Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

A Philosophical Discussion of the Physical Limits

Farzad Sadjadi

Published Jan 1, 2003• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Any radar setup is limited by the physical properties of the electromagnetic radiation used to gather information about a target. Some of the limits on accuracy are due to the quantum nature of the photons, others due to the limitations of the electronic equipment used to perform the modulations. The techniques used to record the characteristics of the radiation are as important as the method by which that information is analyzed and interpreted. In each stage of the travels of the radiation, from creation and propagation to recording and analysis, the physical properties of the photons involved play a key role in the behavior of the radiation. The techniques by which these properties are modulated, monitored and recorded are also important. In this paper, these topics are discussed and weighed in detail. From this understanding of the flow of information a theoretical apparatus will be constructed that will be capable of recovering a maximum of that information for later use.

Related papers

Information retrievable from an image in natural light

Lev B. Levitin, Tommaso Toffoli

A most common way to store information is to encode it in the optical properties of an object and to retrieve it by viewing the object by reflected and transmitted natural (thermalized) light - or even by light emitted by the object itself - for a specified time interval. The discreteness of the radiation degrees of freedom and the statistical properties of thermal (incoherent) radiation impose limitations on the amount of the retrieved information. We derive the maximum information that can be retrieved from the object. This amount is always finite and is proportional to the area of the object, the solid angle under which the entrance pupil of the receiver is seen from the object, and the time of observation. An explicit expression for the information in the case where the information recorded by the receiver obeys Planck's spectral distribution is obtained. The amount of information per photon of recorded radiation is a universal numerical constant, independent of the parameters of observation.

International Conference on Advances in Computing, Communications and Informatics (ICACCI)•Aug 1, 2015•0 citations

Self-intervening Networks

George Jaroszkiewicz

Introduction In this chapter, we discuss some of the differences between apparatus and systems under observation (SUOs). The discussion is phrased in terms of self–intervening networks , wherein partial quantum outcomes in an early stage of an apparatus can alter future configurations of that apparatus. To explain what we mean, we introduce the following classification of experiments. Note that reference to apparatus here includes real and virtual detectors, and real and virtual modules. Virtual detectors and modules are mathematical fictions that are introduced into the formalism for convenience. Type-Zero Experiments Many important experiments involve signal propagation through “empty space.” We classify these as type zero (T0). The feature of T0 experiments qualifying for this classification is that the observer has no control of the modules in the information void. Examples are experiments in astrophysics, where the observer can choose which source to observe and how they observe it, but has no influence on the physical properties of whatever lies between source and detector. If there are gas clouds between source and detector, the observer can only recognize that fact after the experimental data are analyzed. An important modern variant of T0 experiments involves map location via the Global Positioning System (GPS): signals sent from Earth to geostationary satellites and received by mobile devices back on Earth have traveled through Earth's atmosphere and through empty space, where special relativistic and general relativistic effects have to be taken into account (Ashby, 2002). Before the rise of experimental science, most “experiments” were based on visual observations, which are principally of T0 classification. The advent of the telescope and the microscope did not change things in this respect. Indeed, it has been suggested that science did not progress in antiquity precisely because of the philosophical principle that the only valid experiments could be of T0, as these do not introduce the artificiality of constructed modules into observation, which (it was argued) would give a false perspective on “reality.” The logic of that argument is superb, but it is a dead-end principle in science. Several sciences such as geology, archaeology, and, indeed, cosmology started off with periods of basic observation rather than experimentation. During such initial stages of these sciences, the observations could be classified as T0 experiments.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 28, 2017•0 citations

Perspectives on The Quantum Electrodynamics of Detection

T. Kenneth Gustafson

Detection will be discussed from a broad perspective with particular emphasis on those aspects and questions which are of concern when the quantized nature of the radiation field is important.

Nonlinear Optical Properties of Materials•Jan 1, 1988•0 citations

10 Bohr’s legacy in Cavity QED

S. Haroche, J. M. Raimond

Bohr played a central role in the interpretation of quantum mechanics.He based many discussions of its strange consequences on thought experiments.He imagined moving slit interferometers, able to record which-path information, he played with photon boxes, storing photons for such long times that they could be weighed.The technological progress provided by quantum physics itself now make it possible to realize some of these thought experiments.We describe in this paper a few experiments based on microwave Cavity Quantum Electrodynamics (CQED) techniques.We trap photons in boxes and weigh them with scales at the atomic level.We are able to count the number of photons in the box without absorbing them in an ideal Quantum Non Demolition measurement of the field intensity.We can record which-path information in an atomic interferometer and directly illustrate complementarity.We can also prepare mesoscopic quantum superpositions reminiscent of the famous Schrödinger cat.We can get insight into the decoherence of these states and into ways to protect them, for instance by quantum feedback strategies.

EDP Sciences eBooks•Nov 4, 2020•1 citation

Historical introduction: photons and measurements using photons

Vladimir B. Braginsky, Farid Ya Khalili, Kip S. Thorne

In the standard, textbook treatment of quantum mechanics, the contact with experiment is described in terms of probabilities for obtaining this, that, or another result, when identical experiments are performed on a huge number (ensemble) of identical objects. Such an ensemble description was adequate during the first half century of quantum theory, because the technology of that era was incapable of making a measurement without destroying or severely changing the measured object (photon, atom, …). In recent years, however, advances in technology and technique have made possible repetitive quantum measurements on a single quantum object, with each measurement influencing the object only minimally. Such measurements cannot be analyzed using solely the ensemble theory. Additional theoretical concepts are needed. The purpose of this book is to describe the methods and theory of such measurements (as well as the more elementary theory of ensembles of measurements).

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 24, 1992•2 citations

What is a photon?

Oleg N Krokhin

Certain properties of photons viewed as quanta (particles of an electromagnetic field) are discussed. Specifically, the nature of localization (size) of photons along and across the direction of wave propagation is examined.

Bulletin of the Russian Academy of Sciences Physics•May 1, 2016•0 citations
Any radar setup is limited by the physical properties of the electromagnetic radiation used to gather information about a target. Some of the limits on accuracy are due to the quantum nature of the photons, others due to the limitations of the electronic equipment used to perform the modulations. The techniques used to record the characteristics of the radiation are as important as the method by which that information is analyzed and interpreted. In each stage of the travels of the radiation, from creation and propagation to recording and analysis, the physical properties of the photons involved play a key role in the behavior of the radiation. The techniques by which these properties are modulated, monitored and recorded are also important. In this paper, these topics are discussed and weighed in detail. From this understanding of the flow of information a theoretical apparatus will be constructed that will be capable of recovering a maximum of that information for later use.
A most common way to store information is to encode it in the optical properties of an object and to retrieve it by viewing the object by reflected and transmitted natural (thermalized) light - or even by light emitted by the object itself - for a specified time interval. The discreteness of the radiation degrees of freedom and the statistical properties of thermal (incoherent) radiation impose limitations on the amount of the retrieved information. We derive the maximum information that can be retrieved from the object. This amount is always finite and is proportional to the area of the object, the solid angle under which the entrance pupil of the receiver is seen from the object, and the time of observation. An explicit expression for the information in the case where the information recorded by the receiver obeys Planck's spectral distribution is obtained. The amount of information per photon of recorded radiation is a universal numerical constant, independent of the parameters of observation.
Introduction In this chapter, we discuss some of the differences between apparatus and systems under observation (SUOs). The discussion is phrased in terms of self–intervening networks , wherein partial quantum outcomes in an early stage of an apparatus can alter future configurations of that apparatus. To explain what we mean, we introduce the following classification of experiments. Note that reference to apparatus here includes real and virtual detectors, and real and virtual modules. Virtual detectors and modules are mathematical fictions that are introduced into the formalism for convenience. Type-Zero Experiments Many important experiments involve signal propagation through “empty space.” We classify these as type zero (T0). The feature of T0 experiments qualifying for this classification is that the observer has no control of the modules in the information void. Examples are experiments in astrophysics, where the observer can choose which source to observe and how they observe it, but has no influence on the physical properties of whatever lies between source and detector. If there are gas clouds between source and detector, the observer can only recognize that fact after the experimental data are analyzed. An important modern variant of T0 experiments involves map location via the Global Positioning System (GPS): signals sent from Earth to geostationary satellites and received by mobile devices back on Earth have traveled through Earth's atmosphere and through empty space, where special relativistic and general relativistic effects have to be taken into account (Ashby, 2002). Before the rise of experimental science, most “experiments” were based on visual observations, which are principally of T0 classification. The advent of the telescope and the microscope did not change things in this respect. Indeed, it has been suggested that science did not progress in antiquity precisely because of the philosophical principle that the only valid experiments could be of T0, as these do not introduce the artificiality of constructed modules into observation, which (it was argued) would give a false perspective on “reality.” The logic of that argument is superb, but it is a dead-end principle in science. Several sciences such as geology, archaeology, and, indeed, cosmology started off with periods of basic observation rather than experimentation. During such initial stages of these sciences, the observations could be classified as T0 experiments.
Bohr played a central role in the interpretation of quantum mechanics.He based many discussions of its strange consequences on thought experiments.He imagined moving slit interferometers, able to record which-path information, he played with photon boxes, storing photons for such long times that they could be weighed.The technological progress provided by quantum physics itself now make it possible to realize some of these thought experiments.We describe in this paper a few experiments based on microwave Cavity Quantum Electrodynamics (CQED) techniques.We trap photons in boxes and weigh them with scales at the atomic level.We are able to count the number of photons in the box without absorbing them in an ideal Quantum Non Demolition measurement of the field intensity.We can record which-path information in an atomic interferometer and directly illustrate complementarity.We can also prepare mesoscopic quantum superpositions reminiscent of the famous Schrödinger cat.We can get insight into the decoherence of these states and into ways to protect them, for instance by quantum feedback strategies.
In the standard, textbook treatment of quantum mechanics, the contact with experiment is described in terms of probabilities for obtaining this, that, or another result, when identical experiments are performed on a huge number (ensemble) of identical objects. Such an ensemble description was adequate during the first half century of quantum theory, because the technology of that era was incapable of making a measurement without destroying or severely changing the measured object (photon, atom, …). In recent years, however, advances in technology and technique have made possible repetitive quantum measurements on a single quantum object, with each measurement influencing the object only minimally. Such measurements cannot be analyzed using solely the ensemble theory. Additional theoretical concepts are needed. The purpose of this book is to describe the methods and theory of such measurements (as well as the more elementary theory of ensembles of measurements).