Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Localizing Dirac field states

Aleksander M. Kubicki

Published Sep 17, 2015• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Non-locality and quantum appear together entitling scientific projects and papers quite usually. \nThese are two hardly detachable concepts and modern quantum theories are built up taking into \naccount this aspect explicitly. However, that characteristic turns challenging from a fundamental \npoint of view and can be unhelpful for practical purposes. Here, we construct quantum \nfield theory with deliberately local aspects for a 1+1 dimensional Dirac field in flat spacetime \ngeneralizing a recently developed formalism for scalar fields. That purpose is achieved exploiting \nthe non-uniqueness of quantization process. This local construction leads to a natural notion of \nlocal quanta and provides a local algebra of operators. As an application, it is shown that the \nstandard vacuum state is a boiling soup of local particles and this fact is connected with a still \nGedankenexperiment consisting in slamming down and removing a mirror in an empty cavity.

Related papers

Localization for Dirac fermions

Aleksander M. Kubicki, Westman, Hans, Juan León

This work is devoted to incorporating into QFT the notion that particles and hence the particle states should be localizable in space. It focuses on the case of the Dirac field in 1+1 dimensional flat spacetime, generalizing a recently developed formalism for scalar fields. This is achieved exploiting again the non-uniqueness of quantization process. Instead of elementary excitations carrying definite amounts of energy and momentum, we construct the elementary excitations of the field localized (at some instant) in a definite region of space. This construction not only leads to a natural notion of localized quanta, but also provides a local algebra of operators. Once constructed, the new representation is confronted to the standard global (Fock) construction. In spite of being unitarily inequivalent representations, the localized operators are well defined in the conventional Fock space. By using them we dig up the issues of localization in QFT showing how the globality of the vacuum state is responsible for the lack of a "common sense localization" notion for particles in the standard Fock representation of QFT and propose a method to meet its requirements.

arXiv:1606.03286•Jun 10, 2016•4 citations

Photon localization: Local measurements, localized states, and causality

Jan Gulla, Johannes Skaar

We review what it means for a relativistic particle to be localized and argue that the most useful approach is through local measurement. This perspective ties localization directly to relativistic causality and measurable outcomes in spacetime. Strict localization in quantum field theory is formalized by states that give the same expectation value as vacuum for all local observables outside some spacetime region. With this formalism, single photons cannot be strictly localized, but coherent states can. The structure and interpretation of local observables and local operator algebras are discussed in connection with the Reeh-Schlieder theorem. Since probabilities of local measurement outcomes cannot vanish in vacuum, particle detection events must be phrased carefully. Key characteristics of strictly localized states are surveyed alongside concrete strategies for constructing them. The relationship between localization, causality, and on-demand sources is analyzed, finding that strictly localized states can represent localized, propagating information in quantum field theory. Explicit examples of localized photonic states are presented with an emphasis on quantum optics, including states that approximate single photons and (entangled) Bell states.

quant-pharXiv:2610.30473•Reviews of Modern Physics•Oct 23, 2026•0 citations

Fighting non-locality with non-locality: microcausality and boundary conditions in QED

Philipp A. Hoehn, Josh Kirklin

In gauge theories, globally charged observables necessarily depend non-locally on the kinematical fields, with this dependence extending to the asymptotic boundary of spacetime. Despite this, we show that a subset of such observables can be consistently regarded as local to the bulk, in a manner that respects microcausality and leaves locality properties of uncharged observables untouched. A sufficient condition for this is to impose kinematically non-local boundary conditions on the large gauge sector of the theory, and to invoke a relational notion of localisation for observables. This reveals a relatively underappreciated link between boundary conditions, and different notions of microcausality and locality. We develop this point through a detailed case study in scalar QED, describing non-local boundary conditions that allow a large family of observables on a codimension-1 bulk surface to be viewed as local to that surface, despite being dressed by asymptotic Wilson lines. We show that this property continues to hold within a perturbative quantisation of the theory, and we argue that this leads to a consistent local net of algebras that includes these charged observables in bulk algebras. We explain how this setup may be understood in terms of a preferred dynamical reference frame for small gauge transformations appearing in the boundary conditions. Many features of the theory (such as microcausality, the vacuum state, and the net of algebras of observables) depend on the choice of this frame, and we briefly discuss some repercussions of this for algebraic formulations of QFT. While our analysis is performed in QED, we expect our results to carry over qualitatively to more complicated theories including gravity.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2512.16898•Dec 19, 2025

Where's that quantum?

Stephan De Bièvre

The nature and properties of the vacuum as well as the meaning and localization properties of one or many particle states have attracted a fair amount of attention and stirred up sometimes heated debate in relativistic quantum field theory over the years. I will review some of the literature on the subject and will then show that these issues arise just as well in non-relativistic theories of extended systems, such as free bose fields. I will argue they should as such not have given rise either to surprise or to controversy. They are in fact the result of the misinterpretation of the vacuum as ``empty space'' and of a too stringent interpretation of field quanta as point particles. I will in particular present a generalization of an apparently little known theorem of Knight on the non-localizability of field quanta, Licht's characterization of localized excitations of the vacuum, and explain how the physical consequences of the Reeh-Schlieder theorem on the cyclicity and separability of the vacuum for local observables are already perfectly familiar from non-relativistic systems of coupled oscillators.

arXiv:math-ph/0607044•Jul 20, 2006•2 citations

From quantum time to manifestly covariant QFT: On the need for a quantum-action-based quantization

N. L. Diaz

In quantum time (QT) schemes, time is promoted to a degree of freedom, allowing Lorentz covariance to be made explicit for single particles. We ask whether this can be lifted to QFT, so that Lorentz covariance becomes manifest at the Hilbert-space level, rather than being hidden as in the standard canonical formulation. We address this question by proposing a second-quantized approach in which the elementary particle is the QT particle itself, leading naturally to the notion of spacetime field algebras and of quantum action. We show, however, that a naive many-body construction runs into inconsistencies. To pinpoint their origin we introduce a classical counterpart of the second-quantized formalism, spacetime classical mechanics (SCM), and prove a no-go theorem: Dirac quantization of SCM collapses back to standard QFT and therefore hides covariance. We circumvent this problem by presenting a quantum-action-based quantization that yields a spacetime version of quantum mechanics (SQM), making covariance manifest for (interacting) QFTs. Finally, we show that this resolution is tied to a genuine spacetime generalization of the notion of quantum state, required by causality and closely connected to recent ``states over time'' proposals and, in dS/CFT-motivated settings, to microscopic notions of timelike entanglement and emergent time.

quant-pharXiv:2602.23625•Mar 2, 2026

Quantum Holism from Geometric Projections

A.B.M Masum Billah Mim

This paper introduces a mathematically unified, fully local, and realistic framework for quantum entanglement by deriving non-local correlations directly from the global invariants of a smooth, inherently non-commutative operator field manifold. Moving away from background-dependent spacetime stress tensors, we establish a strict ontological hierarchy where the universe is governed by a global operator invariant constraint, formulated as an eigenvalue equation $(\hat{A} + \hat{B})|\Psi\rangle = \mathcal{I}|\Psi\rangle$. We resolve previous fragmentation in topological interpretations by explicitly constructing the operators $\hat{A}$ and $\hat{B}$ as localized spatial integrals of a quantized winding density operator $\hat{\Omega}_{\mathrm{top}}(x)$ and establishing their formal evaluation action on the state space. In a zero-baseline vacuum ($\mathcal{I}=0$), the states of localized field excitations are shown to be structural mirror images. Crucially, by modeling measurement as a geometric projection (the ``Shadow'' view), we provide the explicit algebraic derivation connecting the holistic state vector to the characteristic quantum cosine correlation $-\cos(\theta_1 - \theta_2)$. This framework naturally violates Bell's inequalities up to the Tsirelson bound ($2\sqrt{2}$) while strictly preserving local causality, offering a mathematically cohesive alternative to the Copenhagen probability collapse.

•Jun 2, 2026•0 citations
Non-locality and quantum appear together entitling scientific projects and papers quite usually. \nThese are two hardly detachable concepts and modern quantum theories are built up taking into \naccount this aspect explicitly. However, that characteristic turns challenging from a fundamental \npoint of view and can be unhelpful for practical purposes. Here, we construct quantum \nfield theory with deliberately local aspects for a 1+1 dimensional Dirac field in flat spacetime \ngeneralizing a recently developed formalism for scalar fields. That purpose is achieved exploiting \nthe non-uniqueness of quantization process. This local construction leads to a natural notion of \nlocal quanta and provides a local algebra of operators. As an application, it is shown that the \nstandard vacuum state is a boiling soup of local particles and this fact is connected with a still \nGedankenexperiment consisting in slamming down and removing a mirror in an empty cavity.
This work is devoted to incorporating into QFT the notion that particles and hence the particle states should be localizable in space. It focuses on the case of the Dirac field in 1+1 dimensional flat spacetime, generalizing a recently developed formalism for scalar fields. This is achieved exploiting again the non-uniqueness of quantization process. Instead of elementary excitations carrying definite amounts of energy and momentum, we construct the elementary excitations of the field localized (at some instant) in a definite region of space. This construction not only leads to a natural notion of localized quanta, but also provides a local algebra of operators. Once constructed, the new representation is confronted to the standard global (Fock) construction. In spite of being unitarily inequivalent representations, the localized operators are well defined in the conventional Fock space. By using them we dig up the issues of localization in QFT showing how the globality of the vacuum state is responsible for the lack of a "common sense localization" notion for particles in the standard Fock representation of QFT and propose a method to meet its requirements.
We review what it means for a relativistic particle to be localized and argue that the most useful approach is through local measurement. This perspective ties localization directly to relativistic causality and measurable outcomes in spacetime. Strict localization in quantum field theory is formalized by states that give the same expectation value as vacuum for all local observables outside some spacetime region. With this formalism, single photons cannot be strictly localized, but coherent states can. The structure and interpretation of local observables and local operator algebras are discussed in connection with the Reeh-Schlieder theorem. Since probabilities of local measurement outcomes cannot vanish in vacuum, particle detection events must be phrased carefully. Key characteristics of strictly localized states are surveyed alongside concrete strategies for constructing them. The relationship between localization, causality, and on-demand sources is analyzed, finding that strictly localized states can represent localized, propagating information in quantum field theory. Explicit examples of localized photonic states are presented with an emphasis on quantum optics, including states that approximate single photons and (entangled) Bell states.
In gauge theories, globally charged observables necessarily depend non-locally on the kinematical fields, with this dependence extending to the asymptotic boundary of spacetime. Despite this, we show that a subset of such observables can be consistently regarded as local to the bulk, in a manner that respects microcausality and leaves locality properties of uncharged observables untouched. A sufficient condition for this is to impose kinematically non-local boundary conditions on the large gauge sector of the theory, and to invoke a relational notion of localisation for observables. This reveals a relatively underappreciated link between boundary conditions, and different notions of microcausality and locality. We develop this point through a detailed case study in scalar QED, describing non-local boundary conditions that allow a large family of observables on a codimension-1 bulk surface to be viewed as local to that surface, despite being dressed by asymptotic Wilson lines. We show that this property continues to hold within a perturbative quantisation of the theory, and we argue that this leads to a consistent local net of algebras that includes these charged observables in bulk algebras. We explain how this setup may be understood in terms of a preferred dynamical reference frame for small gauge transformations appearing in the boundary conditions. Many features of the theory (such as microcausality, the vacuum state, and the net of algebras of observables) depend on the choice of this frame, and we briefly discuss some repercussions of this for algebraic formulations of QFT. While our analysis is performed in QED, we expect our results to carry over qualitatively to more complicated theories including gravity.
The nature and properties of the vacuum as well as the meaning and localization properties of one or many particle states have attracted a fair amount of attention and stirred up sometimes heated debate in relativistic quantum field theory over the years. I will review some of the literature on the subject and will then show that these issues arise just as well in non-relativistic theories of extended systems, such as free bose fields. I will argue they should as such not have given rise either to surprise or to controversy. They are in fact the result of the misinterpretation of the vacuum as ``empty space'' and of a too stringent interpretation of field quanta as point particles. I will in particular present a generalization of an apparently little known theorem of Knight on the non-localizability of field quanta, Licht's characterization of localized excitations of the vacuum, and explain how the physical consequences of the Reeh-Schlieder theorem on the cyclicity and separability of the vacuum for local observables are already perfectly familiar from non-relativistic systems of coupled oscillators.
In quantum time (QT) schemes, time is promoted to a degree of freedom, allowing Lorentz covariance to be made explicit for single particles. We ask whether this can be lifted to QFT, so that Lorentz covariance becomes manifest at the Hilbert-space level, rather than being hidden as in the standard canonical formulation. We address this question by proposing a second-quantized approach in which the elementary particle is the QT particle itself, leading naturally to the notion of spacetime field algebras and of quantum action. We show, however, that a naive many-body construction runs into inconsistencies. To pinpoint their origin we introduce a classical counterpart of the second-quantized formalism, spacetime classical mechanics (SCM), and prove a no-go theorem: Dirac quantization of SCM collapses back to standard QFT and therefore hides covariance. We circumvent this problem by presenting a quantum-action-based quantization that yields a spacetime version of quantum mechanics (SQM), making covariance manifest for (interacting) QFTs. Finally, we show that this resolution is tied to a genuine spacetime generalization of the notion of quantum state, required by causality and closely connected to recent ``states over time'' proposals and, in dS/CFT-motivated settings, to microscopic notions of timelike entanglement and emergent time.
This paper introduces a mathematically unified, fully local, and realistic framework for quantum entanglement by deriving non-local correlations directly from the global invariants of a smooth, inherently non-commutative operator field manifold. Moving away from background-dependent spacetime stress tensors, we establish a strict ontological hierarchy where the universe is governed by a global operator invariant constraint, formulated as an eigenvalue equation (A^+B^)∣Ψ⟩=I∣Ψ⟩(\hat{A} + \hat{B})|\Psi\rangle = \mathcal{I}|\Psi\rangle(A^+B^)∣Ψ⟩=I∣Ψ⟩. We resolve previous fragmentation in topological interpretations by explicitly constructing the operators A^\hat{A}A^ and B^\hat{B}B^ as localized spatial integrals of a quantized winding density operator Ω^top(x)\hat{\Omega}_{\mathrm{top}}(x)Ω^top​(x) and establishing their formal evaluation action on the state space. In a zero-baseline vacuum (I=0\mathcal{I}=0I=0), the states of localized field excitations are shown to be structural mirror images. Crucially, by modeling measurement as a geometric projection (the ``Shadow'' view), we provide the explicit algebraic derivation connecting the holistic state vector to the characteristic quantum cosine correlation −cos⁡(θ1−θ2)-\cos(\theta_1 - \theta_2)−cos(θ1​−θ2​). This framework naturally violates Bell's inequalities up to the Tsirelson bound (222\sqrt{2}22​) while strictly preserving local causality, offering a mathematically cohesive alternative to the Copenhagen probability collapse.