Abstract Even though physicists often claim that their theories can, in principle, be reduced to the supposedly most fundamental theory, which is quantum physics, a look at how physics is practiced reveals that this reduction is almost never performed. Instead, effective models are built that include various types of contextual information and that are often incompatible with the supposedly fundamental theory. The phenomena described by these models can be characterized as contextually emergent. This chapter illustrates contextual emergence by means of examples from different fields of physics. In quantum physics, explanations of the measurement process require the assumption of a classical context that specifies the observable being measured and that induces the measurement event. In condensed matter theory, we find many types of quasiparticles that can only exist due to the solid that embeds them and the structure of which determines the properties of the quasiparticles. In thermodynamics, state variables such as the pressure and temperature of a system are given by its environment, and its phase transitions are triggered by changes in the environment. In the early universe, the degrees of freedom and the density and temperature determine the types of particles that are found in the universe. Later, the overall properties of the universe determine whether matter can condense to form stars. From all this it follows that processes and descriptions at different scales are equally important in physics. There are even contextual influences from outside physics. The chapter will thus conclude that physics is not causally closed.
Abstract Even though physicists often claim that their theories can, in principle, be reduced to the supposedly most fundamental theory, which is quantum physics, a look at how physics is practiced reveals that this reduction is almost never performed. Instead, effective models are built that include various types of contextual information and that are often incompatible with the supposedly fundamental theory. The phenomena described by these models can be characterized as contextually emergent. This chapter illustrates contextual emergence by means of examples from different fields of physics. In quantum physics, explanations of the measurement process require the assumption of a classical context that specifies the observable being measured and that induces the measurement event. In condensed matter theory, we find many types of quasiparticles that can only exist due to the solid that embeds them and the structure of which determines the properties of the quasiparticles. In thermodynamics, state variables such as the pressure and temperature of a system are given by its environment, and its phase transitions are triggered by changes in the environment. In the early universe, the degrees of freedom and the density and temperature determine the types of particles that are found in the universe. Later, the overall properties of the universe determine whether matter can condense to form stars. From all this it follows that processes and descriptions at different scales are equally important in physics. There are even contextual influences from outside physics. The chapter will thus conclude that physics is not causally closed.
Emergent Causality Through Decoherence An imaginary hypothesis, not a theory. What if causality were not fundamental? What if it emerged, like temperature, from the degree of decoherence in a system? This hypothesis proposes that there is no single causality, but three regimes of the same process. The core idea:There is no single causality. There are causalities that emerge according to the degree of decoherence in a system. In other words: causality is not a property of the universe. It is a property of the level of description. The three regimes: Quantum causality (zero or low decoherence). The system is isolated. What exists are pure correlations: entanglement, superposition. There is no causality in the classical sense. There is correlation without direction. There is no defined "before" or "after." Relativistic causality (medium decoherence). The system interacts with the environment, but not completely. There is a causal structure defined by spacetime. There is causality, but it is relative: it depends on the observer. Classical causality (high decoherence). The system is fully coupled to the environment. It is classical. There is absolute, local causality: cause → effect, without ambiguity. The mechanism: decoherence.The more degrees of freedom interact with the system, the more decoherence. More decoherence → more classical → more causal. There is no "line" that is crossed. There is a continuum. Causality emerges gradually, just as temperature emerges from the number of particles. Why this makes the three regimes fit together: They are not separate levels. They are degrees of the same process. Time emerges together with causality. Without decoherence, there is no defined time. With decoherence, irreversibility emerges. And with it, the arrow of time. Relativity is the intermediate regime. What it would resolve: The problem of time: it emerges with decoherence. The arrow of time: it is the irreversibility of decoherence. The relativity–quantum clash: it is not a clash. They are different regimes of the same process. Causality: it is not fundamental. It is emergent. What it does not resolve: What decoherence exactly is. How to quantize gravity. Why there is decoherence. The information paradox. The label (important):This is an imaginary hypothesis, not a theory. It is coherent with what we know, but it is not demonstrated. It lacks mathematics, predictions, and confirmation. It does not say that time does not exist. It says that time could emerge. It does not say that causality does not exist. It says that causality could emerge. All of this, if one takes decoherence seriously, without adding anything else. But no one has demonstrated it. That is why it is a hypothesis, not a theory. A note on the anchor:This hypothesis does not invent its premise. It takes it from established physics: quantum mechanics already treats information as correlation, not as substance. Entanglement is pure correlation. Decoherence is entanglement with the environment. If information is always relational, then causality could be relational too. Related work: "Measure Reinforcement: Emergent Causality From Quantum Interactions" (Zenodo, 2025). Proposes emergent causality from quantum interactions without predefined time. Difference: includes a conscious observer. This hypothesis does not. Here decoherence is the mechanism, without consciousness. "Spacetime as an Emergent Causal Structure: A Quantum Mechanical Perspective" (Preprints.org, 2026). Derives proper time from the degree of decoherence. Difference: focuses on time, not causality as a regime. This hypothesis unifies the three regimes (quantum, relativistic, classical) into a single continuum. "Causal Space-Time: Emergent Physics from Causality" (2010). Proposes that physics emerges from a causal network. Difference: opposite direction. There causality is fundamental; here it emerges from decoherence. "Radial Coherential Dynamics: Emergent Causality" (2025). Proposes collapse as a decoherence front that generates time and causality. Difference: it is radial and has specific predictions. This hypothesis is more general: it describes causality as a regime of description, not as a radial process. The gap: no one has unified the three regimes (quantum, relativistic, classical) into a continuum parametrized by the degree of decoherence, nor has proposed that causality is a property of the level of description, not of the universe. Keywords: decoherence, emergent causality, quantum mechanics, foundations of physics, emergent time, quantum-classical transition.
The context of an operational description is given by the distinction between what we consider as relevant and what as irrelevant for a particular experiment or observation. A rigorous description of a context in terms of a mathematically formulated context-independent fundamental theory is possible by the restriction of the domain of the basic theory and the introduction of a new coarser topology. Such a new topology is never given by first principles, but depends in a crucial way on the abstractions made by the cognitive apparatus or the pattern recognition devices used by the experimentalist. A consistent mathematical formulation of a higher-level theory requires the closure of the restriction of the basic theory in the new contextual topology. The validity domain of the so constructed higher-level theory intersects nontrivially with the validity domain of the basic theory: neither domain is contained in the other. Therefore, higher-level theories cannot be totally ordered and theory reduction is not transitive. The emergence of qualitatively new properties is a necessary consequence of such a formulation of theory reduction (which does not correspond to the traditional one). Emergent properties are not manifest on the level of the basic theory, but they can be derived rigorously by imposing new, contextually selected topologies upon context-independent first principles. Most intertheoretical relations are mathematically describable as singular asymptotic expansions which do not converge in the topology of the primary theory, or by choosing one of the infinitely many possible, physically inequivalent representations of the primary theory (Gelfand Naimark Segal-construction of algebraic quantum mechanics). As examples we discuss the emergence of shadows, inductors, capacitors and resistors from Maxwell's electrodynamics, the emergence of order parameters in statistical mechanics, the emergence of mass as a classical observable in Galilei-relativistic theories, the emergence of the shape of molecules in quantum mechanics, the emergence of temperature and other classical observables in algebraic quantum mechanics.
Quantum mechanics has achieved unparalleled success as an operational theory, describing a wide range of experiments to remarkable accuracy. However, the physical foundations on which it rests remain as puzzling as they were a century ago, and a concise statement of the physical principles that underlie quantum mechanics is still outstanding. One promising approach holds that these principles should be formulated in terms of information, since many of the counter-intuitive effects in quantum theory concern questions such as what one can know about a quantum system and how the information encoded therein can be processed and distributed between parties. Another challenging feature of quantum theory is its incompatibility with the other cornerstone of modern physics, general relativity. In order to reconcile the two, one must identify and retain only the essential concepts and principles of each theory, and in the case of general relativity, causality has been identified as such a concept. This raises the question of how our classical understanding of causality must change when quantum theory is taken into account. In order to address these questions about information, knowledge and causality, I turn to the framework of causal models. In classical statistics, causal models explain the relations among a set of variables in terms of causal influences, which makes them a powerful tool for structuring our knowledge about complex systems and developing strategies for interacting with them. More importantly, the framework provides the conceptual underpinnings and mathematical methods for addressing questions about causation, information and knowledge in a rigorous manner. In this thesis, I develop a version of the classical causal models framework that is compatible with quantum theory and explore its physical implications. \n \n \nA first step is to define quantum versions of fundamental elements such as variables, conditionals and belief propagation rules. This allows one to consider the question of what one can come to know about a quantum variable from the point of view of causal modelling. The conditionals relating quantum variables are found to have a richer structure than their classical counterparts, which can be exploited for the task of discerning causal relations given limited data -- a central problem in classical causal modelling. The mathematical properties of quantum conditionals also establish a correspondence between various classes of two-party correlations, such as bound and distillable entanglement, and the types of causal structures that can give rise to them, which may become a useful tool for entanglement theory and quantum information processing. In the context of open quantum systems dynamics, quantum causal models provide a clear physical explanation of not completely positive maps and, more broadly, of non-Markovian quantum dynamics. Finally, I consider the possibility of non-classical effects in the way that different causal mechanisms are combined -- that is, non-classical causal structures. For the simple case of two causally ordered variables, I propose indicators that witness different classes of combinations of causal mechanisms, including a non-classical mixture, and describe an experiment realizing examples of the different classes. \n \n \nAs these results illustrate, the framework of quantum causal models provides both greater conceptual clarity and a comprehensive mathematical formalism for studying a diverse set of problems, ranging from foundational questions to applications in open systems dynamics and the exploration of non-classical causal structures, which are likely to feature in a future theory of quantum gravity. The material presented in this thesis is intended as a foundation and inspiration for further applications of quantum causal models.
This short review paper is devoted to 90th anniversary of S.T. Belyaev birthday. Belyaev’s ideas associated with the condensate state in Bose interacting systems have stimulated intensive studies of the possible manifestation of such a condensation in Fermi systems. In many Fermi systems and compounds at zero temperature a phase transition happens that leads to a quite specific state called fermion condensation. As a signal of such a fermion condensation quantum phase transition (FCQPT) serves unlimited increase of the effective mass of quasiparticles that determines the excitation spectrum and creates flat bands. We show that the class of Fermi liquids with the fermion condensate forms a new state of matter. We discuss the phase diagrams and the physical properties of systems located near that phase transition. A common and essential feature of such systems is quasiparticles different from those suggested by L.D. Landau by crucial dependence of their effective mass on temperature, external magnetic field, pressure, etc. It is demonstrated that a huge amount of experimental data collected on different compounds suggest that they, starting from some temperature and down, form the new state of matter, and are governed by the fermion condensation. Our discussion shows that the theory of fermion condensation develops completely good description of the NFL behavior of strongly correlated Fermi systems. Moreover, the fermion condensation can be considered as the universal reason for the NFL behavior observed in various HF metals, liquids, compounds with quantum spin liquids, and quasicrystals. We show that these systems exhibit universal scaling behavior of their thermodynamic properties. Therefore, the quantum critical physics of different strongly correlated compounds is universal, and emerges regardless of the underlying microscopic details of the compounds. This uniform behavior, governed by the universal quantum critical physics, allows us to view it as the main characteristic of the new state of matter.
In this digital age, machine learning (a prominent element within the context of artificial intelligence) has become an integral part of modern life, influencing various aspects of our daily activities.The predictive power of these tools is increasing with the advancements in algorithms, increased computational power, and the availability of large data sets: one basic example of this is language-based models, which have revolutionized our capabilities of transferring and processing information.Data is the foundational element of machine learning, and the quality and relevance of the data sets have a profound impact on the performance and accuracy of machine learning models.Thus "data is the new gold", captures the immense value that data holds in our modern world.With the exponential growth in data, the increasing demand for better machine-learning tools comes as a natural consequence.The field of physics is no exception to this, especially with the rise of big simulations and experiments generating huge amounts of data.Experiments at particle accelerators like the Large Hadron Collider(LHC) and Fermi lab, gravitational waves detector by LIGO and Virgo, climate models and weather simulations, Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS), Cosmic Microwave Background(CMB) radiation providing insights into the early universe; all these studies generate massive data sets.In this context, developing more powerful, accurate, and specialized tools, is essential to meet the evolving needs in physics as well.In this thesis, we aim to study different types of ML tools to characterize the many-body problem in the context of classical and quantum statistical mechanics, with a focus on unbiased and interpretable methods.We use techniques coming from so-called non-parametric learning (NPL), where the analysis is done without specifying a fixed set of parameters in an assumption-free vi manner.NPL is a subset of the broad unsupervised learning category; the algorithm learns from the intrinsic structure of the data set.NPL is particularly valuable in scenarios where data assumptions are uncertain, data distributions are non-standard, or when dealing with complex data sets where relationships are difficult to predict beforehand.This works in our favor as the relation between data sets coming from many-body physics system and their effect on data structures when physical parameters change is not well understood -the simple reason being that the typical physicists mindset is very much focused on performing huge dimensional reduction from microscopic physical information (a canonical example of this being mean field theories, where the behavior of a large number of degrees of freedom is replaced by a single one).The thesis is organized as follows.In Chapter 1, we discuss the theoretical framework behind the NPL methods used.We present basic ideas in our methodologies, which encompass the overarching principles guiding our approach.These include the linkage between statistical physics and data analysis, particularly in relation to intrinsic dimension (Id) and its significance in understanding critical characteristics.Additionally, we delve into the application of Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and introduce the notion of PCA entropy -a witness of information spreading under linear transformation, whose relevance to physical phenomena we start investigating here.In Chapter 2, we describe the data sets we work with; statistical mechanics inspired data sets, such as those generated via sampling classical Ising models through advanced Monte Carlo algorithms, and experimental data of a spinor Bose-Einstein condensate.The following chapters present the applications I worked on.In Chapter 3, we present and thoroughly assess a framework for understanding critical behavior in classical partition functions by employing NPL techniques on data sets containing thermal configurations; provide a robust analysis of phase transitions using different NPL methods.In Chapter 4, we present a theoretical framework for information extraction in synthetic quantum matter for the case of a quantum quench in a spinor Bose-Einstein vii condensate experiment.In Chapter 5, we demonstrate how the field of network science can significantly improve and elevate our assumption-free characterization of various phases of matter.We present compelling evidence that network science offers a transparent and effective set of methods for investigating the properties of distinct phases and phase transitions, enabling us to identify critical points.
At each level of hierarchy, especially in the relevant energies for the phenomena under study, various concepts and entities of physics emerge. While reducible to other levels that are smaller in size or higher in energy, many of those degrees of freedom are frozen and do not come into play, so that it is the emergent entities that are relevant. With examples such as temperature and phases of matter, this approach to complexity is seen as fundamental, with lessons also for emergent concepts in other sciences. In blurring over the coherences of quantum wave functions, classical mechanics,with its familiar concepts of position, momentum etc., is itself emergent from quantum physics. Much of the mystery of quantum physics lies in this distinction between the underlying reality, which is out of reach directly, but accessible only through these emergent concepts, however natural they may appear.