Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Foundations of Physics

Bell's theorem based on a generalized EPR criterion of reality

Philippe H. Eberhard, Philippe Rosselet

Published Jan 1, 1995• 13 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1007/bf02054658

Related papers

Bell theorem

Franck Laloë

The Bell theorem [103] can be seen in several different ways, as the EPR argument. Initially, Bell invented it as a direct logical continuation of the EPR theorem: the idea is to take the existence of the EPR elements of reality seriously, and to push it further by introducing them explicitly into the mathematics with the notation λ; one then proceeds to study all possible kinds of correlations that can be obtained from the fluctuations of one or several variables λ, making the condition of locality explicit in the mathematics (locality was already useful in the EPR theorem, but not used in equations). The reasoning develops within determinism (considered as proved by the EPR reasoning) and classical probabilities; it studies in a completely general way all kinds of correlations that can be predicted from the fluctuations of some classical common cause in the past – if one prefers, from some random choice concerning the initial state of the system. This leads to the famous inequalities. But subsequent studies have shown that the scope of the Bell theorem is not limited to determinism; for instance, the λ variables may determine the probabilities of the results of future experiments, instead of the results themselves (see Appendix B), without canceling the theorem. We postpone the discussion of the various possible generalizations to §4.2.3. For the moment, we just emphasize that the essential condition for the validity of the Bell theorem is locality: all kinds of fluctuations can be assumed, but their effect must affect physics only locally.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Aug 30, 2012•0 citations

Bell’s theorem and the EPR paradox

Dipankar Home, F. Selleri

Rivista Del Nuovo Cimento•Sep 1, 1991•125 citations

EPR and Bell's theorem: A critical review

Henry Pierce Stapp

Foundations of Physics•Jan 1, 1991•21 citations

Quantum Theory and Locality: EPR , B ell's Theorem, and the Aspect Experiments

Richard DeWitt

This chapter focuses on recent experiments that are often claimed to have substantial implications for interpretations of quantum theory. These experiments fall under the heading of quantum facts. These new facts are most easily understood by looking at the EPR/Bell/Aspect trilogy. This trilogy consists of the EPR thought experiment; John Bell's 1964 proof, generally referred to as Bell's theorem or Bell's inequality; and a series of experiments from Alain Aspect's lab. The EPR argument argues that quantum theory is an incomplete theory of reality, in that quantum theory fails to represent an element of reality, namely, the polarization of the photons before they are detected. One can summarize the EPR argument in this way: either the locality assumption is false or quantum theory is an incomplete theory. Bell discovered that predictions based on quantum theory, on the one hand, and predictions based on the locality assumption, on the other hand, do not agree.

Wiley eBooks•Jun 5, 2018•0 citations

A generalized Bell's theorem

А. В. Белинский

Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics•Apr 1, 1994•2 citations

Review of Nelson's analysis of Bell's theorem

B. Schulz

This article contains a review of Nelson's analysis of Bell's theorem. It shows that Bell's inequalities can be violated with a theory of local random variables if one accepts that the outcomes of these variables are not predetermined prior to measurement. The article describes the relation between Bell's theorem and the Strong Free Will theorem of Conway and Kochen. Then, the original articles of Bell are analyzed in detail. Following an article of Faris, it is explained that Bell's work on the hidden variable question in fact describes two separate theorems. Bell's first theorem says that there can be no model for the singlet state where an outcome does not depend locally on the settings of the detector where the outcome was measured. Bell's second theorem shows that Bell's inequalities can be violated by a theory that is either not deterministic, or violates causality in the sense of relativity or the free will assumption of the experimenters. It is shown in detail where Bell implicitly makes the various locality assumptions that Nelson has shown to be necessary for deriving Bell's inequality. The article closes by relating the various assumptions needed to derive Bell's theorem with the reality criterion of EPR

arXiv:1302.4180•Feb 18, 2013•3 citations
The Bell theorem [103] can be seen in several different ways, as the EPR argument. Initially, Bell invented it as a direct logical continuation of the EPR theorem: the idea is to take the existence of the EPR elements of reality seriously, and to push it further by introducing them explicitly into the mathematics with the notation λ; one then proceeds to study all possible kinds of correlations that can be obtained from the fluctuations of one or several variables λ, making the condition of locality explicit in the mathematics (locality was already useful in the EPR theorem, but not used in equations). The reasoning develops within determinism (considered as proved by the EPR reasoning) and classical probabilities; it studies in a completely general way all kinds of correlations that can be predicted from the fluctuations of some classical common cause in the past – if one prefers, from some random choice concerning the initial state of the system. This leads to the famous inequalities. But subsequent studies have shown that the scope of the Bell theorem is not limited to determinism; for instance, the λ variables may determine the probabilities of the results of future experiments, instead of the results themselves (see Appendix B), without canceling the theorem. We postpone the discussion of the various possible generalizations to §4.2.3. For the moment, we just emphasize that the essential condition for the validity of the Bell theorem is locality: all kinds of fluctuations can be assumed, but their effect must affect physics only locally.
This chapter focuses on recent experiments that are often claimed to have substantial implications for interpretations of quantum theory. These experiments fall under the heading of quantum facts. These new facts are most easily understood by looking at the EPR/Bell/Aspect trilogy. This trilogy consists of the EPR thought experiment; John Bell's 1964 proof, generally referred to as Bell's theorem or Bell's inequality; and a series of experiments from Alain Aspect's lab. The EPR argument argues that quantum theory is an incomplete theory of reality, in that quantum theory fails to represent an element of reality, namely, the polarization of the photons before they are detected. One can summarize the EPR argument in this way: either the locality assumption is false or quantum theory is an incomplete theory. Bell discovered that predictions based on quantum theory, on the one hand, and predictions based on the locality assumption, on the other hand, do not agree.
This article contains a review of Nelson's analysis of Bell's theorem. It shows that Bell's inequalities can be violated with a theory of local random variables if one accepts that the outcomes of these variables are not predetermined prior to measurement. The article describes the relation between Bell's theorem and the Strong Free Will theorem of Conway and Kochen. Then, the original articles of Bell are analyzed in detail. Following an article of Faris, it is explained that Bell's work on the hidden variable question in fact describes two separate theorems. Bell's first theorem says that there can be no model for the singlet state where an outcome does not depend locally on the settings of the detector where the outcome was measured. Bell's second theorem shows that Bell's inequalities can be violated by a theory that is either not deterministic, or violates causality in the sense of relativity or the free will assumption of the experimenters. It is shown in detail where Bell implicitly makes the various locality assumptions that Nelson has shown to be necessary for deriving Bell's inequality. The article closes by relating the various assumptions needed to derive Bell's theorem with the reality criterion of EPR