Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Edward Elgar Publishing eBooks

Prologue: ‘Not even wrong’

Jesús Felipe, John S. L. McCombie

Published Oct 31, 2013• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Prologue: 'Not even wrong'The physicist Wolfgang Pauli was, with Heisenberg, Schrödinger and Dirac, one of the early leaders in the development of quantum mechanics.He was renowned for being a tough audience, exclaiming 'wrong' (falsch), or 'completely wrong' (ganz falsch) when he disagreed with a speaker.Near the end of his life, when asked his opinion of a recent article by a younger physicist, he sadly said 'it is not even wrong' (Das ist nicht einmal falsch) . . .A scientific idea is 'not even wrong' if it is so incomplete that it cannot be used to make predictions that could be compared to observations to see if the idea is wrong.

DOI
10.4337/9781782549680.00004

Related papers

Wolfgang Pauli. Spin and Sarcasm

Helge Kastrup, Jeffry V. Mallow A

Atomic spectra had twice as many lines as predicted. As a solution, two young physicists, George Uhlenbeck and Samuel Goudsmit, proposed that in addition to orbiting its nucleus, an electron “spins” around its axis. (Not really, but the idea works.) Wolfgang Pauli showed that the spin could only have two opposing orientations. This could account for all of the lines. He further proposed an “Exclusion Principle”: that no electrons could be described by all the same quantum numbers, otherwise atoms (and we) could not exist. In 1930, he predicted the existence of a new particle, the neutrino, which was not observed until 26 years later. In addition to contributions to quantum mechanics, Pauli was famous for nasty remarks. A couple of gems:“This paper is so bad it is not even wrong.”“I don't mind your thinking slowly; I mind your publishing faster than you think.”

•Sep 27, 2022•0 citations

Genealogy

Jonathan Allday

Quantum theory was not the work of one person. During a period from ca. 1900 to 1927, a collection of highly talented minds worked toward a communal understanding of the new theory and experimental results. ere were many wrong turns and not everyone who made decisive contributions fully agreed with the end result. Figure 14.1 attempts to summarize the chain of in uences in terms of ideas leading to the end products, at least as far as 1927 is concerned. Not everyone is represented here (Wolfgang Pauli, made several important contributions). I have focussed on people whose ideas will be helpful to us in understanding the nature of quantum theory. Inevitably, not everyone will agree with my choice. Figure 14.1 is only an outline at best, and the number of arrows connecting a person to the rest of the group is not an entirely fair representation of how in uential they were, as it takes no account of the importance of the ideas involved. However, as we work our way through this outline history, you might nd it useful to refer back to the gure from time to time to check your bearings.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 3, 2009•0 citations

Heisenberg and the Creation of Quantum Mechanics (1925)

S. Brandt

Abstract There is a certain similarity in the early lives of Planck and of Heisenberg [1,2]. Both had fathers who were professors at the University of Munich, both visited the Maximilians-Gymnasium in Munich, and both went to see a professor in Munich to seek advice for their studies. We have mentioned at the beginning of the Prologue how Jolly in vain tried to dissuade Planck from studying physics. Heisenberg, in his autobiographic book [3], which is devised as a series of conversations, tells us of a similar experience. In the autumn of 1920, when he was about to enter the university, his first choice was mathematics. He wanted not only to do course work but also learn about problems of current interest. This, he thought, he could do best by participating in a professor’s seminar usually reserved to advanced students and Ph.D. candidates. He asked for an interview with Lindemann , the most distinguished mathematician in Munich, who was famous for having proved that the number π is transcendental. But the old professor and the young student found no understanding, partly because Lindemann’s dog noisily interfered. The result was that Heisenberg opted for theoretical physics and went to ask Sommerfeld to be admitted to his seminar. Sommerfeld agreed. At that time Pauli, only a year older than Heisenberg, was already actively doing research under Sommerfeld. The two young men became life-long friends.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 22, 1992•0 citations

EARLY HISTORY OF BELL’S THEOREM THEORY AND EXPERIMENT

John F. Clauser

Before 1980 it was unfashionable for a physicist to admit that he either did not understand and/or doubted the Truth and/or Orthodoxy of Quantum Mechanics (QM). Contemporary wisdom deemed it impossible that it may lead to incorrect predictions. Thus, it was foolish to suggest that it warranted further testing. Said wisdom proclaimed that nothing would ever be gained by any such pursuit. Bohr had won his debates with Einstein. Von Neumann had proven all other interpretations wrong. That was the end to it! Only an iconoclast dared think otherwise. Here I provide a brief history of some of my encounters with a few fellow iconoclasts, past denizens of a QM doubter’s subculture.

Foundations of Quantum Mechanics•Apr 1, 1992•12 citations

Heisenberg and the early days of quantum mechanics

Felix Bloch

It is appropriate in this year, when we celebrate the 50th anniversary of quantum mechanics, and during which we have been saddened by the death of one of its leading founders, Werner Heisenberg, to reminisce about the formative years of the new mechanics. At the time when the foundations of physics were being replaced with totally new concepts I was a student of physics. I sat in the colloquium audience when Peter Debye made the suggestions to Erwin Schrödinger that started him on the study of de Broglie waves and the search for their wave equation. It was from Heisenberg, as his first doctorate student, that I caught the spirit of research, and that I received the encouragement to make my own contributions.

Physics Today•Dec 1, 1976•59 citations

Another Visit with Wolfgang Pauli

Karl von Meÿenn, E. L. Schücking

SCHUCKING AND VON MEYENN REPLY: Yes, indeed, it was at the Solvay Conference in 1930 that Bohr reminded Einstein of his elevator. How the wrong date crept into our manuscript baffles us still.Kurt Gottfried is surprised that Pauli thought of Dirac as a formalist. Dirac was a formalist. He wrote in 1931: “The most powerful method of advance that can be suggested at present is to employ all the resources of pure mathematics in attempts to perfect and generalize the mathematical formalism that forms the existing basis of theoretical physics, and after each success in this direction, to try to interpret the new mathematical features in terms of physical entities.” 1 1. P. A. M. Dirac, Proc. R. Soc. A 133, 60 (1931) https://doi.org/10.1098/rspa.1931.0130. We disagree with Gottfried’s characterization of the Pauli equation for the electron as merely an elegant restatement of a Heisenberg–Jordan paper. Paul Ehrenfest wrote on 25 March 1931 about the Pauli equation: “This work has become very important. It has opened the way to Dirac’s ingenious work on the spin-electrons and probably also to Heisenberg’s famous work about the helium spectrum.” 2 2. W. Pauli, Scientific Correspondence, Vol. 2, K. von Meyenn, ed., Springer-Verlag, New York (1985) p. 71. Pauli introduced spinors into quantum mechanics and thus—in hindsight—made the step from two to four components not such a giant leap.We agree with Gottfried that the golden rule 3 3. K. Gottfried, Quantum Mechanics, Addison-Wesley, Redwood City, Calif. (1989), eq. 35, p. 444. is due to Dirac. When Pauli derived this equation using Dirac’s time-dependent perturbation theory, he analyzed its domain of validity using the uncertainty relation for time and energy that he had first pointed out in a letter to Heisenberg. Apparently, Pauli and Heisenberg 4 4. W. Pauli, Scientific Correspondence, Vol. 1, A. Hermann, ed., Springer-Verlag, New York (1979), p. 460. had first thought that Dirac had “gemogelt” (cheated) in its derivation.We both cherish Dirac’s beautiful physics, but his approach to theory was different from Pauli’s or Heisenberg’s. By praising Galileo, one does not demean Kepler.On Dirac’s comment about Schrödinger, we stand corrected. Luis Boya also may have a point on vacuum degeneracy. But Pauli’s crucial role in the Heisenberg theory still needs clarification. There are 144 letters from the correspondence between Pauli and Heisenberg in 1957 and 1958, up to 30 pages in length, which still await analysis.With regard to the early history of quantum field theory, we agree that much more could be said about it, and we refer Boya to Tian Yu Cao. 5 5. T. Y. Cao, Conceptual Developments of 20th Century Field Theories, Cambridge U. Press, New York (1997) https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511563997. For the history of nuclear magnetism, we suggest that Boya might consult Hendrik Casimir. 6 6. H. Casimir, Haphazard Reality, Harper & Row, New York (1983); appendix B, p. 322. Boya remarks that Heisenberg “never tried using his newborn matrix mechanics to solve for the hydrogen spectrum.” On 3 November 1925 Heisenberg wrote to Pauli: “After your first letter, I had also tried at once the calculation in three dimensions and was busy just this afternoon with the evaluation of the last equations and the elimination of the many possible mistakes in calculation when the postman entered and made my work superfluous.” 7 7. See ref. 4, p. 252. The postman had brought Pauli’s three-dimensional calculation for the H-atom. We believe that Boya underrates the role Pauli played in the dialogue with Heisenberg and that a careful reading of their correspondence supports our view. Freeman Dyson, with his unique insight into physics and the ways of physicists seems to agree with our assessment.Finally, we thank Gottfried, Boya, and Dyson for their comments.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<1. P. A. M. Dirac, Proc. R. Soc. A 133, 60 (1931) https://doi.org/10.1098/rspa.1931.0130. Google ScholarCrossref, CAS2. W. Pauli, Scientific Correspondence, Vol. 2, K. von Meyenn, ed., Springer-Verlag, New York (1985) p. 71. Google Scholar3. K. Gottfried, Quantum Mechanics, Addison-Wesley, Redwood City, Calif. (1989), eq. 35, p. 444. Google Scholar4. W. Pauli, Scientific Correspondence, Vol. 1, A. Hermann, ed., Springer-Verlag, New York (1979), p. 460. Google Scholar5. T. Y. Cao, Conceptual Developments of 20th Century Field Theories, Cambridge U. Press, New York (1997) https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511563997. Google ScholarCrossref6. H. Casimir, Haphazard Reality, Harper & Row, New York (1983); appendix B, p. 322. Google Scholar7. See ref. 4, p. 252. Google Scholar© 2001 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Aug 1, 2001•0 citations
Prologue: 'Not even wrong'The physicist Wolfgang Pauli was, with Heisenberg, Schrödinger and Dirac, one of the early leaders in the development of quantum mechanics.He was renowned for being a tough audience, exclaiming 'wrong' (falsch), or 'completely wrong' (ganz falsch) when he disagreed with a speaker.Near the end of his life, when asked his opinion of a recent article by a younger physicist, he sadly said 'it is not even wrong' (Das ist nicht einmal falsch) . . .A scientific idea is 'not even wrong' if it is so incomplete that it cannot be used to make predictions that could be compared to observations to see if the idea is wrong.
Atomic spectra had twice as many lines as predicted. As a solution, two young physicists, George Uhlenbeck and Samuel Goudsmit, proposed that in addition to orbiting its nucleus, an electron “spins” around its axis. (Not really, but the idea works.) Wolfgang Pauli showed that the spin could only have two opposing orientations. This could account for all of the lines. He further proposed an “Exclusion Principle”: that no electrons could be described by all the same quantum numbers, otherwise atoms (and we) could not exist. In 1930, he predicted the existence of a new particle, the neutrino, which was not observed until 26 years later. In addition to contributions to quantum mechanics, Pauli was famous for nasty remarks. A couple of gems:“This paper is so bad it is not even wrong.”“I don't mind your thinking slowly; I mind your publishing faster than you think.”
Quantum theory was not the work of one person. During a period from ca. 1900 to 1927, a collection of highly talented minds worked toward a communal understanding of the new theory and experimental results. ere were many wrong turns and not everyone who made decisive contributions fully agreed with the end result. Figure 14.1 attempts to summarize the chain of in uences in terms of ideas leading to the end products, at least as far as 1927 is concerned. Not everyone is represented here (Wolfgang Pauli, made several important contributions). I have focussed on people whose ideas will be helpful to us in understanding the nature of quantum theory. Inevitably, not everyone will agree with my choice. Figure 14.1 is only an outline at best, and the number of arrows connecting a person to the rest of the group is not an entirely fair representation of how in uential they were, as it takes no account of the importance of the ideas involved. However, as we work our way through this outline history, you might nd it useful to refer back to the gure from time to time to check your bearings.
Abstract There is a certain similarity in the early lives of Planck and of Heisenberg [1,2]. Both had fathers who were professors at the University of Munich, both visited the Maximilians-Gymnasium in Munich, and both went to see a professor in Munich to seek advice for their studies. We have mentioned at the beginning of the Prologue how Jolly in vain tried to dissuade Planck from studying physics. Heisenberg, in his autobiographic book [3], which is devised as a series of conversations, tells us of a similar experience. In the autumn of 1920, when he was about to enter the university, his first choice was mathematics. He wanted not only to do course work but also learn about problems of current interest. This, he thought, he could do best by participating in a professor’s seminar usually reserved to advanced students and Ph.D. candidates. He asked for an interview with Lindemann , the most distinguished mathematician in Munich, who was famous for having proved that the number π is transcendental. But the old professor and the young student found no understanding, partly because Lindemann’s dog noisily interfered. The result was that Heisenberg opted for theoretical physics and went to ask Sommerfeld to be admitted to his seminar. Sommerfeld agreed. At that time Pauli, only a year older than Heisenberg, was already actively doing research under Sommerfeld. The two young men became life-long friends.
Before 1980 it was unfashionable for a physicist to admit that he either did not understand and/or doubted the Truth and/or Orthodoxy of Quantum Mechanics (QM). Contemporary wisdom deemed it impossible that it may lead to incorrect predictions. Thus, it was foolish to suggest that it warranted further testing. Said wisdom proclaimed that nothing would ever be gained by any such pursuit. Bohr had won his debates with Einstein. Von Neumann had proven all other interpretations wrong. That was the end to it! Only an iconoclast dared think otherwise. Here I provide a brief history of some of my encounters with a few fellow iconoclasts, past denizens of a QM doubter’s subculture.
It is appropriate in this year, when we celebrate the 50th anniversary of quantum mechanics, and during which we have been saddened by the death of one of its leading founders, Werner Heisenberg, to reminisce about the formative years of the new mechanics. At the time when the foundations of physics were being replaced with totally new concepts I was a student of physics. I sat in the colloquium audience when Peter Debye made the suggestions to Erwin Schrödinger that started him on the study of de Broglie waves and the search for their wave equation. It was from Heisenberg, as his first doctorate student, that I caught the spirit of research, and that I received the encouragement to make my own contributions.
SCHUCKING AND VON MEYENN REPLY: Yes, indeed, it was at the Solvay Conference in 1930 that Bohr reminded Einstein of his elevator. How the wrong date crept into our manuscript baffles us still.Kurt Gottfried is surprised that Pauli thought of Dirac as a formalist. Dirac was a formalist. He wrote in 1931: “The most powerful method of advance that can be suggested at present is to employ all the resources of pure mathematics in attempts to perfect and generalize the mathematical formalism that forms the existing basis of theoretical physics, and after each success in this direction, to try to interpret the new mathematical features in terms of physical entities.” 1 1. P. A. M. Dirac, Proc. R. Soc. A 133, 60 (1931) https://doi.org/10.1098/rspa.1931.0130. We disagree with Gottfried’s characterization of the Pauli equation for the electron as merely an elegant restatement of a Heisenberg–Jordan paper. Paul Ehrenfest wrote on 25 March 1931 about the Pauli equation: “This work has become very important. It has opened the way to Dirac’s ingenious work on the spin-electrons and probably also to Heisenberg’s famous work about the helium spectrum.” 2 2. W. Pauli, Scientific Correspondence, Vol. 2, K. von Meyenn, ed., Springer-Verlag, New York (1985) p. 71. Pauli introduced spinors into quantum mechanics and thus—in hindsight—made the step from two to four components not such a giant leap.We agree with Gottfried that the golden rule 3 3. K. Gottfried, Quantum Mechanics, Addison-Wesley, Redwood City, Calif. (1989), eq. 35, p. 444. is due to Dirac. When Pauli derived this equation using Dirac’s time-dependent perturbation theory, he analyzed its domain of validity using the uncertainty relation for time and energy that he had first pointed out in a letter to Heisenberg. Apparently, Pauli and Heisenberg 4 4. W. Pauli, Scientific Correspondence, Vol. 1, A. Hermann, ed., Springer-Verlag, New York (1979), p. 460. had first thought that Dirac had “gemogelt” (cheated) in its derivation.We both cherish Dirac’s beautiful physics, but his approach to theory was different from Pauli’s or Heisenberg’s. By praising Galileo, one does not demean Kepler.On Dirac’s comment about Schrödinger, we stand corrected. Luis Boya also may have a point on vacuum degeneracy. But Pauli’s crucial role in the Heisenberg theory still needs clarification. There are 144 letters from the correspondence between Pauli and Heisenberg in 1957 and 1958, up to 30 pages in length, which still await analysis.With regard to the early history of quantum field theory, we agree that much more could be said about it, and we refer Boya to Tian Yu Cao. 5 5. T. Y. Cao, Conceptual Developments of 20th Century Field Theories, Cambridge U. Press, New York (1997) https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511563997. For the history of nuclear magnetism, we suggest that Boya might consult Hendrik Casimir. 6 6. H. Casimir, Haphazard Reality, Harper & Row, New York (1983); appendix B, p. 322. Boya remarks that Heisenberg “never tried using his newborn matrix mechanics to solve for the hydrogen spectrum.” On 3 November 1925 Heisenberg wrote to Pauli: “After your first letter, I had also tried at once the calculation in three dimensions and was busy just this afternoon with the evaluation of the last equations and the elimination of the many possible mistakes in calculation when the postman entered and made my work superfluous.” 7 7. See ref. 4, p. 252. The postman had brought Pauli’s three-dimensional calculation for the H-atom. We believe that Boya underrates the role Pauli played in the dialogue with Heisenberg and that a careful reading of their correspondence supports our view. Freeman Dyson, with his unique insight into physics and the ways of physicists seems to agree with our assessment.Finally, we thank Gottfried, Boya, and Dyson for their comments.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<1. P. A. M. Dirac, Proc. R. Soc. A 133, 60 (1931) https://doi.org/10.1098/rspa.1931.0130. Google ScholarCrossref, CAS2. W. Pauli, Scientific Correspondence, Vol. 2, K. von Meyenn, ed., Springer-Verlag, New York (1985) p. 71. Google Scholar3. K. Gottfried, Quantum Mechanics, Addison-Wesley, Redwood City, Calif. (1989), eq. 35, p. 444. Google Scholar4. W. Pauli, Scientific Correspondence, Vol. 1, A. Hermann, ed., Springer-Verlag, New York (1979), p. 460. Google Scholar5. T. Y. Cao, Conceptual Developments of 20th Century Field Theories, Cambridge U. Press, New York (1997) https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511563997. Google ScholarCrossref6. H. Casimir, Haphazard Reality, Harper & Row, New York (1983); appendix B, p. 322. Google Scholar7. See ref. 4, p. 252. Google Scholar© 2001 American Institute of Physics.