An on-chip magnetic shielding technique was characterized on several DC-SQUIDs to prepare the next generation of complex digital RSFQ circuits designed by the FLUXONICS foundry. The maximal frequency of operation of a toggle flip-flop cell was used as a criteria to validate the concept. It goes from a simulated value of 52 GHz (46 ± 2 GHz experimentally), for a McCumber parameter βc= 1 with JC= 1 kA/cm2 in the absence of external magnetic field, down to 29 GHz in the presence of an external field of 88 μT. The shielding technique consists of surrounding a circuit by one or several superconducting niobium loops with the same layers as for the SFQ circuit. The loops are connected to the ground plane with vias. It is shown experimentally that the local magnetic field is reduced by a factor of 4 for the best shielded configuration, which limits the reduction of the maximal frequency of operation in presence of external magnetic field.
An on-chip magnetic shielding technique was characterized on several DC-SQUIDs to prepare the next generation of complex digital RSFQ circuits designed by the FLUXONICS foundry. The maximal frequency of operation of a toggle flip-flop cell was used as a criteria to validate the concept. It goes from a simulated value of 52 GHz (46 ± 2 GHz experimentally), for a McCumber parameter βc= 1 with JC= 1 kA/cm2 in the absence of external magnetic field, down to 29 GHz in the presence of an external field of 88 μT. The shielding technique consists of surrounding a circuit by one or several superconducting niobium loops with the same layers as for the SFQ circuit. The loops are connected to the ground plane with vias. It is shown experimentally that the local magnetic field is reduced by a factor of 4 for the best shielded configuration, which limits the reduction of the maximal frequency of operation in presence of external magnetic field.
ENGLISH ABSTRACT: Single Flux Quantum (SFQ) based electronic circuits are susceptible to failure if exposed to external magnetic fields, even in very small quantities. Operating margins of SFQ circuits have shown to decrease significantly in the presence of magnetic fields as small as 5 μT. This challenge makes SFQ circuits infeasible for the normal environment in which other technologies, such as CMOS, operate. Sources of magnetic fields include SFQ circuit’s own bias lines, the Earth, which can produce magnetic fields up to 65 μT and any other electromagnetic interference sources. Without protective measures, most SFQ circuits cannot work in the open environment. \nBy using the tools available in the inductance extraction tool, InductEx, a method for projecting uniform magnetic fields, of varying orientations on SFQ cells, strides have been made to make SFQ circuits more tolerant to magnetic fields. On-chip analysis of SFQ cells was done in the presence of magnetic fields from the x, y and z orientations. In addition, by varying currents in 3-D coils, the orientation of the magnetic fields can be varied. This way, it is now possible to analyse bias, parameter and operating field margins of SFQ cells in any direction of the magnetic field. \nTwo on-chip shielding solutions were analysed and developed. The conventional continuous superconductor \nlayer shield, dubbed the solid shield, and the grid shield. The grid shield resembles a Faraday \ncage and it is implemented by laying out bars of 2.5 μm width using the topmost layer in the Hypres0 \n4.5 kA/cm2 process. The solid shield is more effective against perpendicular (z-directed) magnetic fields \nthan against those in-plain (x and y-directed). In addition, the solid shield’s inclusion in SFQ cells results \nin the reduction of circuit inductance by up to 25 %. The grid shield is a very effective approach against \nin-plane magnetic fields. However, its effectiveness is inversely proportional to the spacing between grid \nbars. Compared to the solid shield, the grid shield has less effect on circuit inductance with a typical \nreduction of 8 % at a grid bar spacing of 5 μm. The large reduction in inductance can be overcome \nby making the inductors thinner and shorter. Shielding effectiveness of on-chip shields is enhanced by \nmaking ground contact vias from the shield layer to the ground plane. So far, uniformly grounded shields \nhave shown to be the most effective approach. \nThe solid shield improved the operating field margin of a DFF cell against a z-directed magnetic field \nfrom 30 μT to 531 μT, while the grid shield, of 5 μm grid spacing, improved the margins from 68 μT \nto 290 μT against an x-directed magnetic field. In the DC-SFQ cell, the operating field margin was \nimproved with a solid shield from 47 μT to 464 μT, against a z-directed magnetic field, while with a \ngrid shield, the improvement was from 211 μT to 381 μT, against an x-directed fields. \nTo further enhance the magnetic field tolerance of SFQ circuits, design tenets that target specific components, \nsuch as inductors, were analysed. Thin and narrow inductors have shown less coupling to \nexternal magnetic fields. In addition, moats have shown to influence OFM results depending on the \norientation of magnetic fields. \nThis work has delivered design and analysis methods for magnetic field tolerant SFQ circuits.
A promising application of a single-flux quantum (SFQ) circuit is read-out circuitry for a multi-channel superconductive sensor array. In such applications, the SFQ read-out circuit is expected to operate outside a magnetic shield. We investigated an SFQ circuit structure, which is tolerant to an external magnetic field, using the AIST 2.5kA/cm2 Nb standard 2 process, which has four Nb wiring layers including the ground plane. By covering the entire circuit using an upper Nb wiring layer called the control (CTL) layer, the influences of the external magnetic field on the SFQ circuit operation can be avoided. We experimentally evaluated the sheet inductance of the wiring layer underneath the CTL shielding layer to design a magnetic-field-tolerant SFQ circuit. We implemented and measured test circuits comprising toggle flip-flops (TFFs) to evaluate their magnetic field tolerances. The operating margin and maximum operating frequency of the designed TFF did not deteriorate with increases in the magnetic field applied to the test circuit, whereas the operating margin of the conventional TFF was reduced by applying the magnetic field. We have also demonstrated the high-speed operation of the designed TFF operated in an unshielded environment at a frequency of up to 120GHz with a wide operating margin.
Operation of Low-Tc Circuits in a Magnetic Environment
The operating margins of unshielded SFQ circuits are influenced by external magnetic fields, and earlier research showed experimental results of operating region versus bias current for circuits with in-plane and perpendicularly applied magnetic fields. Here, we report a method that can be used to analyze shields to protect SFQ circuits from external magnetic fields. To validate the approach, we investigated a grid-patterned shield of varying spacing. The analysis was done with cell layouts made according to the Hypres' 4.5 kA/cm2process, in which the top-most layer, M3, was used to implement the shields. It was calculated that a grid shield of 2.5 μm grid bar width and spacing of 5 μm offered a good compromise at both providing shielding and causing a relatively small drift in circuit inductance. In order to make SFQ circuits more tolerant to magnetic fields, we have simulated with circuit parameter alterations to realize the best bias and higher operating held margins, due to external magnetic fields. The external magnetic fields are modeled through three orthogonal coils that generate roughly a uniform magnetic held density throughout the cell under test.
Single-flux-quantum (SFQ) digital circuits are mostly based on cells that rely on reliable foundry processes that make use of a superconducting ground plane as a reference for the active elements and the microstrip line interconnects. The quantum of magnetic flux h/2e, associated with the binary information, corresponds to a magnetic field energy density that needs to be localized in space to limit interactions between adjacent cells. In other words, mutual inductances can harm the proper behaviour of circuits unless they are taken carefully into account during the design phase. We studied extensively the Josephson transmission line cell with different geometrical configurations of the ground plane and bias pads. We found with the use of InductEx that the return current sometimes follows paths that are far from what intuition tells, which can lead to nonoptimized designs. In this paper, we emphasize the limitations due to the presence of external or internal magnetic fields. Then, we compare obtained performances with the ones with optimized geometries for which the presence of the magnetic field is taken into account from the design phase.
We have investigated the flux state in high- and low- T c SFQ circuits having superconducting ground planes with moats by a scanning SQUID microscope (SSM) system. Observation of YBa 2 Cu 3 O y (YBCO) sampler circuits having superconducting ground planes with 5 µm-wide moats confirmed that magnetic flux was excluded from the moat-surrounded area including ramp-edge Josephson junctions. The threshold value for complete flux exclusion was about 0.8 µT slightly depending on chips, which can be achieved readily with dual μ-metal magnetic shielding. Moreover, we have observed the flux state in Nb multilayer structures having a superconducting ground plane with 4 µm wide moats, which was designed and fabricated using the CONNECT cell library. It was confirmed that magnetic flux was trapped selectively into moats with appropriate configuration, which were fabricated within each 40 µm × 40 µm unit cell.