Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

World Scientific series in 20th century physics

On Wave Packet Reduction in the Coleman–Hepp Model

J. S. Bell

Published Sep 1, 1995• 23 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The quantum mechanical measurement problem is considered in a model due to Hepp and Coleman. Whereas Hepp emphasized a ‘rigorous “reduction of the wave packet”’, in a certain mathematical limit, it is emphasized here that no such reduction ever actually occurs. Some general remarks are made on the advantages of the Heisenberg picture for such considerations, especially in connection with extension to relativistic theories. The non-reduction of the wave packet is directly related to the deterministic character of Heisenberg equations of motion.

DOI
10.1142/9789812795854_0077

Related papers

On Wave Packet Reduction in the Coleman–Hepp Model

J. S. Bell

The quantum mechanical measurement problem is considered in a model due to Hepp and Coleman. Whereas Hepp emphasized a 'rigorous "reduction of the wave packet"', in a certain mathematical limit, it is emphasized here that no such reduction ever actually occurs. Some general remarks are made on the advantages of the Heisenberg picture for such considerations, especially in connection with extension to relativistic theories. The non-reduction of the wave packet is directly related to the deterministic character of Heisenberg equations of motion.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Aug 1, 2001•40 citations

On wave packet reduction in the Coleman–Hepp model

J. S. Bell

In a very elegant and rigorous paper, K. Hepp has discussed quantum measurement theory. He uses the C* algebra description of infinite quantum systems. Here an attempt is made to give a more popular account of some of his reasoning. Such an attempt seems worthwhile because many people not familiar with the C* algebra approach, and even somewhat intimidated by it, have been intrigued by the following statement in Hepp's abstract:

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jun 3, 2004•124 citations

Quantum dynamical model for wave-function reduction in classical and macroscopic limits

Chang-Pu Sun

In this paper, a quantum dynamical model describing the quantum-measurement process is presented as an extensive generalization of the Coleman-Hepp model. In both the classical limit with very large quantum number and the macroscopic limit with very large particle number in the measuring instrument, this model generally realizes the wave-packet collapse in quantum measurement as a consequence of the Schr\"odinger time evolution in either the exactly solvable case or the non-exactly-solvable case. For the latter, the quasiadiabatic case is explicitly analyzed by making use of the high-order adiabatic-approximation method, which manifests the wave-packet collapse as well as in the exactly solvable case. By highlighting these analyses, it is finally found that an essence of the dynamical model of wave-packet collapse is the factorization of the Schr\"odinger evolution rather than the exact solvability. Therefore many dynamical models including the previous well-known ones, whether they are exactly solvable or not, can be shown to be only the concrete realizations of this factorizability.

arXiv:hep-th/9303121•Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1993•93 citations

Dynamical Realizability for Quantum Measurement and Factorization of Evolution Operator

Sun, Chang_Pu

By building a general dynamical model for quantum measurement process,it is shown that the factorization of reduced evolution operator sufficiently results in the quantum mechanical realization of the wave packet collapse and the state correlation between the measured system and the measuring instrument-detector.This realizability is largely independent of the details of both the interaction and Hamiltonian of detector. The Coleman-Hepp model and all its generalizations are only the special cases of the more universal model given in this letter.An explicit example of this model is finally given in connection with coherent state.

arXiv:hep-th/9303010•Mar 2, 1993•4 citations

How the Measurement Problem Is an Artefact of the Mathematics

Nancy Delaney Cartwright

Abstract Precursing now popular ‘spontaneous reduction’ views, this chapter argues that the measurement problem in quantum mechanics is not a problem of measurement at all. Reductions happen in a variety of circumstances and are particularly important in the preparation of quantum states. But there is no reason to think there is any simple physical characterization of situations in which reduction of the wave packet occurs from when it does not. There is a difference in the mathematical characteristics of the evolution operator between the two (unitary operators versus non‐unitary), but this mathematical difference need mark no interesting physical difference distinguishing the situations to which operators apply.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jun 9, 1983•3 citations

Desiderata for a Modified Quantum Dynamics

Abner Shimony

A cluster of problems — the “quantum mechanical measurement problem”, the “problem of the reduction of the wave packet”, the “problem of the actualization of potentialities,” and the “Schrödinger Cat problem” — are raised by standard quantum dynamics when certain assumptions are made about the interpretation of the quantum mechanical formalism. Investigators who are unwilling to abandon these assumptions will be motivated to propose modifications of the quantum formalism. Among these, many (including Professor Ghirardi and Professor Pearle) have felt that the most promising locus of modification is quantum dynamics, and in their presentations (this Volume) they have suggested stochastic modifications of the standard deterministic and linear evolution of the quantum state.

PSA Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association•Jan 1, 1990•92 citations
The quantum mechanical measurement problem is considered in a model due to Hepp and Coleman. Whereas Hepp emphasized a ‘rigorous “reduction of the wave packet”’, in a certain mathematical limit, it is emphasized here that no such reduction ever actually occurs. Some general remarks are made on the advantages of the Heisenberg picture for such considerations, especially in connection with extension to relativistic theories. The non-reduction of the wave packet is directly related to the deterministic character of Heisenberg equations of motion.
The quantum mechanical measurement problem is considered in a model due to Hepp and Coleman. Whereas Hepp emphasized a 'rigorous "reduction of the wave packet"', in a certain mathematical limit, it is emphasized here that no such reduction ever actually occurs. Some general remarks are made on the advantages of the Heisenberg picture for such considerations, especially in connection with extension to relativistic theories. The non-reduction of the wave packet is directly related to the deterministic character of Heisenberg equations of motion.
In this paper, a quantum dynamical model describing the quantum-measurement process is presented as an extensive generalization of the Coleman-Hepp model. In both the classical limit with very large quantum number and the macroscopic limit with very large particle number in the measuring instrument, this model generally realizes the wave-packet collapse in quantum measurement as a consequence of the Schr\"odinger time evolution in either the exactly solvable case or the non-exactly-solvable case. For the latter, the quasiadiabatic case is explicitly analyzed by making use of the high-order adiabatic-approximation method, which manifests the wave-packet collapse as well as in the exactly solvable case. By highlighting these analyses, it is finally found that an essence of the dynamical model of wave-packet collapse is the factorization of the Schr\"odinger evolution rather than the exact solvability. Therefore many dynamical models including the previous well-known ones, whether they are exactly solvable or not, can be shown to be only the concrete realizations of this factorizability.
By building a general dynamical model for quantum measurement process,it is shown that the factorization of reduced evolution operator sufficiently results in the quantum mechanical realization of the wave packet collapse and the state correlation between the measured system and the measuring instrument-detector.This realizability is largely independent of the details of both the interaction and Hamiltonian of detector. The Coleman-Hepp model and all its generalizations are only the special cases of the more universal model given in this letter.An explicit example of this model is finally given in connection with coherent state.
Abstract Precursing now popular ‘spontaneous reduction’ views, this chapter argues that the measurement problem in quantum mechanics is not a problem of measurement at all. Reductions happen in a variety of circumstances and are particularly important in the preparation of quantum states. But there is no reason to think there is any simple physical characterization of situations in which reduction of the wave packet occurs from when it does not. There is a difference in the mathematical characteristics of the evolution operator between the two (unitary operators versus non‐unitary), but this mathematical difference need mark no interesting physical difference distinguishing the situations to which operators apply.
A cluster of problems — the “quantum mechanical measurement problem”, the “problem of the reduction of the wave packet”, the “problem of the actualization of potentialities,” and the “Schrödinger Cat problem” — are raised by standard quantum dynamics when certain assumptions are made about the interpretation of the quantum mechanical formalism. Investigators who are unwilling to abandon these assumptions will be motivated to propose modifications of the quantum formalism. Among these, many (including Professor Ghirardi and Professor Pearle) have felt that the most promising locus of modification is quantum dynamics, and in their presentations (this Volume) they have suggested stochastic modifications of the standard deterministic and linear evolution of the quantum state.