Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.30473 · Reviews of Modern Physics

Photon localization: Local measurements, localized states, and causality

Jan Gulla, Johannes Skaar

quant-phSubmitted Oct 21, 2026• Announced Oct 23, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We review what it means for a relativistic particle to be localized and argue that the most useful approach is through local measurement. This perspective ties localization directly to relativistic causality and measurable outcomes in spacetime. Strict localization in quantum field theory is formalized by states that give the same expectation value as vacuum for all local observables outside some spacetime region. With this formalism, single photons cannot be strictly localized, but coherent states can. The structure and interpretation of local observables and local operator algebras are discussed in connection with the Reeh-Schlieder theorem. Since probabilities of local measurement outcomes cannot vanish in vacuum, particle detection events must be phrased carefully. Key characteristics of strictly localized states are surveyed alongside concrete strategies for constructing them. The relationship between localization, causality, and on-demand sources is analyzed, finding that strictly localized states can represent localized, propagating information in quantum field theory. Explicit examples of localized photonic states are presented with an emphasis on quantum optics, including states that approximate single photons and (entangled) Bell states.

AI Summary

This review asks how photon localization should be defined operationally and reconciled with positive energy and relativistic causality. It connects quantum-optical descriptions with local operator algebras, the Reeh–Schlieder theorem, and earlier localization results. Strict localization means agreement with vacuum for every local observable outside a specified spacetime region, rather than compact support of a photon wavefunction or a position-measurement distribution. Single photons cannot be strictly localized. Positive-frequency analyticity forces tails in their expected normal-ordered energy density; more generally, Knight’s theorem requires nonvacuum strictly localized pure states to contain arbitrarily high particle-number components. These conclusions are developed through Fourier analysis and Reeh–Schlieder arguments. Coherent states can be strictly localized, and constructions using local unitaries and nonunitary isometries yield other examples, including states approximating single photons and Bell states. Causality concerns changes relative to vacuum statistics, not zero-to-nonzero detection probabilities: nontrivial local measurement outcomes already have nonzero vacuum probabilities. This distinction reconciles strict localization with Hegerfeldt-type constraints and explains why localized on-demand sources cannot emit exact single photons. A broadband discussion gives the rough duration constraint $\omega_0\Delta\tau\gtrsim1$, with a definition-dependent constant. The treatment primarily concerns free fields in flat Minkowski spacetime. Physical implementability of arbitrary local-algebra measurements remains unresolved; most arguments bracket realizable observables between narrowly smeared field measurements and the full local algebra. The on-demand-source conclusion uses stronger measurement assumptions or suitable source-locality assumptions. Interacting theories, renormalization, and detailed detector implementations remain outside the main treatment.

No sign of AI-generated text

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

DOI
10.1103/wxqn-hj7x

Related papers

Is Quantum Field Theory ontologically interpretable? On localization, particles and fields in relativistic Quantum Theory

David Schroeren

In this paper, I provide a formal set of assumptions and give a natural criterion for a quantum field theory to admit particles. I construct a naïve approach to localization for a free bosonic quantum field theory and show how this localization scheme, as a consequence of the Reeh-Schlieder theorem, fails to satisfy this criterion. I then examine the Newton-Wigner concept of localization and show that it fails to obey strong microcausality and thus is subject to a more general version of the Reeh-Schlieder theorem. I review approaches to quantum field theoretic explanations of particle detection events and explain how particles can be regarded as emergent phenomena of a relativistic field theory. In particular, I show that effective localization of Hilbert space vectors is equivalent to an approximate locality of observable algebras.

arXiv:1007.0664•Jul 5, 2010•1 citation

Strict Localization and Single-Photon Approximation

Kai Ryen

States whose local expectation values are identical to those of vacuum outside of a given region of localization are known as strictly localized states. It is believed that states generated on-demand need to be strictly localized to satisfy causality requirements. Single particle states, however, cannot be strictly localized. In this case, to conform with observation, there should exist strictly localized states which are close enough to single particle states to be indistinguishable from them by standards of contemporary experimental precision. A class of photonic states has been constructed which is fully consistent with the above considerations in that they are strictly localized, causally evolving, and generally closer to single photons than experimental precision can distinguish. We call these eta-states. The author's work represents a versatile method of constructing this class of states in a fully physical, three dimensional electromagnetic field. This is to our best knowledge the first such state constructed. Furthermore, by repeated application of the operator which excites the state from vacuum, states close to n-photons follow readily. Several relevant properties of eta-states are derived analytically, such as their energy density expectation value, number expectation value, and their coefficients in a so-called pulse mode basis. Their fidelity, the coefficient corresponding to a single particle component, is studied analytically and numerically. General bounds on the fidelity of an arbitrary strictly localized state to a given single photon are also presented. The fidelity can be made arbitrarily close to 1, but is shown to decrease as the region of localization decreases relative to the carrier frequency of the pulse. This indicates the following: One may falsify the hypothesis that on-demand states must be strictly localized by observing fidelities exceeding this limit. On the other hand, the bounds may pose a real practical limit to the single-photon approximation in experiments and potential photonics applications in the future. The author's work also includes a potential candidate for a localized Dirac fermion state following a similar method to the photonic eta-state, with the notable feature that it is a superposition between a fermion and an antifermion.

•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations

Spatial Localization of Relativistic Quantum Systems: The Commutativity Requirement and the Locality Principle. Part I: A General Analysis

Valter Moretti

We investigate whether commutativity is necessary to represent relativistic locality for localization observables of relativistic quantum systems in Minkowski spacetime. A well known no-go theorem by Halvorson and Clifton shows that commutativity of localization effects for causally separated regions is incompatible with other seemingly natural assumptions about spatial localization. Since commutativity is taken to represent locality in the Araki-Haag-Kastler framework of QFT, this prompts the question whether it follows from more elementary locality principles of quantum theory. Using Busch's operational analysis in terms of no-signaling and relativistic consistency, we argue that for particle-like systems commutativity is not implied by these principles. Assuming a natural local detectability principle, elementary localization observables are not localized in arbitrarily small spacetime neighborhoods of the relevant spatial regions, but rather in regions containing the entire rest space (a Cauchy surface) on which the measurement is performed. This reflects the particle picture itself, where localization occurs at a unique place on a rest space filled with ideal detectors, and therefore does not directly conflict with the Araki-Haag-Kastler notion of locality. We also show that commutativity and localization can coexist for less idealized localization procedures. To this end, we introduce conditional localization POVMs associated with bounded spatial regions interpreted as laboratories. By the gentle measurement lemma, these observables describe conditional localization probabilities and can, in principle, satisfy commutativity for causally separated laboratories. They may therefore be represented by local observables in the Araki-Haag-Kastler sense. Explicit examples are presented in a second work within local QFT.

math-phCross-listedarXiv:2604.03729•Letters in Mathematical Physics•Apr 7, 2026•2 citations

Relativistic Time-of-Arrival Measurements: Predictions, Post-Selection and Causality Problems

Charis Anastopoulos, Maria-Electra Plakitsi

We analyze time-of-arrival probability distributions for relativistic particles in the context of quantum field theory (QFT). We show that QFT leads to a unique prediction, modulo post-selection that incorporates properties of the apparatus into the initial state. We also show that an experimental distinction of different probability assignments is possible especially in near-field measurements. We also analyze causality in relativistic measurements. We consider a quantum state obtained by a spacetime-localized operation on the vacuum, and we show that detection probabilities are typically characterized by small transient non-causal terms. We explain that these terms originate from Feynman propagation of the initial operation, because the Feynman propagator does not vanish outside the light cone. We discuss possible ways to restore causality, and we argue that this may not be possible in measurement models that involve switching the field–apparatus coupling on and off.

arXiv:2210.05591•Foundations•Nov 29, 2023•2 citations

Spatial Localization of Relativistic Quantum Systems: The Commutativity Requirement and the Locality Principle. Part II: A Model from Local QFT

Valter Moretti

This paper is the second and final part of a two-part study. We construct positive-energy relativistic spatial localization observables in Minkowski spacetime within standard quantum field theory, using the stress--energy--momentum tensor smeared with suitable test functions. For each fixed timelike direction, the construction gives positive operator-valued measures (POVMs) on spacelike hypersurfaces, well defined on every $n$-particle sector and satisfying a relativistic causality condition excluding superluminal propagation of detection probabilities. The observables are built from local or quasi-local field-theoretic quantities, thus providing a rigorous version of earlier heuristic proposals. In the one-particle sector, the construction reduces to the observable previously introduced by the author, and its first moment gives the Newton--Wigner position operator under appropriate normalization and centering assumptions. Because the Reeh--Schlieder theorem prevents the normally ordered stress--energy--momentum tensor from being positive on the full Fock space, we use quantum energy inequalities to obtain lower bounds controlling deviations from positivity. This leads to regularized operator families, bounded from below, which approximate the localization effects. Finally, we define conditional localization observables for finite laboratories through modified local energy operators. By Haag duality, the corresponding conditional POVMs belong to local von Neumann algebras and commute for causally separated regions, in accordance with the Araki--Haag--Kastler framework. The results show how commutativity of localization observables is recovered for conditional measurements in finite spacetime regions.

math-phCross-listedarXiv:2604.04173•Letters in Mathematical Physics•Apr 7, 2026•2 citations

Where's that quantum?

Stephan De Bièvre

The nature and properties of the vacuum as well as the meaning and localization properties of one or many particle states have attracted a fair amount of attention and stirred up sometimes heated debate in relativistic quantum field theory over the years. I will review some of the literature on the subject and will then show that these issues arise just as well in non-relativistic theories of extended systems, such as free bose fields. I will argue they should as such not have given rise either to surprise or to controversy. They are in fact the result of the misinterpretation of the vacuum as ``empty space'' and of a too stringent interpretation of field quanta as point particles. I will in particular present a generalization of an apparently little known theorem of Knight on the non-localizability of field quanta, Licht's characterization of localized excitations of the vacuum, and explain how the physical consequences of the Reeh-Schlieder theorem on the cyclicity and separability of the vacuum for local observables are already perfectly familiar from non-relativistic systems of coupled oscillators.

arXiv:math-ph/0607044•Jul 20, 2006•2 citations
We review what it means for a relativistic particle to be localized and argue that the most useful approach is through local measurement. This perspective ties localization directly to relativistic causality and measurable outcomes in spacetime. Strict localization in quantum field theory is formalized by states that give the same expectation value as vacuum for all local observables outside some spacetime region. With this formalism, single photons cannot be strictly localized, but coherent states can. The structure and interpretation of local observables and local operator algebras are discussed in connection with the Reeh-Schlieder theorem. Since probabilities of local measurement outcomes cannot vanish in vacuum, particle detection events must be phrased carefully. Key characteristics of strictly localized states are surveyed alongside concrete strategies for constructing them. The relationship between localization, causality, and on-demand sources is analyzed, finding that strictly localized states can represent localized, propagating information in quantum field theory. Explicit examples of localized photonic states are presented with an emphasis on quantum optics, including states that approximate single photons and (entangled) Bell states.
This review asks how photon localization should be defined operationally and reconciled with positive energy and relativistic causality. It connects quantum-optical descriptions with local operator algebras, the Reeh–Schlieder theorem, and earlier localization results. Strict localization means agreement with vacuum for every local observable outside a specified spacetime region, rather than compact support of a photon wavefunction or a position-measurement distribution.
Single photons cannot be strictly localized. Positive-frequency analyticity forces tails in their expected normal-ordered energy density; more generally, Knight’s theorem requires nonvacuum strictly localized pure states to contain arbitrarily high particle-number components. These conclusions are developed through Fourier analysis and Reeh–Schlieder arguments. Coherent states can be strictly localized, and constructions using local unitaries and nonunitary isometries yield other examples, including states approximating single photons and Bell states. Causality concerns changes relative to vacuum statistics, not zero-to-nonzero detection probabilities: nontrivial local measurement outcomes already have nonzero vacuum probabilities. This distinction reconciles strict localization with Hegerfeldt-type constraints and explains why localized on-demand sources cannot emit exact single photons. A broadband discussion gives the rough duration constraint ω0Δτ≳1\omega_0\Delta\tau\gtrsim1ω0​Δτ≳1, with a definition-dependent constant.
The treatment primarily concerns free fields in flat Minkowski spacetime. Physical implementability of arbitrary local-algebra measurements remains unresolved; most arguments bracket realizable observables between narrowly smeared field measurements and the full local algebra. The on-demand-source conclusion uses stronger measurement assumptions or suitable source-locality assumptions. Interacting theories, renormalization, and detailed detector implementations remain outside the main treatment.
In this paper, I provide a formal set of assumptions and give a natural criterion for a quantum field theory to admit particles. I construct a naïve approach to localization for a free bosonic quantum field theory and show how this localization scheme, as a consequence of the Reeh-Schlieder theorem, fails to satisfy this criterion. I then examine the Newton-Wigner concept of localization and show that it fails to obey strong microcausality and thus is subject to a more general version of the Reeh-Schlieder theorem. I review approaches to quantum field theoretic explanations of particle detection events and explain how particles can be regarded as emergent phenomena of a relativistic field theory. In particular, I show that effective localization of Hilbert space vectors is equivalent to an approximate locality of observable algebras.
States whose local expectation values are identical to those of vacuum outside of a given region of localization are known as strictly localized states. It is believed that states generated on-demand need to be strictly localized to satisfy causality requirements. Single particle states, however, cannot be strictly localized. In this case, to conform with observation, there should exist strictly localized states which are close enough to single particle states to be indistinguishable from them by standards of contemporary experimental precision. A class of photonic states has been constructed which is fully consistent with the above considerations in that they are strictly localized, causally evolving, and generally closer to single photons than experimental precision can distinguish. We call these eta-states. The author's work represents a versatile method of constructing this class of states in a fully physical, three dimensional electromagnetic field. This is to our best knowledge the first such state constructed. Furthermore, by repeated application of the operator which excites the state from vacuum, states close to n-photons follow readily. Several relevant properties of eta-states are derived analytically, such as their energy density expectation value, number expectation value, and their coefficients in a so-called pulse mode basis. Their fidelity, the coefficient corresponding to a single particle component, is studied analytically and numerically. General bounds on the fidelity of an arbitrary strictly localized state to a given single photon are also presented. The fidelity can be made arbitrarily close to 1, but is shown to decrease as the region of localization decreases relative to the carrier frequency of the pulse. This indicates the following: One may falsify the hypothesis that on-demand states must be strictly localized by observing fidelities exceeding this limit. On the other hand, the bounds may pose a real practical limit to the single-photon approximation in experiments and potential photonics applications in the future. The author's work also includes a potential candidate for a localized Dirac fermion state following a similar method to the photonic eta-state, with the notable feature that it is a superposition between a fermion and an antifermion.
We investigate whether commutativity is necessary to represent relativistic locality for localization observables of relativistic quantum systems in Minkowski spacetime. A well known no-go theorem by Halvorson and Clifton shows that commutativity of localization effects for causally separated regions is incompatible with other seemingly natural assumptions about spatial localization. Since commutativity is taken to represent locality in the Araki-Haag-Kastler framework of QFT, this prompts the question whether it follows from more elementary locality principles of quantum theory. Using Busch's operational analysis in terms of no-signaling and relativistic consistency, we argue that for particle-like systems commutativity is not implied by these principles. Assuming a natural local detectability principle, elementary localization observables are not localized in arbitrarily small spacetime neighborhoods of the relevant spatial regions, but rather in regions containing the entire rest space (a Cauchy surface) on which the measurement is performed. This reflects the particle picture itself, where localization occurs at a unique place on a rest space filled with ideal detectors, and therefore does not directly conflict with the Araki-Haag-Kastler notion of locality. We also show that commutativity and localization can coexist for less idealized localization procedures. To this end, we introduce conditional localization POVMs associated with bounded spatial regions interpreted as laboratories. By the gentle measurement lemma, these observables describe conditional localization probabilities and can, in principle, satisfy commutativity for causally separated laboratories. They may therefore be represented by local observables in the Araki-Haag-Kastler sense. Explicit examples are presented in a second work within local QFT.
We analyze time-of-arrival probability distributions for relativistic particles in the context of quantum field theory (QFT). We show that QFT leads to a unique prediction, modulo post-selection that incorporates properties of the apparatus into the initial state. We also show that an experimental distinction of different probability assignments is possible especially in near-field measurements. We also analyze causality in relativistic measurements. We consider a quantum state obtained by a spacetime-localized operation on the vacuum, and we show that detection probabilities are typically characterized by small transient non-causal terms. We explain that these terms originate from Feynman propagation of the initial operation, because the Feynman propagator does not vanish outside the light cone. We discuss possible ways to restore causality, and we argue that this may not be possible in measurement models that involve switching the field–apparatus coupling on and off.
This paper is the second and final part of a two-part study. We construct positive-energy relativistic spatial localization observables in Minkowski spacetime within standard quantum field theory, using the stress--energy--momentum tensor smeared with suitable test functions. For each fixed timelike direction, the construction gives positive operator-valued measures (POVMs) on spacelike hypersurfaces, well defined on every nnn-particle sector and satisfying a relativistic causality condition excluding superluminal propagation of detection probabilities. The observables are built from local or quasi-local field-theoretic quantities, thus providing a rigorous version of earlier heuristic proposals. In the one-particle sector, the construction reduces to the observable previously introduced by the author, and its first moment gives the Newton--Wigner position operator under appropriate normalization and centering assumptions. Because the Reeh--Schlieder theorem prevents the normally ordered stress--energy--momentum tensor from being positive on the full Fock space, we use quantum energy inequalities to obtain lower bounds controlling deviations from positivity. This leads to regularized operator families, bounded from below, which approximate the localization effects. Finally, we define conditional localization observables for finite laboratories through modified local energy operators. By Haag duality, the corresponding conditional POVMs belong to local von Neumann algebras and commute for causally separated regions, in accordance with the Araki--Haag--Kastler framework. The results show how commutativity of localization observables is recovered for conditional measurements in finite spacetime regions.
The nature and properties of the vacuum as well as the meaning and localization properties of one or many particle states have attracted a fair amount of attention and stirred up sometimes heated debate in relativistic quantum field theory over the years. I will review some of the literature on the subject and will then show that these issues arise just as well in non-relativistic theories of extended systems, such as free bose fields. I will argue they should as such not have given rise either to surprise or to controversy. They are in fact the result of the misinterpretation of the vacuum as ``empty space'' and of a too stringent interpretation of field quanta as point particles. I will in particular present a generalization of an apparently little known theorem of Knight on the non-localizability of field quanta, Licht's characterization of localized excitations of the vacuum, and explain how the physical consequences of the Reeh-Schlieder theorem on the cyclicity and separability of the vacuum for local observables are already perfectly familiar from non-relativistic systems of coupled oscillators.