Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0512098

Can the Quantum Measurement Problem be resolved within the framework of Schroedinger Dynamics?

Geoffrey L. Sewell

Published Dec 13, 2005• 8 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We formulate the dynamics of the generic quantum system S_{c} comprising a microsystem S and a macroscopic measuring instrument I, whose pointer positions are represented by orthogonal subspaces of the Hilbert space of its pure states. These subspaces are simultaneous eigenspaces of a set of coarse grained intercommuting macroscopic observables and, most crucially, their dimensionalities are astronomically large, increasing exponentially with the number, N, of particles comprising I. We formulate conditions under which the conservative dynamics of S_{c} yields both a reduction of the wave packet describing the state of S and a one-to-one correspondence, following a measurement, between the pointer position of I and the resultant eigenstate of S; and we show that these conditions are fulfilled, up to utterly negligible corrections that decrease exponentially with N, by the finite version of the Coleman-Hepp model.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0512098

Related papers

Can the Quantum Measurement Problem be Resolved within the Framework of Schroedinger Dynamics and Quantum Probability?

Geoffrey Sewell, Guillaume Adenier, Andrei Yu. Khrennikov +3 more

We provide an affirmative answer to the question posed in the title. Our argument is based on a treatment of the Schroedinger dynamics of the composite, Sc, of a quantum microsystem, S, and a macroscopic measuring apparatus, J, consisting of N interacting particles. The pointer positions of this apparatus are represented by subspaces of its representative Hilbert space that are simultaneous eigenspaces of coarse‐grained intercommuting macroscopic observables. By taking explicit account of their macroscopicality, we prove that, for suitably designed apparatus J, the evolution of the composite Sc leads both to the reduction of the wave‐packet of S and to a one‐to‐one correspondence between the resultant state of this microsystem and the pointer position of J, up to utterly neglible corrections that decrease exponentially with N.

arXiv:0710.3315•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2007•3 citations

Quantum dynamical model for wave-function reduction in classical and macroscopic limits

Chang-Pu Sun

In this paper, a quantum dynamical model describing the quantum-measurement process is presented as an extensive generalization of the Coleman-Hepp model. In both the classical limit with very large quantum number and the macroscopic limit with very large particle number in the measuring instrument, this model generally realizes the wave-packet collapse in quantum measurement as a consequence of the Schr\"odinger time evolution in either the exactly solvable case or the non-exactly-solvable case. For the latter, the quasiadiabatic case is explicitly analyzed by making use of the high-order adiabatic-approximation method, which manifests the wave-packet collapse as well as in the exactly solvable case. By highlighting these analyses, it is finally found that an essence of the dynamical model of wave-packet collapse is the factorization of the Schr\"odinger evolution rather than the exact solvability. Therefore many dynamical models including the previous well-known ones, whether they are exactly solvable or not, can be shown to be only the concrete realizations of this factorizability.

arXiv:hep-th/9303121•Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1993•93 citations

Dynamical Realizability for Quantum Measurement and Factorization of Evolution Operator

Sun, Chang_Pu

By building a general dynamical model for quantum measurement process,it is shown that the factorization of reduced evolution operator sufficiently results in the quantum mechanical realization of the wave packet collapse and the state correlation between the measured system and the measuring instrument-detector.This realizability is largely independent of the details of both the interaction and Hamiltonian of detector. The Coleman-Hepp model and all its generalizations are only the special cases of the more universal model given in this letter.An explicit example of this model is finally given in connection with coherent state.

arXiv:hep-th/9303010•Mar 2, 1993•4 citations

Quantum measurements without Schrödinger cat states

Dominique Spehner, Fritz Haake

We report and give an alternative derivation of some results on a model for a quantum measurement studied in [1]. The measured microscopic system is coupled to the position of a macroscopic pointer, which itself interacts with its environment via its momentum. The entanglement between the system and the pointer produced by their mutual interaction is simultaneous with the decoherence of distinct pointer readings resulting from leakage of information to the environment. After a discussion on the various time scales in the model we calculate the matrix elements of the system-pointer density operator between eigenstates of the measured observable with distinct eigenvalues. In general, the decay with time of these coherences is neither exponential nor gaussian. We determine the decoherence (decay) time in terms of the strength of the system-pointer and pointer-environment couplings. This decoherence time does not depend upon the details of the pointer-bath coupling as soon as it is smaller than the bath correlation time (non-Markov regime). In contrast, in the Markov regime it depends strongly on whether this coupling is Ohmic or super-Ohmic.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Oct 1, 2007•1 citation

From quantum to classical by numbers

D. Sokolovski, S. Brouard, Daniel Alonso

We follow Kofler and Brukner (2007 Phys. Rev. Lett. 99 180403) in studying the conditions under which a classical picture emerges from the results of not too accurate quantum measurements made on large macroscopic objects. We show that for such objects, consisting of a large number of microscopic elements obeying quantum laws, the Central Limit theorem guarantees the existence of classical values for collective variables, even if the corresponding operators do not commute. Owing to localisation of the overall wave function in any chosen representation, these values can be measured to a small relative error without significantly altering the state of the object. We study a simple model, which includes a rudimentary observer capable of detecting in the coordinate space the position of a macroscopic pointer. The pointer can be employed to measure such quantities, not directly accessible to the observer, as linear or angular momenta. A purely classical picture arises provided the measurements are made on macroscopic objects. Results of measurements, made on small quantum objects, cannot be predicted with certainty, but acquire certain objectivity when encoded in macroscopic pointers’ positions accessible to all observers. Our estimates show that the classical conditions could, in principle, be realised for systems with number of constituent parts of the order of the Avogadro constant. It is possible that the approach captures the essential features of the quantum-to-classical behaviour, although its extension to more realistic systems is likely to be required.

New Journal of Physics•Nov 20, 2019•2 citations

A Coherent Understanding of Solvable Models for Quantum Measurement Processes

Hiromichi Nakazato, Saverio Pascazio

By making use of Schwinger’s oscillator model of angular momentum, we put forward an interesting connection among three solvable Hamiltonians, widely used for discussions on the quantum measurement problem. This connection implies that a particular macroscopic limit has to be taken for these models to be physically sensible. PACS: 03.65.Fd; 03.80.+r; 42.52.+x; 03,65.BzThe quantum measurement problem [1] [2] has been a central issue in the foundations and interpretation of quantum mechanics, and is profoundly related to the investigation of the internal consistency of quantum theory. In order to find a resolution within the quantum mechanical framework, one usually describes a quantum measurement process in the following way: An elementary particle Q, on which the measurement is performed, interacts with a detection system D, which is considered to be made up of N elementary constituents. Generally, it is not easy to handle such a complicated system like Q + D, however, it is also true that several solvable models of measurement processes are now at hand. Among these are the Cini [3] and Coleman-Hepp [4] Hamiltonians and its modified version [5], which were all proposed

•Jul 22, 1993•5 citations
We formulate the dynamics of the generic quantum system S_{c} comprising a microsystem S and a macroscopic measuring instrument I, whose pointer positions are represented by orthogonal subspaces of the Hilbert space of its pure states. These subspaces are simultaneous eigenspaces of a set of coarse grained intercommuting macroscopic observables and, most crucially, their dimensionalities are astronomically large, increasing exponentially with the number, N, of particles comprising I. We formulate conditions under which the conservative dynamics of S_{c} yields both a reduction of the wave packet describing the state of S and a one-to-one correspondence, following a measurement, between the pointer position of I and the resultant eigenstate of S; and we show that these conditions are fulfilled, up to utterly negligible corrections that decrease exponentially with N, by the finite version of the Coleman-Hepp model.
We provide an affirmative answer to the question posed in the title. Our argument is based on a treatment of the Schroedinger dynamics of the composite, Sc, of a quantum microsystem, S, and a macroscopic measuring apparatus, J, consisting of N interacting particles. The pointer positions of this apparatus are represented by subspaces of its representative Hilbert space that are simultaneous eigenspaces of coarse‐grained intercommuting macroscopic observables. By taking explicit account of their macroscopicality, we prove that, for suitably designed apparatus J, the evolution of the composite Sc leads both to the reduction of the wave‐packet of S and to a one‐to‐one correspondence between the resultant state of this microsystem and the pointer position of J, up to utterly neglible corrections that decrease exponentially with N.
In this paper, a quantum dynamical model describing the quantum-measurement process is presented as an extensive generalization of the Coleman-Hepp model. In both the classical limit with very large quantum number and the macroscopic limit with very large particle number in the measuring instrument, this model generally realizes the wave-packet collapse in quantum measurement as a consequence of the Schr\"odinger time evolution in either the exactly solvable case or the non-exactly-solvable case. For the latter, the quasiadiabatic case is explicitly analyzed by making use of the high-order adiabatic-approximation method, which manifests the wave-packet collapse as well as in the exactly solvable case. By highlighting these analyses, it is finally found that an essence of the dynamical model of wave-packet collapse is the factorization of the Schr\"odinger evolution rather than the exact solvability. Therefore many dynamical models including the previous well-known ones, whether they are exactly solvable or not, can be shown to be only the concrete realizations of this factorizability.
By building a general dynamical model for quantum measurement process,it is shown that the factorization of reduced evolution operator sufficiently results in the quantum mechanical realization of the wave packet collapse and the state correlation between the measured system and the measuring instrument-detector.This realizability is largely independent of the details of both the interaction and Hamiltonian of detector. The Coleman-Hepp model and all its generalizations are only the special cases of the more universal model given in this letter.An explicit example of this model is finally given in connection with coherent state.
We report and give an alternative derivation of some results on a model for a quantum measurement studied in [1]. The measured microscopic system is coupled to the position of a macroscopic pointer, which itself interacts with its environment via its momentum. The entanglement between the system and the pointer produced by their mutual interaction is simultaneous with the decoherence of distinct pointer readings resulting from leakage of information to the environment. After a discussion on the various time scales in the model we calculate the matrix elements of the system-pointer density operator between eigenstates of the measured observable with distinct eigenvalues. In general, the decay with time of these coherences is neither exponential nor gaussian. We determine the decoherence (decay) time in terms of the strength of the system-pointer and pointer-environment couplings. This decoherence time does not depend upon the details of the pointer-bath coupling as soon as it is smaller than the bath correlation time (non-Markov regime). In contrast, in the Markov regime it depends strongly on whether this coupling is Ohmic or super-Ohmic.
We follow Kofler and Brukner (2007 Phys. Rev. Lett. 99 180403) in studying the conditions under which a classical picture emerges from the results of not too accurate quantum measurements made on large macroscopic objects. We show that for such objects, consisting of a large number of microscopic elements obeying quantum laws, the Central Limit theorem guarantees the existence of classical values for collective variables, even if the corresponding operators do not commute. Owing to localisation of the overall wave function in any chosen representation, these values can be measured to a small relative error without significantly altering the state of the object. We study a simple model, which includes a rudimentary observer capable of detecting in the coordinate space the position of a macroscopic pointer. The pointer can be employed to measure such quantities, not directly accessible to the observer, as linear or angular momenta. A purely classical picture arises provided the measurements are made on macroscopic objects. Results of measurements, made on small quantum objects, cannot be predicted with certainty, but acquire certain objectivity when encoded in macroscopic pointers’ positions accessible to all observers. Our estimates show that the classical conditions could, in principle, be realised for systems with number of constituent parts of the order of the Avogadro constant. It is possible that the approach captures the essential features of the quantum-to-classical behaviour, although its extension to more realistic systems is likely to be required.
By making use of Schwinger’s oscillator model of angular momentum, we put forward an interesting connection among three solvable Hamiltonians, widely used for discussions on the quantum measurement problem. This connection implies that a particular macroscopic limit has to be taken for these models to be physically sensible. PACS: 03.65.Fd; 03.80.+r; 42.52.+x; 03,65.BzThe quantum measurement problem [1] [2] has been a central issue in the foundations and interpretation of quantum mechanics, and is profoundly related to the investigation of the internal consistency of quantum theory. In order to find a resolution within the quantum mechanical framework, one usually describes a quantum measurement process in the following way: An elementary particle Q, on which the measurement is performed, interacts with a detection system D, which is considered to be made up of N elementary constituents. Generally, it is not easy to handle such a complicated system like Q + D, however, it is also true that several solvable models of measurement processes are now at hand. Among these are the Cini [3] and Coleman-Hepp [4] Hamiltonians and its modified version [5], which were all proposed