in this field over the past fifteen years, including the idea of 'consistent histories' to which a completely new chapter is devoted.
Quantum physics is believed to be the fundamental theory underlying our understanding of the physical universe. However, it is based on concepts and principles that have always been difficult to understand and controversial in their interpretation. This book aims to explain these issues using a minimum of technical language and mathematics. After a brief introduction to the ideas of quantum physics, the problems of interpretation are identified and explained. The rest of the book surveys, describes and criticises a range of suggestions that have been made with the aim of resolving these problems; these include the traditional, or 'Copenhagen' interpretation, the possible role of the conscious mind in measurement, and the postulate of parallel universes. This new edition has been revised throughout to take into account developments in this field over the past fifteen years, including the idea of 'consistent histories' to which a completely new chapter is devoted.
Quantum theory was not the work of one person. During a period from ca. 1900 to 1927, a collection of highly talented minds worked toward a communal understanding of the new theory and experimental results. ere were many wrong turns and not everyone who made decisive contributions fully agreed with the end result. Figure 14.1 attempts to summarize the chain of in uences in terms of ideas leading to the end products, at least as far as 1927 is concerned. Not everyone is represented here (Wolfgang Pauli, made several important contributions). I have focussed on people whose ideas will be helpful to us in understanding the nature of quantum theory. Inevitably, not everyone will agree with my choice. Figure 14.1 is only an outline at best, and the number of arrows connecting a person to the rest of the group is not an entirely fair representation of how in uential they were, as it takes no account of the importance of the ideas involved. However, as we work our way through this outline history, you might nd it useful to refer back to the gure from time to time to check your bearings.
[概要]本論では,ボーアの水素原子モデルがどのようにして前期量子論へと結実していったのかを見る。ボーアの理論は,ゾンマーフェルトによる量子条件のさらなる一般化とアインシュタインによる遷移確率の理論の定式化を促した。さらにまた,これらの一般化がボーアの対応原理の定式化を準備することとなる。しかしながら,かかる理論の進展にもかかわらず,量子の過程において何が生じているのかは依然として謎なのであった。本論は,この知識の欠如がやがて哲学的問いを誘発することについても若干の考察を施すものである。 [Abstract] We will see the theoretical development of Bohr’s new theory about the hydrogen atom in this paper. This theory shows a new perspective on the so-called old quantum theory. His theory was a trigger for the Sommerfeld theory and the Einstein theory of transition probability. Additionally, we will see how the Bohr’s correspondence principle was formulated. These theoretical developments will help to create a quantum theory in near future. However, in spite of these developments related to the theory, nobody knows about the real quantum process. This lack of knowledge leads us to the philosophical questions about quantum. This paper implies these points in order to prompt some discussion regarding our future research, plan into the history of quantum theory.
The early twentieth century brought about the rejection by physicists of the doctrine of determinism - the belief that complete knowledge of the initial conditions of an interaction in nature allows precise and unambiguous prediction of the outcome. This book traces the origins of a central problem leading to this change in viewpoint and paradoxes raised by attempts to formulate a consistent theory of the nature of light. It outlines the different approaches adopted by members of different national cultures to the apparent inconsistencies, explains why Einstein's early (1905) attempt at a resolution was not taken seriously for fifteen years, and describes the mixture of ideas that created a route to a new, antideterministic formulation of the laws of nature. Dr Wheaton describes the experimental work on the new forms of radiation found at the turn of the century and shows how the interpretation of energy transfer from X-rays to matter gradually transformed a classical wave explanation of light to one based on particle like quanta of energy, and further, he explains how influential scientists came reluctantly to accept a wavelike interpretation of matter as well. This new and distinctively different account of one of the major theoretical shifts in modern physical thought will be of fundamental interest to physical scientists and philosophers, as well as to historians of science.
Now that we have reached the end of our brief tour through the early history of quantum theory, we need to stop and consider some important themes. From a historical point of view, a distinction can be drawn between ‘old quantum theory’ and the full quantum theory that we now use. Old quantum theory was in essence a patchwork cobbled together from classical physics with a few quantum ideas thrown in. e works of Planck, Einstein, Bohr, and Sommerfeld can be classed as old quantum theory. is is not meant to undermine the tremendous achievements that old quantum theory represents, but simply to underline its standing as a stage on the way to a fully formed quantum theory, which slowly emerged from the works of Heisenberg, Schrödinger, Born, and Dirac.