Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2512.16898

Fighting non-locality with non-locality: microcausality and boundary conditions in QED

Philipp A. Hoehn, Josh Kirklin

hep-thgr-qcquant-phSubmitted Dec 18, 2025• Announced Dec 19, 2025
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In gauge theories, globally charged observables necessarily depend non-locally on the kinematical fields, with this dependence extending to the asymptotic boundary of spacetime. Despite this, we show that a subset of such observables can be consistently regarded as local to the bulk, in a manner that respects microcausality and leaves locality properties of uncharged observables untouched. A sufficient condition for this is to impose kinematically non-local boundary conditions on the large gauge sector of the theory, and to invoke a relational notion of localisation for observables. This reveals a relatively underappreciated link between boundary conditions, and different notions of microcausality and locality. We develop this point through a detailed case study in scalar QED, describing non-local boundary conditions that allow a large family of observables on a codimension-1 bulk surface to be viewed as local to that surface, despite being dressed by asymptotic Wilson lines. We show that this property continues to hold within a perturbative quantisation of the theory, and we argue that this leads to a consistent local net of algebras that includes these charged observables in bulk algebras. We explain how this setup may be understood in terms of a preferred dynamical reference frame for small gauge transformations appearing in the boundary conditions. Many features of the theory (such as microcausality, the vacuum state, and the net of algebras of observables) depend on the choice of this frame, and we briefly discuss some repercussions of this for algebraic formulations of QFT. While our analysis is performed in QED, we expect our results to carry over qualitatively to more complicated theories including gravity.

Comments
52 pages, 7 figures, comments welcome

Related papers

A Dissolution of the Problem of Locality

Simon W. Saunders

Relativistic quantum theory poses a number of conceptual problems over and above the non-relativistic mechanics. From a purely mathematical point of view it is also much more sophisticated. Even the kinematic theory poses considerable difficulties: locality, antimatter, negative energy, and charge are already systematically linked in ways that cannot simply be paraphrased. A further complication is that in the midst of this structure we have what is usually called the Newton-Wigner representation (or, in the case of the Dirac theory, the Foldy-Wouthuysen representation), in which fields and states are no longer covariantly described and where the “local” self-adjoint quantities (NW-local observables) do not obey microcausality, but only satisfy equal-time commutators with respect to a particular inertial frame. If we pass to this represenation, we obtain at a stroke the basic structure of non-relativistic quantum field theory; it is not too hard to descend from that to a many-particle mechanics, and to recover the usual definitions of localization.

PSA Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association•Jan 1, 1994•13 citations

Detection times are not local observables in quantum field theory

Charis Anastopoulos, Ntina Savvidou

Detection times are routinely recorded in quantum experiments. We show that, under natural covariance and consistency requirements, the observables describing these times cannot be algebraically localized in any bounded spacetime region, even when the records themselves are localized. This challenges the identification of algebraic localization with the physical localization of measurements and shows why microcausality alone does not establish non-signalling for measurements in quantum field theory.

quant-pharXiv:2611.02135•Nov 3, 2026•0 citations

Circuit locality from relativistic locality in scalar field mediated entanglement

Andrea Di Biagio, Richard Howl, Časlav Brukner +2 more

Locality is a central notion in modern physics, but different disciplines understand it in different ways. Quantum field theory focuses on relativistic locality, based on spacetime regions, while quantum information theory focuses circuit locality, based on the notion of subsystems. Here, we investigate how spacetime and subsystem locality are related in the context of systems getting entangled while interacting via a scalar field. We show how, when the systems are put in a quantum-controlled superposition of localised states, relativistic locality (in the form of microcausality) gives rise to a specific kind of circuit. The relation between these forms of locality is relevant for understanding whether it is possible to formulate quantum field theory in quantum circuit language, and has bearing on the recent discussions on low-energy tests of quantum gravity.

arXiv:2305.05645•Quantum•Mar 24, 2026•17 citations

A groupoidal approach to quantum reference frames

Samuel Fedida, Alberto Ibort, Arnau Mas-Dorca

We develop the kinematical and operator-algebraic foundations of a groupoid-based relational quantum field theory (RQFT) on curved spacetimes. Indeed, the usual group-based quantum reference frame (QRF) formalism is not directly suited to generic curved Lorentzian backgrounds as global symmetry groups are typically absent or too small. We formulate a notion of QRF for a continuous groupoid. This yields a groupoid relativization map and relational observables. We show that a localization limit recovers the ordinary non-relational description. We construct canonical sharp groupoid QRFs, which form the groupoidal counterpart of the ideal group QRFs based on $L^2(G)$. We further prove that the groupoid QRF construction reduces to the standard operational QRF formalism for locally compact groups. The action groupoid QRFs are torsor QRFs only for specific classes of fields of positive operator-valued measures (POVMs), and the torsor relativization map only applies to constant operator fields of system observables. We review the foundations of RQFT in Minkowski spacetime. We prove new results that further link RQFT to Wightman QFT. We show that covariant POVMs are $μ$-continuous with respect to quasi-invariant $σ$-finite positive Borel measures $μ$. Thus, relational quantum fields can be understood as the smearing of pointwise-defined kernels with respect to the QRF's statistics. We develop RQFT in curved spacetime, where we argue that the correct replacement for the Poincaré group is the Poincaré groupoid of the spacetime. We also indicate how the framework extends further to internal gauge symmetry and relational gauge-covariant quantum field theory via Atiyah groupoids, providing a first step towards formulating a relational quantum Yang-Mills field theory.

quant-pharXiv:2608.14133•Aug 17, 2026•2 citations

Quantum Gravity I—Emergent Hypercomplex Operator Gauge Theory for Microcausal Lattice Spacetime

Jau Tang

We propose a novel operator-based formulation of quantum gravity grounded in two foundational principles: a discrete causal lattice and algebraic microcausality. Departing from traditional continuum approaches and wavefunction-based quantum mechanics, this framework models spacetime and matter as emergent phenomena arising from the algebraic structure of displacement operators. In this first part of a two-part series, we construct the foundational framework and demonstrate how key features of quantum mechanics—such as the uncertainty principle, de Broglie relations, and entanglement—emerge naturally without invoking wavefunctions, path integrals, or metric-based geometry. Operator non-commutativity on the causal lattice gives rise to a self-consistent quantum structure with natural ultraviolet finiteness, intrinsic time directionality, and a microcausal interpretation of measurement. This foundational part lays the groundwork for gravitational dynamics, cosmology, and the grand unification principles of gravity and the Standard Model to be explored in the sequel to quantum gravity part II.

•Nov 6, 2025•0 citations

Must the Microcausality Condition Be Interpreted Causally? Beyond Reduction and Matters of Fact

Jordi Cat

The 'microcausality' condition in quantum field theory is typically resented and justified on the basis of general principles of physical causality. I explore in detail a number of alternative causal interpretations of this condition. I conclude that none is fully satisfactory, independent of further and controversial assumptions about the object and scope of quantum field theories. In particular the stronger causal readings require a fully reductionist and fundamentalist attitude to quantum field theory. I argue, in a deflationary spirit, for a reading of the 'microcausality' condition as mere boundary condition, inspired by Relativity, that different possible formulations of quantum field theory must obey

•Jan 1, 2000•1 citation
In gauge theories, globally charged observables necessarily depend non-locally on the kinematical fields, with this dependence extending to the asymptotic boundary of spacetime. Despite this, we show that a subset of such observables can be consistently regarded as local to the bulk, in a manner that respects microcausality and leaves locality properties of uncharged observables untouched. A sufficient condition for this is to impose kinematically non-local boundary conditions on the large gauge sector of the theory, and to invoke a relational notion of localisation for observables. This reveals a relatively underappreciated link between boundary conditions, and different notions of microcausality and locality. We develop this point through a detailed case study in scalar QED, describing non-local boundary conditions that allow a large family of observables on a codimension-1 bulk surface to be viewed as local to that surface, despite being dressed by asymptotic Wilson lines. We show that this property continues to hold within a perturbative quantisation of the theory, and we argue that this leads to a consistent local net of algebras that includes these charged observables in bulk algebras. We explain how this setup may be understood in terms of a preferred dynamical reference frame for small gauge transformations appearing in the boundary conditions. Many features of the theory (such as microcausality, the vacuum state, and the net of algebras of observables) depend on the choice of this frame, and we briefly discuss some repercussions of this for algebraic formulations of QFT. While our analysis is performed in QED, we expect our results to carry over qualitatively to more complicated theories including gravity.
Relativistic quantum theory poses a number of conceptual problems over and above the non-relativistic mechanics. From a purely mathematical point of view it is also much more sophisticated. Even the kinematic theory poses considerable difficulties: locality, antimatter, negative energy, and charge are already systematically linked in ways that cannot simply be paraphrased. A further complication is that in the midst of this structure we have what is usually called the Newton-Wigner representation (or, in the case of the Dirac theory, the Foldy-Wouthuysen representation), in which fields and states are no longer covariantly described and where the “local” self-adjoint quantities (NW-local observables) do not obey microcausality, but only satisfy equal-time commutators with respect to a particular inertial frame. If we pass to this represenation, we obtain at a stroke the basic structure of non-relativistic quantum field theory; it is not too hard to descend from that to a many-particle mechanics, and to recover the usual definitions of localization.
Detection times are routinely recorded in quantum experiments. We show that, under natural covariance and consistency requirements, the observables describing these times cannot be algebraically localized in any bounded spacetime region, even when the records themselves are localized. This challenges the identification of algebraic localization with the physical localization of measurements and shows why microcausality alone does not establish non-signalling for measurements in quantum field theory.
Locality is a central notion in modern physics, but different disciplines understand it in different ways. Quantum field theory focuses on relativistic locality, based on spacetime regions, while quantum information theory focuses circuit locality, based on the notion of subsystems. Here, we investigate how spacetime and subsystem locality are related in the context of systems getting entangled while interacting via a scalar field. We show how, when the systems are put in a quantum-controlled superposition of localised states, relativistic locality (in the form of microcausality) gives rise to a specific kind of circuit. The relation between these forms of locality is relevant for understanding whether it is possible to formulate quantum field theory in quantum circuit language, and has bearing on the recent discussions on low-energy tests of quantum gravity.
We develop the kinematical and operator-algebraic foundations of a groupoid-based relational quantum field theory (RQFT) on curved spacetimes. Indeed, the usual group-based quantum reference frame (QRF) formalism is not directly suited to generic curved Lorentzian backgrounds as global symmetry groups are typically absent or too small. We formulate a notion of QRF for a continuous groupoid. This yields a groupoid relativization map and relational observables. We show that a localization limit recovers the ordinary non-relational description. We construct canonical sharp groupoid QRFs, which form the groupoidal counterpart of the ideal group QRFs based on L2(G)L^2(G)L2(G). We further prove that the groupoid QRF construction reduces to the standard operational QRF formalism for locally compact groups. The action groupoid QRFs are torsor QRFs only for specific classes of fields of positive operator-valued measures (POVMs), and the torsor relativization map only applies to constant operator fields of system observables. We review the foundations of RQFT in Minkowski spacetime. We prove new results that further link RQFT to Wightman QFT. We show that covariant POVMs are μμμ-continuous with respect to quasi-invariant σσσ-finite positive Borel measures μμμ. Thus, relational quantum fields can be understood as the smearing of pointwise-defined kernels with respect to the QRF's statistics. We develop RQFT in curved spacetime, where we argue that the correct replacement for the Poincaré group is the Poincaré groupoid of the spacetime. We also indicate how the framework extends further to internal gauge symmetry and relational gauge-covariant quantum field theory via Atiyah groupoids, providing a first step towards formulating a relational quantum Yang-Mills field theory.
We propose a novel operator-based formulation of quantum gravity grounded in two foundational principles: a discrete causal lattice and algebraic microcausality. Departing from traditional continuum approaches and wavefunction-based quantum mechanics, this framework models spacetime and matter as emergent phenomena arising from the algebraic structure of displacement operators. In this first part of a two-part series, we construct the foundational framework and demonstrate how key features of quantum mechanics—such as the uncertainty principle, de Broglie relations, and entanglement—emerge naturally without invoking wavefunctions, path integrals, or metric-based geometry. Operator non-commutativity on the causal lattice gives rise to a self-consistent quantum structure with natural ultraviolet finiteness, intrinsic time directionality, and a microcausal interpretation of measurement. This foundational part lays the groundwork for gravitational dynamics, cosmology, and the grand unification principles of gravity and the Standard Model to be explored in the sequel to quantum gravity part II.
The 'microcausality' condition in quantum field theory is typically resented and justified on the basis of general principles of physical causality. I explore in detail a number of alternative causal interpretations of this condition. I conclude that none is fully satisfactory, independent of further and controversial assumptions about the object and scope of quantum field theories. In particular the stronger causal readings require a fully reductionist and fundamentalist attitude to quantum field theory. I argue, in a deflationary spirit, for a reading of the 'microcausality' condition as mere boundary condition, inspired by Relativity, that different possible formulations of quantum field theory must obey