Quantum information processing using linear optics is challenging due to the limited set of deterministic operations achievable without using complicated resource-intensive methods. While techniques such as the use of ancillary photons can enhance the information processing capabilities of linear optical systems, they are technologically demanding. Therefore, determining the constraints posed by linear optics and optimizing linear optical operations for specific tasks under those constraints, without the use of ancillae, can facilitate their potential implementation. Here, we consider the task of unambiguously discriminating between Bell-like states using linear optics and without the use of ancillary photons. This is a basic problem relevant in diverse settings, for example, in the measurement of the output of an entangling quantum circuit or for entanglement swapping at a quantum repeater station. While it is known that exact Bell states of two qubits can be discriminated with an optimal success probability of 50%, we find, surprisingly, that for Bell-like states the optimal probability can be only 25%. We analyze a set of Bell-like states in terms of their distinguishability, entanglement as measured by concurrence, and parameters of the beam-splitter network used for unambiguous discrimination. Further, we provide the linear optical configuration comprising single-photon detectors and beam splitters with input-state-dependent parameters that achieves optimal discrimination in the Bell-like case.
A linear optics-based scheme to implement various quantum information processing tasks is of paramount importance due to its ease of implementation and low noise. Many information-theoretic tasks depend on the successful discrimination of Bell states. A no-go theorem states that it is not possible to perfectly discriminate among the four Bell states when the measurement apparatus is restricted to linear optical elements. The success probability is only
50%. Using extra resources such as hyperentanglement, ancillary entanglement, and even a minimum amount of non-linearity, complete Bell-state discrimination can be achieved. The success probability for Bell-like state discrimination is only
25%. Bell-like states are non-maximally entangled two-qubit states that resemble Bell states in structure but have unequal Schmidt coefficients. We find that this can be boosted to
50% using hyperentanglement, where extra ancillary degrees of freedom (DOF) of photons, such as polarization, momentum, or OAM, are also entangled along with the system DOF. This contrasts with Bell-state discrimination, where
100% can be achieved. Furthermore, we find that using correlations in the photons' arrival times, all four Bell states can be distinguished with
100% success probability, while for Bell-like state discrimination, it increases only to
37.5% from
25%. We observe a similar contrast when using ancillary entangled photons. While the success probability for discriminating all four Bell states increases as
1−2N1, where
N is the number of ancillary photon pairs, for Bell-like states, it depends on the state parameters and can be less than
25% in some cases. Also, adding further ancillary photons decreases the success probability. We then show that using non-linear gadgets, namely SFG,
100% success probability can be achieved even for Bell-like state discrimination.
We propose a framework to analyze linear optical circuits based on an analogy with stabilizer formalism in quantum circuits, which provides efficiently computable formulas related to state discriminations. Hence, we analyze a Bell-state discrimination scheme with linear optics and ancillary single photons. With an increasing number of ancilla photons, the success probability of Bell-state discrimination has a maximum of
512403≃0.787 at
28 ancilla photons. By contrast, the corresponding two-qubit measurement asymptotically approaches a maximally entangling measurement.
Bell-state projections serve as a fundamental basis for most quantum communication and computing protocols today. However, with current Bell-state measurement schemes based on linear optics, only two of four Bell states can be identified, which means that the maximum success probability of this vital step cannot exceed 50%. Here, we experimentally demonstrate a scheme that amends the original measurement with additional modes in the form of ancillary photons, which leads to a more complex measurement pattern, and ultimately a higher success probability of 62.5%. Experimentally, we achieve a success probability of (57.9 ± 1.4)%, a substantial improvement over the conventional scheme. With the possibility of extending the protocol to a larger number of ancillary photons, our work paves the way toward more efficient realizations of quantum technologies based on Bell-state measurements.
In the last decade Grice [Phys. Rev. A 84, 042331 (2011)] and Ewert and van Loock [Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 140403 (2014)] found linear optical networks achieving near-unit efficiency unambiguous Bell state discrimination, when fed with increasingly complex ancillary states. However, except for the vacuum ancilla case [Appl. Phys. B 72, 67 (2001)], the optimality of these schemes is unknown. Here, the optimality of these networks is investigated through analytical and numerical means. We show an analytical upper bound to the success probability for interferometers that preserve the polarization of the input photons, saturated by both Grice's and Ewert--van Loock's strategies. Furthermore, such an upper bound links the complexity of their ancilla states with the scaling of their performance. We also show a computer-aided approach to the optimization of such measurement schemes for generic interferometers, by simulating an optical network supplied with various kinds of ancillary input states. We numerically confirm the optimality of known small schemes. We use both methods to investigate other ancilla states, some of them never studied before.