In this paper, we present a reliable measurement method to study the influence of the GaN buffer layer on phonon-escape time in comparison with commonly used Si substrates and, in consequence, on the IF bandwidth of HEBs. One of the key aspects is to operate the HEB mixer at elevated bath temperatures close to the critical temperature of the NbN ultra-thin film, where contributions from electron-phonon processes and self-heating effects are relatively small, therefore IF roll-off will be governed by the phonon-escape.Two independent experiments were performed at GARD and MSPU on a similar experimental setup at frequencies of approximately 180 and 140 GHz, respectively, and have shown reproducible and consistent results. The entire IF chain was characterized by S-parameter measurements. We compared the measurement results of epitaxial NbN grown onto GaN buffer-layer with Tc of 12.5 K (4.5 nm) with high quality polycrystalline NbN films on Si substrate with Tc of 10.5 K (5 nm) and observed a strong indication of an enhancement of phonon escape to the substrate by a factor of two for the NbN/GaN material combination.
In this paper, we present a reliable measurement method to study the influence of the GaN buffer layer on phonon-escape time in comparison with commonly used Si substrates and, in consequence, on the IF bandwidth of HEBs. One of the key aspects is to operate the HEB mixer at elevated bath temperatures close to the critical temperature of the NbN ultra-thin film, where contributions from electron-phonon processes and self-heating effects are relatively small, therefore IF roll-off will be governed by the phonon-escape.Two independent experiments were performed at GARD and MSPU on a similar experimental setup at frequencies of approximately 180 and 140 GHz, respectively, and have shown reproducible and consistent results. The entire IF chain was characterized by S-parameter measurements. We compared the measurement results of epitaxial NbN grown onto GaN buffer-layer with Tc of 12.5 K (4.5 nm) with high quality polycrystalline NbN films on Si substrate with Tc of 10.5 K (5 nm) and observed a strong indication of an enhancement of phonon escape to the substrate by a factor of two for the NbN/GaN material combination.
In this paper, we present IF bandwidth measurement results of NbN HEB mixers, which are employing NbN thin films grown on a GaN buffer-layer. The HEB mixers were operated in the heterodyne regime at a bath temperature of approximately 4.5 K and with a local oscillator operating at a frequency of 2 THz. A quantum cascade laser served as the local oscillator and a reference synthesizer based on a BWO generator (130-160 GHz) and a semiconductor superlattice (SSL) frequency multiplier was used as a signal source. By changing the LO frequency it was possible to record the IF response or gain bandwidth of the HEB with a spectrum analyzer at the operation point, which yielded lowest noise temperature. The gain bandwidth that was recorded in the heterodyne regime at 2 THz amounts to approximately 5 GHz and coincides well with a measurement that has been performed at elevated bath temperatures and lower LO frequency of 140 GHz. These findings strongly support that by using a GaN buffer-layer the phonon escape time of NbN HEBs can be significantly lower as compared to e.g. Si substrate, thus, providing higher gain bandwidth.
We have measured the frequency dependent IF impedance and mixer conversion gain of a small area NbN hot electron bolometer (HEB). The device used is a twin slot antenna coupled NbN HEB mixer with a bridge area of 1 x 0.15 mm, and a critical temperature of 8.3K. In the experiment the local oscillator (LO) frequency was 1.300 THz, and the intermediate frequency (IF) 0.05-10 GHz. We find that the measured data can be described in a self consistent manner with a thin film model presented by Nebosis, Semenov, Gousev, and Renk, that is based on the two temperature electron-phonon heat balance equations of Perrin-Vanneste. From these results the thermal time constant, governing the gain bandwidth of HEB mixers, is observed to not only be a function of the electron-phonon scattering time and phonon escape time, but also a function of electron temperature. The latter is due to the temperature dependence of the electron and phonon specific heat. Because hot electron bolometers nominally operate at, or slightly above, the critical temperature (TO of the superconducting film, where local resistivity as a function of electron temperature is largest, it follows that the critical temperature of the film plays an important role in determining the FMB mixer gain bandwidth. For an NbN based hot electron bolometer, the maximum predicted gain bandwidth is approximately 5.5 GHz, given a film thickness of 3.5 nm and a Tc=12K.
The intermediate frequency (IF) characteristics, the frequency dependent IF impedance, and the mixer conversion gain of a small area hot electron bolometer (HEB) have been measured and modeled. The device used is a twin slot antenna coupled NbN HEB mixer with a bridge area of 1×0.15μm2, and a critical temperature of 8.3K. In the experiment the local oscillator frequency was 1.300THz, and the (IF) 0.05–10GHz. We find that the measured data can be described in a self-consistent manner with a thin film model presented by Nebosis et al. [Proceedings of the Seventh International Symposium on Space Terahertz Technology, Charlottesville, VA, 1996 (unpublished), pp. 601–613], that is based on the two temperature electron-phonon heat balance equations of Perrin-Vanneste [J. Phys. (Paris) 48, 1311 (1987)]. From these results the thermal time constant, governing the gain bandwidth of HEB mixers, is observed to be a function of the electron-phonon scattering time, phonon escape time, and the electron temperature. From the developed theory the maximum predicted gain bandwidth for a NbN HEB is found to be 5.5–6GHz. In contrast, the gain bandwidth of the device under discussion was measured to be ∼2.3GHz which, consistent with the outlined theory, is attributed to a somewhat low critical temperature and nonoptimal film thickness (6nm).
We realized ultra thin NbN films sputtered grown on a 3C-SiC/Si substrate. The film with a thickness of 3.5-4.5 nm shows a 1', of 11.8 K, which is the highest I`, observed among ultra thin NbN films on different substrates. The high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM) studies show that the film has a monocrystalline structure, confirming the epitaxial growth on the 3C-SiC. Based on a two-temperature model and input parameters from standard NbN films on Si, simulations predict that the new film can increase the IF bandwidth of a HEB mixer by about a factor of 2 in comparison to the standard films. In addition, we find standard NbN films on Si with a T c of 9.4 K have a thickness of around 5.5 nm, being thicker than expected (3.5 nm).
The key of improving hot-electron bolometer (HEB) mixer performance lies inevitably in the quality of ultra-thin NbN films itself. This work presents a thorough investigation of crucial process parameters of NbN films deposited by means of reactive DC-sputtering on Si-substrates at elevated temperatures up to 750°C.The polycrystalline NbN films with thickness of 4 to 10nm were characterized by DC resistivity measurements, ellipsometry and high resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM) in order to confirm thickness and film structure. Since the macroscopic properties such as critical temperature, thickness as well as the transition width to the superconducting state are directly linked to HEB mixer noise temperature and IF bandwidth, a set of experiments were conducted to enhance aforementioned properties. We considered deposition temperature, RF biasing, nitrogen and argon partial and total pressure during deposition as major process variable parameters. Careful optimization of the deposition conditions allowed setting up a process resulting in high-quality NbN ultra-thin films with thickness of 5.5nm exhibiting Tc of 10.5K. Moreover, the transition width could be kept as low as 1.4K. The produced films were stored at ambient conditions and re-characterized over a period of 4 month without measurable degradation.
In this paper, we present the results of IF bandwidth measurements on 3-4 nm thick NbN hot electron bolometer waveguide mixers, which have been fabricated on a 200-nm thick MgO buffer layer deposited on a crystalline quartz substrate. The 3-dB IF bandwidth, measured at an LO frequency of 0.81 THz, is 3.7 GHz at the optimal bias point for low noise receiver operation. We have also made measurements of the IF dynamic impedance, which allow us to evaluate the intrinsic electron temperature relaxation time and self-heating parameters at different bias conditions.