Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Quantum nonlocality: How does Nature perform the trick?(1)

Nicolas Gisin

Published Jan 1, 2009• 3 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Since our early childhood we know in our bones that in order to interact with an object we have either to go to it or to throw something at it. Yet, contrary to all our daily experience, Nature is nonlocal: there are spatially separated systems that exhibit nonlocal correlations. In recent years this led to new experiments, deeper understanding of the tension between quantum physics and relativity and to proposals for disruptive technologies. Consider two spatially separated quantum systems, one controlled by Alice, the other by Bob, in a pure state . Alice and Bob may perform some measurements x and y on their systems and collect the results a and b, respectively. This situation is described by a conditional probability distribution p (a,bj x,y). In general this correlation doesn’t factorize: p (a,bj x,y) 6 p (aj x) � p (bj y), i.e. the two systems are correlated. At first, this is no surprise, correlations are everywhere. For example, consider two cups of the same color, either both red or both green, one in Alice’s and one in Bob’s hands. If they looks at the color of their cups, Alice and Bob’s results are correlated. In this example the origin of the correlation is obvious, Alice and Bob had only partial information: they knew that both have the same color, but they ignored which color. This differs deeply from the quantum situation, as quantum theory claims that a pure state provides a complete description of the two systems. This led EPR[2] to believe that quantum theory is incomplete in the same sense as the description ”of the same color” provides only an incomplete description of the color state of the cups.

Related papers

Characterizing and witnessing multipartite correlations : from nonlocality to contextuality

Ana Belén Sainz

In the past century, experimental discoveries have witnessed phenomena in Nature which challenge our everyday classical intuition. In order to explain these facts, quantum theory was developed, which so far has been able to reproduce the observed results. However, I believe that our understanding of quantum mechanics can be significantly improved by the search for an operational meaning behind its mathematical formulation, which would help to identify the limitations and possibilities of the theory for information processing. An intriguing property of quantum theory is its intrinsic randomness. Indeed, Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen in 1935 questioned the completeness of quantum theory. They argued the possibility of the existence of a complete theory where variables to which we have not access determine the behaviour of physical systems, and the randomness observed in quantum mechanics is then due to our ignorance of these variables. These hidden variables theories, however, were proved not to be enough for explaining the predictions of quantum theory, as shown in the no-go theorems by Bell on quantum-nonlocality and by Kochen and Specker on quantum-contextuality. In the past decades, many experiments have corroborated the nonlocal and contextual character of Nature. However, no intuition behind these phenomena has been found, in particular about what limits their strength. In fact, special relativity alone would allow for phenomena which are more nonlocal than what quantum theory allows. Hence, much effort has been devoted to find the physical properties of quantum theory that restricts these phenomena. In this thesis, we study the constraints that arise on nonlocal and contextual phenomena when a certain exclusiveness structure compatible with quantum theory is imposed in the space of events. Here, an event denotes the situation where an outcome is obtained given that a measurement is performed on the physical system. Regarding nonlocality, we introduce a notion of orthogonality that states that events involving different outcomes of the same local measurement are exclusive, and construct constraints that the correlations among observers should satisfy. We denote this by Local Orthogonality principle (LO), which is the first intrinsically multipartite principle for bounding quantum correlations. We prove that LO identifies the supra-quantum character of some bipartite and multipartite correlations, and gets close to the quantum boundary. When studying contextuality, the same abstract event may correspond to outcomes of different measurements, which introduces a non-trivial structure in the space of events. For its study, we develop a general formalism for contextuality scenarios in the spirit of the recent approach by Cabello, Severini and Winter. In our framework, nonlocality arises as a particular case of contextuality, which allows us to study a generalization of LO. Both in nonlocality and contextuality, we find close connections to problems in combinatorics and hence use graph-theoretical tools for studying correlations. Finally, this thesis also studies the detection of nonlocal correlations. Most results on quantum nonlocality focus on few particles' experiments, while less is known about the detection of quantum nonlocality in many-body systems. Standard many-body observables involve correlations among few particles, while there is still no multipartite Bell inequality to test nonlocality merely from these data. In this thesis, we provide the first proposal for nonlocality detection in many-body systems using two-body correlations. We construct families of Bell inequalities from two-body correlators, which can detect nonlocality for systems with large number of constituents. In addition, we prove violations by systems which are relevant in nuclear and atomic physics, and show how to test these inequalities by measuring global spin components, hence opening the problem to experimental realizations.

•Feb 10, 2014•0 citations

Nonlocality in multipartite correlation networks

Lars Erik Würflinger

Despite the success of quantum mechanics in predicting the outcomes of experiments in many branches of physics, the foundations of the theory have remained subject of research and dispute. At the basis of this struggle with the theory lie the phenomena of nonlocality and entanglement. Since it was first predicted by Bell in 1964, nonlocality was not only verified in numerous experiments, but also identified as a useful resource for quantum information processing. Thus, the study of nonlocality is important both from a fundamental point of view and with respect to new applications in quantum information theory, such as secure cryptography and randomness generation. The identification of entanglement as a resource for quantum information led to a strong theoretical effort devoted to its characterisation and detection. Many of the resulting mathematical tools find application in several domains of physics. Although the only known way to create nonlocal correlations is to measure entangled quantum systems, it has been shown that entanglement and nonlocality constitute two inequivalent properties. Therefore, in the light of the success of entanglement theory, it is of interest to also devise a resource theory of nonlocality. The task of this thesis is to develop such a theoretical framework for the characterisation of nonlocality as a resource. To gain a better understanding of nonlocal correlations it will be necessary to investigate correlation scenarios that go beyond the situation originally considered by Bell. In doing so, this thesis provides new description of nonlocality that also have implications for the characterisation of quantum correlations and the detection of new forms of nonlocality. The first question we address is how nonlocality can consistently be defined in a scenario of arbitrarily many parties that may collaborate among each other. To this end we recognise which are the allowed physical operations in this situation and then define nonlocality as the resource that cannot be created by these operations. Our approach shows that the conventional definition of multipartite nonlocality, adopted by the community so far, is inconsistent with this operational definition; we further propose and analyse new models that do not suffer from these inconsistencies. Furthermore, we show that our findings have implications for the characterisation of quantum correlations. A recent approach to describe the set of quantum correlation consists in using principles inspired from information theory. By using a special instance of the models we defined earlier we show a fundamental limitation of this approach: no bipartite information principle is sufficient to single out the set of quantum correlations from the set of nonsignalling correlations. We then developed a description of nonlocality in an even more generalised scenario of several parties. Motivated by a result of Popescu we study scenarios where the parties are allowed to perform not only a single but sequences of measurements on their systems. Characterising nonlocality also in this scenario in operational terms and defining local models compatible with this definition, we show that a new form of nonlocality can be detected Lastly, we examine the problem of detecting the presence of nonlocality in a multipartite scenario when one is given only partial access to the global system. We find that one can verify that the total system must display nonlocality, even though the accessible subsystems only exhibit local correlations.

•Sep 18, 2013•0 citations

Nonlocality and Interaction

Manfred Buth

In order to understand nonlocal phenomena, the corresponding processes must be treated as scattering experiments and investigated in the frame of quantum eld theory. Quantum mechanics is not su cient for this task, because it is only concerned with the in uence of a potential on a physical object. But in processes with nonlocal e ects the role of interaction between physical objects must be su ciently respected. All this is shown rst of all for the special case of the spin-1/2-experiment, and then generalized to arbitrary scattering processes. 1. What is the problem? Nonlocal phenomena are discussed and analyzed, since Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen in their famous paper [1] have drawn attention to a di culty of quantum mechanics. By means of their also famous gedankenexperiment the three authors have demonstrated their thesis that quantum mechanics is incomplete. So called local theories were developed in order to repair this pretended fault. The work of Bell [2] consisted in describing mathematically a general kind of such theories, and inferring the inequality bearing his name from characteristic features of such theories by mere logical deduction. In quantum mechanics a corresponding condition can be given, too. These two inequalities are not compatible with one another. Hence it seems to be quite natural to decide between them by experiment. Since all results of experimental investigations from Aspect et al. [3, 4] up to Erven et al. [5] have shown that Bell's inequality is not compatible with the empirical results, local theories nowadays are quite generally refuted. On the other hand all these experiments are supporting the results of quantum mechanics. Hence one could infer that quantum mechanics is correct. But that would be an illegal conclusion, because the agreement with experiment is a necessary, but no su cient condition for the validity of a theory. Hence one would convert a double negation into a positive assertion. In this paper the thesis is claimed and proved that quantum mechanics, indeed, is incomplete, not on the philosophical level, where Bohr and Einstein were quarrelling, but in an immediately physical sense.

•Dec 1, 2011•0 citations

Quantum nonlocality via local contextuality with qubit-qubit entanglement

Debashis Saha, Adán Cabello, Sujit K. Choudhary +1 more

Quantum nonlocality can be revealed ``via local contextuality'' in qudit-qudit entangled systems with $d>2$, that is, through the violation of inequalities containing Alice-Bob correlations that admit a local description, and Alice-Alice correlations (between the results of sequences of measurements on Alice's subsystem) that admit a local (but contextual) description. A fundamental question to understand the respective roles of entanglement and local contextuality is whether nonlocality via local contextuality exists when the parties have only qubit-qubit entanglement. Here we respond affirmatively to this question. This result further clarifies the connection between contextuality and nonlocality and opens the door for observing nonlocality via local contextuality in actual experiments.

arXiv:1507.08480•Physical Review A•Apr 28, 2016•6 citations

NONLOCAL CORRELATIONS AND RELATIVITY OF PHYSICAL QUANTITIES

Aleksandr V. Belinsky, I. I. Djadan

Since the paper of Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen was published where the quantum nonlocality phenomenon was first problematized many physical explanations for this have been proposed. None of them won full recognition from physicists. Perhaps it is time to consider the issue more broadly with the involvement of non-physical arguments that have an abstract mathematical, general scientific, philosophical and historical projections. This work is an attempt at such a direction.

Metafizika•Jul 17, 2023•1 citation

Density-Matrix Description of the EPR "Paradox"

Kirk T. McDonald

,that is observed/measured some time after its creation by Alice and Bob, who are separated by a distance large compared to the spatial extents of the two qbits (labeled A and B). If Alice and Bob measure the qbits in the same basis, and later compared their results, these will be either |0� A|0� B or |1� A|1� B, with 50% probability each if the experiment is repeated many times. This correlation led Einstein and others to suppose that either the initial state was actually a mixture of the two states |0� A|0� B and |1� A|1� B rather than the superposition (1), or that the observation of qbit A by Alice somehow caused qbit B to take on a value correlated with that found by Alice (or that the observation of qbit B by Bob somehow caused qbit A to take on a value correlated with that found by Bob). Experiments that evaluate certain inequalities, first suggested by Bohm and Aharonov [2], and later a stronger version due to Bell [3], confirm that the initial, entangled state is not a mixture. 1 These impressive results leave many people with the uncomfortable feeling that quantum phenomena either involve faster-than-light “influences,” or that Nature is “nonlocal.” Discussions of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen “paradox” are usually given in terms of wavefunctions, which are not the technical language appropriate if mixtures of states are involved. Give a discussion using density matrix operators (as introduced independently(?) in 1927 by Landau and by von Neumann).

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations
Since our early childhood we know in our bones that in order to interact with an object we have either to go to it or to throw something at it. Yet, contrary to all our daily experience, Nature is nonlocal: there are spatially separated systems that exhibit nonlocal correlations. In recent years this led to new experiments, deeper understanding of the tension between quantum physics and relativity and to proposals for disruptive technologies. Consider two spatially separated quantum systems, one controlled by Alice, the other by Bob, in a pure state . Alice and Bob may perform some measurements x and y on their systems and collect the results a and b, respectively. This situation is described by a conditional probability distribution p (a,bj x,y). In general this correlation doesn’t factorize: p (a,bj x,y) 6 p (aj x) � p (bj y), i.e. the two systems are correlated. At first, this is no surprise, correlations are everywhere. For example, consider two cups of the same color, either both red or both green, one in Alice’s and one in Bob’s hands. If they looks at the color of their cups, Alice and Bob’s results are correlated. In this example the origin of the correlation is obvious, Alice and Bob had only partial information: they knew that both have the same color, but they ignored which color. This differs deeply from the quantum situation, as quantum theory claims that a pure state provides a complete description of the two systems. This led EPR[2] to believe that quantum theory is incomplete in the same sense as the description ”of the same color” provides only an incomplete description of the color state of the cups.
In the past century, experimental discoveries have witnessed phenomena in Nature which challenge our everyday classical intuition. In order to explain these facts, quantum theory was developed, which so far has been able to reproduce the observed results. However, I believe that our understanding of quantum mechanics can be significantly improved by the search for an operational meaning behind its mathematical formulation, which would help to identify the limitations and possibilities of the theory for information processing. An intriguing property of quantum theory is its intrinsic randomness. Indeed, Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen in 1935 questioned the completeness of quantum theory. They argued the possibility of the existence of a complete theory where variables to which we have not access determine the behaviour of physical systems, and the randomness observed in quantum mechanics is then due to our ignorance of these variables. These hidden variables theories, however, were proved not to be enough for explaining the predictions of quantum theory, as shown in the no-go theorems by Bell on quantum-nonlocality and by Kochen and Specker on quantum-contextuality. In the past decades, many experiments have corroborated the nonlocal and contextual character of Nature. However, no intuition behind these phenomena has been found, in particular about what limits their strength. In fact, special relativity alone would allow for phenomena which are more nonlocal than what quantum theory allows. Hence, much effort has been devoted to find the physical properties of quantum theory that restricts these phenomena. In this thesis, we study the constraints that arise on nonlocal and contextual phenomena when a certain exclusiveness structure compatible with quantum theory is imposed in the space of events. Here, an event denotes the situation where an outcome is obtained given that a measurement is performed on the physical system. Regarding nonlocality, we introduce a notion of orthogonality that states that events involving different outcomes of the same local measurement are exclusive, and construct constraints that the correlations among observers should satisfy. We denote this by Local Orthogonality principle (LO), which is the first intrinsically multipartite principle for bounding quantum correlations. We prove that LO identifies the supra-quantum character of some bipartite and multipartite correlations, and gets close to the quantum boundary. When studying contextuality, the same abstract event may correspond to outcomes of different measurements, which introduces a non-trivial structure in the space of events. For its study, we develop a general formalism for contextuality scenarios in the spirit of the recent approach by Cabello, Severini and Winter. In our framework, nonlocality arises as a particular case of contextuality, which allows us to study a generalization of LO. Both in nonlocality and contextuality, we find close connections to problems in combinatorics and hence use graph-theoretical tools for studying correlations. Finally, this thesis also studies the detection of nonlocal correlations. Most results on quantum nonlocality focus on few particles' experiments, while less is known about the detection of quantum nonlocality in many-body systems. Standard many-body observables involve correlations among few particles, while there is still no multipartite Bell inequality to test nonlocality merely from these data. In this thesis, we provide the first proposal for nonlocality detection in many-body systems using two-body correlations. We construct families of Bell inequalities from two-body correlators, which can detect nonlocality for systems with large number of constituents. In addition, we prove violations by systems which are relevant in nuclear and atomic physics, and show how to test these inequalities by measuring global spin components, hence opening the problem to experimental realizations.
Despite the success of quantum mechanics in predicting the outcomes of experiments in many branches of physics, the foundations of the theory have remained subject of research and dispute. At the basis of this struggle with the theory lie the phenomena of nonlocality and entanglement. Since it was first predicted by Bell in 1964, nonlocality was not only verified in numerous experiments, but also identified as a useful resource for quantum information processing. Thus, the study of nonlocality is important both from a fundamental point of view and with respect to new applications in quantum information theory, such as secure cryptography and randomness generation. The identification of entanglement as a resource for quantum information led to a strong theoretical effort devoted to its characterisation and detection. Many of the resulting mathematical tools find application in several domains of physics. Although the only known way to create nonlocal correlations is to measure entangled quantum systems, it has been shown that entanglement and nonlocality constitute two inequivalent properties. Therefore, in the light of the success of entanglement theory, it is of interest to also devise a resource theory of nonlocality. The task of this thesis is to develop such a theoretical framework for the characterisation of nonlocality as a resource. To gain a better understanding of nonlocal correlations it will be necessary to investigate correlation scenarios that go beyond the situation originally considered by Bell. In doing so, this thesis provides new description of nonlocality that also have implications for the characterisation of quantum correlations and the detection of new forms of nonlocality. The first question we address is how nonlocality can consistently be defined in a scenario of arbitrarily many parties that may collaborate among each other. To this end we recognise which are the allowed physical operations in this situation and then define nonlocality as the resource that cannot be created by these operations. Our approach shows that the conventional definition of multipartite nonlocality, adopted by the community so far, is inconsistent with this operational definition; we further propose and analyse new models that do not suffer from these inconsistencies. Furthermore, we show that our findings have implications for the characterisation of quantum correlations. A recent approach to describe the set of quantum correlation consists in using principles inspired from information theory. By using a special instance of the models we defined earlier we show a fundamental limitation of this approach: no bipartite information principle is sufficient to single out the set of quantum correlations from the set of nonsignalling correlations. We then developed a description of nonlocality in an even more generalised scenario of several parties. Motivated by a result of Popescu we study scenarios where the parties are allowed to perform not only a single but sequences of measurements on their systems. Characterising nonlocality also in this scenario in operational terms and defining local models compatible with this definition, we show that a new form of nonlocality can be detected Lastly, we examine the problem of detecting the presence of nonlocality in a multipartite scenario when one is given only partial access to the global system. We find that one can verify that the total system must display nonlocality, even though the accessible subsystems only exhibit local correlations.
In order to understand nonlocal phenomena, the corresponding processes must be treated as scattering experiments and investigated in the frame of quantum eld theory. Quantum mechanics is not su cient for this task, because it is only concerned with the in uence of a potential on a physical object. But in processes with nonlocal e ects the role of interaction between physical objects must be su ciently respected. All this is shown rst of all for the special case of the spin-1/2-experiment, and then generalized to arbitrary scattering processes. 1. What is the problem? Nonlocal phenomena are discussed and analyzed, since Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen in their famous paper [1] have drawn attention to a di culty of quantum mechanics. By means of their also famous gedankenexperiment the three authors have demonstrated their thesis that quantum mechanics is incomplete. So called local theories were developed in order to repair this pretended fault. The work of Bell [2] consisted in describing mathematically a general kind of such theories, and inferring the inequality bearing his name from characteristic features of such theories by mere logical deduction. In quantum mechanics a corresponding condition can be given, too. These two inequalities are not compatible with one another. Hence it seems to be quite natural to decide between them by experiment. Since all results of experimental investigations from Aspect et al. [3, 4] up to Erven et al. [5] have shown that Bell's inequality is not compatible with the empirical results, local theories nowadays are quite generally refuted. On the other hand all these experiments are supporting the results of quantum mechanics. Hence one could infer that quantum mechanics is correct. But that would be an illegal conclusion, because the agreement with experiment is a necessary, but no su cient condition for the validity of a theory. Hence one would convert a double negation into a positive assertion. In this paper the thesis is claimed and proved that quantum mechanics, indeed, is incomplete, not on the philosophical level, where Bohr and Einstein were quarrelling, but in an immediately physical sense.
Quantum nonlocality can be revealed ``via local contextuality'' in qudit-qudit entangled systems with d>2d>2d>2, that is, through the violation of inequalities containing Alice-Bob correlations that admit a local description, and Alice-Alice correlations (between the results of sequences of measurements on Alice's subsystem) that admit a local (but contextual) description. A fundamental question to understand the respective roles of entanglement and local contextuality is whether nonlocality via local contextuality exists when the parties have only qubit-qubit entanglement. Here we respond affirmatively to this question. This result further clarifies the connection between contextuality and nonlocality and opens the door for observing nonlocality via local contextuality in actual experiments.
,that is observed/measured some time after its creation by Alice and Bob, who are separated by a distance large compared to the spatial extents of the two qbits (labeled A and B). If Alice and Bob measure the qbits in the same basis, and later compared their results, these will be either |0� A|0� B or |1� A|1� B, with 50% probability each if the experiment is repeated many times. This correlation led Einstein and others to suppose that either the initial state was actually a mixture of the two states |0� A|0� B and |1� A|1� B rather than the superposition (1), or that the observation of qbit A by Alice somehow caused qbit B to take on a value correlated with that found by Alice (or that the observation of qbit B by Bob somehow caused qbit A to take on a value correlated with that found by Bob). Experiments that evaluate certain inequalities, first suggested by Bohm and Aharonov [2], and later a stronger version due to Bell [3], confirm that the initial, entangled state is not a mixture. 1 These impressive results leave many people with the uncomfortable feeling that quantum phenomena either involve faster-than-light “influences,” or that Nature is “nonlocal.” Discussions of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen “paradox” are usually given in terms of wavefunctions, which are not the technical language appropriate if mixtures of states are involved. Give a discussion using density matrix operators (as introduced independently(?) in 1927 by Landau and by von Neumann).