Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity

Noise in NbTiN, Al, and Ta Superconducting Resonators on Silicon and Sapphire Substrates

R. Barends, H. L. Hortensius, T. Zijlstra, J. J. A. Baselmans, S. J. C. Yates, J. R. Gao, T. M. Klapwijk

Published Jun 1, 2009• 45 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We present measurements of the frequency noise and resonance frequency temperature dependence in planar superconducting resonators on both silicon and sapphire substrates. We show, by covering the resonators with sputtered SiOxlayers of different thicknesses, that the temperature dependence of the resonance frequency scales linearly with thickness, whereas the observed increase in noise is independent of thickness. The frequency noise decreases when increasing the width of the coplanar waveguide in NbTiN on hydrogen passivated silicon devices, most effectively by widening the gap. We find up to an order of magnitude more noise when using sapphire instead of silicon as substrate. The complete set of data points towards the noise being strongly affected by superconductor-dielectric interfaces.

DOI
10.1109/tasc.2009.2018086

Related papers

Contribution of dielectrics to frequency and noise of NbTiN superconducting resonators

R. Barends, H. L. Hortensius, T. Zijlstra +4 more

We study NbTiN resonators by measurements of the temperature dependent resonance frequency and frequency noise. Additionally, resonators are studied covered with SiOx dielectric layers of various thicknesses. The resonance frequency develops a nonmonotonic temperature dependence with increasing SiOx layer thickness. The increase in the noise is independent of the SiOx thickness, demonstrating that the noise is not dominantly related to the low temperature resonance frequency deviations.

arXiv:0804.3499•Applied Physics Letters•Jun 2, 2008•108 citations

Reduced frequency noise in superconducting resonators

R. Barends, N. Vercruyssen, Akira Endo +4 more

We report a reduction in the frequency noise in coplanar waveguide superconducting resonators. The reduction of 7 dB is achieved by removing the exposed dielectric substrate surface from the region with high electric fields and by using NbTiN. In a model-analysis the surface of NbTiN is found to be a negligible source of noise, experimentally supported by a comparison with NbTiN on SiOx resonators. The reduction is additive to decreasing the noise by widening the resonators.

arXiv:1005.5394•Applied Physics Letters•Jul 19, 2010•57 citations

Temperature dependence of the frequency and noise of superconducting coplanar waveguide resonators

Shwetank Kumar, Jiansong Gao, Jonas Zmuidzinas +3 more

We present measurements of the temperature and power dependence of the resonance frequency and frequency noise of superconducting niobium thin-film coplanar waveguide resonators carried out at temperatures well below the superconducting transition (Tc=9.2K). The noise decreases by nearly two orders of magnitude as the temperature is increased from 120to1200mK, while the variation of the resonance frequency with temperature over this range agrees well with the standard two-level system (TLS) model for amorphous dielectrics. These results support the hypothesis that TLSs are responsible for the noise in superconducting microresonators and have important implications for resonator applications such as qubits and photon detectors.

arXiv:0802.4268•Applied Physics Letters•Mar 24, 2008•81 citations

Frequency and quality factor of NbTiN∕Au bilayer superconducting resonators

R. Barends, Werner Karl-Gustav Daalman, Akira Endo +6 more

We have measured the temperature dependence of the resonance frequency and quality factor of superconducting resonators made of a 300 nm thick NbTiN and 10 nm thick Au bilayer down to a temperature of 350 mK. At low temperatures we find a strong temperature dependence compared to bare NbTiN resonators: when increasing the temperature from 350 mK to 2 K the quality factor drops from a value of 105 down to 103 and the frequency decreases by about 1%. This while for bare NbTiN the quality factor remains on the order of 106 and the fractional frequency change remains below 10−4. These results indicate that the proximitised thin Au layer dominates the low temperature properties. Using the Usadel equations and Nam’s expression for the complex conductivity we can accurately describe the data assuming an interface transparency of 0.15.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2009•11 citations

Fabrication and characterization of NbTi microwave superconducting resonators

Roberto Russo, André Chatel, Nergiz Şahin Solmaz +4 more

Superconducting resonators are widely used in fields spanning from quantum computing to electron spin resonance (ESR) spectroscopy. With the goal of realizing superconducting resonators, a broad variety and combination of superconducting materials, substrates and fabrication processes have been used and thoroughly reported in the literature. High temperature superconductors such as YBCO and low temperature superconductors such as Nb, NbN, NbTiN and Al are the major actors in the domain. In this work, we investigate the possibility to extend the family of suitable low temperature superconductors for the realization of planar superconducting microwave resonators for future ESR applications. In particular, this study focuses on NbTi, a widely used material to realize superconducting cables but not investigated for planar resonating structures at GHz frequencies. A 150 nm thick film of NbTi is sputtered and patterned on top of an Al2O3 substrate. For devices resonating around 6.8 GHz quality factors greater than 10,000 are observed at 3 K and in magnetic fields up to 250 mT.

Micro and Nano Engineering•May 10, 2023•9 citations

Properties of superconducting planar resonators at millikelvin temperatures

T. Lindström, J E Healey, M. S. Colclough +2 more

Planar superconducting resonators are now being increasingly used at mK temperatures in a number of novel applications. We have experimentally investigated three types of niobium resonators including a lumped-element design fabricated on sapphire and ${\text{SiO}}_{2}/\text{Si}$ substrates. They all exhibit a nonmonotonic temperature dependence of their center frequency which could be accurately described by resonant absorption by two-level fluctuators (TLF). By analyzing the temperature dependence we extracted information about the distribution of TLF. Our results are consistent with there being a spread of TLF at the interface between superconductor and substrate.

arXiv:0905.1481•Physical Review B•Oct 5, 2009•71 citations
We present measurements of the frequency noise and resonance frequency temperature dependence in planar superconducting resonators on both silicon and sapphire substrates. We show, by covering the resonators with sputtered SiOxlayers of different thicknesses, that the temperature dependence of the resonance frequency scales linearly with thickness, whereas the observed increase in noise is independent of thickness. The frequency noise decreases when increasing the width of the coplanar waveguide in NbTiN on hydrogen passivated silicon devices, most effectively by widening the gap. We find up to an order of magnitude more noise when using sapphire instead of silicon as substrate. The complete set of data points towards the noise being strongly affected by superconductor-dielectric interfaces.
We present measurements of the temperature and power dependence of the resonance frequency and frequency noise of superconducting niobium thin-film coplanar waveguide resonators carried out at temperatures well below the superconducting transition (Tc=9.2K). The noise decreases by nearly two orders of magnitude as the temperature is increased from 120to1200mK, while the variation of the resonance frequency with temperature over this range agrees well with the standard two-level system (TLS) model for amorphous dielectrics. These results support the hypothesis that TLSs are responsible for the noise in superconducting microresonators and have important implications for resonator applications such as qubits and photon detectors.
We have measured the temperature dependence of the resonance frequency and quality factor of superconducting resonators made of a 300 nm thick NbTiN and 10 nm thick Au bilayer down to a temperature of 350 mK. At low temperatures we find a strong temperature dependence compared to bare NbTiN resonators: when increasing the temperature from 350 mK to 2 K the quality factor drops from a value of 105 down to 103 and the frequency decreases by about 1%. This while for bare NbTiN the quality factor remains on the order of 106 and the fractional frequency change remains below 10−4. These results indicate that the proximitised thin Au layer dominates the low temperature properties. Using the Usadel equations and Nam’s expression for the complex conductivity we can accurately describe the data assuming an interface transparency of 0.15.
Superconducting resonators are widely used in fields spanning from quantum computing to electron spin resonance (ESR) spectroscopy. With the goal of realizing superconducting resonators, a broad variety and combination of superconducting materials, substrates and fabrication processes have been used and thoroughly reported in the literature. High temperature superconductors such as YBCO and low temperature superconductors such as Nb, NbN, NbTiN and Al are the major actors in the domain. In this work, we investigate the possibility to extend the family of suitable low temperature superconductors for the realization of planar superconducting microwave resonators for future ESR applications. In particular, this study focuses on NbTi, a widely used material to realize superconducting cables but not investigated for planar resonating structures at GHz frequencies. A 150 nm thick film of NbTi is sputtered and patterned on top of an Al2O3 substrate. For devices resonating around 6.8 GHz quality factors greater than 10,000 are observed at 3 K and in magnetic fields up to 250 mT.
Planar superconducting resonators are now being increasingly used at mK temperatures in a number of novel applications. We have experimentally investigated three types of niobium resonators including a lumped-element design fabricated on sapphire and SiO2/Si{\text{SiO}}_{2}/\text{Si}SiO2​/Si substrates. They all exhibit a nonmonotonic temperature dependence of their center frequency which could be accurately described by resonant absorption by two-level fluctuators (TLF). By analyzing the temperature dependence we extracted information about the distribution of TLF. Our results are consistent with there being a spread of TLF at the interface between superconductor and substrate.