Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics World

Bohr’s inspirations

Cormac O’Raifeartaigh

Published Aug 1, 2013• 0 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1088/2058-7058/26/08/32

Related papers

L'évolution de la complémentarité dans les textes de Bohr (1927-1939)

Bernadette Bensaude‐Vincent

SUMMARY. — This paper emphasizes the evolution of complementarity, in Niels Bohr's successive formulations of this idea, from 1927 to 1939, despite little, if any change in the definition of the concept with time. In the Como lecture, in 1927, Bohr introduced the idea of « complementary descriptions » in a problematic, polemical way. Against Schrödinger' s interpretation, he stressed the « irrationality » inherent in the quantum postulate. In 1935, Bohr again used complementarity polemically, in his reply to Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen. But far from intending it to convey irrationality this time, he meant to use it instead to prove that quantum mechanics is a complete theory. Finally, I will take up Bohr's attempts to apply complementarity to fundamental problems in biology, psychology, sociology, and so forth. I will argue that the introduction of complementarity outside physics was not motivated by an imperialist ambition of the Copenhagen School, but rather inspired by Bohr's own personal philosophy.

Revue d histoire des sciences•Jan 1, 1985•3 citations

Bohr’s Model

Wolfgang W. Osterhage

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Bohr's Interpretation

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•May 1, 2000•0 citations

Niels Bohr. Rule Breaker

Helge Kastrup, Jeffry V. Mallow A

Niels Bohr made numerous contributions to physics. But his most important was to break the rules. Bohr propounded several postulates. First, that electrons revolved in their orbits around the nucleus of an atom without emitting energy. Second, that spectral lines came from electrons emitting energy by jumping from one orbit to a lower one. Third, that only certain orbital radii were allowed. All three of these unsubstantiated claims violated classical physics, according to which accelerating charges emit energy. Thus, electrons should lose their energy and spiral into the nucleus. But this theory could not account for spectra; Bohr's postulates could. Bohr was the leader of a brilliant group of physicists who developed most of the fundamentals of quantum mechanics and showed that its laws proved the validity of his inspired guesses. A non-member of the group was Einstein, who disagreed with his friend Bohr over the actual meaning of quantum mechanics.

•Sep 27, 2022•0 citations

Jocular Physics: A Tribute to Bohr in Humor

Paul Halpern

Copenhagen, starting in the 1920s and 1930s and continuing after the Second World War, was not just a center for extraordinary developments in quantum and nuclear physics; it also provided a perfect stage for physicists' abundant humor. We will examine the Journal of Jocular Physics, a humorous tribute to Bohr published on the occasions of his 50th, 60th and 70th birthdays. We will discuss how the articles in the journal reflected attempts by the contributors, such as Leon Rosenfeld, Victor Weisskopf and others, to interpret and explain aspects of Bohr’s philosophy, such as complementarity and the abandonment of pure Laplacian determinism. This talk (its title loosely translated in German to ‘lustige Physik’) is dedicated to the memory of the inspiring physicist and historian of physics Harry Lustig Journal of Jocular Physics • Tribute to Bohr on his 50th, 60th and 70th birthdays (October 7 -1935, 1945, 1955) • Alternative to “Festschrift:” otherwise Bohr would “feel it as his duty to read the contents and even try to learn something.” • Written by those who had research visits or associations with the Institute of Theoretical Physics (now Niels Bohr Institute) • Reprinted by Niels Bohr Archive during Bohr’s centenary in 1985 along with the much more widelyknown Copenhagen Faust • Shares much with CF in terms of rich veins of cynical humor Gamow’s description of humorous plays that proceeded and inspired the journal: “It became customary at the end of each spring conference at Blegdamsvej 15 (the street address of Bohr's Institute of Theoretical Physics) to produce a stunt pertaining to recent developments in physics. (Gamow, Thirty Years that Shook Physics, p. 167). Cover of the reprint version of the Journal of Jocular Physics Cover of Journal of Jocular Physics, Volume I, October 7, 1935 (Caricature of Bohr kneeling on the Earth, right hand on forehead, & pondering deep thoughts, like Rodin’s “The Thinker”) First piece: “Niels Bohr on His Fiftieth Birthday” by Kanetaka Ariyama. Sentimental ode to Bohr’s excellent teaching. Discusses progress in physics, including particles known and speculated about at the time: neutron, neutrino, positron. Written in Japanese translated into German Role of neutrino plays a central, humorous role throughout series • Prominent role in Copenhagen Faust • Association with Pauli, a much-satirized (and admired) physicist • “La Plainte du Neutrino” (The neutrino’s complaint) a parody of “Un secret” by Felix Arvers that compares the neutrino’s elusiveness to a secret unrequited love. Languages used in the first volume

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•May 1, 2011•0 citations

The Bohr Model

IMPERIAL COLLEGE PRESS eBooks•Oct 1, 2011•0 citations
SUMMARY. — This paper emphasizes the evolution of complementarity, in Niels Bohr's successive formulations of this idea, from 1927 to 1939, despite little, if any change in the definition of the concept with time. In the Como lecture, in 1927, Bohr introduced the idea of « complementary descriptions » in a problematic, polemical way. Against Schrödinger' s interpretation, he stressed the « irrationality » inherent in the quantum postulate. In 1935, Bohr again used complementarity polemically, in his reply to Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen. But far from intending it to convey irrationality this time, he meant to use it instead to prove that quantum mechanics is a complete theory. Finally, I will take up Bohr's attempts to apply complementarity to fundamental problems in biology, psychology, sociology, and so forth. I will argue that the introduction of complementarity outside physics was not motivated by an imperialist ambition of the Copenhagen School, but rather inspired by Bohr's own personal philosophy.
Niels Bohr made numerous contributions to physics. But his most important was to break the rules. Bohr propounded several postulates. First, that electrons revolved in their orbits around the nucleus of an atom without emitting energy. Second, that spectral lines came from electrons emitting energy by jumping from one orbit to a lower one. Third, that only certain orbital radii were allowed. All three of these unsubstantiated claims violated classical physics, according to which accelerating charges emit energy. Thus, electrons should lose their energy and spiral into the nucleus. But this theory could not account for spectra; Bohr's postulates could. Bohr was the leader of a brilliant group of physicists who developed most of the fundamentals of quantum mechanics and showed that its laws proved the validity of his inspired guesses. A non-member of the group was Einstein, who disagreed with his friend Bohr over the actual meaning of quantum mechanics.
Copenhagen, starting in the 1920s and 1930s and continuing after the Second World War, was not just a center for extraordinary developments in quantum and nuclear physics; it also provided a perfect stage for physicists' abundant humor. We will examine the Journal of Jocular Physics, a humorous tribute to Bohr published on the occasions of his 50th, 60th and 70th birthdays. We will discuss how the articles in the journal reflected attempts by the contributors, such as Leon Rosenfeld, Victor Weisskopf and others, to interpret and explain aspects of Bohr’s philosophy, such as complementarity and the abandonment of pure Laplacian determinism. This talk (its title loosely translated in German to ‘lustige Physik’) is dedicated to the memory of the inspiring physicist and historian of physics Harry Lustig Journal of Jocular Physics • Tribute to Bohr on his 50th, 60th and 70th birthdays (October 7 -1935, 1945, 1955) • Alternative to “Festschrift:” otherwise Bohr would “feel it as his duty to read the contents and even try to learn something.” • Written by those who had research visits or associations with the Institute of Theoretical Physics (now Niels Bohr Institute) • Reprinted by Niels Bohr Archive during Bohr’s centenary in 1985 along with the much more widelyknown Copenhagen Faust • Shares much with CF in terms of rich veins of cynical humor Gamow’s description of humorous plays that proceeded and inspired the journal: “It became customary at the end of each spring conference at Blegdamsvej 15 (the street address of Bohr's Institute of Theoretical Physics) to produce a stunt pertaining to recent developments in physics. (Gamow, Thirty Years that Shook Physics, p. 167). Cover of the reprint version of the Journal of Jocular Physics Cover of Journal of Jocular Physics, Volume I, October 7, 1935 (Caricature of Bohr kneeling on the Earth, right hand on forehead, & pondering deep thoughts, like Rodin’s “The Thinker”) First piece: “Niels Bohr on His Fiftieth Birthday” by Kanetaka Ariyama. Sentimental ode to Bohr’s excellent teaching. Discusses progress in physics, including particles known and speculated about at the time: neutron, neutrino, positron. Written in Japanese translated into German Role of neutrino plays a central, humorous role throughout series • Prominent role in Copenhagen Faust • Association with Pauli, a much-satirized (and admired) physicist • “La Plainte du Neutrino” (The neutrino’s complaint) a parody of “Un secret” by Felix Arvers that compares the neutrino’s elusiveness to a secret unrequited love. Languages used in the first volume