Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

CRC Press eBooks

Genealogy

Jonathan Allday

Published Mar 3, 2009• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quantum theory was not the work of one person. During a period from ca. 1900 to 1927, a collection of highly talented minds worked toward a communal understanding of the new theory and experimental results. ere were many wrong turns and not everyone who made decisive contributions fully agreed with the end result. Figure 14.1 attempts to summarize the chain of in uences in terms of ideas leading to the end products, at least as far as 1927 is concerned. Not everyone is represented here (Wolfgang Pauli, made several important contributions). I have focussed on people whose ideas will be helpful to us in understanding the nature of quantum theory. Inevitably, not everyone will agree with my choice. Figure 14.1 is only an outline at best, and the number of arrows connecting a person to the rest of the group is not an entirely fair representation of how in uential they were, as it takes no account of the importance of the ideas involved. However, as we work our way through this outline history, you might nd it useful to refer back to the gure from time to time to check your bearings.

DOI
10.1201/9781584887041-23

Related papers

Short History of the Development of Quantum Theory

Reinhold Fürth

Elsevier eBooks•Jan 1, 1970•0 citations

A new fixed point for Mottness

Jinchao Zhao

Understanding electronic behavior in solids remains a central challenge in condensed matter physics.Historically, Landau's Fermi liquid theory, BCS superconductor theory, and Bloch's electron band theory have provided robust frameworks for describing electronic states in conventional metals, superconductors, insulators, and semiconductors.However, these frameworks fail to fully account for the physics observed in strongly correlated electron systems, notably Mott insulators and their doped counterparts, which exhibit unconventional superconductivity and novel topological phases.This thesis reflects not only my own efforts and ideas but also the invaluable guidance, collaboration, and support of many people.My journey in Champaign-Urbana began in 2019, just before the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic.The first class I attended at the University of Illinois was PHYS 561: Condensed Matter Physics II, taught by Dr. Philip Phillips.It remains the most inspiring course I have ever taken.I was fortunate that Philip responded to my initial inquiry right away.Looking back, choosing to work with him was one of the smartest decisions I made.Throughout my time at UIUC, Philip provided not only deep physical insights but also clear physical intuition.Working with him was a unique and rewarding experience.We often walked into each other's offices like colleagues and friends, discussing ideas freely.These interactions have definitely shaped my intellectual approach and working style.The mathematical depth of our research was greatly enriched by Dr. Gabriele La Nave, whose breadth of knowledge initially overwhelmed me.Yet over time, I was able to keep up, and we developed into a productive and balanced team.I also want to express my sincere appreciation to Dr. Barry Bradlyn for the countless discussions-via Zoom or phone-whenever Philip and I found ourselves puzzled.Barry was often the final word that helped us move forward.It wasn't until I was planning my graduation that I fully appreciated the privilege of being part of such an intellectually vibrant community.The nearly daily seminars and colloquia-featuring both experimentalists and theorists-broadened my mind in ways I hadn't anticipated.I am especially grateful to the organizers and speakers who made these events possible.The life as a PhD student during and after the pandemic was also enlightened by the v wonderful people in the Engineering Sciences Building.Whenever I encountered a difficult problem, it was always a good idea to take a walk through the building.More often than not, I would stumble upon someone willing to talk, offering a fresh perspective that led to real progress.I would like to thank Edwin Huang, Peizhi Mai, Penghao Zhu, Jacopo Gliozzi, Kevin Kleiner, Xuchen Cao,

•Jul 13, 2025•0 citations

The Origin and Development of the Quantum Theory

Max Planck

•Jan 1, 1922•18 citations

Introduction

James Robert Brown

Feynman diagrams have fascinated physicists and philosophers since they were introduced to the world about 70 years ago. Clearly, they help in calculation; they have allowed nearly impossible problems to be solved with relative ease. This is agreed by all, but that is probably where the consensus ends. Are they pictures of physical processes? Are they just devices for keeping track of mathematical formulae, that do the real work? Are they some sort of mix of both?They are almost as famous as representations of the Bohr atom, even though most people could not give even a sketchy account of what they do. In spite of this they have taken on a role as a cultural icon. Feynman used them to decorate his own van (Fig. 1). The van was even used in an episode of the popular TV series The Big Bang Theory. They have been used as art work in everything from posters, to coffee mugs, to wallpaper. But none of this is particularly helpful in understanding how they work.If we ask working physicists who use Feynman diagrams what it is they are doing, we get a variety of responses. One is puzzlement; a shrug of indifference. Even those very skilled at using Feynman diagrams might be hard pressed to explain (to a philosopher’s satisfaction) what’s happening. After all, most of us can ride a bike but would be similarly hard pressed to explain in any detail what we’re doing. A more common response might go like this: The diagram, or series of diagrams, is a schematic picture of some physical process, say, two electrons interacting, which we then link to mathematical terms. After writing out the mathematical terms in the form of a series, we calculate and get the probability of an interaction happening. This sounds good initially, but runs into trouble when we ask what a “picture of a physical process” could mean? This is, after all, the quantum world where things do not move continuously through space and time. It seems doubtful the diagrams could be diagrams of things in the physical realm. They are connected to physical reality and they are connected to wonderfully accurate predictions. And yet, mystery remains.The following articles on Feynman diagrams address several timely issues, both historical and contemporary. These are metaphysical and epistemological questions related to models and how we represent the world. The papers are united by these themes, but otherwise are independent of one another. They are arranged alphabetically and can be read in any order.James Robert Brown, “How Do Feynman Diagrams Work?” takes the view that they are not representations or models of the world at all. Like others, he stresses that they cannot be pictures of reality, since, thanks to the Heisenberg relations, there can be no such thing as a trajectory. Rather than seek some other more abstract type of representation, he introduces a distinction between descriptive and prescriptive flow charts. The latter could be a representation of physical reality, but not the former. A prescriptive flow chart is more like a recipe to bake a cake. He takes Feynman diagrams to be this sort of thing.Mauro Dorato and Emanuele Rossanese, “The Nature of Representation in Feynman Diagrams,” also reject the idea that Feynman diagrams can be considered to be pictures or depictions of actual physical processes. But unlike Brown, they do not abandon the thought that they can be models in some sense. They appeal to a famous account by RIG Hughes, known as the Denotation, Deduction, and Interpretation theory of models, where “models” are to be interpreted as merely inferential, non-representational devices constructed in given social contexts by the community of physicists.Letitia Meynell, “Picturing Feynman Diagrams and the Epistemology of Understanding,” assumes that Feynman diagrams are pictorial representations but agrees with Brown and Dorato and Rossanese that they do not represent actual physical processes. She then takes up the following puzzle: If Feynman diagrams represent states of affairs, but do not do so truthfully, what can their epistemic value be? She argues that Feynman diagrams have been epistemically powerful (at least in part) because, as pictorial representations, they facilitate an understanding of QED, and particle physics more generally. Appealing to Feynman’s own remarks, she draws out what it might mean to have an understanding of something that is not factive. Although her approach allows for a thin sense of substantively non-factive epistemic success, it is continuous with a factive sense of understanding that is more familiar in the sciences.Michael Stöltzner, “Feynman Diagrams: Modeling between Physics and Mathematics,” analyzes Feynman diagrams within the context of recent debates about models in science and against the backdrop of other diagrammatic methods in mathematical physics when dealing with infinite or asymptotic series. This allows one to avoid the dichotomy of whether Feynman diagrams represent mathematical or physical objects, or a mere tool mediating between them. Along those lines one does not, however, obtain a universal answer to the question as to what Feynman diagrams represent. A single Feynman diagram, in actual scientific practice, can stand for a single mathematical expression or for a physical phenomenon depending on whether the diagram stands for a single term in an infinite series or for a subseries that is given a physical interpretation. Stöltzner’s reading of the representation problem also derives support from the historical fact that Feynman was initially motivated by the Breit-Schrödinger model of a quivering electron and from interpreting this model within the context of stochastic processes.Adrian Wüthrich, “The Exigencies of War and the Stink of a Theoretical Problem,” approaches these topics from an historian’s point of view, shedding light on the issues by focussing on debates in this historical context. As he put it in his subtitle, Wüthrich’s aim is to understand the genesis of Feynman’s electrodynamics as mechanistic modelling at different levels. Feynman’s idiosyncratic method of dealing with quantum electrodynamic phenomena has been cast as an instance of a non-rigorous, modular and rule-based style of theorizing. Given such a characterization, it seems natural that significant changes in Feynman’s style were triggered by work he was assigned during World War II, where quick fixes may have counted more than derivations from first principles. Indeed, Feynman’s theoretical proposals of an improved electrodynamics do bear traces of Feynman’s war-related work, which immediately preceded it. However, Wüthrich explains, the attempt to apply the vocabulary of the “new mechanistic philosophy” to lesser known pieces of archival evidence brings to the fore a new kind of shift in Feynman’s style. Feynman’s disposition for such a shift may also have been fostered during the war, but it was forced upon him by a specific theoretical difficulty, which was largely unrelated to his war-time research.These articles contain some technicalities, but they should all be sufficiently accessible to general readers who would like to know more about Feynman diagrams and how they relate to theories, models, mathematics, and the world. The best philosophy of science is intimately linked to and draws upon current science and its history. It pays close attention to details: the details of theorizing, the details of models and how they function, the details of experimentation and measurement, and so on. We hope this collection of five articles on Feynman diagrams, by focussing closely on detail, will contribute to a better understanding of these strange but highly productive ciphers and symbols.

Perspectives on Science•Jul 31, 2018•1 citation

History of Quantum Theory

Ilya Prigogine

Science•Aug 12, 1983•4 citations

What are the future prospects for quantum cognition and decision?

Jerome R. Busemeyer, Peter Bruza

Quantum theory has inspired many new ideas for understanding Cognition and decision making. Given the nascent state of this field, many new challenges still remain. What are the strengths and unique contributions of these ideas? What are likely next steps in its development? How can it be applied to practical problems in cognitive science? Is this a rational or an irrational system of reasoning? What, if any, are its connections to neuroscience? Should the hard problem of consciousness be considered? These are questions that we try to address in this chapter, albeit at times in a limited way. We end with a debate with a fictitious skeptic (actually previous reviewers) of these ideas. Let us start by reviewing what we have covered so far. Contributions to cognition and decision We begin by summarizing the conclusions reached in previous chapters regarding the usefulness of quantum theory for modelling phenomena in cognition and decision. Chapter 1 provided some motivation and Chapter 2 provided a theoretical introduction to quantum theory. Chapter 3 presented a quantum model to account for question order effects on survey research. An exact and parameter-free test was derived from the model, which produced surprisingly accurate predictions for results obtained from three different large Gallup poll survey studies. Chapter 4 described a quantum model of probability judgments to account for findings that produce violations of classic probability theory, including conjunction and disjunction fallacies and order effects on inference.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jul 26, 2012•0 citations
Quantum theory was not the work of one person. During a period from ca. 1900 to 1927, a collection of highly talented minds worked toward a communal understanding of the new theory and experimental results. ere were many wrong turns and not everyone who made decisive contributions fully agreed with the end result. Figure 14.1 attempts to summarize the chain of in uences in terms of ideas leading to the end products, at least as far as 1927 is concerned. Not everyone is represented here (Wolfgang Pauli, made several important contributions). I have focussed on people whose ideas will be helpful to us in understanding the nature of quantum theory. Inevitably, not everyone will agree with my choice. Figure 14.1 is only an outline at best, and the number of arrows connecting a person to the rest of the group is not an entirely fair representation of how in uential they were, as it takes no account of the importance of the ideas involved. However, as we work our way through this outline history, you might nd it useful to refer back to the gure from time to time to check your bearings.
Understanding electronic behavior in solids remains a central challenge in condensed matter physics.Historically, Landau's Fermi liquid theory, BCS superconductor theory, and Bloch's electron band theory have provided robust frameworks for describing electronic states in conventional metals, superconductors, insulators, and semiconductors.However, these frameworks fail to fully account for the physics observed in strongly correlated electron systems, notably Mott insulators and their doped counterparts, which exhibit unconventional superconductivity and novel topological phases.This thesis reflects not only my own efforts and ideas but also the invaluable guidance, collaboration, and support of many people.My journey in Champaign-Urbana began in 2019, just before the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic.The first class I attended at the University of Illinois was PHYS 561: Condensed Matter Physics II, taught by Dr. Philip Phillips.It remains the most inspiring course I have ever taken.I was fortunate that Philip responded to my initial inquiry right away.Looking back, choosing to work with him was one of the smartest decisions I made.Throughout my time at UIUC, Philip provided not only deep physical insights but also clear physical intuition.Working with him was a unique and rewarding experience.We often walked into each other's offices like colleagues and friends, discussing ideas freely.These interactions have definitely shaped my intellectual approach and working style.The mathematical depth of our research was greatly enriched by Dr. Gabriele La Nave, whose breadth of knowledge initially overwhelmed me.Yet over time, I was able to keep up, and we developed into a productive and balanced team.I also want to express my sincere appreciation to Dr. Barry Bradlyn for the countless discussions-via Zoom or phone-whenever Philip and I found ourselves puzzled.Barry was often the final word that helped us move forward.It wasn't until I was planning my graduation that I fully appreciated the privilege of being part of such an intellectually vibrant community.The nearly daily seminars and colloquia-featuring both experimentalists and theorists-broadened my mind in ways I hadn't anticipated.I am especially grateful to the organizers and speakers who made these events possible.The life as a PhD student during and after the pandemic was also enlightened by the v wonderful people in the Engineering Sciences Building.Whenever I encountered a difficult problem, it was always a good idea to take a walk through the building.More often than not, I would stumble upon someone willing to talk, offering a fresh perspective that led to real progress.I would like to thank Edwin Huang, Peizhi Mai, Penghao Zhu, Jacopo Gliozzi, Kevin Kleiner, Xuchen Cao,
Feynman diagrams have fascinated physicists and philosophers since they were introduced to the world about 70 years ago. Clearly, they help in calculation; they have allowed nearly impossible problems to be solved with relative ease. This is agreed by all, but that is probably where the consensus ends. Are they pictures of physical processes? Are they just devices for keeping track of mathematical formulae, that do the real work? Are they some sort of mix of both?They are almost as famous as representations of the Bohr atom, even though most people could not give even a sketchy account of what they do. In spite of this they have taken on a role as a cultural icon. Feynman used them to decorate his own van (Fig. 1). The van was even used in an episode of the popular TV series The Big Bang Theory. They have been used as art work in everything from posters, to coffee mugs, to wallpaper. But none of this is particularly helpful in understanding how they work.If we ask working physicists who use Feynman diagrams what it is they are doing, we get a variety of responses. One is puzzlement; a shrug of indifference. Even those very skilled at using Feynman diagrams might be hard pressed to explain (to a philosopher’s satisfaction) what’s happening. After all, most of us can ride a bike but would be similarly hard pressed to explain in any detail what we’re doing. A more common response might go like this: The diagram, or series of diagrams, is a schematic picture of some physical process, say, two electrons interacting, which we then link to mathematical terms. After writing out the mathematical terms in the form of a series, we calculate and get the probability of an interaction happening. This sounds good initially, but runs into trouble when we ask what a “picture of a physical process” could mean? This is, after all, the quantum world where things do not move continuously through space and time. It seems doubtful the diagrams could be diagrams of things in the physical realm. They are connected to physical reality and they are connected to wonderfully accurate predictions. And yet, mystery remains.The following articles on Feynman diagrams address several timely issues, both historical and contemporary. These are metaphysical and epistemological questions related to models and how we represent the world. The papers are united by these themes, but otherwise are independent of one another. They are arranged alphabetically and can be read in any order.James Robert Brown, “How Do Feynman Diagrams Work?” takes the view that they are not representations or models of the world at all. Like others, he stresses that they cannot be pictures of reality, since, thanks to the Heisenberg relations, there can be no such thing as a trajectory. Rather than seek some other more abstract type of representation, he introduces a distinction between descriptive and prescriptive flow charts. The latter could be a representation of physical reality, but not the former. A prescriptive flow chart is more like a recipe to bake a cake. He takes Feynman diagrams to be this sort of thing.Mauro Dorato and Emanuele Rossanese, “The Nature of Representation in Feynman Diagrams,” also reject the idea that Feynman diagrams can be considered to be pictures or depictions of actual physical processes. But unlike Brown, they do not abandon the thought that they can be models in some sense. They appeal to a famous account by RIG Hughes, known as the Denotation, Deduction, and Interpretation theory of models, where “models” are to be interpreted as merely inferential, non-representational devices constructed in given social contexts by the community of physicists.Letitia Meynell, “Picturing Feynman Diagrams and the Epistemology of Understanding,” assumes that Feynman diagrams are pictorial representations but agrees with Brown and Dorato and Rossanese that they do not represent actual physical processes. She then takes up the following puzzle: If Feynman diagrams represent states of affairs, but do not do so truthfully, what can their epistemic value be? She argues that Feynman diagrams have been epistemically powerful (at least in part) because, as pictorial representations, they facilitate an understanding of QED, and particle physics more generally. Appealing to Feynman’s own remarks, she draws out what it might mean to have an understanding of something that is not factive. Although her approach allows for a thin sense of substantively non-factive epistemic success, it is continuous with a factive sense of understanding that is more familiar in the sciences.Michael Stöltzner, “Feynman Diagrams: Modeling between Physics and Mathematics,” analyzes Feynman diagrams within the context of recent debates about models in science and against the backdrop of other diagrammatic methods in mathematical physics when dealing with infinite or asymptotic series. This allows one to avoid the dichotomy of whether Feynman diagrams represent mathematical or physical objects, or a mere tool mediating between them. Along those lines one does not, however, obtain a universal answer to the question as to what Feynman diagrams represent. A single Feynman diagram, in actual scientific practice, can stand for a single mathematical expression or for a physical phenomenon depending on whether the diagram stands for a single term in an infinite series or for a subseries that is given a physical interpretation. Stöltzner’s reading of the representation problem also derives support from the historical fact that Feynman was initially motivated by the Breit-Schrödinger model of a quivering electron and from interpreting this model within the context of stochastic processes.Adrian Wüthrich, “The Exigencies of War and the Stink of a Theoretical Problem,” approaches these topics from an historian’s point of view, shedding light on the issues by focussing on debates in this historical context. As he put it in his subtitle, Wüthrich’s aim is to understand the genesis of Feynman’s electrodynamics as mechanistic modelling at different levels. Feynman’s idiosyncratic method of dealing with quantum electrodynamic phenomena has been cast as an instance of a non-rigorous, modular and rule-based style of theorizing. Given such a characterization, it seems natural that significant changes in Feynman’s style were triggered by work he was assigned during World War II, where quick fixes may have counted more than derivations from first principles. Indeed, Feynman’s theoretical proposals of an improved electrodynamics do bear traces of Feynman’s war-related work, which immediately preceded it. However, Wüthrich explains, the attempt to apply the vocabulary of the “new mechanistic philosophy” to lesser known pieces of archival evidence brings to the fore a new kind of shift in Feynman’s style. Feynman’s disposition for such a shift may also have been fostered during the war, but it was forced upon him by a specific theoretical difficulty, which was largely unrelated to his war-time research.These articles contain some technicalities, but they should all be sufficiently accessible to general readers who would like to know more about Feynman diagrams and how they relate to theories, models, mathematics, and the world. The best philosophy of science is intimately linked to and draws upon current science and its history. It pays close attention to details: the details of theorizing, the details of models and how they function, the details of experimentation and measurement, and so on. We hope this collection of five articles on Feynman diagrams, by focussing closely on detail, will contribute to a better understanding of these strange but highly productive ciphers and symbols.
Quantum theory has inspired many new ideas for understanding Cognition and decision making. Given the nascent state of this field, many new challenges still remain. What are the strengths and unique contributions of these ideas? What are likely next steps in its development? How can it be applied to practical problems in cognitive science? Is this a rational or an irrational system of reasoning? What, if any, are its connections to neuroscience? Should the hard problem of consciousness be considered? These are questions that we try to address in this chapter, albeit at times in a limited way. We end with a debate with a fictitious skeptic (actually previous reviewers) of these ideas. Let us start by reviewing what we have covered so far. Contributions to cognition and decision We begin by summarizing the conclusions reached in previous chapters regarding the usefulness of quantum theory for modelling phenomena in cognition and decision. Chapter 1 provided some motivation and Chapter 2 provided a theoretical introduction to quantum theory. Chapter 3 presented a quantum model to account for question order effects on survey research. An exact and parameter-free test was derived from the model, which produced surprisingly accurate predictions for results obtained from three different large Gallup poll survey studies. Chapter 4 described a quantum model of probability judgments to account for findings that produce violations of classic probability theory, including conjunction and disjunction fallacies and order effects on inference.