Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

On wave packet reduction in the Coleman–Hepp model

J. S. Bell

Published Jun 3, 2004• 124 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In a very elegant and rigorous paper, K. Hepp has discussed quantum measurement theory. He uses the C* algebra description of infinite quantum systems. Here an attempt is made to give a more popular account of some of his reasoning. Such an attempt seems worthwhile because many people not familiar with the C* algebra approach, and even somewhat intimidated by it, have been intrigued by the following statement in Hepp's abstract:

DOI
10.1017/cbo9780511815676.008

Related papers

Quantum dynamics and decoherence in generalized Coleman-Hepp model and boson detector model

Sachiko Kitajima, C. Takahashi, Fumio Shibata

The European Physical Journal D•Aug 9, 2004•9 citations

Quantum theory of measurement without wave packet collapse

Marcello Cini

Il Nuovo cimento della Società italiana di fisica. B/Il Nuovo cimento B•Jan 1, 1983•103 citations

On Wave Packet Reduction in the Coleman–Hepp Model

J. S. Bell

The quantum mechanical measurement problem is considered in a model due to Hepp and Coleman. Whereas Hepp emphasized a ‘rigorous “reduction of the wave packet”’, in a certain mathematical limit, it is emphasized here that no such reduction ever actually occurs. Some general remarks are made on the advantages of the Heisenberg picture for such considerations, especially in connection with extension to relativistic theories. The non-reduction of the wave packet is directly related to the deterministic character of Heisenberg equations of motion.

World Scientific series in 20th century physics•Sep 1, 1995•23 citations

Quantum Theory of Measurement Without Wave Packet Collapse

Marcello Cini

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1985•3 citations

On Wave Packet Reduction in the Coleman–Hepp Model

J. S. Bell

The quantum mechanical measurement problem is considered in a model due to Hepp and Coleman. Whereas Hepp emphasized a 'rigorous "reduction of the wave packet"', in a certain mathematical limit, it is emphasized here that no such reduction ever actually occurs. Some general remarks are made on the advantages of the Heisenberg picture for such considerations, especially in connection with extension to relativistic theories. The non-reduction of the wave packet is directly related to the deterministic character of Heisenberg equations of motion.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Aug 1, 2001•40 citations

Can the Quantum Measurement Problem be resolved within the framework of Schroedinger Dynamics?

Geoffrey L. Sewell

We formulate the dynamics of the generic quantum system S_{c} comprising a microsystem S and a macroscopic measuring instrument I, whose pointer positions are represented by orthogonal subspaces of the Hilbert space of its pure states. These subspaces are simultaneous eigenspaces of a set of coarse grained intercommuting macroscopic observables and, most crucially, their dimensionalities are astronomically large, increasing exponentially with the number, N, of particles comprising I. We formulate conditions under which the conservative dynamics of S_{c} yields both a reduction of the wave packet describing the state of S and a one-to-one correspondence, following a measurement, between the pointer position of I and the resultant eigenstate of S; and we show that these conditions are fulfilled, up to utterly negligible corrections that decrease exponentially with N, by the finite version of the Coleman-Hepp model.

arXiv:quant-ph/0512098•Dec 13, 2005•8 citations
In a very elegant and rigorous paper, K. Hepp has discussed quantum measurement theory. He uses the C* algebra description of infinite quantum systems. Here an attempt is made to give a more popular account of some of his reasoning. Such an attempt seems worthwhile because many people not familiar with the C* algebra approach, and even somewhat intimidated by it, have been intrigued by the following statement in Hepp's abstract:
The quantum mechanical measurement problem is considered in a model due to Hepp and Coleman. Whereas Hepp emphasized a ‘rigorous “reduction of the wave packet”’, in a certain mathematical limit, it is emphasized here that no such reduction ever actually occurs. Some general remarks are made on the advantages of the Heisenberg picture for such considerations, especially in connection with extension to relativistic theories. The non-reduction of the wave packet is directly related to the deterministic character of Heisenberg equations of motion.
The quantum mechanical measurement problem is considered in a model due to Hepp and Coleman. Whereas Hepp emphasized a 'rigorous "reduction of the wave packet"', in a certain mathematical limit, it is emphasized here that no such reduction ever actually occurs. Some general remarks are made on the advantages of the Heisenberg picture for such considerations, especially in connection with extension to relativistic theories. The non-reduction of the wave packet is directly related to the deterministic character of Heisenberg equations of motion.
We formulate the dynamics of the generic quantum system S_{c} comprising a microsystem S and a macroscopic measuring instrument I, whose pointer positions are represented by orthogonal subspaces of the Hilbert space of its pure states. These subspaces are simultaneous eigenspaces of a set of coarse grained intercommuting macroscopic observables and, most crucially, their dimensionalities are astronomically large, increasing exponentially with the number, N, of particles comprising I. We formulate conditions under which the conservative dynamics of S_{c} yields both a reduction of the wave packet describing the state of S and a one-to-one correspondence, following a measurement, between the pointer position of I and the resultant eigenstate of S; and we show that these conditions are fulfilled, up to utterly negligible corrections that decrease exponentially with N, by the finite version of the Coleman-Hepp model.