Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Symmetry

Quantum Theory and Probability Theory: Their Relationship and Origin in Symmetry

Philip Goyal, Kevin H. Knuth

Published Apr 27, 2011• 31 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quantum theory is a probabilistic calculus that enables the calculation of the probabilities of the possible outcomes of a measurement performed on a physical system. But what is the relationship between this probabilistic calculus and probability theory itself? Is quantum theory compatible with probability theory? If so, does it extend or generalize probability theory? In this paper, we answer these questions, and precisely determine the relationship between quantum theory and probability theory, by explicitly deriving both theories from first principles. In both cases, the derivation depends upon identifying and harnessing the appropriate symmetries that are operative in each domain. We prove, for example, that quantum theory is compatible with probability theory by explicitly deriving quantum theory on the assumption that probability theory is generally valid.

DOI
10.3390/sym3020171

Related papers

Quantum State Analysis : Probability theory as logic in Quantum mechanics

Anders Månsson

Quantum mechanics is basically a mathematical recipe on how to construct physical models. Historically its origin and main domain of application has been in the microscopic regime, although it strictly seen constitutes a general mathematical framework not limited to this regime. Since it is a statistical theory, the meaning and role of probabilities in it need to be defined and understood in order to gain an understanding of the predictions and validity of quantum mechanics. The interpretational problems of quantum mechanics are also connected with the interpretation of the concept of probability. In this thesis the use of probability theory as extended logic, in particular in the way it was presented by E. T. Jaynes, will be central. With this interpretation of probabilities they become a subjective notion, always dependent on one's state of knowledge or the context in which they are assigned, which has consequences on how things are to be viewed, understood and tackled in quantum mechanics. For instance, the statistical operator or density operator, is usually defined in terms of probabilities and therefore also needs to be updated when the probabilities are updated by acquisition of additional data. Furthermore, it is a context dependent notion, meaning, e.g., that two observers will in general assign different statistical operators to the same phenomenon, which is demonstrated in the papers of the thesis. It is also presented an alternative and conceptually clear approach to the problematic notion of "probabilities of probabilities", which is related to such things as probability distributions on statistical operators. In connection to this, we consider concrete numerical applications of Bayesian quantum state assignment methods to a three-level quantum system, where prior knowledge and various kinds of measurement data are encoded into a statistical operator, which can then be used for deriving probabilities of other measurements. The thesis also offers examples of an alternative quantum state assignment technique, using maximum entropy methods, which in some cases are compared with the Bayesian quantum state assignment methods. Finally, the interesting and important problem whether the statistical operator, or more generally quantum mechanics, gives a complete description of "objective physical reality" is considered. A related concern is here the possibility of finding a "local hidden-variable theory" underlying the quantum mechanical description. There have been attempts to prove that such a theory cannot be constructed, where the most well-known impossibility proof claiming to show this was given by J. S. Bell. In connection to this, the thesis presents an idea for an interpretation or alternative approach to quantum mechanics based on the concept of space-time.

•Jan 1, 2007•0 citations

Causal Consistency Selects the Born Rule: A Derivation from Steering in Generalized Probabilistic Theories

Enso O. Torres Alegre

Within finite-dimensional generalized probabilistic theories (GPTs), we distinguish between the geometric transition probability tau(psi,phi), defined as the maximum probability of accepting phi when the state is psi, and the predictive probability P(phi|psi) assigned to measurement outcomes. We ask what functional relationship P = Phi(tau) is compatible with relativistic causality. We prove that in any GPT satisfying purification, and therefore admitting steering, the only such relationship consistent with no-signaling is the identity Phi(p) = p. Any strictly convex or concave deviation from linearity enables superluminal signaling through steering scenarios. We provide an explicit qubit example showing how nonlinear probability rules generate detectable signaling channels. Combined with standard reconstruction results, this yields the Born rule |<phi|psi>|^2 as the unique causally consistent probability assignment. Our analysis clarifies the distinction between geometric structure and probabilistic prediction in quantum theory, and identifies steering as the mechanism enforcing the Born rule.

quant-pharXiv:2512.12636•Dec 16, 2025•1 citation

Quantum theory as a statistical theory under symmetry

Inge Svein Helland

Both statistics and quantum theory deal with prediction using probability. We will show that there can be established a connection between these two areas. This will at the same time suggest a new, less formalistic way of looking upon basic quantum theory.A total parameter space Φ, equipped with a group G of transformations, gives the mental image of some quantum system, in such a way that only certain components, functions of the total parameter φ can be estimated. Choose an experiment/question a, and get from this a parameter space Λa, perhaps after some model reduction compatible with the group structure. As in statistics, it is important always to distinguish between observations and parameters, in particular between (minimal) observations ta and state variables (parameters) λa. Let Ka be the L2 ‐space of functions of ta, and let Ha be the image of Ka under the expectation operator of the model. The measure determining the L2‐spaces is the invariant measure under the maximal subgroup which induces a transformation on Λa.There is a unitary connection between Ka and Ha, and then under natural conditions between Ha and Hb for a and b are different. Thus there exists a common Hilbert space H such that Ha equals UaH for a unitary Ua. In agreement with the common formulation of quantum mechanics, the vectors of H are taken to represent the states of the system. The state interpretation is then: An ideal experiment Ea has been performed, and the result of this experiment, disregarding measurement errors, is that the parameter λa is equal to some fixed number λka. This essentially statistical construction leads under natural assumptions to the basic axioms of quantum mechanics, and thus implies a new statistical interpretation of this traditionally very formal theory. The probabilities are introduced via Born’s formula, and this formula is proved from general, reasonable assumptions, essentially symmetry assumptions.The theory is illustrated by a simple macroscopic example, and by the example of a spin 12 particle. As a last example we show a connection to inference between related macroscropic experiments under symmetry. The result of this last example seems to have potential for being generalized considerably.

arXiv:quant-ph/0411174•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2005•3 citations

INTERPRETATIONS OF PROBABILITY AND QUANTUM THEORY

L. E. Ballentine

There is a peculiar similarity between Probability Theory and Quantum Mechanics: both subjects are mature and successful, yet both remain subject to controversy about their foundations and interpretation. I first present a classification of the various interpretations of probability, arguing that they should not be thought of as rivals, but rather as applications of a general theory to different kinds of subject matter. An axiom system that makes conditional probability the fundamental concept is put forward as being superior to Kolmogorov's axioms. I then discuss the relevance to quantum theory of the various interpretations of probability, the applicability of classical probability theory within quantum mechanics, and the relations between the interpretation of probability and the interpretation of quantum mechanics.

Foundations of probability and physics•Dec 1, 2001•46 citations

Probability theory in quantum mechanics

L. E. Ballentine

The abstract theory of probability and its interpretation are briefly reviewed, and it is explicitly demonstrated that the formalism of quantum mechanics satisfies the axioms of probability theory. This refutes the suggestions which have occasionally been made that ‘‘classical’’ probability theory does not apply to quantum mechanics. Several erroneous applications of probability theory to quantum mechanics are examined, and the nature of the errors are exposed. It is urged that more attention be given to probability theory in the physics curriculum.

American Journal of Physics•Oct 1, 1986•71 citations

Toward the Origin of Quantum Probability

James Johan Sebastian Allen

Toward the Origin of Quantum Probability investigates the physical foundations of quantum probability within Pattern Field Theory (PFT), establishing an exact conservation and local Transport-current law while examining how the continuous distribution of quantum amplitudes relates to discrete, exclusive measurement outcomes. Building upon Quantum Gravity Fully Derived, the phase-valued Allen Orbital Lattice (AOL), and the relational quantum-field architecture of PFT, this paper develops a mathematical and computational account of phase-dependent Transport, conserved quadratic participation, detector interaction and the conditions required for physical measurement commitment. The central result is an exact local continuity equation derived from Hermitian lattice Transport. The construction establishes conservation of quadratic density, identifies the directed currents responsible for transferring participation between relational configurations, and demonstrates how quantum interference is preserved within a closed physical system. Principal contributions include: Exact Transport Conservation: Derives the local continuity equation for the phase-valued AOL operator and establishes global conservation of quadratic density under Hermitian Transport dynamics. Origin of the Quadratic Measure: Extends the inherited Quadratic Measure Lemma, examining the mathematical conditions under which a conserved quadratic measure arises and its relationship to the probability structure of quantum mechanics. Phase-Dependent Transport Currents: Establishes the relationship between relational phase, directed boundary currents and the redistribution of conserved participation across detector regions. Closed-System Detector Calculation: Presents a reproducible numerical investigation of a closed Hermitian Transport configuration containing a phase-bearing ring coupled to three detector channels. Conservation at Numerical Precision: Demonstrates quadratic norm conservation with maximum numerical deviations of approximately 1.8 x 10^-14 across the examined configurations. Quantum Interference: Reproduces phase-dependent detector distributions, including destructive interference at the central detector, where the calculated participation approaches 3.8 x 10^-30. Detector Retention and Return Currents: Identifies transient reverse currents and demonstrates why participation transferred into a detector must be distinguished from a permanently retained measurement record. Cut-Invariance: Demonstrates that the asymptotic detector participation pattern becomes independent of the chosen system-detector partition in the completed-transfer limit, while transient measurements retain partition dependence. Transport Versus Physical Commitment: Establishes the distinction between conserved, continuously distributed quantum participation and the exclusive physical commitment required for an individual detector outcome. Native EQUI Allocation: Identifies the physical connection required between phase-sensitive Equilibrion (EQUI) participation, inherited detector configurations and the eventual frequency distribution of committed events. Conditional Outcome Correspondence: Examines deterministic successor selection using phase-sensitive admissible currents and inherited route residuals, identifying the equilibrium conditions under which the resulting distributions reproduce quadratic outcome weighting. Reproducible Computational Evidence: Includes the Python source code and machine-readable numerical results used in the closed-Transport detector investigation, permitting independent examination of conservation, current integration, interference and detector participation. The paper identifies a precise remaining physical question: how does native Transport convert distributed, conserved participation into one retained measurement outcome per preparation, with observed frequencies determined by the appropriate quadratic measure? The mathematical conservation law, phase-dependent currents, detector calculations and asymptotic participation results are established within the specified Hermitian construction. The physical identification between native EQUI participation and spectral density, together with the commitment rule governing exclusive records, remains the explicitly defined closure problem. A Derivation Ledger distinguishes exact mathematical results, inherited PFT constructions, conditional correspondence results and the physical commitments requiring further derivation. The paper also examines operational reconstructions of quantum theory, composite systems, correlations, no-signalling conditions and the relationship between native causal continuation and downstream Mensural spacetime. The significance of this work lies in connecting quantum probability to a physically specified conservation and Transport architecture while isolating the exact mechanism still required to explain individual measurement outcomes. It establishes a reproducible mathematical and computational foundation for investigating the origin of the Born measure, detector commitment and the transition from distributed quantum participation to observed physical events. Together with Recovering General Relativity in Pattern Field Theory and Recovering Quantum Field Structure in Pattern Field Theory, this work extends the common relational Transport architecture into quantum conservation, probability and measurement. James Johan Sebastian AllenPattern Field Theoryhttps://patternfieldtheory.com/https://zenodo.org/communities/pft

•Nov 5, 2026•0 citations
Quantum theory is a probabilistic calculus that enables the calculation of the probabilities of the possible outcomes of a measurement performed on a physical system. But what is the relationship between this probabilistic calculus and probability theory itself? Is quantum theory compatible with probability theory? If so, does it extend or generalize probability theory? In this paper, we answer these questions, and precisely determine the relationship between quantum theory and probability theory, by explicitly deriving both theories from first principles. In both cases, the derivation depends upon identifying and harnessing the appropriate symmetries that are operative in each domain. We prove, for example, that quantum theory is compatible with probability theory by explicitly deriving quantum theory on the assumption that probability theory is generally valid.
Quantum mechanics is basically a mathematical recipe on how to construct physical models. Historically its origin and main domain of application has been in the microscopic regime, although it strictly seen constitutes a general mathematical framework not limited to this regime. Since it is a statistical theory, the meaning and role of probabilities in it need to be defined and understood in order to gain an understanding of the predictions and validity of quantum mechanics. The interpretational problems of quantum mechanics are also connected with the interpretation of the concept of probability. In this thesis the use of probability theory as extended logic, in particular in the way it was presented by E. T. Jaynes, will be central. With this interpretation of probabilities they become a subjective notion, always dependent on one's state of knowledge or the context in which they are assigned, which has consequences on how things are to be viewed, understood and tackled in quantum mechanics. For instance, the statistical operator or density operator, is usually defined in terms of probabilities and therefore also needs to be updated when the probabilities are updated by acquisition of additional data. Furthermore, it is a context dependent notion, meaning, e.g., that two observers will in general assign different statistical operators to the same phenomenon, which is demonstrated in the papers of the thesis. It is also presented an alternative and conceptually clear approach to the problematic notion of "probabilities of probabilities", which is related to such things as probability distributions on statistical operators. In connection to this, we consider concrete numerical applications of Bayesian quantum state assignment methods to a three-level quantum system, where prior knowledge and various kinds of measurement data are encoded into a statistical operator, which can then be used for deriving probabilities of other measurements. The thesis also offers examples of an alternative quantum state assignment technique, using maximum entropy methods, which in some cases are compared with the Bayesian quantum state assignment methods. Finally, the interesting and important problem whether the statistical operator, or more generally quantum mechanics, gives a complete description of "objective physical reality" is considered. A related concern is here the possibility of finding a "local hidden-variable theory" underlying the quantum mechanical description. There have been attempts to prove that such a theory cannot be constructed, where the most well-known impossibility proof claiming to show this was given by J. S. Bell. In connection to this, the thesis presents an idea for an interpretation or alternative approach to quantum mechanics based on the concept of space-time.
Within finite-dimensional generalized probabilistic theories (GPTs), we distinguish between the geometric transition probability tau(psi,phi), defined as the maximum probability of accepting phi when the state is psi, and the predictive probability P(phi|psi) assigned to measurement outcomes. We ask what functional relationship P = Phi(tau) is compatible with relativistic causality. We prove that in any GPT satisfying purification, and therefore admitting steering, the only such relationship consistent with no-signaling is the identity Phi(p) = p. Any strictly convex or concave deviation from linearity enables superluminal signaling through steering scenarios. We provide an explicit qubit example showing how nonlinear probability rules generate detectable signaling channels. Combined with standard reconstruction results, this yields the Born rule |<phi|psi>|^2 as the unique causally consistent probability assignment. Our analysis clarifies the distinction between geometric structure and probabilistic prediction in quantum theory, and identifies steering as the mechanism enforcing the Born rule.
Both statistics and quantum theory deal with prediction using probability. We will show that there can be established a connection between these two areas. This will at the same time suggest a new, less formalistic way of looking upon basic quantum theory.A total parameter space Φ, equipped with a group G of transformations, gives the mental image of some quantum system, in such a way that only certain components, functions of the total parameter φ can be estimated. Choose an experiment/question a, and get from this a parameter space Λa, perhaps after some model reduction compatible with the group structure. As in statistics, it is important always to distinguish between observations and parameters, in particular between (minimal) observations ta and state variables (parameters) λa. Let Ka be the L2 ‐space of functions of ta, and let Ha be the image of Ka under the expectation operator of the model. The measure determining the L2‐spaces is the invariant measure under the maximal subgroup which induces a transformation on Λa.There is a unitary connection between Ka and Ha, and then under natural conditions between Ha and Hb for a and b are different. Thus there exists a common Hilbert space H such that Ha equals UaH for a unitary Ua. In agreement with the common formulation of quantum mechanics, the vectors of H are taken to represent the states of the system. The state interpretation is then: An ideal experiment Ea has been performed, and the result of this experiment, disregarding measurement errors, is that the parameter λa is equal to some fixed number λka. This essentially statistical construction leads under natural assumptions to the basic axioms of quantum mechanics, and thus implies a new statistical interpretation of this traditionally very formal theory. The probabilities are introduced via Born’s formula, and this formula is proved from general, reasonable assumptions, essentially symmetry assumptions.The theory is illustrated by a simple macroscopic example, and by the example of a spin 12 particle. As a last example we show a connection to inference between related macroscropic experiments under symmetry. The result of this last example seems to have potential for being generalized considerably.
There is a peculiar similarity between Probability Theory and Quantum Mechanics: both subjects are mature and successful, yet both remain subject to controversy about their foundations and interpretation. I first present a classification of the various interpretations of probability, arguing that they should not be thought of as rivals, but rather as applications of a general theory to different kinds of subject matter. An axiom system that makes conditional probability the fundamental concept is put forward as being superior to Kolmogorov's axioms. I then discuss the relevance to quantum theory of the various interpretations of probability, the applicability of classical probability theory within quantum mechanics, and the relations between the interpretation of probability and the interpretation of quantum mechanics.
The abstract theory of probability and its interpretation are briefly reviewed, and it is explicitly demonstrated that the formalism of quantum mechanics satisfies the axioms of probability theory. This refutes the suggestions which have occasionally been made that ‘‘classical’’ probability theory does not apply to quantum mechanics. Several erroneous applications of probability theory to quantum mechanics are examined, and the nature of the errors are exposed. It is urged that more attention be given to probability theory in the physics curriculum.
Toward the Origin of Quantum Probability investigates the physical foundations of quantum probability within Pattern Field Theory (PFT), establishing an exact conservation and local Transport-current law while examining how the continuous distribution of quantum amplitudes relates to discrete, exclusive measurement outcomes. Building upon Quantum Gravity Fully Derived, the phase-valued Allen Orbital Lattice (AOL), and the relational quantum-field architecture of PFT, this paper develops a mathematical and computational account of phase-dependent Transport, conserved quadratic participation, detector interaction and the conditions required for physical measurement commitment. The central result is an exact local continuity equation derived from Hermitian lattice Transport. The construction establishes conservation of quadratic density, identifies the directed currents responsible for transferring participation between relational configurations, and demonstrates how quantum interference is preserved within a closed physical system. Principal contributions include: Exact Transport Conservation: Derives the local continuity equation for the phase-valued AOL operator and establishes global conservation of quadratic density under Hermitian Transport dynamics. Origin of the Quadratic Measure: Extends the inherited Quadratic Measure Lemma, examining the mathematical conditions under which a conserved quadratic measure arises and its relationship to the probability structure of quantum mechanics. Phase-Dependent Transport Currents: Establishes the relationship between relational phase, directed boundary currents and the redistribution of conserved participation across detector regions. Closed-System Detector Calculation: Presents a reproducible numerical investigation of a closed Hermitian Transport configuration containing a phase-bearing ring coupled to three detector channels. Conservation at Numerical Precision: Demonstrates quadratic norm conservation with maximum numerical deviations of approximately 1.8 x 10^-14 across the examined configurations. Quantum Interference: Reproduces phase-dependent detector distributions, including destructive interference at the central detector, where the calculated participation approaches 3.8 x 10^-30. Detector Retention and Return Currents: Identifies transient reverse currents and demonstrates why participation transferred into a detector must be distinguished from a permanently retained measurement record. Cut-Invariance: Demonstrates that the asymptotic detector participation pattern becomes independent of the chosen system-detector partition in the completed-transfer limit, while transient measurements retain partition dependence. Transport Versus Physical Commitment: Establishes the distinction between conserved, continuously distributed quantum participation and the exclusive physical commitment required for an individual detector outcome. Native EQUI Allocation: Identifies the physical connection required between phase-sensitive Equilibrion (EQUI) participation, inherited detector configurations and the eventual frequency distribution of committed events. Conditional Outcome Correspondence: Examines deterministic successor selection using phase-sensitive admissible currents and inherited route residuals, identifying the equilibrium conditions under which the resulting distributions reproduce quadratic outcome weighting. Reproducible Computational Evidence: Includes the Python source code and machine-readable numerical results used in the closed-Transport detector investigation, permitting independent examination of conservation, current integration, interference and detector participation. The paper identifies a precise remaining physical question: how does native Transport convert distributed, conserved participation into one retained measurement outcome per preparation, with observed frequencies determined by the appropriate quadratic measure? The mathematical conservation law, phase-dependent currents, detector calculations and asymptotic participation results are established within the specified Hermitian construction. The physical identification between native EQUI participation and spectral density, together with the commitment rule governing exclusive records, remains the explicitly defined closure problem. A Derivation Ledger distinguishes exact mathematical results, inherited PFT constructions, conditional correspondence results and the physical commitments requiring further derivation. The paper also examines operational reconstructions of quantum theory, composite systems, correlations, no-signalling conditions and the relationship between native causal continuation and downstream Mensural spacetime. The significance of this work lies in connecting quantum probability to a physically specified conservation and Transport architecture while isolating the exact mechanism still required to explain individual measurement outcomes. It establishes a reproducible mathematical and computational foundation for investigating the origin of the Born measure, detector commitment and the transition from distributed quantum participation to observed physical events. Together with Recovering General Relativity in Pattern Field Theory and Recovering Quantum Field Structure in Pattern Field Theory, this work extends the common relational Transport architecture into quantum conservation, probability and measurement. James Johan Sebastian AllenPattern Field Theoryhttps://patternfieldtheory.com/https://zenodo.org/communities/pft