Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

PSA Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association

Correlations and Physical Locality

Arthur I. Fine

Published Jan 1, 1980• 51 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Correlations between the behavior of pairs of particles are generated in the following experimental situation. An on-line source emits a stream of two-particle systems, where each system is in one and the same quantum state. After emission, the particles – call then (I) and (II) – move off in opposite directions. Each particle then encounters one of several possible barriers that either it passes or doesn't. A short distance behind each barrier is a detector set to register the presence of the particle, should it get that far. Finally, the detectors are connected by a timed relay and counter that registers a “coincidence count” should the two detectors fire within a set, brief time interval. When the experiment is run with various different barriers, detection rates accumulate for each barrier singly, and coincidence rates (the correlations) for the various pairs of barriers.

DOI
10.1086/psaprocbienmeetp.1980.2.192609

Related papers

Comments on the quantum correlation and entanglement

S. V. Gantsevich, V. L. Gurevich

In recent decades it was established that the quantum measurements of physical quantities in space-time points divided by space-like intervals may be correlated. Though such correlation follows from the formulas of quantum mechanics its physics so far remains unclear and there is a number of different and rather contradictory interpretations. They concern particularly the so-called Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox where the momentary action at a distance together with non-local entangled states is used for the interpretation. We assume that the quantum theory can be formulated as local and look for the consequences of this assumption. Accordingly we try to explain the correlation phenomena in a local way looking for the origin of correlation. To exclude a presupposed correlation of participating quantum particles we consider two independent particle sources and two detectors that are independent as well. We show that the origin of the correlation is the feature that the occupation number of a particle (and other its measurable quantities) is formed by a pair of complex conjugated wave functions with in general arbitrary phases. We consider this point as crucial as it provides interpretation of the observed correlation phenomena that may otherwise look puzzling. We briefly discuss a special type of noise that is typical for the quantum correlation phenomena.

arXiv:1512.03672•Dec 11, 2015•2 citations

Interference of independently generated beams of γ-quanta

It should be pointed out that a sharp decrease in the angular divergence of radiation produced by a spatially–modulated beam appreciably facilitates the conditions for performing experiments for observation of the interference of the pairs of X-ray quanta that this beam emits. Such interference arises due to photon identity when the pairs of X-ray quanta are registered by two independent counters (see Fig. 18.1) in the so-called regime of counting the coincidence of particle registrations by both detectors at time moment t within a certain small time interval Δ t (instantaneous coincidence counting) or in the counting regime when the coincidence is the event in which after the registration in one of the detectors, the other detector registers the particle after time Δ T in the time interval Δ t (delayed coincidence counting). This interference of the pairs of quanta in the optical range enabled designing the Brown–Twiss interferometer [Hanbury Brown and Twiss (1954); Bromberg et al . (2010)]. The requirement that should be met for performing these interesting experiments in the X-ray range are stated in [Baryshevskii and Podgoretskii (1968); Baryshevsky and Feranchuk (1980)]. Note that this phenomenon has a general character and, e.g., for pions and other particles it is not only observed, but used to study space–time characteristics of the production processes [Grishin et al . (1971); Kopylov and Podgoretskii (1972); Kopylov (1974); Kopylov and Podgoretskii (1975); Podgoretskii (1989); Wiedemann et al . (1997); Lisa et al . (2000); Lednicky (2007)].

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

Quantum correlation between a particle and potential well or barrier

Frank V. Kowalski, R. S. Browne

A two-body quantum correlation is calculated for a particle and an infinite potential well in which it is trapped or either a barrier or finite well over which it traverses. Correlated interference results when the incident and reflected particle substates and their associated well or barrier substates overlap. Measurement of the particle in this region causes a splitting of the well or barrier substate at subsequent times. The joint probability density, which is a function both of the different positions and different times at which the particle and well or barrier are measured, is derived assuming that no interaction occurs between the time each is measured.

arXiv:1405.0619•May 3, 2014•2 citations

Experimental observation of nonclassical effects in a single detection rate

Resch, Steinberg

Summary form only given. In any optical system, quantum and classical theory yield identical predictions for the mean intensity. The quantum mechanical predictions diverge from the classical theory only for higher order correlations. For this reason, typical quantum-interference experiments are performed by measuring coincidence rates between two or more detectors. The usual approximation, following Glauber, is that a single-photon counter fires at a rate proportional to the intensity, or number of incident photons per unit time. This approximation is so good and so entrenched that one routinely assumes that all singles-detection rates are insensitive to quantum effects. However, if one of these detectors fires, it cannot fire again for a characteristic time, called the dead-time. This characteristic of the detectors makes them highly nonlinear over times shorter than the dead-time, and thus sensitive to the higher order intensity correlations. In other words the detector has a different response for two photons arriving at different times, than for two photons arriving at the same time. We use the process of spontaneous parametric-downconversion (SPDC) to create correlated photon-pairs and send them through a polarization-based Hong-Ou-Mander interferometer. This quantum interferometer allows us to change the photon statistics without changing the intensity of the beams.

Quantum Electronics and Laser Science Conference•Jan 1, 2000•0 citations

Quantum nonlocality: How does Nature perform the trick?(1)

Nicolas Gisin

Since our early childhood we know in our bones that in order to interact with an object we have either to go to it or to throw something at it. Yet, contrary to all our daily experience, Nature is nonlocal: there are spatially separated systems that exhibit nonlocal correlations. In recent years this led to new experiments, deeper understanding of the tension between quantum physics and relativity and to proposals for disruptive technologies. Consider two spatially separated quantum systems, one controlled by Alice, the other by Bob, in a pure state . Alice and Bob may perform some measurements x and y on their systems and collect the results a and b, respectively. This situation is described by a conditional probability distribution p (a,bj x,y). In general this correlation doesn’t factorize: p (a,bj x,y) 6 p (aj x) � p (bj y), i.e. the two systems are correlated. At first, this is no surprise, correlations are everywhere. For example, consider two cups of the same color, either both red or both green, one in Alice’s and one in Bob’s hands. If they looks at the color of their cups, Alice and Bob’s results are correlated. In this example the origin of the correlation is obvious, Alice and Bob had only partial information: they knew that both have the same color, but they ignored which color. This differs deeply from the quantum situation, as quantum theory claims that a pure state provides a complete description of the two systems. This led EPR[2] to believe that quantum theory is incomplete in the same sense as the description ”of the same color” provides only an incomplete description of the color state of the cups.

•Jan 1, 2009•3 citations

Positron/Electron Annihilation via the Two-Photon Pathway

Isabelle Gauthier

When a positron/electron pair annihilate via the two-photon pathway, the emitted photons are momentum correlated. This correlation ensures that they move along a straight line path in opposite directions. An experiment performed in 2004 by Dr. V.D. Irby measured the time interval between \ndetection of the photons. He observed a decay in the number of counts with increasing detection time interval, which he described using a Lorentzian, the line width of which at full-width half-maximum is \nmeasured to be 120ps. The data collected by Irby is interesting because current theory predicts that because the source is so localized (the effective source width used by Irby is safely within 5rnrn) the photons should be detected within a time interval of ?t=d/c where d is the thickness of the source. This time interval corresponds to 17ps. This thesis fits the results to an exponential, and shows that this exponentially decaying nature of the coincidence time interval is characteristic of the entanglement of the two photons. We find that the wavefunctions of the photons decoheres in space according to how long the particle pair took to decay (which is exponential), and that the probability of simultaneous \ndetection depends on the exponential of the product of the lifetime of positronium and the detection time interval.

Theory of Computing Systems•Jan 1, 2011•0 citations
Correlations between the behavior of pairs of particles are generated in the following experimental situation. An on-line source emits a stream of two-particle systems, where each system is in one and the same quantum state. After emission, the particles – call then (I) and (II) – move off in opposite directions. Each particle then encounters one of several possible barriers that either it passes or doesn't. A short distance behind each barrier is a detector set to register the presence of the particle, should it get that far. Finally, the detectors are connected by a timed relay and counter that registers a “coincidence count” should the two detectors fire within a set, brief time interval. When the experiment is run with various different barriers, detection rates accumulate for each barrier singly, and coincidence rates (the correlations) for the various pairs of barriers.
In recent decades it was established that the quantum measurements of physical quantities in space-time points divided by space-like intervals may be correlated. Though such correlation follows from the formulas of quantum mechanics its physics so far remains unclear and there is a number of different and rather contradictory interpretations. They concern particularly the so-called Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox where the momentary action at a distance together with non-local entangled states is used for the interpretation. We assume that the quantum theory can be formulated as local and look for the consequences of this assumption. Accordingly we try to explain the correlation phenomena in a local way looking for the origin of correlation. To exclude a presupposed correlation of participating quantum particles we consider two independent particle sources and two detectors that are independent as well. We show that the origin of the correlation is the feature that the occupation number of a particle (and other its measurable quantities) is formed by a pair of complex conjugated wave functions with in general arbitrary phases. We consider this point as crucial as it provides interpretation of the observed correlation phenomena that may otherwise look puzzling. We briefly discuss a special type of noise that is typical for the quantum correlation phenomena.
It should be pointed out that a sharp decrease in the angular divergence of radiation produced by a spatially–modulated beam appreciably facilitates the conditions for performing experiments for observation of the interference of the pairs of X-ray quanta that this beam emits. Such interference arises due to photon identity when the pairs of X-ray quanta are registered by two independent counters (see Fig. 18.1) in the so-called regime of counting the coincidence of particle registrations by both detectors at time moment t within a certain small time interval Δ t (instantaneous coincidence counting) or in the counting regime when the coincidence is the event in which after the registration in one of the detectors, the other detector registers the particle after time Δ T in the time interval Δ t (delayed coincidence counting). This interference of the pairs of quanta in the optical range enabled designing the Brown–Twiss interferometer [Hanbury Brown and Twiss (1954); Bromberg et al . (2010)]. The requirement that should be met for performing these interesting experiments in the X-ray range are stated in [Baryshevskii and Podgoretskii (1968); Baryshevsky and Feranchuk (1980)]. Note that this phenomenon has a general character and, e.g., for pions and other particles it is not only observed, but used to study space–time characteristics of the production processes [Grishin et al . (1971); Kopylov and Podgoretskii (1972); Kopylov (1974); Kopylov and Podgoretskii (1975); Podgoretskii (1989); Wiedemann et al . (1997); Lisa et al . (2000); Lednicky (2007)].
A two-body quantum correlation is calculated for a particle and an infinite potential well in which it is trapped or either a barrier or finite well over which it traverses. Correlated interference results when the incident and reflected particle substates and their associated well or barrier substates overlap. Measurement of the particle in this region causes a splitting of the well or barrier substate at subsequent times. The joint probability density, which is a function both of the different positions and different times at which the particle and well or barrier are measured, is derived assuming that no interaction occurs between the time each is measured.
Summary form only given. In any optical system, quantum and classical theory yield identical predictions for the mean intensity. The quantum mechanical predictions diverge from the classical theory only for higher order correlations. For this reason, typical quantum-interference experiments are performed by measuring coincidence rates between two or more detectors. The usual approximation, following Glauber, is that a single-photon counter fires at a rate proportional to the intensity, or number of incident photons per unit time. This approximation is so good and so entrenched that one routinely assumes that all singles-detection rates are insensitive to quantum effects. However, if one of these detectors fires, it cannot fire again for a characteristic time, called the dead-time. This characteristic of the detectors makes them highly nonlinear over times shorter than the dead-time, and thus sensitive to the higher order intensity correlations. In other words the detector has a different response for two photons arriving at different times, than for two photons arriving at the same time. We use the process of spontaneous parametric-downconversion (SPDC) to create correlated photon-pairs and send them through a polarization-based Hong-Ou-Mander interferometer. This quantum interferometer allows us to change the photon statistics without changing the intensity of the beams.
Since our early childhood we know in our bones that in order to interact with an object we have either to go to it or to throw something at it. Yet, contrary to all our daily experience, Nature is nonlocal: there are spatially separated systems that exhibit nonlocal correlations. In recent years this led to new experiments, deeper understanding of the tension between quantum physics and relativity and to proposals for disruptive technologies. Consider two spatially separated quantum systems, one controlled by Alice, the other by Bob, in a pure state . Alice and Bob may perform some measurements x and y on their systems and collect the results a and b, respectively. This situation is described by a conditional probability distribution p (a,bj x,y). In general this correlation doesn’t factorize: p (a,bj x,y) 6 p (aj x) � p (bj y), i.e. the two systems are correlated. At first, this is no surprise, correlations are everywhere. For example, consider two cups of the same color, either both red or both green, one in Alice’s and one in Bob’s hands. If they looks at the color of their cups, Alice and Bob’s results are correlated. In this example the origin of the correlation is obvious, Alice and Bob had only partial information: they knew that both have the same color, but they ignored which color. This differs deeply from the quantum situation, as quantum theory claims that a pure state provides a complete description of the two systems. This led EPR[2] to believe that quantum theory is incomplete in the same sense as the description ”of the same color” provides only an incomplete description of the color state of the cups.
When a positron/electron pair annihilate via the two-photon pathway, the emitted photons are momentum correlated. This correlation ensures that they move along a straight line path in opposite directions. An experiment performed in 2004 by Dr. V.D. Irby measured the time interval between \ndetection of the photons. He observed a decay in the number of counts with increasing detection time interval, which he described using a Lorentzian, the line width of which at full-width half-maximum is \nmeasured to be 120ps. The data collected by Irby is interesting because current theory predicts that because the source is so localized (the effective source width used by Irby is safely within 5rnrn) the photons should be detected within a time interval of ?t=d/c where d is the thickness of the source. This time interval corresponds to 17ps. This thesis fits the results to an exponential, and shows that this exponentially decaying nature of the coincidence time interval is characteristic of the entanglement of the two photons. We find that the wavefunctions of the photons decoheres in space according to how long the particle pair took to decay (which is exponential), and that the probability of simultaneous \ndetection depends on the exponential of the product of the lifetime of positronium and the detection time interval.