Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Niels Bohr. Rule Breaker

Helge Kastrup, Jeffry V. Mallow A

Published Sep 27, 2022• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Niels Bohr made numerous contributions to physics. But his most important was to break the rules. Bohr propounded several postulates. First, that electrons revolved in their orbits around the nucleus of an atom without emitting energy. Second, that spectral lines came from electrons emitting energy by jumping from one orbit to a lower one. Third, that only certain orbital radii were allowed. All three of these unsubstantiated claims violated classical physics, according to which accelerating charges emit energy. Thus, electrons should lose their energy and spiral into the nucleus. But this theory could not account for spectra; Bohr's postulates could. Bohr was the leader of a brilliant group of physicists who developed most of the fundamentals of quantum mechanics and showed that its laws proved the validity of his inspired guesses. A non-member of the group was Einstein, who disagreed with his friend Bohr over the actual meaning of quantum mechanics.

DOI
10.1063/9780735421721_010

Related papers

Bohr Model

Z. Ficek

This chapter illustrates Niels Bohr's ideas in some detail. In the formulation of his model, Bohr assumed that the electron in the hydrogen atom moves under the influence of the Coulomb attraction between it and the positively charged nucleus, as assumed in classical mechanics. The Bohr model was very successful in explaining the discrete atomic spectra of one-electron atoms. The Bohr model is, of course, a theoretical model of an atom. Using Bohr's quantization postulate, find the linear velocity of the electron's sphere. To find the radius of the orbit, Bohr postulated that the angular momentum of the electron is quantized, i.e., it can only take values that are integer multiples of ħ. The chapter begins with considering the classical equation of motion for the electron in a circular orbit, which is based on Newton's laws of motion and Coulomb's law of electric force.

•Mar 3, 2017•0 citations

The Franck{Hertz Experiment

Michael S. Turner, James W. Waters

In 1912 Niels Bohr developed his model of the atom, in which electrons are allowed only certain discrete orbits. Transitions between these orbits may take place only when the atom absorbs or emits quantized packets of energy E = hc. This explains the spectral lines given o ® by an excited element, such as described by Rydberg's formula for the series of spectral lines for hydrogen. Less than a year after Bohr published his theory, J. Franck1 and G. Hertz2 proved it experimentally, earning themselves the 1925 Nobel Prize in Physics. They boiled electrons o ® a hot ¯lament K, used a potential Ub to accelerate them through a vapor of an element toward a grid A (v. Fig. 1), and looked for them on a plate M, with a small retarding potential V0 = 1.5 V, to stop electrons whose kinetic energy was below a certain value. Figure 1: Circuit diagram for the Franck-Hertz experiment If the kinetic energy of the electrons is too small to excite the atoms in the vapor, the electrons collide elastically and lose almost no energy, as required by the conservation of energy and momentum, and a large current is detected at plate M. If, on the other hand, the electrons gain just enough kinetic energy 1James Franck, American (German-born) physicist, 1882-1964 2Gustav Hertz, German physicist, 1887-1975, nephew of Heinrich Hertz, who discovered radio waves

•Jan 1, 2002•0 citations

Introduction to Quantum Mechanics

Bala Ramu Ramachandran

Most textbooks say that quantum mechanics came into being when Max Planck, in a desperate attempt to construct a theory that explained experimental data, explored the radical idea of energy being radiated or absorbed by all bodies in discrete packets (or quanta). The energy content of a quantum of radiation is proportional to the frequency of the radiation emitted or absorbed, as in , and the proportionality constant bears the name of Planck. Planck himself was rather uncomfortable with the idea of energy packets, and spent a considerable amount of time in later years trying to “restore” the classical picture of continuous energy exchange between bodies and surroundings. However, in 1905 Einstein was able to use the idea of the quantum to explain the mechanism of the photoelectric effect, which cannot be explained in any other way! This established the reality of the quantum and so, it may be said that Einstein, rather than Planck, is the father of quantum mechanics. Within a few years, Neils Bohr constructed his model of the hydrogen atom in which the electron can only occupy certain special orbits around the nucleus, and any jump between these orbits is accompanied by energy being absorbed or emitted in the form of quanta. The nearly exact agreement of Bohr’s predictions based on the model and observed hydrogen atomic spectra was among the first impressive accomplishments of quantum mechanics.

•Jan 1, 1998•26 citations

Niels Bohr’s First 1913 Paper: Still Relevant, Still Exciting, Still Puzzling

Kenneth W. Ford

Many teachers like to introduce the Bohr atom toward the end of an introductory physics course. This is an excellent idea, given the historic importance of Bohr’s 1913 work, which provided the bridge from Planck’s quantized interaction of matter and radiation (1900) to the full theory of quantum mechanics (1925-28). Unfortunately, the version of the Bohr atom that appears in many textbooks and is no doubt often presented to students is more wrong than right and may leave both teachers and students wondering why, more than a hundred years later, it is still being taught. This “pedagogic” version postulates that an electron in a stationary state moves in a circular orbit with an angular momentum that is an integral multiple of h/2π (L = nh/2π = nħ)—ħ for the lowest-energy state, 2ħ for the next state, and so on. This picture of the hydrogen atom is wrong in two senses. First it doesn’t conform to our present understanding of the hydrogen atom. This, in itself, is not a reason to scrap it, for the historical development of quantum physics is certainly of interest. But second, it doesn’t conform to the essence of what Bohr actually did. That is a reason not to teach about circular orbits and L = nħ.

The Physics Teacher•Oct 19, 2018•9 citations

Bohr Model of the Atom

R Manjunath

Through his experiments, the physicist Niels Bohr improved upon Rutherford's model of the atom and developed his model of the atomic structure in 1913 that succeeded in explaining the spectral features of the hydrogen atom. A simple means for extending the conventional non-relativistic Bohr model of the atom to include the wave nature of electrons is presented. As the derivation requires basic knowledge of classical and wave mechanics, it can be taught in standard courses in modern physics and introductory quantum mechanics.

•Mar 1, 2021•0 citations

A quantum model of atoms (the energy levels of atoms)

FranÇois Rafie

In 1913, Niels Bohr developed an accurate model for the hydrogen atom. The mathematics involved and the simplicity of this model is easily understood. The intention of the paper is not to replace Bohr's model, but to find a similar model for all atoms. The model discussed, which was developed on the same basis as Bohr's model for the hydrogen atom, calculates the radii and the energies of the orbits. The wavelength of an emitted photon when an electron makes a ‘jump’ from a higher state to a lower state can also be calculated from the model. Finally, the paper demonstrates that the model obeys the de Broglie's hypothesis that the moving electron exhibits both wave and particle properties.

International Journal of Mathematical Education in Science and Technology•Mar 1, 2001•1 citation
Niels Bohr made numerous contributions to physics. But his most important was to break the rules. Bohr propounded several postulates. First, that electrons revolved in their orbits around the nucleus of an atom without emitting energy. Second, that spectral lines came from electrons emitting energy by jumping from one orbit to a lower one. Third, that only certain orbital radii were allowed. All three of these unsubstantiated claims violated classical physics, according to which accelerating charges emit energy. Thus, electrons should lose their energy and spiral into the nucleus. But this theory could not account for spectra; Bohr's postulates could. Bohr was the leader of a brilliant group of physicists who developed most of the fundamentals of quantum mechanics and showed that its laws proved the validity of his inspired guesses. A non-member of the group was Einstein, who disagreed with his friend Bohr over the actual meaning of quantum mechanics.
This chapter illustrates Niels Bohr's ideas in some detail. In the formulation of his model, Bohr assumed that the electron in the hydrogen atom moves under the influence of the Coulomb attraction between it and the positively charged nucleus, as assumed in classical mechanics. The Bohr model was very successful in explaining the discrete atomic spectra of one-electron atoms. The Bohr model is, of course, a theoretical model of an atom. Using Bohr's quantization postulate, find the linear velocity of the electron's sphere. To find the radius of the orbit, Bohr postulated that the angular momentum of the electron is quantized, i.e., it can only take values that are integer multiples of ħ. The chapter begins with considering the classical equation of motion for the electron in a circular orbit, which is based on Newton's laws of motion and Coulomb's law of electric force.
In 1912 Niels Bohr developed his model of the atom, in which electrons are allowed only certain discrete orbits. Transitions between these orbits may take place only when the atom absorbs or emits quantized packets of energy E = hc. This explains the spectral lines given o ® by an excited element, such as described by Rydberg's formula for the series of spectral lines for hydrogen. Less than a year after Bohr published his theory, J. Franck1 and G. Hertz2 proved it experimentally, earning themselves the 1925 Nobel Prize in Physics. They boiled electrons o ® a hot ¯lament K, used a potential Ub to accelerate them through a vapor of an element toward a grid A (v. Fig. 1), and looked for them on a plate M, with a small retarding potential V0 = 1.5 V, to stop electrons whose kinetic energy was below a certain value. Figure 1: Circuit diagram for the Franck-Hertz experiment If the kinetic energy of the electrons is too small to excite the atoms in the vapor, the electrons collide elastically and lose almost no energy, as required by the conservation of energy and momentum, and a large current is detected at plate M. If, on the other hand, the electrons gain just enough kinetic energy 1James Franck, American (German-born) physicist, 1882-1964 2Gustav Hertz, German physicist, 1887-1975, nephew of Heinrich Hertz, who discovered radio waves
Most textbooks say that quantum mechanics came into being when Max Planck, in a desperate attempt to construct a theory that explained experimental data, explored the radical idea of energy being radiated or absorbed by all bodies in discrete packets (or quanta). The energy content of a quantum of radiation is proportional to the frequency of the radiation emitted or absorbed, as in , and the proportionality constant bears the name of Planck. Planck himself was rather uncomfortable with the idea of energy packets, and spent a considerable amount of time in later years trying to “restore” the classical picture of continuous energy exchange between bodies and surroundings. However, in 1905 Einstein was able to use the idea of the quantum to explain the mechanism of the photoelectric effect, which cannot be explained in any other way! This established the reality of the quantum and so, it may be said that Einstein, rather than Planck, is the father of quantum mechanics. Within a few years, Neils Bohr constructed his model of the hydrogen atom in which the electron can only occupy certain special orbits around the nucleus, and any jump between these orbits is accompanied by energy being absorbed or emitted in the form of quanta. The nearly exact agreement of Bohr’s predictions based on the model and observed hydrogen atomic spectra was among the first impressive accomplishments of quantum mechanics.
Many teachers like to introduce the Bohr atom toward the end of an introductory physics course. This is an excellent idea, given the historic importance of Bohr’s 1913 work, which provided the bridge from Planck’s quantized interaction of matter and radiation (1900) to the full theory of quantum mechanics (1925-28). Unfortunately, the version of the Bohr atom that appears in many textbooks and is no doubt often presented to students is more wrong than right and may leave both teachers and students wondering why, more than a hundred years later, it is still being taught. This “pedagogic” version postulates that an electron in a stationary state moves in a circular orbit with an angular momentum that is an integral multiple of h/2π (L = nh/2π = nħ)—ħ for the lowest-energy state, 2ħ for the next state, and so on. This picture of the hydrogen atom is wrong in two senses. First it doesn’t conform to our present understanding of the hydrogen atom. This, in itself, is not a reason to scrap it, for the historical development of quantum physics is certainly of interest. But second, it doesn’t conform to the essence of what Bohr actually did. That is a reason not to teach about circular orbits and L = nħ.
Through his experiments, the physicist Niels Bohr improved upon Rutherford's model of the atom and developed his model of the atomic structure in 1913 that succeeded in explaining the spectral features of the hydrogen atom. A simple means for extending the conventional non-relativistic Bohr model of the atom to include the wave nature of electrons is presented. As the derivation requires basic knowledge of classical and wave mechanics, it can be taught in standard courses in modern physics and introductory quantum mechanics.
In 1913, Niels Bohr developed an accurate model for the hydrogen atom. The mathematics involved and the simplicity of this model is easily understood. The intention of the paper is not to replace Bohr's model, but to find a similar model for all atoms. The model discussed, which was developed on the same basis as Bohr's model for the hydrogen atom, calculates the radii and the energies of the orbits. The wavelength of an emitted photon when an electron makes a ‘jump’ from a higher state to a lower state can also be calculated from the model. Finally, the paper demonstrates that the model obeys the de Broglie's hypothesis that the moving electron exhibits both wave and particle properties.