Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

Heisenberg and the Creation of Quantum Mechanics (1925)

S. Brandt

Published Apr 22, 1992• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract There is a certain similarity in the early lives of Planck and of Heisenberg [1,2]. Both had fathers who were professors at the University of Munich, both visited the Maximilians-Gymnasium in Munich, and both went to see a professor in Munich to seek advice for their studies. We have mentioned at the beginning of the Prologue how Jolly in vain tried to dissuade Planck from studying physics. Heisenberg, in his autobiographic book [3], which is devised as a series of conversations, tells us of a similar experience. In the autumn of 1920, when he was about to enter the university, his first choice was mathematics. He wanted not only to do course work but also learn about problems of current interest. This, he thought, he could do best by participating in a professor’s seminar usually reserved to advanced students and Ph.D. candidates. He asked for an interview with Lindemann , the most distinguished mathematician in Munich, who was famous for having proved that the number π is transcendental. But the old professor and the young student found no understanding, partly because Lindemann’s dog noisily interfered. The result was that Heisenberg opted for theoretical physics and went to ask Sommerfeld to be admitted to his seminar. Sommerfeld agreed. At that time Pauli, only a year older than Heisenberg, was already actively doing research under Sommerfeld. The two young men became life-long friends.

DOI
10.1093/oso/9780199544691.003.0038

Related papers

Revolution, Part I Heisensberg’s Matrices

David Wick

Werner Heisenberg, co-discoverer of quantum mechanics, was born on December 5, 1901, in Würzburg, Germany, the second son in a scholarly family. His father, August Heisenberg, initially taught at a gymnasium but after his Habilitation was appointed Professor of Greek Philology at the University of Munich in 1911. Werner’s teachers in Munich made observations about the 10-year-old which seem prescient today (but which probably characterize bright children everywhere): “He has an eye for what is essential and never gets lost in details…great interest and thoroughness, and ambition.” Heisenberg excelled over the other boys at skiing and chess. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Birkhäuser Boston eBooks•Jan 1, 1995•0 citations

Heisenberg

Jonathan Allday

The history of physics is not only a sequence of experimental discoveries and observations, followed by their mathematical description; it is also a history of concepts. For an understanding of the phenomena, the first condition is the introduction of adequate concepts; only with the help of the correct concepts can we really know what has been observed. Heisenberg was born on December 5, 1901, in Wurzburg, Germany. His maternal grandfather was the headmaster of the prestigious Maximilian Gymnasium in Munich, and his father, a scholar of ancient Greek philology and modern Greek literature. Heisenberg’s carrier however is regarded as being somewhat controversial due to debate over his activities during World War II. In Heisenberg’s first major paper on quantum theory, he resolved to get rid of any consideration of electron orbits. A cloud chamber is a very simple device for studying particles. They were first used, highly successfully, in the detection of cosmic rays.

CRC Press eBooks•Sep 21, 2022•0 citations

Heisenberg and the early days of quantum mechanics

Felix Bloch

It is appropriate in this year, when we celebrate the 50th anniversary of quantum mechanics, and during which we have been saddened by the death of one of its leading founders, Werner Heisenberg, to reminisce about the formative years of the new mechanics. At the time when the foundations of physics were being replaced with totally new concepts I was a student of physics. I sat in the colloquium audience when Peter Debye made the suggestions to Erwin Schrödinger that started him on the study of de Broglie waves and the search for their wave equation. It was from Heisenberg, as his first doctorate student, that I caught the spirit of research, and that I received the encouragement to make my own contributions.

Physics Today•Dec 1, 1976•59 citations

Introduction

Clive W. Kilmister

This book describes the many aspects of the life and scientific work of Erwin Schrödinger, who, perhaps more than anyone else, serves to represent the whole of modern physics. The contributions to the book are from many hands, and so it seemed useful to me to precede them with a short note giving an uncontroversial account of his life which will serve as a framework into which they can be fitted. Such a collection as this still leaves out many aspects of Schrödinger's thought, for it considers his philosophy only in passing, his poetry not at all and ignores his wide and deep interest in sculpture and painting and in the classics. Schrödinger was born in Vienna on August 12, 1887, and entered the University there to read physics in 1906. He worked there as an assistant from 1910 till his war service, and again after the war. Some short term appointments at Jena, Stuttgart and Breslau led up to his appointment to the chair of theoretical physics in Zürich in 1921. He was already treating a wide range of topics, but concentrating on atomic theory, for the old quantum theory had now entered on its heroic phase of final collapse. His six papers founding wave mechanics came at the end of his Zürich years, and in 1927 he went to the chair in Berlin, to remain there till the advent of Hitler in 1933.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 2, 1987•2 citations

Quantum mechanics

Thomas A. Ryckman

Quantum mechanics originated with a paper of 24-year-old Werner Heisenberg in early July 1925 seeking "to establish a quantum-theoretical mechanics based entirely on relations between quantities that are observable in principle". Heisenberg argues that experimental conditions limit simultaneous use of both kinematic and dynamic concepts in the description of an atomic object, complementarity more broadly enjoined an essential limitation in application of classical concepts to the quantum domain. The quantum-to-classical transition argument then targets the purported universality of quantum mechanics, the claim that descriptions of "real states" of macroscopic systems can be recovered as the classical limit of the more fundamental underlying quantum mechanical ones. The looming problem in quantum-to-classical transition is wave-particle duality and in particular the principle of superposition. As quantum mechanics holds that all possible physical information about the state of the individual system is represented by Ψ, the theory must be incomplete. Einstein suggest quantum orthodoxy holds a completely different sense of quantum mechanical completeness.

Routledge eBooks•May 18, 2017•0 citations

Quantum statistics

Stephen W. McKnight, Christos Zahopoulos

As a young professor of electrical engineering, the first author returned for a visit to the institution where he had received his PhD in Physics. His former thesis advisor, a professor of physics, was on his way to be part of a PhD oral qualifying exam committee for students in their second year of graduate study in physics. “What should I ask this guy [the qualifying exam student]?” he asked. “Why don't you ask him how a p-n junction diode works?” your first author, who had just taught a course in physical electronics, suggested. His former advisor stopped in mid-stride and said “What, do you want him to faint dead away?”

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Aug 10, 2015•0 citations
Abstract There is a certain similarity in the early lives of Planck and of Heisenberg [1,2]. Both had fathers who were professors at the University of Munich, both visited the Maximilians-Gymnasium in Munich, and both went to see a professor in Munich to seek advice for their studies. We have mentioned at the beginning of the Prologue how Jolly in vain tried to dissuade Planck from studying physics. Heisenberg, in his autobiographic book [3], which is devised as a series of conversations, tells us of a similar experience. In the autumn of 1920, when he was about to enter the university, his first choice was mathematics. He wanted not only to do course work but also learn about problems of current interest. This, he thought, he could do best by participating in a professor’s seminar usually reserved to advanced students and Ph.D. candidates. He asked for an interview with Lindemann , the most distinguished mathematician in Munich, who was famous for having proved that the number π is transcendental. But the old professor and the young student found no understanding, partly because Lindemann’s dog noisily interfered. The result was that Heisenberg opted for theoretical physics and went to ask Sommerfeld to be admitted to his seminar. Sommerfeld agreed. At that time Pauli, only a year older than Heisenberg, was already actively doing research under Sommerfeld. The two young men became life-long friends.
Werner Heisenberg, co-discoverer of quantum mechanics, was born on December 5, 1901, in Würzburg, Germany, the second son in a scholarly family. His father, August Heisenberg, initially taught at a gymnasium but after his Habilitation was appointed Professor of Greek Philology at the University of Munich in 1911. Werner’s teachers in Munich made observations about the 10-year-old which seem prescient today (but which probably characterize bright children everywhere): “He has an eye for what is essential and never gets lost in details…great interest and thoroughness, and ambition.” Heisenberg excelled over the other boys at skiing and chess. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
The history of physics is not only a sequence of experimental discoveries and observations, followed by their mathematical description; it is also a history of concepts. For an understanding of the phenomena, the first condition is the introduction of adequate concepts; only with the help of the correct concepts can we really know what has been observed. Heisenberg was born on December 5, 1901, in Wurzburg, Germany. His maternal grandfather was the headmaster of the prestigious Maximilian Gymnasium in Munich, and his father, a scholar of ancient Greek philology and modern Greek literature. Heisenberg’s carrier however is regarded as being somewhat controversial due to debate over his activities during World War II. In Heisenberg’s first major paper on quantum theory, he resolved to get rid of any consideration of electron orbits. A cloud chamber is a very simple device for studying particles. They were first used, highly successfully, in the detection of cosmic rays.
It is appropriate in this year, when we celebrate the 50th anniversary of quantum mechanics, and during which we have been saddened by the death of one of its leading founders, Werner Heisenberg, to reminisce about the formative years of the new mechanics. At the time when the foundations of physics were being replaced with totally new concepts I was a student of physics. I sat in the colloquium audience when Peter Debye made the suggestions to Erwin Schrödinger that started him on the study of de Broglie waves and the search for their wave equation. It was from Heisenberg, as his first doctorate student, that I caught the spirit of research, and that I received the encouragement to make my own contributions.
This book describes the many aspects of the life and scientific work of Erwin Schrödinger, who, perhaps more than anyone else, serves to represent the whole of modern physics. The contributions to the book are from many hands, and so it seemed useful to me to precede them with a short note giving an uncontroversial account of his life which will serve as a framework into which they can be fitted. Such a collection as this still leaves out many aspects of Schrödinger's thought, for it considers his philosophy only in passing, his poetry not at all and ignores his wide and deep interest in sculpture and painting and in the classics. Schrödinger was born in Vienna on August 12, 1887, and entered the University there to read physics in 1906. He worked there as an assistant from 1910 till his war service, and again after the war. Some short term appointments at Jena, Stuttgart and Breslau led up to his appointment to the chair of theoretical physics in Zürich in 1921. He was already treating a wide range of topics, but concentrating on atomic theory, for the old quantum theory had now entered on its heroic phase of final collapse. His six papers founding wave mechanics came at the end of his Zürich years, and in 1927 he went to the chair in Berlin, to remain there till the advent of Hitler in 1933.
Quantum mechanics originated with a paper of 24-year-old Werner Heisenberg in early July 1925 seeking "to establish a quantum-theoretical mechanics based entirely on relations between quantities that are observable in principle". Heisenberg argues that experimental conditions limit simultaneous use of both kinematic and dynamic concepts in the description of an atomic object, complementarity more broadly enjoined an essential limitation in application of classical concepts to the quantum domain. The quantum-to-classical transition argument then targets the purported universality of quantum mechanics, the claim that descriptions of "real states" of macroscopic systems can be recovered as the classical limit of the more fundamental underlying quantum mechanical ones. The looming problem in quantum-to-classical transition is wave-particle duality and in particular the principle of superposition. As quantum mechanics holds that all possible physical information about the state of the individual system is represented by Ψ, the theory must be incomplete. Einstein suggest quantum orthodoxy holds a completely different sense of quantum mechanical completeness.
As a young professor of electrical engineering, the first author returned for a visit to the institution where he had received his PhD in Physics. His former thesis advisor, a professor of physics, was on his way to be part of a PhD oral qualifying exam committee for students in their second year of graduate study in physics. “What should I ask this guy [the qualifying exam student]?” he asked. “Why don't you ask him how a p-n junction diode works?” your first author, who had just taught a course in physical electronics, suggested. His former advisor stopped in mid-stride and said “What, do you want him to faint dead away?”