The context of an operational description is given by the distinction between what we consider as relevant and what as irrelevant for a particular experiment or observation. A rigorous description of a context in terms of a mathematically formulated context-independent fundamental theory is possible by the restriction of the domain of the basic theory and the introduction of a new coarser topology. Such a new topology is never given by first principles, but depends in a crucial way on the abstractions made by the cognitive apparatus or the pattern recognition devices used by the experimentalist. A consistent mathematical formulation of a higher-level theory requires the closure of the restriction of the basic theory in the new contextual topology. The validity domain of the so constructed higher-level theory intersects nontrivially with the validity domain of the basic theory: neither domain is contained in the other. Therefore, higher-level theories cannot be totally ordered and theory reduction is not transitive. The emergence of qualitatively new properties is a necessary consequence of such a formulation of theory reduction (which does not correspond to the traditional one). Emergent properties are not manifest on the level of the basic theory, but they can be derived rigorously by imposing new, contextually selected topologies upon context-independent first principles. Most intertheoretical relations are mathematically describable as singular asymptotic expansions which do not converge in the topology of the primary theory, or by choosing one of the infinitely many possible, physically inequivalent representations of the primary theory (Gelfand Naimark Segal-construction of algebraic quantum mechanics). As examples we discuss the emergence of shadows, inductors, capacitors and resistors from Maxwell's electrodynamics, the emergence of order parameters in statistical mechanics, the emergence of mass as a classical observable in Galilei-relativistic theories, the emergence of the shape of molecules in quantum mechanics, the emergence of temperature and other classical observables in algebraic quantum mechanics.
The context of an operational description is given by the distinction between what we consider as relevant and what as irrelevant for a particular experiment or observation. A rigorous description of a context in terms of a mathematically formulated context-independent fundamental theory is possible by the restriction of the domain of the basic theory and the introduction of a new coarser topology. Such a new topology is never given by first principles, but depends in a crucial way on the abstractions made by the cognitive apparatus or the pattern recognition devices used by the experimentalist. A consistent mathematical formulation of a higher-level theory requires the closure of the restriction of the basic theory in the new contextual topology. The validity domain of the so constructed higher-level theory intersects nontrivially with the validity domain of the basic theory: neither domain is contained in the other. Therefore, higher-level theories cannot be totally ordered and theory reduction is not transitive. The emergence of qualitatively new properties is a necessary consequence of such a formulation of theory reduction (which does not correspond to the traditional one). Emergent properties are not manifest on the level of the basic theory, but they can be derived rigorously by imposing new, contextually selected topologies upon context-independent first principles. Most intertheoretical relations are mathematically describable as singular asymptotic expansions which do not converge in the topology of the primary theory, or by choosing one of the infinitely many possible, physically inequivalent representations of the primary theory (Gelfand Naimark Segal-construction of algebraic quantum mechanics). As examples we discuss the emergence of shadows, inductors, capacitors and resistors from Maxwell's electrodynamics, the emergence of order parameters in statistical mechanics, the emergence of mass as a classical observable in Galilei-relativistic theories, the emergence of the shape of molecules in quantum mechanics, the emergence of temperature and other classical observables in algebraic quantum mechanics.
Abstract Even though physicists often claim that their theories can, in principle, be reduced to the supposedly most fundamental theory, which is quantum physics, a look at how physics is practiced reveals that this reduction is almost never performed. Instead, effective models are built that include various types of contextual information and that are often incompatible with the supposedly fundamental theory. The phenomena described by these models can be characterized as contextually emergent. This chapter illustrates contextual emergence by means of examples from different fields of physics. In quantum physics, explanations of the measurement process require the assumption of a classical context that specifies the observable being measured and that induces the measurement event. In condensed matter theory, we find many types of quasiparticles that can only exist due to the solid that embeds them and the structure of which determines the properties of the quasiparticles. In thermodynamics, state variables such as the pressure and temperature of a system are given by its environment, and its phase transitions are triggered by changes in the environment. In the early universe, the degrees of freedom and the density and temperature determine the types of particles that are found in the universe. Later, the overall properties of the universe determine whether matter can condense to form stars. From all this it follows that processes and descriptions at different scales are equally important in physics. There are even contextual influences from outside physics. The chapter will thus conclude that physics is not causally closed.
The general view is that all fundamental physical laws should be formulated within the framework given by quantum mechanics (QM). In a sense, QM therefore has the character of a metaphysical theory. Consequently, if it is possible to derive QM from more basic principles, these principles should be of general, philosophical nature. Here, we derive the formalism of QM from well-motivated epistemic principles. A key assumption is that a physical theory that relies on entities or distinctions that are unknowable in principle gives rise to wrong predictions. First, an epistemic formalism is developed, using concepts like knowledge and potential knowledge, identifying a physical state S with the potential knowledge of the physical world. It is demonstrated that QM emerges from this formalism. However, Hilbert spaces, wave functions and probabilities are defined in certain well-defined observational contexts only. This means that the epistemic formalism is broader than QM. In the fundamental layer of description, the physical state S is a subset of a state space S={Z}, such that S always contains many elements Z. These elements correspond to unattainable states of complete knowledge of the world. The evolution of S cannot be determined in terms of the individual evolution of the elements Z, unlike the evolution of an ensemble in classical phase space. The evolution of S is described in terms of sequential time n∈N, which is updated according to n→n+1 each time an event occurs, each time potential knowledge changes. Sequential time n can be separated from relational time t, which describes distances between events in space-time. There is an entire space-time associated with each n, in which t represents the knowledge at sequential time n about the temporal relations between present and past events.
This author has been engaged over the past several years in the effort to develop certain basic intuitions into a fully mathematical theory. These evolving intuitions first began with the idea that the economist's notion of utility might more truly be represented mathematically by a normed measure on the commodity space rather than by a point function, the value of the measure on a particular set of goods having the sense of a relative propensity of the individual to select a good in that set. With this idea there came in turn, quite naturally, the insight that utility and probability are one and the same thing. And accordingly it emerged that the theory we were seeking would not be restricted to the economic behavior of human beings, nor even to the behavior in general of human beings: it would pertain, in utmost generality, to all behavior of all systems. Thus, it must affirm that all behavior is the evolution of stochastic processes, and that all systems are stochastic processes. Consistent with this the structural elements of stochastic processes are seen as the fundamental, objective, real entities, the ultimate building-blocks of reality. These are eventualities and acts and-according to the traditional mathematical representation of stochastic processes, also-probabilities. This structural aspect of the theory under development puts into sharp evidence its wide divergence from the classical scientific conception of reality. Our intensive search failed to discover a dynamical law for the proposed new theory within the mathematical context of the traditional, σ-field-real-valued-measure representation of stochastic processes. We therefore have gone on to a higher level of possible mathematical representation. This particular representation would have collections of eventualities represented by lattices of certain configurations in a unitary space. Closed linear manifolds are among these configurations, and indeed the formalism of quantum mechanics falls into the context of this representation. But the general lattice element in the kinds of lattices being investigated is more complicated than a linear manifold, being heuristically comparable with an acute-angle cone of vectors. These configurations are formulated by means of a ƒlanking relation between linear manifolds. One such lattice has been developed. Others are currently being sought through variations on the notion of flanking. The fact that probabilities present themselves in the unitary space representation-as is familiar from quantum mechanics-as parameters of the relationship between linear manifolds suggests that probability is not a fundamental structural concept. It is consequently indicated that eventualities and acts alone are the basic elements of real structure. Accordingly, the dynamical law must be formulable in terms of these elements only. There is a natural suggestion of what the law might look like. Even at the present early stage of development of the new theory being sought it is possible to cite many pieces of empirical evidence vouching for its exclusive validity. Such evidence is particularly noteworthy in the domain of human behavior.
Emergent Causality from Decoherence: A Postulated Regime with an Explicit Conjecture An imaginary hypothesis, not a theory. This is the third revision. It corrects the definition of causality, changes the parameter, acknowledges the circularity of time, and states the conjecture explicitly. It is still a hypothesis, not a theory. ________________________________________ Abstract This manuscript proposes that classical causality is not fundamental but emergent, arising from the degree of decoherence of a system. We define causality as definite causal order between events. We choose a decoherence parameter that is basis-dependent and dimension-independent: the interference suppression factor relative to the pointer basis. We postulate (not derive) that definite causal order emerges when this parameter exceeds a critical value. We acknowledge the circularity of time, the lack of a full mathematical derivation, and the absence of experimental confirmation. We add an explicit conjecture connecting the parameter to the process-matrix formalism of Oreshkov, Costa and Brukner. The hypothesis is offered as a framework for critique and development. ________________________________________ 1. Introduction The nature of causality remains an open problem in physics. In quantum mechanics, there are correlations, not causes in the classical sense. In classical physics, causality is absolute and local. These descriptions do not obviously fit together. This manuscript proposes that classical causality is not a fundamental property of the universe, but a property of the level of description. It emerges from the degree of decoherence of a system, in a manner analogous to how temperature emerges from the collective behaviour of many particles. The hypothesis is labelled "imaginary" because it lacks full mathematical formalism, experimental confirmation, and a resolution of the circularity of time. It is offered as a framework for critique, not as a completed theory. Scope: This hypothesis addresses only the transition between the quantum regime (no definite causal order) and the classical regime (definite causal order). It does not address the relativistic regime. ________________________________________ 2. Defining "Causality" In this manuscript, "causality" means definite causal order between events. That is: for any two events A and B, either A precedes B, or B precedes A. Not intervention. Not deterministic evolution. Definite order. This definition is chosen because it is the one that can be connected to the process-matrix formalism (Oreshkov et al., 2012), and because it is the one that emerges in the classical limit. Other definitions (interventionist causation, deterministic evolution) are distinct and are not addressed here. This is a choice. Other definitions are possible. This choice is made for definiteness. ________________________________________ 3. The Parameter The central parameter is the degree of decoherence, γ. We choose a specific measure: the interference suppression factor relative to the pointer basis. This measure is: • Basis-dependent. It is defined relative to the pointer basis selected by the environment. • Dimension-independent. It is a ratio (a contrast), not an absolute quantity, so it ranges from 0 to 1 regardless of the dimension of the Hilbert space. • Explicit about the cut. It requires specifying the system, the environment, and the pointer basis. This measure is chosen over purity because purity has three defects: it depends on dimension, it is basis-independent, and it presupposes an unspecified system-environment cut. The interference suppression factor does not have these defects. This is a choice. Other measures are possible. This choice is made for definiteness, not because it is uniquely correct. ________________________________________ 4. The Postulate (Not a Derivation) With this parameter, we postulate that classical causality emerges when γ exceeds a critical value, γ_c. Below γ_c, the system is in a quantum regime: correlations without definite causal order. Above γ_c, the system is in a classical regime: definite causal order. This is not a derivation from first principles. It is a postulate. But it is a postulate with a defined parameter. And it is a starting point. The intermediate regime is not derived. It is postulated as a transition. And it is acknowledged that this placement is in tension with established physics: relativistic causal structure is a property of the spacetime metric, not of partial decoherence. This hypothesis does not address the relativistic regime. It addresses only the transition between the quantum regime (no definite causal order) and the classical regime (definite causal order). ________________________________________ 5. Co-Emergence (and the Circularity of Time) This hypothesis proposes that causality and the arrow of time co-emerge from decoherence. Neither is prior. Neither is the cause of the other. They emerge together. This is a conjecture, not a derivation. And it is acknowledged that this position is in tension with the literature: Oreshkov et al. (2012) suggest that the arrow of time produces causal order, not that they co-emerge. The difference is subtle but important: if the arrow of time is prior, then time is more fundamental than causality. If they co-emerge, neither is more fundamental. The circularity of time is not resolved. Decoherence presupposes time. The arrow of time is traced to a low-entropy initial condition, not to decoherence itself. The hypothesis does not resolve this circularity. It assumes it. ________________________________________ 6. Confrontation with the Literature The hypothesis is placed against the established literature. We do not confront as attacks, nor attempt to surpass. We use as anchors. • Zurek (2003), "Decoherence, einselection, and the quantum origins of the classical," Rev. Mod. Phys. 75, 715. Zurek shows that decoherence selects a small set of stable states (pointer states) and that the combination of einselection with dynamics leads to the emergence of classical phase-space structure. This hypothesis assumes, as an additional premise, that classical dynamics is causal. This premise is not derived from Zurek. It is an independent claim, and it is the weakest point in the argumentative chain. If the premise is true, then causality emerges from decoherence. If it is false, the hypothesis fails. • Gell-Mann and Hartle (1994, 2014), "Quasiclassical Realms in a Quantum Universe" (gr-qc/9404017) and "Adaptive Coarse Graining, Environment, Strong Decoherence, and Quasiclassical Realms" (arXiv:1312.7454). These works derive classical deterministic time-correlations and the fixed-past/open-future asymmetry from coarse-graining and strong decoherence, with no observer. The present hypothesis is close to this programme. It differs in framing the result as "emergent causality" rather than "quasiclassical realms." The substance is similar. • Oreshkov, Costa, and Brukner (2012), "Quantum correlations with no causal order," Nature Communications 3, 1092. DOI: 10.1038/ncomms2076. This work constructs correlations with no definite causal order and shows that definite order is recovered in a classical limit. The present hypothesis is consistent with this, but does not engage with the formalism. A conjecture connecting the two is offered in Section 7. • Page and Wootters (1983), "Evolution without evolution: Dynamics described by stationary observables," Phys. Rev. D 27, 2885. This work obtains time from entanglement with an internal clock. The present hypothesis does not address this. It assumes time as a parameter. • Joos and Zeh (1985), "The emergence of classical properties through interaction with the environment," Z. Phys. B 59, 223. Foundational work on decoherence in open quantum systems. • Rovelli (1996), "Relational quantum mechanics," Int. J. Theor. Phys. 35, 1637. Relational quantum mechanics holds that states are relational, not absolute. The present hypothesis extends this to causality: if states are relational, perhaps causal structure is too. But the extension is not derived. It is proposed. • Schlosshauer (2005), "Decoherence, the measurement problem, and interpretations of quantum mechanics," Rev. Mod. Phys. 76, 1267. A review of decoherence and its interpretational implications. • Allen, Barrett, Horsman, Lee, and Spekkens (2017), "Quantum Common Causes and Quantum Causal Models," Phys. Rev. X 7, 031021. This work defines interventionist causation in quantum mechanics. The present hypothesis uses a different definition (definite causal order), but acknowledges that other definitions are possible. The honest assessment: The hypothesis is not new in its intuition. It is new in its emphasis on causality as the emergent property, and in its attempt to frame the quantum-classical transition as a causal transition. But the emphasis is not a theory, and the transition is not derived. ________________________________________ 7. Conjecture: Connection with the Process-Matrix Formalism Oreshkov, Costa and Brukner (2012) have shown that, if one does not assume a global causal order, there exist quantum correlations that violate the causal inequality. These correlations are described by process matrices that are causally non-separable. In a classical limit, causal order emerges. This hypothesis proposes, as a conjecture, that the causally non-separable process matrix could correspond to γ = 0 (no decoherence, no definite causal order). The causally separable process matrix could correspond to γ > γ_c (sufficient decoherence, emergent causal order). The quantum-to-classical transition mentioned by Oreshkov et al. could be the transition in γ. This is a conjecture. It is not derived. There is no formalism that supports it. It is offered as a direction for future work: if someone with the appropriate mathematical tools wishes to attempt the connection, here is the intuition. And here is the criterion for
Emergent Causality from Decoherence: A Postulated Regime with an Explicit Conjecture An imaginary hypothesis, not a theory. This is the third revision. It corrects the definition of causality, changes the parameter, acknowledges the circularity of time, and states the conjecture explicitly. It is still a hypothesis, not a theory. Abstract This manuscript proposes that classical causality is not fundamental but emergent, arising from the degree of decoherence of a system. We define causality as definite causal order between events. We choose a decoherence parameter that is basis-dependent and dimension-independent: the interference suppression factor relative to the pointer basis. We postulate (not derive) that definite causal order emerges when this parameter exceeds a critical value. We acknowledge the circularity of time, the lack of a full mathematical derivation, and the absence of experimental confirmation. We add an explicit conjecture connecting the parameter to the process-matrix formalism of Oreshkov, Costa and Brukner. The hypothesis is offered as a framework for critique and development. 1. Introduction The nature of causality remains an open problem in physics. In quantum mechanics, there are correlations, not causes in the classical sense. In classical physics, causality is absolute and local. These descriptions do not obviously fit together. This manuscript proposes that classical causality is not a fundamental property of the universe, but a property of the level of description. It emerges from the degree of decoherence of a system, in a manner analogous to how temperature emerges from the collective behaviour of many particles. The hypothesis is labelled "imaginary" because it lacks full mathematical formalism, experimental confirmation, and a resolution of the circularity of time. It is offered as a framework for critique, not as a completed theory. Scope: This hypothesis addresses only the transition between the quantum regime (no definite causal order) and the classical regime (definite causal order). It does not address the relativistic regime. 2. Defining "Causality" In this manuscript, "causality" means definite causal order between events. That is: for any two events A and B, either A precedes B, or B precedes A. Not intervention. Not deterministic evolution. Definite order. This definition is chosen because it is the one that can be connected to the process-matrix formalism (Oreshkov et al., 2012), and because it is the one that emerges in the classical limit. Other definitions (interventionist causation, deterministic evolution) are distinct and are not addressed here. This is a choice. Other definitions are possible. This choice is made for definiteness. 3. The Parameter The central parameter is the degree of decoherence, γ. We choose a specific measure: the interference suppression factor relative to the pointer basis. This measure is: Basis-dependent. It is defined relative to the pointer basis selected by the environment. Dimension-independent. It is a ratio (a contrast), not an absolute quantity, so it ranges from 0 to 1 regardless of the dimension of the Hilbert space. Explicit about the cut. It requires specifying the system, the environment, and the pointer basis. This measure is chosen over purity because purity has three defects: it depends on dimension, it is basis-independent, and it presupposes an unspecified system-environment cut. The interference suppression factor does not have these defects. This is a choice. Other measures are possible. This choice is made for definiteness, not because it is uniquely correct. 4. The Postulate (Not a Derivation) With this parameter, we postulate that classical causality emerges when γ exceeds a critical value, γ_c. Below γ_c, the system is in a quantum regime: correlations without definite causal order. Above γ_c, the system is in a classical regime: definite causal order. This is not a derivation from first principles. It is a postulate. But it is a postulate with a defined parameter. And it is a starting point. The intermediate regime is not derived. It is postulated as a transition. And it is acknowledged that this placement is in tension with established physics: relativistic causal structure is a property of the spacetime metric, not of partial decoherence. This hypothesis does not address the relativistic regime. It addresses only the transition between the quantum regime (no definite causal order) and the classical regime (definite causal order). 5. Co-Emergence (and the Circularity of Time) This hypothesis proposes that causality and the arrow of time co-emerge from decoherence. Neither is prior. Neither is the cause of the other. They emerge together. This is a conjecture, not a derivation. And it is acknowledged that this position is in tension with the literature: Oreshkov et al. (2012) suggest that the arrow of time produces causal order, not that they co-emerge. The difference is subtle but important: if the arrow of time is prior, then time is more fundamental than causality. If they co-emerge, neither is more fundamental. The circularity of time is not resolved. Decoherence presupposes time. The arrow of time is traced to a low-entropy initial condition, not to decoherence itself. The hypothesis does not resolve this circularity. It assumes it. 6. Confrontation with the Literature The hypothesis is placed against the established literature. We do not confront as attacks, nor attempt to surpass. We use as anchors. Zurek (2003), "Decoherence, einselection, and the quantum origins of the classical," Rev. Mod. Phys. 75, 715. Zurek shows that decoherence selects a small set of stable states (pointer states) and that the combination of einselection with dynamics leads to the emergence of classical phase-space structure. This hypothesis assumes, as an additional premise, that classical dynamics is causal. This premise is not derived from Zurek. It is an independent claim, and it is the weakest point in the argumentative chain. If the premise is true, then causality emerges from decoherence. If it is false, the hypothesis fails. Gell-Mann and Hartle (1994, 2014), "Quasiclassical Realms in a Quantum Universe" (gr-qc/9404017) and "Adaptive Coarse Graining, Environment, Strong Decoherence, and Quasiclassical Realms" (arXiv:1312.7454). These works derive classical deterministic time-correlations and the fixed-past/open-future asymmetry from coarse-graining and strong decoherence, with no observer. The present hypothesis is close to this programme. It differs in framing the result as "emergent causality" rather than "quasiclassical realms." The substance is similar. Oreshkov, Costa, and Brukner (2012), "Quantum correlations with no causal order," Nature Communications 3, 1092. DOI: 10.1038/ncomms2076. This work constructs correlations with no definite causal order and shows that definite order is recovered in a classical limit. The present hypothesis is consistent with this, but does not engage with the formalism. A conjecture connecting the two is offered in Section 7. Page and Wootters (1983), "Evolution without evolution: Dynamics described by stationary observables," Phys. Rev. D 27, 2885. This work obtains time from entanglement with an internal clock. The present hypothesis does not address this. It assumes time as a parameter. Joos and Zeh (1985), "The emergence of classical properties through interaction with the environment," Z. Phys. B 59, 223. Foundational work on decoherence in open quantum systems. Rovelli (1996), "Relational quantum mechanics," Int. J. Theor. Phys. 35, 1637. Relational quantum mechanics holds that states are relational, not absolute. The present hypothesis extends this to causality: if states are relational, perhaps causal structure is too. But the extension is not derived. It is proposed. Schlosshauer (2005), "Decoherence, the measurement problem, and interpretations of quantum mechanics," Rev. Mod. Phys. 76, 1267. A review of decoherence and its interpretational implications. Allen, Barrett, Horsman, Lee, and Spekkens (2017), "Quantum Common Causes and Quantum Causal Models," Phys. Rev. X 7, 031021. This work defines interventionist causation in quantum mechanics. The present hypothesis uses a different definition (definite causal order), but acknowledges that other definitions are possible. The honest assessment: The hypothesis is not new in its intuition. It is new in its emphasis on causality as the emergent property, and in its attempt to frame the quantum-classical transition as a causal transition. But the emphasis is not a theory, and the transition is not derived. 7. Conjecture: Connection with the Process-Matrix Formalism Oreshkov, Costa and Brukner (2012) have shown that, if one does not assume a global causal order, there exist quantum correlations that violate the causal inequality. These correlations are described by process matrices that are causally non-separable. In a classical limit, causal order emerges. This hypothesis proposes, as a conjecture, that the causally non-separable process matrix could correspond to γ = 0 (no decoherence, no definite causal order). The causally separable process matrix could correspond to γ > γ_c (sufficient decoherence, emergent causal order). The quantum-to-classical transition mentioned by Oreshkov et al. could be the transition in γ. This is a conjecture. It is not derived. There is no formalism that supports it. It is offered as a direction for future work: if someone with the appropriate mathematical tools wishes to attempt the connection, here is the intuition. And here is the criterion for success: if the connection is derived, the hypothesis gains. If it is not, it loses. Both outcomes are valuable. 8. The Limits (and the Doors) The hypothesis has several limits, acknowledged here: The parameter is chosen, not derived. The interference suppression factor is one m
This work introduces the Universal Principle of Algebraic Formalization (PUFA), formulated in an axiomatic–theorematic framework grounded in C*-algebra theory and operator algebras. The principle states that observable systems whose operations admit composition, involution, and completeness can be faithfully represented as subalgebras of operators on Hilbert spaces, allowing the emergence of dynamics, states, entropy, measurement, and composition from established mathematical results, including the Gelfand–Naimark–Segal construction, Tomita–Takesaki modular theory, Stinespring dilation, and the KMS equilibrium condition. The article proposes PUFA as a methodological protocol for formalization, enabling qualitative domains to be translated into algebraic structures with deductive consistency. The work explicitly distinguishes between rigorously demonstrated mathematical components, epistemological modeling hypotheses, and interpretative or ontological layers. Illustrative applications are developed across six domains—physics, political systems, the psyche, economics, music, and topological economics—aiming to demonstrate the structural generality of the framework while preserving the distinction between formal consistency and empirical validation. The PUFA framework is positioned at the intersection of functional analysis, mathematical physics, information theory, and systems theory, proposing a unified formal language for structural comparison across heterogeneous domains while maintaining explicit limits regarding empirical applicability and interpretation.